Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Quinn

banjo minnow

22 posts in this topic

I just bought the banjo minnow kit the other day. There is some well know fisherman that supposedly swear by them confused (Their supposed to act like an injured minnow when jerked properly). Has anyone used them and if so how do you like them?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My wife bought me a set a couple of years ago. I've yet to take them out because I keep forgetting where I put them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I actully have caught several fish on them. Not my "go to" lure by any long shot but they are fun to take out and mess around with.

If you figure out how to work them and catch fish on them, more power to you.

and welcome to the site

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My dad got hooked on the Banjo minnow a number of years ago and of course bought me and my brother a kit for Christmas one year. I used them quite a bit one summer and I caught a lot of bass with them. They worked as advertised, but there are equally effective ways to fish plastics that are just easier to use.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of my best fishing stories involved the Banjo Minnows. One of my fishing buddies still talks about it every time we go out.

He about laughed his head off when I told him I fell for the advertisement -"Fish are genetically programmed to eat the Banjo Minnow." He repeated that about 20 times as he caught bass from the back of the boat, after I'd go over them with the Banjo.

I'm pretty stubborn at this point and getting frustrated, because it does look good, and my pride is at stake. Suddenly, a legit 20"er comes after it, strikes it, and tears it off the hook!! She spits the Banjo out, swims aways away, and see's it slowly fluttering down to the bottom, and comes back, inhales it, and swims away!! Shortly after, he want's to know how much they cost, and mumbles something about "genetic response." lol.

Haven't used them for over 15yrs. Didn't realize they were still around, to tell the truth. They definately look great in the water, and can be fun to fish with. Good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have had them for a few years now.If the stars are lined up,the moon is right,the wind is right,the sun is at the right angle,you pick the right color and if you twitch em right,they are the hottest thing going.They are either hot or not.I like to use them for sight fishing small mouth,large mouth and northerns,(no leader=lost minnows) you will know with in a couple casts if they will work that day.If they are working they are a blast.I also have had luck using the minnows on the back end of a big olde buck tail mepps spinner or a white double spinner.I have never caught a walleye on one but will continue to try from time to time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bought the set last summer and fished it for the first time in a metro lake and landed a nice largemouth. I will try it some more this year and see what happens. They defenitely do look attractive in the water as do many other baits for that matter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Babe Winkleman loves them.

. . . yeah . . . Babe gets paid to love them . . .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: zepman
Babe Winkleman loves them.

. . . yeah . . . Babe gets paid to love them . . .

Haha true grin but the camera doesnt lie and if you have seen his show where he uses these up in canadia 4 post-spawn pike, its pretty amazing. But to be honest I can never find the big ones so instead I fish a Storm Kickn' Minnow and love them for sight fishing skies. I broke of the lip on the 6" version and just let it fall right in front of their face, then hop it once and game over! Not much tops the sight of a 45" skie crushing a bait right under your feet smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: zepman
Babe Winkleman loves them.

. . . yeah . . . Babe gets paid to love them . . .

He also loves the Rocket Launcher fishing rod!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My oldest son says he used to catch quite a few bass with them under docks about 8-10 years ago. I purchased a set for my youngest son for Xmas a couple years ago, but I don't think he's tried them much.

A couple observations about the banjo minnow- When I look at the larger ones (6-8"?) It looks like the hooks are of a very thin wire. I don't think the hooks would hold up to a big fish. Also, the hooks are attached by a small wire about 1/4 inch in front of the bait. I wonder if the would be subject to a lot of short strikes?

I've never tried them myself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ill bet it works about as good as the "SHAM-WOW"!!!

Sorry I dont do infomercials.

Billy Mayes here...you wanna catch fish.....POW!!!!!!!!!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: Shorelunch
Originally Posted By: zepman
Babe Winkleman loves them.

. . . yeah . . . Babe gets paid to love them . . .

He also loves the Rocket Launcher fishing rod!!

if i ever saw anyone teaching their kid to fish with one of those.. i would probably find it my responsibility to "set them straight"... i almost had an aneurysm when i saw that commercial

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've fished the lake and the bays that Babe filmed in Canada using the Banjo. In those particular conditions baits like that work very well. That was right after ice out and all sight fishing for fish that were not particularily aggressive. Have not used that brand myself but have used similar baits in the same conditions with success.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've fished the lake and the bays that Babe filmed in Canada using the Banjo. In those particular conditions baits like that work very well. That was right after ice out and all sight fishing for fish that were not particularily aggressive. Have not used that brand myself but have used similar baits in the same conditions with success.

Here's a hint . . . they generally don't film fishing shows or commercials, for that matter, when conditions aren't ideal. They're filming when the bite is, or usually is, on. Plus, they don't film commercials on a overfished metro area lake, they go north. I believe Berkley did their Gulp studies where they "proved Gulp out fishes live bait" on the Canadian side of LOTW and either Rainy or Lac Seul. Sometimes, you can catch fish with a dried up twig and shoelace up there.

As Homer Simpson says, "if it's on TV, it must be true" right? laugh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i LOVE them! i caught so many fish one them i went through an entire kit last year!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That reminds me, I have a "Flying Lure" set in the shed at the cabin. I should break that bad boy out this year (since I haven't the other 11 years I owned it).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ive used them in summer for smallmouth and northerns, nothing amazing, but they do work pretty good

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: Shorelunch
Originally Posted By: zepman
Babe Winkleman loves them.

. . . yeah . . . Babe gets paid to love them . . .

He also loves the Rocket Launcher fishing rod!!

There's a name for ya. I wonder if he rides in a radio flyer boat. laugh

Thought it was funny but I guess we sometimes do get hung up on brand names. grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I get that, not the point, or i wouldnt have posted in the first place. How about he is stubborn and wont wear a life jacket and instead of freezing in his old deer hunting garb a pair of new outerwear designed for ice fishing would be great and as a bonus add safety?
    • You were definitely against it.  BD not.   And, as the old joke goes, it is a matter of price.   If they can get jobs for 700 bucks a year subsidy per job, might well be worth doing.  On the other hand 200k per job or whatever it really is seems too expensive.     But if you are one of the purists, then oppose everything.    I'm not that doctrinaire. 
    • I thought it was worth mentioning that I;ve found great mounting boards and mounting ideas from checking the catalogs of some taxidermy supply page and catalogs. 
    • I get being concerned about the ones you love, that's aways a good practice, but it seems like no matter how well I try to educate my wife on ice safety and my precautions regarding it, she still thinks I'm going to die.  If they have $400+ to burn, so be it, but I've compromised by saying I'll wear a life jacket out the first time or two.  Seems like a more economical solution to me. 
    • I agree with Hawg and Sea Hage. This is a convection heater and heat rises through the top vents. At 15k BTU the area where you put the fan will reach 300+ deg. f. and deform the fan blades as they are made of plastic. Put the fan at the bottom as suggested. Your main objective is to get hot air circulation through the house. The floor will usually be cooler due to the holes but with the fan blowing at the bottom cold air is returned at the bottom of the heater through circulation. My house is same size as yours. I have a 9k BTU Dura Flame convection heater and tried several fan configurations. I did burn up the fan blades when installed as in you pic running at about 7k BTU. I than converted it to a forced air with air flow fan control using temperature controlled relays. The burner I posted earlier is from that heater where I increased the BTU to 12k. The temp in my house is very consistent floor to ceiling and operates same as my home furnace. May be a bit of overkill for what your looking for but really works well with great comfort at any outside temp and wind.   The bump  on the air duct has 3 four inch compute fans to maintain. Behind the white framed box I put a 4 speed auto fan for fast warm-up I turn off when warm. Runs at 12.5k BTU. The pipe duct going to the door I added this fall to heat my attached flip. Cold air return is opening below the heat chamber and at the auto fan.   When I am not in the house and want to keep it warm, I turn off the temp control relays and open the door to the original convection and turn the heat down.  
    • I have a Crossfire II 4-16x50 on my .308 elk rifle and I love it. Great scope, very clear and bright and Vortex quality. I have not had a single issue with it and the Crossfire is on the budget end of their glass. I've great reports from those with the higher end scopes. I wouldn't hesitate for a second. As far as which one to choose, I find the 50mm scope a little big and heavy. You'll likely have issues mounting to an AR due to its size. Mine had the benefit of the barrel taper allowing for the larger lens to fit. If I had a flat top like an AR it wouldn't fit as well. 
    • This is a post on the low flame issue that was brought up awhile back along with a question. As most said the low flame is normal and says so in the manual. I just picked one up, a used one. Hooked it all up and had very minimal flame. I have several of these units in rental houses so I am able to compare. The unit I just picked up is an abnormally low flame. I took a little square head bolt out of the black pipe that goes directly into the burner and blew it out. This was a mistake as at this point I can not get the burner to light. Ok now I need to get to the burner. I took apart the unit and took the burner out and blew it out real good then reassembled the unit and wa-la great flame and great heat, better then my newer units.   Now for the ? part of my post. I am having a 10degree drop in the temp before the unit starts back up. My other shacks are not much better but a little. Anyone have any experience with this issue?
    • usually 2 weeks to get stuff at st jo.  did brats3 weeks ago. buncha meat sticks this last week  
  • Our Sponsors