Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
311Hemi

Gifting fish?

20 posts in this topic

Is there any special requirement to gift fish like giving a piece of paper with my name and license number, or marking the packages? I tried searching the online regs but it keep locking up my computer here at work.

I have someone coming (driving) into town from out west that I would like to give a few fillet's to to take home.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would just buy some walleye fillets and give them, this way it's 100% legal and no questions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's my understanding the gifting fish is 100% legal. I have a few in the freezer from this summer and I plan to give them to someone who doesn't get to fish them much if at all.

Thus why I am asking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Follow any regs as they pertain to the watershed in question as to slots, limits, and I.D and such and put your license # on the package. It's then 100% legal the way I read the statute.

I do this quite regular on the LOTW, especially come wintertime.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

do you have your flame proof shorts on??? eek

I say, look up the regs, follow the regs. I gift fish from one licenced fisherman to someone who does not fish much, who likes to eat fish. As far as I am concerned as long as he is eating them and not getting over limit, I will keep giving him fish.

Others will come on here and tell you not to give fish at all.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just follow the storage guidelines listed in the regulations.

Here's a cut and paste.

"Storage

new • A person who stores fish for another must plainly mark the

package, in ink, with the name, address, and fishing license number of the owner, and the number of fish in the package, the waterbody where taken, and total length of each fish with a size limit."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't understand minnesota's definition of "possession of sport fish"

So.. you can only possess a certain amount(1 day's limit). If you fillet it and throw it in your freezer and don't eat it, and you have a full limit in your freezer, you can't go fishing until you eat some of your fillets? That seems to be what I gather from reading the regs. Kinda sucks you can't stock up a freezer full.

If that's the case, shouldn't trophies made from fish count towards your possession limit? You're still possessing sport-caught fish. (it sounds silly I know, but read the regs! "Fish are in an angler’s possession whether on hand, in cold storage, in transport, or elsewhere.")

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't understand minnesota's definition of "possession of sport fish"

So.. you can only possess a certain amount(1 day's limit). If you fillet it and throw it in your freezer and don't eat it, and you have a full limit in your freezer, you can't go fishing until you eat some of your fillets? That seems to be what I gather from reading the regs. Kinda sucks you can't stock up a freezer full.

If that's the case, shouldn't trophies made from fish count towards your possession limit? You're still possessing sport-caught fish. (it sounds silly I know, but read the regs! "Fish are in an angler’s possession whether on hand, in cold storage, in transport, or elsewhere.")

Yep it fish in possession and that includes your freezer. And I see nothing wrong with that, you can still fish, you just can't keep anymore fish until you eat what you have.

The trophy on the wall doesn't really have any meat there. Most just styrofoam and some skin.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's exactly why the law is like that........specifically to keep people from going out every day and "stocking" up there freezer.

Fresh fish tastes much better anyways wink

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So what is the differance if you go out every day catch your limit and go home and eat them foe dinner. Or you go and catch your limit every day and put your limit in the freezer so you can have friends and family over for a fish fry. The limit is still the same and the same amount of fish are taken. Just becuase one way is the fish are compost sooner is no differance. The only reason that I know this rule to be is for people that will catch a limit, run back in and store the fish, then goback out and catch another limit or more the same day. I think the daily limit should be it, not possesion as long as you don't exceed your daily limit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So with that logic, then an out of stater could come here with a party of 4 and stay for 7 days, then take 4 limits x seven days home with them.

So if they were fishing crappies that would legally be 280 crappies. That is one group for one week…….

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't understand minnesota's definition of "possession of sport fish"

So.. you can only possess a certain amount(1 day's limit). If you fillet it and throw it in your freezer and don't eat it, and you have a full limit in your freezer, you can't go fishing until you eat some of your fillets? That seems to be what I gather from reading the regs. Kinda sucks you can't stock up a freezer full.

If that's the case, shouldn't trophies made from fish count towards your possession limit? You're still possessing sport-caught fish. (it sounds silly I know, but read the regs! "Fish are in an angler’s possession whether on hand, in cold storage, in transport, or elsewhere.")

OMG! I wish I wouldn't have read that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know who needs a freezer full of fish. I've done fish fries for people at work and a limit of waleye and crappie fed a lot of people. I'm all for keeping fish, but don't get rediculous with it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jerkbait ------

The difference is that someone is not likely to eat fish everyday, and therefore the resource is not depleted.

As far as gifting fish. I provided my neighbor fresh fish for several years before he died this past March at the age of 90. He was a real outdoorsman and in years past would go and catch his own. As he got older he couldn't get around very well, but he still liked a good walleye or crappie dinner every month or so which I was happy to supply.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That was just an example I was making. 2 different scenarios, same number of fish. Also I do know people that eat fish everyday. My point is what is the differance if you eat them or freeze them for a later date. Maybe you only get to fish at certain times of the year, but like to have fish dinners every now and then.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"The difference is that someone is not likely to eat fish everyday, and therefore the resource is not depleted."

What about the guide who takes out 3 clients in the morning and they get their limit and then he takes out three more in the afternoon and they get their limit. He does this day after day all summer. He is part of a larger group who all do this, day in and day out. The resource was not designed to take this kind of pressure. This is part of the reason for the heavy stocking. Just another angle to look at.

The "average" Joe who fishes to have a meal is doing VERY little damage. I say gift all you want. I gift fish all the time and never think twice about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is a possession limit. In place to keep people from hoarding fish. Once you have the fish in your freezer there is no way to tell when or where they were caught.

If you want to have a fish fry get a bunch of guys with their limits and you will have plenty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a real interesting debate, and I can see merit in both sides of the argument. My opinion is that fish and game are a resource that provide quality food as well as recreational activities. No one should feel guilty for using this resource in a sustainable manner. I get real put off by elitists that rip others for using this resource.

Here's an example that illustrates my point:

1- "Jack" is a road construction equipment operator. From frost-out til freeze-up he's working grueling 6-day weeks, usually away from home and when he gets home for his day off, he spends it at home with his family. In the winter, he's laid off and gets out ice-fishing 2-3 times a week and usually comes home with a decent catch of pannies. He cleans these fish and freezes them in water in milk cartons and puts them up in the freezer. Throughout the yr, his family is able to enjoy a fish dinner about once a week.

On one hand, this is clearly a violation of the law. On the other, "Jack" is no harder on the resource than I am(we eat fresh fish on average about once a week). I sure don't regard this guy as a criminal or game-hog. Do you?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

with four fishing lisc in the house we have know problem keeping the freezer fresh and turned over. I do gift out dux and geese in the fall to stay ligit

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I too, have, and will continue gift a meal of walleye to a fellow sportman (grand-father in-law) that is no longer able to get out in the boat due to age / health. I've also given a meal (not a full limit) once a year to a neighbor that I appreciate.

I have thought twice about gifting fish, though. I do not see it as a problem if done responsibly. But, I don't believe our lakes are a gift store or a food shelf for others. I know this is not a view that alot of fisherman agree with. Myself, I've thought about it twice, and when I was hostest about it, I found I was stroking / getting my ego stoked and used "being nice by (over) gifting as an excuse to keep any fish I caught. All done at the expense of our fisheries. I've kept fish in the past that I didn't need / want them, but I'd caught them and I didn't want to show up at the landing / go home with nothing. My ego couldn't take not being able to prove that I caught something.

I no longer need this "chest thumping" ego stroke. I go out with a plan now. Most times I plan on keeping nothing. Especially if I've recently kept some or still have some in the freezer. I don't go out and use the neighbors / relatives as an excuse / reason to keep my limit of fish, or even the two or three I may end up with. I appreciate not wanting to waste fish, but it irriates me when guys at the landing are looking for someone to give their one or two fish away to because they don't want to just clean one of two fish.

I also do not understand the fisherman that fill there freezer or "double dip" by irresposible gifting, and, when the fish they're catching are gone (months, years later), they blame the DNR for not stocking more. It seems like it's the "freezer stockers" / irresponsible gifters that are most critical of the DNR.

I don't believe we can use our fathers/ grandfathers views on fish harvest. Maybe if we go back to their equipment. We have tools today that I believe make fishing more fun and productive. This equipment is a double-edged sword if not used responsibly though. Times (equipment & technology) have changed. I believe fishermen's views on fish harvest ought to change also. IMO.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Nope, they've always been much too spineless to receive my vote.   I've always been more libertarian minded, but without the crazy parts. You have to include human and societal behavior into the equation to get ideals to actually work in the real world.      
    • 34 IN THE BOAT HERE ON HIDDEN BAY today and I am eating strawberries and drinking lemonade, more about that later. Wednesday I did make it to the Resort and I spent the afternoon relaxing. I went in search of Elmer as I saw his truck parked out back. I went up to his room and tapped on the door only to hear what I thought was a loud grunt. I took that to mean "Come in" and so I did. I opened the door and was hit by a wall of heat. Elmer was sitting in a wood rocking chair, with a book in hand looking over a pair of cheater reading glasses at me. "Close the door" he commanded and I did. "Sit" he said and I did in an overstuffed chair in front of the window where a stream of sunshine was pouring into the room.   I sat back deep in the chair and relaxed. I let out some air and sat back even deeper into the cushions and I told myself this is what I was needing. I spoke out loudly to Elmer "Wife call?" And Elmer nodded his head yes. I then closed my eyes and just relaxed, Elmer already knew why I was there. I was almost ready for a nap when I felt then saw a hardback book fall into my lap. I reached down and picked it up and saw it was the new Clive Clusser book that I had bought Elmer for Christmas. I know this because I has written inside the book "Merry Christmas Elmer from Bobby." Also inside the book was a punch card from the Masterbaiters Shop for suckers, I think it was being used as a book marker. The book had not been read yet and I looked at Elmer and he said "Knock yourself out" When I bought the book for Elmer I was going to buy myself a copy to but had not gotten around to it.   I opened the book up and bent back the hard book covers slowly and then I went through the book every hundred pages or so and bent them back. This is how you break the binder on a hardback book without breaking the book. I heard the tapping of a glass on wood and I looked up to see Elmer offering me a empty glass and he said "Open the little fridge" and I did. Inside I found a cold carton of pink lemonade and a plastic container of strawberries. I took them both out and set them down on the little wood table between us. "Well pour" Elmer said and so I did. A few minutes later I was a few pages into Clives book and I was sipping on cold lemonade, eating strawberries in a warm room that was no longer hot with sunshine on my shoulders in a place far far away. Just the way I wanted to be the day before a visit to the hospital   I spent the afternoon and went late into the evening reading until I was done with the book. I closed it with a satisfied feeling like all of Mr. Clusser’s books leave me with. Strawberries and lemonade were long gone but it did not stop me from tipping my glass over my open mouth where I hoped I might get just one last drop but I did not. I said good night to Elmer and went down stairs where Chuck gave me a ride back to the cabin. Today finds me writing this story with a bowl of strawberries close at hand and a glass of lemonade. Not the same as summer but good enough for this time of year.   Sunshine Ray is a little off in his forecast. I did go to the hospital in sunny weather and I got all my tests done in record time. Every department I went to there was no waiting and I zipped right through. Today finds me in the den and although Ray’s forecast called for clouds he missed out on the rain that has been falling. Sitting here I can hear the water coming off the eves to make splattering sounds as it hits the snow on the ground. Ice dams on the roofs are gone, each time one slides off the roof Duncan starts barking and running around the cabin. Glad they are off the roof and even better they have come down when no one is beneath them to get hurt. Ray also forgot to mention that when it is not raining the snow fog moves in and if and when it gets cold out we are going to have ice every where here at Lake Iwanttobethere
    • And yup, the BLM certainly was there....the fruitcakes, and the rest of mainstream America, even the voting llama's...  
    • Hillary catches Bill staring at Ivanka  
    • Nothing wrong with liking some of the ideas......being a full blown nut job libertarian is another.
    • I've never watched one of these parades before........... it's so weird. Some funny arse signs in the crowds. At least they could have had some clowns throwing candy to kids. It's not like there is a shortage of clowns in DC.
    • Always the Russians.....
    • Trump does not use the POTUS twitter ..   Who ever twittered it, was not trump.   Prolly the russians ??  
    • They changed it today to the Obama inauguration pic, then changed it to the US flag, then changed it a third time to the grainy potato-cam pic of Trump staring at squirrels........
  • Our Sponsors