Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Gadgetman

Rain gear to avoid?

51 posts in this topic

My current gear is shot and needs to be replaced. There appear to be so many good options out their that I am wondering if anyone has recommendations of brands to avoid. I am kind of leaning towards the Scheels extreme bibs and parka, or the Gander h2o bibs and parka. I kind of like the Cabelas Guide wear but it seems so stiff that I dont know how comfortable it would be. Any input would be appreciated as I want to get a suit that I can be happy with for 5-10 years

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

cheap suits are a waste of money. Spend the money and get a good suit and you will be thankful. get something that bresthes and is comfortable. I have had my suit for 10 years got it at bass pro shop and it isgoing to last 10 more

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wife has the Gander stuff I wear guideware, I thonk mines a little better and that stiffness is no bother at all. Go with GorTex

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yup, whichever, make sure you go a quality brand with Gortex. I've had my Guidewear for 3 yrs now, and love it. I don't know about the Scheel's line, but I've also heard good things about the GM H2O line. Good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Check out Gamehide's Typhoon raingear. There's a lot of people swearing by it over their Cabela's GuideWear, I will be buying a parka soon. Read some reviews on it and email me gking_xc@msn.com. I might be able to get you a deal on a parka, and maybe bibs later on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This year my Guide Ware is having its 10th birthday. It has been through many a gale and downpour and hasn't let me down. I always dry it out before storage and follow the maintenance instructions. It cost $375 new, but that's down to $37.50 per year. Not a bad price to pay to be sure the gear will work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guideware is the only way to go.

Never head of Gamehide where do you get it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It all depends on the conditions. I find myself using my $59 Frog Toggs more than my $400 Guide Wear. I don't fish in heavy Rain, Snow, Sleet that often but those times Guide Wear is needed and worth the money.

But in moderate rain and temps I found my Frog Toggs to be spot on perfect, really comfortable and not to warm.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have the Game Hide stuff, I only use it for ice fishing now, replaced it with the Guideware and much dryer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have heard nothing but good things on Guide wear and the BPS 100mph suits. For me, Frog Togs for spring/summer/fall. Price is right, put some polar fleece under it when its cool or cold and your warm and dry. For summer rain it is the best thing going, light weight yet keeps you bone dry and not over heating. For cold weather, ice armor or guide wear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have used Guide Wear for the past few years and also Frog Togs. Guide Wear is the best I have ever owned, and if there is ever a problem, Cabelas has always been very open minded with exchange and warranty replacement. Frog Togs for the price is also an excellent choice, I agree with grab the net's assesment. The only question I might have about F Togs is how much stress and wear they can take if you fish alot. But then again, how often you wear your rain suit is up to you. I wear the Guide Wear as a warm wind shell in the early spring and fall besides as rain wear. Dont think you can go wrong with either choice, just that the GW might be a little more durable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have the guideware also, nice and dry, I even carry it on the motor cycle, this stuff holds up in 70 mph winds!, the velcro over the zippers make it rain tight, well worth the money. I bought it for both the bike and fishing, I have had $200.00 H.D. suits that shred and this suit is still going strong after 4 years, To some 4 years is not enough to justify the price. But realize that when on the bike I have riddin 400 miles in pouring rain at or above 70mph many times trying to get home and it still keeps me dry. so if you only use it for fishing it will last forever in my opinion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When you think that some of those designer motorcycle suits cost $700 to $800 Guideware is not a bad deal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gortex if you can otherwise dont get anything cheaper than the Gander H2o series. Buy it to fit a bit loose so you can get boots through the bib legs easy enough.

Frog Togs are ok for light use.

The Bass Pro and Cabelas is real nice stuff.

Helly Hanson makes some nice light weight stuff as does columbia.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have had my GW for a couple years now and it has been the best investment in comfort I have every made. I fish allot in the early spring/late fall so I use it for rain and wind protection. Yes it was a little stiff the first couple times I wore it but is breaks in nicely after a short while.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a cheaper (under $100) basically good plastic/rubber type stuff from Columbia and I just can't find a reason to "upgrade" to a goretex type suit....they might not breath great but I have worn them in all types of conditions and with the proper attire on under it I have been warm and dry.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would go with the Guide Wear. I had the H2O Guide Series and they worked great for 2 years and then sprung a leak. I returned them and upgraded to the Guide Series Pro Staff rain gear which is the same as the Bass Pro Shops 100 mhp version. I haven't needed to wear it, but it seems nice, but for the money I wish I would have gotten the Guide Wear.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bought a Gander Tech H2O jacket the day after Christmas a few years ago. The jacket was normally priced at $129.99 marked down to $65.99. That day it was on a rack that was 50% the marked down price. So when it rang up it was about $33! I bought Tech H2O bibs a while later (only on sale for 25% off the $99.99 price grin). So for about $110 I got a complete set. It is excellent. The sleeves have neoprene cuffs so the water doesn't roll down my arm. It stays dry all the time. I have had GoreTex and I like the Tech H2O better. The jacket was well thought out. The neoprene cuffs like I mentoned and outer pocket zippers with "gaskets" (not sure what esle to call them).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I looked at guidewear it looks like a nice suit, kind of spendy though. Do any of you have a suggestion as to if a person should spend more and get the thinsulated version?

Would the insulated suit be to warm in the summer time? would the non insulated suit be to cold in the spring and fall?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have uninsulated 100 mph. I wear it year round and it is big enough that I can layer underneath with thermals/Under Armor/fleece/etc. Depends where you fish. Up north, July rains can still be pretty cold. You wont be disappointed either way. My vote is go with a size bigger in the uninsulated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you fish into Oct. or Nov. you want the thinsulate. For summer I have my old goretex rain suit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just wear the unisulated and wear fleece and under aumour with a sweatshirt and stay warm. I'm normaly casting though till ice up so generate a little heat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would avoid Frogg Toggs if you are doing anything serious. They would work as a back up pair I guess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I was out last night on a local lake and was surprised to see the water temp down to 57.  Caught a couple cookie cutter fish, but not the big ones I was looking for. Fished a lot of weeds in the 6-9ft range, but not a lot going on there. The biggest one was still shallow in some reeds, so not sure if we are still in the spawn/post spawn stage.     Whats everyone else seeing out there for a bite and fishing conditions. Big weekend coming up, Good luck!! 
    • Maxine_Partain, Welcome to the forum.  There seem to be a lot of folks from Canada joining up in the last half a year which is nice. The sad thing is they all seem to make about 3 posts on the same day they joined and then they never come back which is sad. Hopefully you will keep posting.
    •   Hazel Hain, Welcome to the forum.  There seem to be a lot of folks from Canada joining up in the last half a year which is nice. The sad thing is they all seem to make about 3 posts on the same day they joined and then they never come back which is sad. Hopefully you will keep posting.
    • hi and welcome to HSO. I think you mean double hung not double pane. if you have moisture between the panes you have a seal failure. depending on the brand you might be able to just replace the glass. If you have lots of rot you may need to do a complete replacement. Best to have a window person pop by and check out the situation. 
    • Some times it's just nice getting out of town and when your with the right people a wet weekend can still be fun. This weekend should be better!
    • Cool story! 
    • Reb's old girlfriend might have had a diaphragm, but you would find that one in the lower unit - not in the carburetor...
    • Most of the homeowner's expense comes from heating and cooling inside a home. Double pane windows have gasses like argon or krypton filled to displace the air between the panels. But the problem is when this leaks from the window panes and settles down at the bottom. 1) The main problem that would arise is condensation. The moisture level goes high thus causing mold, mildew and rotting wood sills. 2) If the gas leaks, the window will not provide better insulation. 3) The windows start to make squeaky sounds thus it is hard to close and open. 4) It also affects the stripping to loose. I live here in Canada. In our house, we have double pane windows in almost all the rooms. Now I could see that some of the windows to be in a foggy condition. Will it be due to the gas in the window panes? Should I need to replace the windows? I have heard that casement windows.are good compared to double pane windows. I would like to know the benefits of casement windows. Will it cut down my utility bills? Please do share your thoughts and valuable suggestions. Thanks for the time.
    • We spent last weekend in the camper, holed up hiding from the rain. Not the worst thing ever, but a hike would've been nice. Hopefully we'll have better weather over Memorial Day. It looks good now so I'm excited. 
    • I am in a confusion on which one to choose. I have anyways decided to separate the bath area from the toilet. Which one would be better? I don't have enough area in the bathroom. One of my friends said that when it comes to energy efficiency and water conservation, a quick shower virtually always beats a bath. Is it true??   Although it is good for relaxing and ideal for bathing small children, I think it will be difficult for older people and people with injuries to get in and out. When it comes to the case of water heaters also I think it will be difficult to fill the tub. I think all these issues can be sorted out using a shower. Showers always need only less water. But if there is any leak, it will be difficult to fix.   I personally prefer bathtubs. Although it has many disadvantages compared to showers, the relaxation and freshness we get after bathing in a tube are very different. What is your opinion? Based on your opinion, I want to fix my decision and approach a plumbing company for installing it. Feel free to share your thoughts.
  • Our Sponsors