Marcum VX-1 (new style) / Hummingbird 35 / VexilarFL12

[dodger31]

Looks like these three are about the same price within $50 or so.

Let's hear the pros and cons from the owners. I am looking for the best unit out there for the money.

My main problem in the past has been interference from other units. Thanks for your help in advance!

Dodger

[broman]

I had the previous VX-1 and thought it was a very good unit. If you want zoom, skip the FL-12. Both the VX-1 and Hummingbird have zoom.

Overall, I would go with the VX-1. You won't be disappointed. I do with it had that flat screen like the FL-12.

[Eric Wettschreck]

I have not used the Humminbird, so I can't comment on that one.

With the remaining flashers you listed, I'd go VX-1 due to the bottom zoom capabilities. Once you've used bottom zoom you'll be in love with it.

[broman]

I have an LX-3 now and I miss the bottom zoom lock.

[BartmanMN]

Love my VX-1

[harvey lee]

I would say the Humm. 35 or the Marcum VX1

[Drewski]

Go with the fl-12. I've used one before and it is like a newer style fl-8. The flat screen is really nice too. They are the best unit in their price range IMO.

[Ed Carlson]

Vexilar FL-12 Pro Pack with the duel beam ducer.

You won't need the zoom, and the overall year around versatility will be a huge plus.

[NTW]

I have the k-35 and am not extremely impressed with it. It makes a strange humming sound (ironic) that drove me nuts!

I am returning it tonight and am currently struggling with what I will switch to. I am considering giving hummingbird another try by upgrading to k-45 (because of added power and the case rebate), or a different brand...

[asleson]

vx-1 pro 274.99 at fleet right now. Great unit for that price with a soft cover.

[Dave]

My main problem in the past has been interference from other units.

The Marcum VX-1P was upgraded to include 12-steps of IR.

[CNY Tim]

Target seperation

MarCum VX-1P - 2.25" (The Auto Tune feature is worth it) Soft pack and takes a beating

Humminbird 35 - 2.5" (standard dual beam)

Vexilar - 2.65" (Dual Beam will run you and extra $75 for that unless you can get something off the standard 12 deg.)

There all selling well and my Gander just has birds left, sold out of MarCum's and Vexes already.

[shizzy]

vx-1 pro 274.99 at fleet right now. Great unit for that price with a soft cover.

got one last night!!!

[mozy]

I bought the regular VX-1 a few weeks ago and really like it. The ICE 35 has some really nice features, but after the issues I had with a 45 I decided to go with something tried and true. After they get any bugs worked out, I'm sure the Humminbirds will be really popular. I considered an 8 or 12 Vex, but I felt that I would kick myself for not getting a unit with zoom. I think I made the right choice, the zoom feature is really nice to have, and the screen on the MarCum is clear and easy to read.

[Deitz Dittrich]

I have an LX-3 now and I miss the bottom zoom lock.

Broman- just put the 5' zoom on the bottom. Its the same thing?

[Jethro80]

Vx1-p, worth every penny

[Seabass77]

FL - 12. Super dependable. Nothing worse than being out of town fishing and having your ducer go out on your or having some chip burn out on the unit.

Vexilar is reliable and quality.

[Northlander]

I would go LX-1. More bang for the buck.

[koonie]

Marcum is the best choice period!

[dodger31]

Thanks for the all the help! I will be getting a Marcum very soon!

Dodger

[DooWap]

I have the LX-5 and the bottom zoom is great. It's like watching HDTV, once you've seen it you can't live without it. I like the Super Fine Line resolution on the Marcum too, it has a much crisper look, so it doesn't feel like you've been drinking all day (even if you have been )

[Caleb S]

VX-1, have had it for 3 years now and love it. the bottom zoom is great.

[bigbad401]

I had the same problem about buying a new $300 flasher. I didn't look at the Vexilar because the Marcum and the Humminbird had so many more features for the money. I ended up with Humminbird ICE35 mainly because of the dual band transducer. I am a little worried about new products, but Humminbird has been around for a very long time.

[Tye]

I have the ICE-45 and really like it.Still waiting for my "free" bag

[Shack]

I am a die hard Humminbird guy during open water. With that said I currently own a new LX-5 by Marcum for ice time. I love every feature this unit has, but the new ICE-55 from Humminbird has me turning my head .

I believe Humminbird’s new ICE units are going to be a force to be wreak-in with. I might make a switch some time in the future, but for now my LX-5 does a fabulous job helping me find fish.

It would be hard to switch, but for now the Marcum is my unit I would recommend .

Good luck!