Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
olbaidhh

State Warns About Eating Fish From Henn. Co. Lake

19 posts in this topic

State Warns About Eating Fish From Henn. Co. Lake

ST. PAUL (AP) ―

The department said Friday that people shouldn't eat fish from Twin Lake in Robbinsdale and Crystal more than once a month.

The department has issued similar warnings after PFCs were found in lakes Calhoun, Elmo and Johanna.

PFCs were first discovered in metro area lakes in 2007.

The chemicals were made by Maplewood-based 3M beginning in the 1940s for such household products as Scotchgard and Teflon. The company no longer makes the chemicals.

There are few studies of the health effects of PFCs on people, but studies by 3M of workers exposed to PFCs during manufacturing show no apparent problems.

However, laboratory studies have found high concentrations of PFCs caused changes in the liver and other organs of test animals

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

geeeez! Twin and Crystal are my home waters! I don't think i've EVER eaten anything outta them though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Of course the studies of 3M by 3M are going to favor 3M.There capping all the wells in that area showing signs of PFCs.I believe 3Ms payin the bill. Now the lakes? they'll only find more lakes and the list will grow just as the area well list has continuly grown since first discovered,by people constantly sick! But it does no harm???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its a bummer because those lakes are right down the road from me too. I guess I never really ate anything from out of there but its still too bad. Twin has seemed to decline since they did that bridge project, dont really see anyone out there much. Used to be a decent little hole to go throw a line in once in a while, lots of stunted crappies and sunnies now. I guess its good that i didnt keep anything from there after all.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Only good thing is the fish don't stick to the pan when you fry them. hahahaah laugh

LOL!!! grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: BartmanN
Only good thing is the fish don't stick to the pan when you fry them. hahahaah laugh

LOL!!! grin

Hilarious laughlaugh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ya, you could say they really slide right through you too.

Hmmmm is it white castle or is it fish from Hen Lakes?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats one thing about White Castle- either you really love it or you really hate it. There is really no in between with them.

Back on topic, I am really trying to figure out why any company ever thought pumping stuff into any body of water was a good idea.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll guess 3M knew it was bad! But back then pollution was a given fact it was ignorance on most behalfs but 3M scientists??? I bet they just kept quiet knowing their job was at steak!

Back then the Mississippi was next to dead raw sewage flowing in was accepted!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ya how the times have changed. I always hear my grandpa and the old guys talk about the good old days, but im thinking we got better conditions now (maybe not better fishing, but i wasnt there so i got no clue about that). Some of the things that used to happen are almost unimaginable now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Aren't there alot of lakes closer to the 3M plant than Twin Lakes in Crystal?? Makes me wonder about the rest of the lakes in Mpls/St Paul.

I don't eat any fish from the lakes in the Metro area anyway because of the polution concern

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used to fish Twin Lake alot in the winter. Mostly for pike.

I'd put out a couple of tip ups, sit in the truck and read the paper and wait for a flag.

If a flag didn't fly by the time I was done, I'd do the crosswords. If nothing by then, I would usually wind it up and make the long five minute drive home.

I ate a couple of pike out of there years back, pickled em. Then I read in the Minnesota Volunteer where pickling doesn't destroy parasites like tapeworm larvae that might be in the meat....that pretty much ended my pike fishing in the winter.

But I was thinking about something? Wouldn't a person get a higher dose of the contaminant by cooking on a Teflon surface, or spraying, or using a product like ScotchGard? Way more then what a fish fillet would contain.

You can still buy Teflon stuff, we got a gridle for Christmas,so I'm wondering,where is the contamination from the new products going now?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can still buy Teflon stuff, we got a gridle for Christmas,so I'm wondering,where is the contamination from the new products going now?

Nowadays they have facilities that can get rid of things like toxic wastes legally and safely. I know it was kind of a chick flick, but Erin Brockovich was a pretty good movie showing the effects of things like this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I ate a couple of pike out of there years back, pickled em. Then I read in the Minnesota Volunteer where pickling doesn't destroy parasites like tapeworm larvae that might be in the meat....that pretty much ended my pike fishing in the winter.

Before putting the fish in the brine it should be frozen. That will kill a lot of the parasites that cooking would normally kill.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you completely freeze your nortins' first you won't have any parasite problem.Lived in bc for over forty years,used to eat sunnies,norts out of Twin weekly(Were not growing gills ,yet?)c63

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Popular Now

  • Posts

    • Thanks for the input guys.

      I did try to look up stuff on line but wasn't convinced of anything there either.

      I've been told the first pic IS honey mushrooms by a person who harvests them.

      The closest thing I found for the second pic was a false truffle.  I was hoping they might be the real deal since I'm seeing them just poking out of the ground around the oaks.  They are pretty solid.

      The third one does have gills, I believe, and develops into a flat cap if it can get to like its third day before the squirrels chomp them down.

      I saw another new one last night growing on an old oak stump but didn't take a pic.

      I agree - I don't eat if I don't know...

    • That's a lot of hens Caddis - nice find!  I had three babies just starting last weekend in my woods, so I'm hoping to get some this weekend.  I've found hens through October by me (South of Metro), so we still have a full month of good shrooming ahead of us.

    • Yep.  I think most people fall into that "rookie" category with mushrooms.  There are 1000's of them.  I think it's best to just learn a handful of the safe/choice shrooms and just admire the rest from a distance.  I had the same guess as Caddis, the 1st pic might be old Honey mushrooms, but they could be old Jack o lanterns too.  In other words - I have no idea!  The 2nd pick looks like an old gem studded puffball.  And the 3rd one I have no idea.  Generally, you need more info to get close to identifying them.  Examples:  Pic of underside to detemine if gills or pores; pic of cut shroom to see if they bruise a color or if it's solid/hollow inside; where it was growing (on wood or on ground, what type of tree etc.; any significant smell etc.  Every little piece of info helps to ID.  And even with all the info, there's a ton that simply fall into the "I don't know - don't eat it" category.

    • On 8/9/2016 at 9:59 PM, monstermoose78 said:

      I picked up this sign

      image.jpeg

      Lets try it like this.

      image.thumb.jpeg.8224b090f90bf86e1e962663f47e18b4.jpeg

      monstermoose78 likes this
    • Yah - great looking decoys!

      MJ - I'm just letting you know I'm breaking into your house and stealing your spear rack.  And mount.

      I found a rickety old 5 tine when I cleaned out the garage.  I might give it a try this season.

      image.jpeg



  • Posts

    • Thanks for the input guys. I did try to look up stuff on line but wasn't convinced of anything there either. I've been told the first pic IS honey mushrooms by a person who harvests them. The closest thing I found for the second pic was a false truffle.  I was hoping they might be the real deal since I'm seeing them just poking out of the ground around the oaks.  They are pretty solid. The third one does have gills, I believe, and develops into a flat cap if it can get to like its third day before the squirrels chomp them down. I saw another new one last night growing on an old oak stump but didn't take a pic. I agree - I don't eat if I don't know...
    • That's a lot of hens Caddis - nice find!  I had three babies just starting last weekend in my woods, so I'm hoping to get some this weekend.  I've found hens through October by me (South of Metro), so we still have a full month of good shrooming ahead of us.
    • Yep.  I think most people fall into that "rookie" category with mushrooms.  There are 1000's of them.  I think it's best to just learn a handful of the safe/choice shrooms and just admire the rest from a distance.  I had the same guess as Caddis, the 1st pic might be old Honey mushrooms, but they could be old Jack o lanterns too.  In other words - I have no idea!  The 2nd pick looks like an old gem studded puffball.  And the 3rd one I have no idea.  Generally, you need more info to get close to identifying them.  Examples:  Pic of underside to detemine if gills or pores; pic of cut shroom to see if they bruise a color or if it's solid/hollow inside; where it was growing (on wood or on ground, what type of tree etc.; any significant smell etc.  Every little piece of info helps to ID.  And even with all the info, there's a ton that simply fall into the "I don't know - don't eat it" category.
    • Lets try it like this.
    • Yah - great looking decoys! MJ - I'm just letting you know I'm breaking into your house and stealing your spear rack.  And mount. I found a rickety old 5 tine when I cleaned out the garage.  I might give it a try this season.
    • I can't identify any of those for sure, and certainly wouldn't recommend eating any of them.  The first pic might be some older honey mushrooms, but it's pretty tough to tell.  I've got about 8 mushrooms that I can positively id.  Beyond that, it's just not worth being wrong.  There are still some fresh hen of the woods mushrooms around the metro if you get out into some oak woods.  You can find them around the base of big mature oaks and they are pretty easy to identify.  Found about 20 on Wednesday.  Many were a little old, but was able to take 4 nice ones home.  Here's a pic of one that I left behind.
    • I'm putting it on my calendar.  Don't forget the Nord Lord trophy since it has a new home to go to. 
    • Detroit News breaks 143 year tradition, endorses Gary Johnson.   The endorsement is the first time in the paper’s 143-year history it has endorsed someone other than the Republican Party’s nominee. http://www.breitbart.com/news/detroit-news-breaks-tradition-endorses-libertarian-gary-johnson/  
    • Kind of like Trump did Monday night.
    • Gets on a bunch of talk shows. Jumps another 5 points in the polls.. This just ain't working the way it's supposed to...
  • Our Sponsors