Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
cm1977

Alumacraft or G3

17 posts in this topic

I am looking at getting either a 2008 Alumacraft Trophy 175 with a Honda 115 or a 2008 G3 V175 FS with a Yamaha 115. Anyone have any thoughts on going one way or the other?

Thanks for your help!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a G3 172T with 75hp Yamaha. Looked at the Alumacrafts, but didnt like the layout. I was told that the hull thickness is better on G3. My opinion is that G3 builds a fine boat. They just havent been around that many years so they're not as well known.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can you get the Alumacraft with the Yamaha? If that was an option I would go with the Alumacraft with the 115 Yamaha. Otherwise I am partial to Alumacrafts. IMO of the aluminum boats they are the best built. The fit and finish (attention to details) is something Alumacrafts do well, again IMO.

The Alumacraft has a bigger fuel tank, bigger livewells and the bow live well includes a bait storage system. The G3 does have a thicker hull, .200" vs. .160". I don't know if the .040" would make the hull noticably more rigid or if the ride would be any different. The Alumacraft is a few inches longer and 90 lbs lighter. Both are the same width.

Check both of them out, sit in both, poke around, see which one you like best.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can get the Alumacraft with the Yamaha. I've been looking at Alumacrafts for a while myself. I haven't looked at the Honda's because they are heavier (I think). As casey said, the Yamaha is the way to go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Alumacraft with Yamaha IMO. Better yet, at least for the pocketbook, Alumacraft with a Suzuki. Bulletproof motor for a bit less money. Like mentioned before, Honda's are a bit heavier. I'd go Yamaha (or Suzuki) with the Alumacraft.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Honda's are a bit heavier.

Nearly 100 lbs heavier!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would buy which ever one has the best rod storage I have a 98 alumacraft 19.5 and no rod storage drives me crazy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would go with a Alum over a G3. Better boat and higher resale value!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Alumacraft all the way until G3 cleans up a lot of fit and finish issues.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

they have only been out for a few years, and need alot of work!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've got the 07 Tournament pro with a Yammy and I love it.

Plenty of rod storage and the lay out works great for me.

I think i have 5 slots for 8' rods and the rest over 7-7.5'

No issues at all in last 2 seasons.

I think the trophy is very similiar to the TP but cant remember for sure.

G3Who?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Trophy is more of a sport & fish boat where as the T-pro is more of a fishing boat. The Trophy has the bow set up so cushions could be put up there for having more than one person sit up there. The T-pro has it set up for more storage, livewell and then the sweet rod storage set-up.

MuleShack - which T-pro and Yammy do you have?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

185CS with the 150 4 stroke & T8 kicker

I think it was more of the hull design that I was thinking of.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the imput guys! I agree on the Yamaha motor, currently have one on both the fishing boat I am trading in and the pontoon and love them both. The Honda can't be switched out, it is rigged up that way as it is last year's model. The search continues...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I was out last night on a local lake and was surprised to see the water temp down to 57.  Caught a couple cookie cutter fish, but not the big ones I was looking for. Fished a lot of weeds in the 6-9ft range, but not a lot going on there. The biggest one was still shallow in some reeds, so not sure if we are still in the spawn/post spawn stage.     Whats everyone else seeing out there for a bite and fishing conditions. Big weekend coming up, Good luck!! 
    • Maxine_Partain, Welcome to the forum.  There seem to be a lot of folks from Canada joining up in the last half a year which is nice. The sad thing is they all seem to make about 3 posts on the same day they joined and then they never come back which is sad. Hopefully you will keep posting.
    •   Hazel Hain, Welcome to the forum.  There seem to be a lot of folks from Canada joining up in the last half a year which is nice. The sad thing is they all seem to make about 3 posts on the same day they joined and then they never come back which is sad. Hopefully you will keep posting.
    • hi and welcome to HSO. I think you mean double hung not double pane. if you have moisture between the panes you have a seal failure. depending on the brand you might be able to just replace the glass. If you have lots of rot you may need to do a complete replacement. Best to have a window person pop by and check out the situation. 
    • Some times it's just nice getting out of town and when your with the right people a wet weekend can still be fun. This weekend should be better!
    • Cool story! 
    • Reb's old girlfriend might have had a diaphragm, but you would find that one in the lower unit - not in the carburetor...
    • Most of the homeowner's expense comes from heating and cooling inside a home. Double pane windows have gasses like argon or krypton filled to displace the air between the panels. But the problem is when this leaks from the window panes and settles down at the bottom. 1) The main problem that would arise is condensation. The moisture level goes high thus causing mold, mildew and rotting wood sills. 2) If the gas leaks, the window will not provide better insulation. 3) The windows start to make squeaky sounds thus it is hard to close and open. 4) It also affects the stripping to loose. I live here in Canada. In our house, we have double pane windows in almost all the rooms. Now I could see that some of the windows to be in a foggy condition. Will it be due to the gas in the window panes? Should I need to replace the windows? I have heard that casement windows.are good compared to double pane windows. I would like to know the benefits of casement windows. Will it cut down my utility bills? Please do share your thoughts and valuable suggestions. Thanks for the time.
    • We spent last weekend in the camper, holed up hiding from the rain. Not the worst thing ever, but a hike would've been nice. Hopefully we'll have better weather over Memorial Day. It looks good now so I'm excited. 
    • I am in a confusion on which one to choose. I have anyways decided to separate the bath area from the toilet. Which one would be better? I don't have enough area in the bathroom. One of my friends said that when it comes to energy efficiency and water conservation, a quick shower virtually always beats a bath. Is it true??   Although it is good for relaxing and ideal for bathing small children, I think it will be difficult for older people and people with injuries to get in and out. When it comes to the case of water heaters also I think it will be difficult to fill the tub. I think all these issues can be sorted out using a shower. Showers always need only less water. But if there is any leak, it will be difficult to fix.   I personally prefer bathtubs. Although it has many disadvantages compared to showers, the relaxation and freshness we get after bathing in a tube are very different. What is your opinion? Based on your opinion, I want to fix my decision and approach a plumbing company for installing it. Feel free to share your thoughts.
  • Our Sponsors