Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
portageman

British Lab vs Golden Retriever?

Recommended Posts

I want a lab. The wife and daughter want a golden. We need a good upland dog, but also a nice indoor family pet. Post your input, but try to keep it to these two breeds. We have narrowed it down to these two - please dont tell me to look at Springers, Brittanys, GSp's, etc.

So which is it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

#1 factor depends on the breeder. I think there is little difference in tempermant and ability between the breeds as long as they are bred for hunting. Long hair in the upland could be a pain in the rear with sticks and burrs getting tangled.

If you want a brit lab and find a breeding that you like after doing some research, take them both to visit and play with the puppies. I'd be willing to bet you go home with one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd have to vote for the Golden .Biased because I have a 6 yr Golden male and he is a treat .My hunting buddy has a black Lab which is also a great dog .They hunt well together , only down side to the Golden is getting the burrs out if you are in that kind of an area , but I just crush them with a pliers and it really is not much of a problem .Both are very friendly , tough decision , both great choices . Im thinking who takes care of it most of the time should have most of the decision , or two votes to one , you lose, get the Golden .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Best way to choose is to go to the different breeders and observe....Or baby sit my british for a weekend (wink)...after season

fishnbuddy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks guys. I would sure like to read some more opinions. I laughed when I read Budman because I say I get to pick because I will be taking care of it, The girls say they win 2 to 1.

Also, Fishingbuddy - I would have been more than happy to babysit on 10/11, but now I will have to pass.......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tuff decision, I have two Brit labs hunting machines (good lines) so said the people I bought them from. One is 7 one is 1 1/2. I am a lab guy. My brother in law has and incredible golden. Both my dogs and his are well trained. Seems his golden needs less attention. I can only say that I think my dogs have more personality than his but that could be because their mine. I think my labs are more from hunting lines where his dog is like the #1 family house dog ever. My labs have that 5 minutes of caos when I first get home, like I have been gone for 3 months every single day. After that its fine. Good luck dont think you can go wrong in either choice. especially if you get a lab...LOL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Golden Retriever. Hands down for the family dog and they are great hunting dogs. I have had 3 of them and would be my only choice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Portageman- I think rcook72 hit the nail on the head when he said: "Good luck dont think you can go wrong in either choice." I own both a lab and golden. They both have characteristics that stand out - but I would say more because of their unique personalities than their breed. Both are good family pets; both are more than adequate in the field.

I suggest you consider the following when picking the breed of your new pup:

1. are you willing to put in the time to train it properly (if so - you will have an adequate hunter)

2. do you have your family's support with the breed you choose (if so - you will have help raising your pup - which is priceless in the long run)

3. are you willing to put your preconceived notions aside about the ins and outs of each breed (if so - you will have a healthy working relathionship with your individual dog)

oh and FYI - my golden has retrieved more birds than my lab, but i'm not really counting

Have fun and enjoy the process of adding a new member to your family.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was in the same boat 7 years ago. I wanted a lab and the wife wanted a golden. The wife of course won. Doing my research I found that goldens actually have the best noses of all the retrieving breeds. And they are the best of all dogs for the home IMHO. My female has proven that to me many times over. Not taking anything away from a good lab, as they are also an excellent upland dog. In my opinion labs shine in the water where their heavier coats keep them warm. But in the pheasant fields, and grouse woods. The golden shines. Being involved in a couple retriever clubs I deal with one breeder who is awesome that I would recomend you calling. If you want to know email me. You won't be disapointed in the golden if you do your research in a good breeder.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

DRH -

I have never tried to email anybody from the site - I dont even know how to do it. Is that Golden Breeder also in Wyoming?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

we have a golden lab and golden retriever based on our 2 dogs if ur looking for a hunting dog the retriver and house the lab our golden is really high strung dont know bout u guys but ours would be a mess in the house!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have had a Golden for 12 years would'nt trade her for the world.

Great in the house and was great in the field.

Sifty

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will put in another plug for the british lab. I have one. She is a great dog. She loves to hunt, has an insaitable desire to retrieve. She has a great temperment, always wants to please. She is a pretty mellow dog. The british labs have all the great lab features but in a smaller package.

If you are looking on information on breeders I could give you some on the kennel I got my pup from. Shoot me an email if you would like the info:

caseymcq@hotmail.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are looking on information on breeders I could give you some on the kennel I got my pup from. Shoot me an email if you would like the info:

caseymcq@hotmail.com

Sent you an email.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Put me down as another vote for the labs. as long as it is a british lab. I have owned two goldens and a black american lab befor this dog and I cant believe the difference. Very smart and trainable, still a lab but the most mellow lab I've seen and the pure physical ability is unreal. The best way I can desribe it is to compare a pro athlete to the average guy the way he can run and jump and all from a smaller package.

To be fair though this was the first dog I bought from a breeder that has a professional set up and before allways got dogs from a family that might have some for sale at a good price. I allways said I would never pay that much for a dog because it couldnt be that big of a difference to justify the high price

but boy was I wrong. Honestly I've never met a guy with a british lab thats been dissapointed. cant say that about the other dogs. But then again it might have something to do with the british seem to be somewhat newer and have more responsible people breeding them with consideration to the bloodlines and traits they posess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: caseymcq
If you are looking on information on breeders I could give you some on the kennel I got my pup from. Shoot me an email if you would like the info:

caseymcq@hotmail.com

Sent you an email.

I just replied.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know about the Brits but I can say that the Goldens are one of the nicest dogs for all around. But they also have a couple of issues that can cause problems, as I am sure most breeds do also. Goldens are prone to develop allergies and cancer is also a little more of an issue than most other breeds. We just put down our 3rd Golden this morning. This one was 8 years old, the other 2 before him only made it to 7. This one developed cancer, the one before him cancer also and the one before him died from congestive heart failure as a result of lupas. Again, they are great dogs, hunt well with minimal training and are truely a great family dog. But next dog will not be a Golden.....to hard to part with them every 7 or 8 years.

Casey, stop by with your dog sometime so I can see it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will definitely bring Maggie over to see you. It might be a while though, she just threw a litter a week ago.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • So our bear friend came back today and she brought somebody with her. It might be time to quit feeding the birds sunflower seeds until next fall.  
    • I picked up that double bag deal about a month ago at Home Depot here in Sioux Falls. Ironically it was the same weekend we had the big April snow storm.
    • I see Home Depot advertising for Memorial day but no Kingsford double bag on sale. Has anyone seen any on sale anywhere? I am down to my last bag and need to stock up, Memorial weekend is usually the time to do it.
    • Found a cardinal nest in one of my shrub bushes. Cute little gray fuzzy things. I tried to take a picture, but my camera phone sucks, and I didn’t want to bother them. I’m so glad I spent $20 on a cardinal nest box, only to have it sit empty.
    • 20180519_060302.mp4 20180519_060302.mp4
    • Wisconsin's turkeys have survived my visit this year.  One is surely deaf after I managed to miss at 18 paces as he walked past me...  Not sure how that happened...   I feel like I rushed the shot when he started to get nervous.  Passed one jake the first morning that I could have taken at 40yd.   Came very close on two other mature gobblers.   One picked me off as he came around a hay pile at 20yd and immediately turned and ran, very smart bird.   The other came in hot, but decided to do a circle around me.  Appeared at 30yd wide open to my side while I was aiming down the sights towards his last gobble, and I had no chance to turn and shoot...  
    • Mentored for the Mn DNR women's Turkey hunt on Fri night and Sat morning. Friday was quiet but the birds flew up within 40 yards af the blind so we were hopefull for what the morning would bring. Sat morning was quiet and I waited till shooting hours to make my first yelps which were immediately cut off by 4 different birds. My lady was excited to say the least. She had never seen a turkey in the wild growing up and living in iron range.  Two of the toms gobbled a little after fly down but I could tell the were going north. The other 2 that were to our east gobbled a bit but shut up but sounded like the were coming down the road towards us. After about 20 minutes they rolled a big triple gobble within 60 yards wondering where this hen was at. I gave them a few purrs and set the call down getting her ready and calming her down for the shot. We still had not seen them put I could hear that unmistakable sound,pfffft boooom. Now I'm getting excited because I know they are danger close but they are on the side we can not see. Like always they proved me a fool and instead of coming right up the little road the cut through a high spot in the swamp and pop out in the field at 30 yards. They immediately hit full strut and throw a huge gobble right in our face and directly at my decoy that is set up at 8 yards. Then instead of coming right in they circle the decoy and blind at 25 yards and go to the side of the blind that is closed and gobble and strut for 15 min finally working into 8 to 10 yards bit still won't come towards the decoy. So I shut the one blind window and get her moved for a shot. The birds are now at 18 yards but getting skittish and moving away. As soon as I get the window open I hear her string drop and whay sounded like a hollow feathery smack and she says she got it. I look up and the birds are still there and look just a little nervous so I hit the call and they gobble back so I know it was a miss. So close but it was so much fun. Those 2 birds hung out for a few hours after strutting and gobbling at everything. 
    • Great bird, way to keep at it.
    • Nice bird, good job!
    • I assuming you are putting on the 5/16 T & G? I pushed mine tight and face nailed. Two nails per stud