IS Cuddy worth 7.66 million??

[UdeLakeTom]

Anybody see the play when Cuddy cut down the runner on the ground ball to 1st??? Excellant fielding again by the Twins.

[PierBridge]

Why is that impossible. Am I missing something here, granted the month is not over, so I assume he is the leader in the AL, so far with 2 days left.

I was kidding Gary. Everybody knows Cuddy is the hottest, Clutchest hitter in the league at the most important time of the year. Some just can't admit it is all...LOL.

Delmon remains solid and is producing big time.

That throw the other day, when he nailed that guy at 2nd was incredible he may have the best arm in the majors to be honest. If he can improve in the many other area's he is weak in he may still make it as a starter... long long way to go though both offensivley and defesively before we get out hopes up on that ...

Go Delmon!

[Gary Crichton]

Good PB I thought I was losing it there. He has a arm.

Just a prediction, since the M and C didn't fare to well at the bat in the first game, look out for game # 2.

[fishin58]

Sponge bath between games for Griddlecakes? Denard said "I am goin to get me a big sandwich."

[fishin58]

Oh where oh where could my Cuddles Be? HMMM the spongebathers have let the tub get cold.

[Gary Crichton]

Him and Mauer flew the coop yesterday. Both of there bats non existant. They must be saving themselves for tonight and Thursday.

[fishin58]

We can only hope.

[SledNeck]

I dont think cuddy can see verlanders fastball

[HOT SPOT]

Delmon does NOT have that good of a arm dont kid yourself PierBridge.

[Gary Crichton]

I don't think he was alone.

[SledNeck]

Delmon was actually rated as having one of the best arms in baseball. Hes made some outstanding throwouts to home.

[HOT SPOT]

Sledneck- where U that ratting from? I would like to read that. Does that mean that He has a better arm than Cuddy?

[Gary Crichton]

Delmon does have a good arm. I think what is missing is the accuracy of the throw.

[SledNeck]

Delmon does have a good arm. I think what is missing is the accuracy of the throw.

Pull up some highlights, he looks pretty accurate to me

[DHanson]

What the heck is Cuddyer swinging at? I know he had a hot streak for a while, but where is the consistency? Some of those pitches aren't even close to the strike zone that he's swinging at.

[fishin58]

hmmmmmmmm, looks like Delmon is now batting .279 and cuddles is .277 hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

[S.D. Ice Angular]

This topic has reached 23 pages

Whoa!!!

[SledNeck]

hmmmmmmmm, looks like Delmon is now batting .279 and cuddles is .277 hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

HEH, I was gonna wait till the season was over to start a stats comparison topic.

[PierBridge]

Originally Posted By: fishin58

hmmmmmmmm, looks like Delmon is now batting .279 and cuddles is .277 hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

HEH, I was gonna wait till the season was over to start a stats comparison topic.

Why wait!

Let's start with Delmons' MLB leading worst Strikeout to Walk ratio.

Delmon Young has walked 11 times the entire season "no that's not a misprint" and Struck out 90 TIMES.

Cuddyer who strikes a lot and is one of his weaker area's like a lot of power hitters do would have to strike out close to 400 times to be the equal of Delmon in this category for the year.LOL!

Fun stat: there are 11 major league PITCHERS who have a better ratio than Delmon...LOL.

Rather than waste time Cuddyer crushes Delmon in almost every category and Young has no category where he dominates Cuddyer at all.

On base percentage by 40 points, Slugging percentage by a whopping 100 pts, Home-runs, RBI's, Stolen base percentage, Feilding percentage, Player of week, Player of Month, web gems, extra base hits, walks.

Throw in the tangibles like Class, being a team player, Brain power "understanding the game", and like ablilty in the Clubhouse where Cuddy crushes Delmon 100 percent to ZERO before, during and after the latest tantrum/meltdown it makes for an BLOW-OUT but we all know that expect, Fish58 who has admitted some of this although reluctantly and Sled the CHIEF Cuddy basher who can't come to grips with his horrible evalution/assessment before during and after Cuddy CRUSHED him and with his 30 Dinger 90 RBI, Gold Glove "2 posistions" MVP type of season!...

And save the blah blah blah about how how Cuddy has played more than Delmon... if you have to ask why Cuddyer has played more than Young this year please leave the forum NOW...LOL.

Truthfully there isn't much of case to have had Delmon play over Go-Go but at least it's not totally re-donk-uless like this Cuddy vs Young comparison.

Truthfully it's a disgrace to even compare the two at all but hey it's a free country so have at it...

[SledNeck]

MVP type season?.. now thats delusional. Seriously.

Could someone with Cuddy's batting avg and less than 100 RBI (considering where he bats in the order) ever win MVP?

1965 was the last yer someone with a lower batting avg than Cuddy has now won MVP

explain how hes having an MVP type season again?

[PierBridge]

Not league MVP, team MVP "type". Mauer aside he is our Team MVP just for his cluch performance that kept us in the race and if you have to ask why ...never mind!

[greebs]

I'd rate him about equal to kubel as far as team value goes but both would still be behind mauer, morneau, and span.

[SledNeck]

Not league MVP, team MVP "type". Mauer aside he is our Team MVP just for his cluch performance that kept us in the race and if you have to ask why ...never mind!

Id rate Kubel, Morneau and Span over Cuddy for team MVP (Pos. player)

[Gary Crichton]

Ya Sledneck, but your holding a grudge for some odd reason against Cuddy, but to each his own opinion. Not saying he is # 1 but # 2 or 3 would fit nicely.

[SledNeck]

#5 works for me

1. Mauer

2. Morneau

3. Kubel

4. Span

5. Cuddy