Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Musky Buck

Wisc. success ?

20 posts in this topic

Sunday star and trib stated Wisc. rifle season hunters took 276,000 deer. In 2007 we took in MN 260,000 deer. I know the issue is mature bucks between the 2 states, but isn't that a low harvest for Wisc. and don't they have about 200,000 more rifle hunters than MN ? If any of this is true what happened in Wisc. why the low number when alledgedly they had good weather for hunting ? Just curious ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What is the speculation on it ? Perfect weather is what I heard, they have a later opener than MN, they have another 500,000 animals than MN, another couple hundred thousand hunters, ??? What's up ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe the pressure being placed on the outdoors with the volume of people are producing a much more nocturnal herd ? Things out there have changed. Remember when the boom on Laq Qui Parle geese was in October ? Now they say come much later, November is when the refuge peaks, are our deer feeling the same way, are they sensing the change or are they not as strong in numbers as we believe they are ? My area is a 5 deer area, zone 2, area 240, from the past 2 years I'd say we should be applying for a doe permit in some of that area, I'm seeing very few deer, even before season and the wintering herd has shrunk sustantially.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh don't even bring this up to friends of mine from Wis. They are ticked off with all the earn a buck, T-zone, etc. things going on over there. There are some real doubts as to the esitmated number of deer in Wis. and the way they are being managed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

we hunt north of hayward and saw all types of deer, both on the stand and doing deer drives. we also shot two very nice bucks, including the biggest ever for my camp, around 150 class. this is in a herd control unit. so to sum it up i personally don't believe there are problems with the wisc herd, it just hunting, the guys who put in the most time will more than likely get a chance, it just happened that my chance came on thanksgiving morning when the herd came by, 3 does and a nice eight, and my darn gun wouldn't shoot, well thats why it called hunting and not killing i guess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:
3 does and a nice eight, and my darn gun wouldn't shoot,

OMG, that happens to me in my dreams all the time. I'm hunting, see a nice buck, and no matter how hard I squeeze the trigger, its like the safety stays on. Happens almost all the time, very frustrating dreams.... LOL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What is the speculation on it ? Perfect weather is what I heard, they have a later opener than MN, they have another 500,000 animals than MN, another couple hundred thousand hunters, ??? What's up ?

I bet all the deer crossed the mighty mississippi when the season started and ended up in the SE part of the state. MNDNR conducted their deer count for this area at that time. We can still shoot 5 deer now because of this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ya i wish it was a dream, now i have a reoccuring nightmare everytime i even think about deer hunting, buck in my scope 30 yards broadside, pull the trigger, nothing, check the chamber, oh theres a bullet in there alright, check the saftey, its definitely off, buck stops this time 20 yards away. pull the trigger, nothing, look at gun ready to cry and boom, only problem is it went off 10 seconds after i pulled the trigger. whats really fun is i shot two does in minnesota, no problems there, finally get a chance at a buck and i got problems. not lol, definitely not a laughing matter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BullMN, in my area it is a 5 deer area still, couple years ago our group quit buying the bonus bambi permits because we aren't seeing deer like we did 5 years ago, way less. Any thoughts on the early antlerless rifle hunts ? The year they did it in my area I saw 14 fawns and 3 bucks. I've seen 2 does in the past 3 years of rifle hunting. Couldn't they hold that hunt after rifle season statistics are in ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe the deer are getting smarter.

I wouldn't necessarily agree. My father and I own some land and we harvested 9 deer this year alone between the regular season and the 2 doe seasons. 2 guys, 9 deer. no more buying beef for a LONG while!!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Snow doesn't lie, deer aren't smart enough to figure out a way not to leave tracks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's the thing Eddie, I mean Cooter, I have monitored wintering herds on my 3 separate areas for 25 years and it's way down, the snow is the key, the tracks aren't there and driving around those sections of land thousands of times noting way fewer deer, but we still can get 5 tags.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: Bear55
Maybe the deer are getting smarter.

I wouldn't necessarily agree. My father and I own some land and we harvested 9 deer this year alone between the regular season and the 2 doe seasons. 2 guys, 9 deer. no more buying beef for a LONG while!!!!!

I was joking there. No doubt deer numbers are way down across most of MN and WI, I think some of you are right, too many extra tags/deer being shot the past 4-5 years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In Wisconsin, at least the zone that I hunt in, you could ultimitely buy an unlimited number of tags if you wanted to. Is that excessive? I agree. There should be a limit on the number of tags that you should be able to buy. In reality though, my immediate family (2 adults and 1 infant) can eat 5 deer a year. We eat almost exclusively venison and/or wild game (fish, pheasent, waterfowl, etc) instead of domesticated meat because it's cheaper in the long run and healthier. Who knows how many growth hormones and whatever else is added to cattle and poultry.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We Hunt North of Pepin, near Plum City. We got 4 deer between 2 hunters. I dont know about perfect weather, It was windy where we were and we saw relatively little pressure from other hunters. That combined with the fact that most of the Farmers still had thousands of Acres of corn left standing in the fields and that more than accounts for the lack of deer seen/taken. The deer had no reason to move. Talk to bow hunters, they have said they saw all kinds of deer. We also went out for the late antlerless season, I had one down before I got out to my stand and saw a total of 24 deer that day(I went out at 3 pm) 10 in the first 15 minutes. There are plenty of deer. In the interest of full disclosure--Zone 61, EAB/Herd Management.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Where is the part where I say I am OK with it?
    • The CWD 'outbreak' in the 4 counties in the NW part of Wisconsin I believe is one case in the NW part of Barron County, or some where close to where those counties all meet.  All counties within X miles (40 miles?) of a positive result are considered CWD counties.  For the year or two after the found positive in that area the MN DNR did test deer in the neighboring MN area(s.)  I was hunting in both Burnett County, WI and east of Hinckley, MN in the year the positive test was found.  It's been awhile, the numbers might be off, but that was generally what happened.   How much money do you want our DNR to spend on so few positive results so far away?
    • We should never have Koivu on the ice in a 3 on 3 OT...Wait, he scored last night. He is phenomenal in OT, finishes with the same move Parise tried moments before him and failed. WTG Koivu! Insert half sarcastic, half praise here... Needed the win, got it. Mcdavid held in check.   Parise is the highest paid 4th line player. There is still something wrong with him. His stride hasn't looked right in over a year. Hope he just stays off the ice if he isn't going to get it together.
    • Looks like after today we'll be making some of the hard stuff!!! Here in the metro anyways
    • Waiting on a reply from the DNR but should be soon
    • They are all the same as the other hook models just a different screen. The Hook is just a re-branded Elite Chrip.
    • Appeared to be a nice product. I was not impressed with the sales guy or who ever he was at the Blane show. I asked if they sell the LED extrusion they had running along both sides of the trailer and he said its their own design I can get them if I buy a trailer bla bla bla... Once I stepped away a salesman from Coates RV said that he can get the extrusion for me being its nothing special! I have little time for people that lie to me, if he didn't know a better answer is no we don't sell to the public or i don't know.
    • One reason for me to be muzzleloading is to scout areas for next bow season.  I liked this low area I found yesterday.  I got a good feel for how the deer use it.  Saw one small 8 and had two put their tracks in mine, but out of sight.  I'd hunt it differently with a bow.  
    • wear a good balaclava and get a open face with a cold weather breath box never had a problem
  • Our Sponsors