Musky Cradle vs Net

[NCLaker]

I need a net/cradle, been using freinds when we go out. I think I can pick up a used cradle for pretty cheap, but not sure if I will like that style of capture tool. Decent hoop style nets seem pretty spendy.

I like that the cradles are pretty compact for storage, but am concerned that it is more difficult to land a fish in them.

Looking for comments/recommendations on personal experience with the use of Cradle vs traditional hoop syle net.

If hoop style is definitely the way to go, what do you recommend for a guy starting out that won't break the bank (please include minimum hoop size, features you like, etc.)

Thanks!

[HugoBox]

If you fish alone at all I think a craddle would be tough. That said I've never used one so I can't comment on which is better.

[50inchpig]

Net! Net! Net!

It is next to impossible to leave a fish in the water and work on them with a cradle, especially if you're by yourself. Sooner than later, you'll get one that requires some work and it won't be pretty dealing with the cradle. I speak from experience - using a net buys you much more time and you can cut hooks, etc while keeping the fish in the water, otherwise you're bound to end up with a dead fish or a hook in your hand before too long.

My biggest net concern is weight, find something that's light and easy to maneuver. Highly recommend checking the buy/sell boards all the fishing sites you use and you should be able to find an affordable one pretty easily. Try to avoid the thin, light mesh for the fishes sake.

[MUSKY18]

As 50 said..........NET NET NET NET!!!

Among the reasons already stated above here is another factor to consider when using a cradle. Now you or your buddy has a nice fish on, lets say a Double CowGirl. You put the cradle into the water, while the fish is lead head first into the cradle. Now that is one pretty upset fish, with a large set of 8/0 hooks in it coming directly towards you. It has the potential to end up not so good!!!

I used a cradle for quite a few years back in the day and they were nothing but trouble for me. With the nets that are out now days, you just can't go wrong with them. As for a weight problem like 50 said, I have a Beckman Musky Master and it is perfect. My 7 year old nets fish for me with it. They make it easy to work with the fish, keeps them breathing in the water, and are easy to use when fishing by yourself.

[DHanson]

Net for sure.

I would buy a nice net the first time, otherwise you will find out that some nets are bad for the fish and are a pain in the a$$. I really like the Frabill big kahuna. Big net, friendly to the fish, and gives the angler a lot of room to work with the fish while it's in the water. You can't go wrong with a big beckman either.

I have found out that with all of the rods, reels, and fishing lures a muskie fishermen purchases, a net (even a really nice one) is really not very expensive compared to your total investment in the sport. Do not go cheap on the must have items: a good net, a knipex hook cutters, mouth spreader, long pliers, and I even suggest a hook pick.

[JRedig]

Also a vote for the net here. And that last paragraph of DHanson's post, wisdom there.

I spent $140 on my net, i'd do it again tomorrow without thinking twice, same goes for a knipex.

[Ice-King]

buy the net it is a lot easier when you go out by yourself

[10,000 Casts]

Net is the way to go... Beckman, Frabill and Stowmaster are the big 3 brands. None of them are cheap. If cost is an issue, you should be able to find a used one in pretty decent shape like stated above. I love my beckman and wouldn't trade it for the world. Just find one that meets your needs and likes.

[guideman]

I have been guiding for Muskies for 23 years and I have used the craddles in the past. They are a pain in the rear, especially when it comes to bigger fish. They also are magnets for hooks and that can only lead to bigger problems.

As was mentioned above, the Big 3 all make great nets. I have both a Beckmen and a frabil, the beckmen is lighter, but I like them both. If you can find a used net somewhere you can always buy a new basket for it if it's in poor condition. I'd also like to ad my voice to the others that mentioned buying all the best release tools.

Even if it's never come up, the time will come, sooner or later when you're going to wish you had them. Believe me!

"Ace"

Ace guide service

[TheHawgTrough]

Cradles are the best! I've got one in the garage with very little use that I'd be willing to sell you....

Like everyone stated above, get a good, quality net. You won't regret it.

[NCLaker]

Thanks for all the advice everyone! Looks like I'll be going the net route ... sorry Hawg, won't be needing your cradle

[fishcast]

Cradles are the best! I've got one in the garage with very little use

[NCLaker]

...As was mentioned above, the Big 3 all make great nets. I have both a Beckmen and a frabil, the beckmen is lighter, but I like them both. If you can find a used net somewhere you can always buy a new basket for it if it's in poor condition. I'd also like to ad my voice to the others that mentioned buying all the best release tools...

"Ace"

Ace guide service

Took your advice and found a great deal on a basically new second hand Beckman. I think it is the Magnum Fin Saver. Got a sweet price at $75. I'm good to go now, Thanks again all for your advice. Now alls I need to do is put some fish in it

[TomWehler]

FinSaver is a hootman of a net.

Been using one since Bruce Beckman came out with it.....super, super way to go.

Thinking of fish first is very special...not to mention you got a good deal.

T.