Is It Too Early To Get an American Idol Thread Going?

[fishlakeman]

I pretty much agree with you Windy. I think Kristy Lee's performance tonight wasn't all that special, but think her looks will carry her into the next round. I think Kady appears way too inmature to carry foward, sometimes looking as if she were stoned or something.

[paceman]

I agree that Luke and sissy boy Danny should go. Kady should have left last week so she is a gonner this week. The second girl is tougher but I will go with Aisha as well. I think if Kristy develops a country feel to her songs she will go a long ways. It was fun to see Amanda and Brooke do well last night. It should be a very good top twelve....

[TwinkeeDink]

Yep, would agree with most. Kady actually was surprised when she didn't go last week. My 2nd would also be Aiesha. Brooke has started to pick it up. i don't know how much longer the rocker chick will last, her song didn't impress me that much and how long can everyone put up with her rocking out. she doesn't have the skills to sing a variety of songs, which she's proven already.

[Windy City Walleye Hunter]

Wow,

And here I thought I was the only one that picked up on the Aisha vibe! I guess I was not seeing things. She has been a powerful singer but this week just left me a little disappointed and when you get to this stage you have to "bring it" as Randy says, every time! We shall see.

Windy

[TwinkeeDink]

Dawg, dawg, what's goin' on?

[Windy City Walleye Hunter]

Yo, Yo, Yo,

Jus keepin it real!

Windy

[lawdog]

Good lookin out though...dude.

What language does Randy speak???

I didn't really think any of the girls stood out either horribly or really good last night. Nothing to get real excited about. Kady and Amanda would be the safest guess as to who's going home, but I realy don't know.

On the other side, has to be the third gal leaving with Danielle Noriega and then I think Luke Menard or maybe Jason Castro.

[Windy City Walleye Hunter]

I don't know about Amanda, Lawdog. I thought she "brung it" last night as Randy says. I would have had her tabbed a week ago but the three stooges all gushed over her, even Simon! I think she is safe which means somebody else has to go!

Windy

[lawdog]

Ya I thought she sounded good last night too, but she is just so one dimensional. She's always doing the exact same thing with every song.

[Windy City Walleye Hunter]

Most definitly a one trick pony!

[mike morris]

See ya Danny! Thank you god.

[The Grebe]

Well, I called it right for the guys(I use that term loosely) didn't see the gals last night, out plowing, so I couldn't venture a guess.

It didn't break my heart that that Asia left, I thought she should have went last week before that Lushinton girl.

That other one that left was really easy on the eyes, thats for sure! That girl was purdy! She has talent and a voice, but she just couldn't make it happen....I bet old H. Hefner for one, is already drawing up a contract!

Little Danny Bananie will have to take his little wounded dove act to another venue, but like William Hung and Sanjaya, I suppose he will hang around for awhile? Ain't gonna miss him or that other guy, thats for sure!

[fishlakeman]

Good vote-off's tonight. I agreed with everyone of em. I'm sure happy Kristi Lee wasn't voted off. I would've been [PoorWordUsage] she never got to do here Country routine, being the country girl she is. Can't wait for next week. I'd say right now everyone of them is good. Not a weak one of the bunch except maybe Amanda.

[Sandmannd]

I like the vote offs, wooulda liked to see Chickodee go, but I'll take this. So glad Danny girl is gone. Was worried there for a bit.

[paceman]

Yes I am also extremely happy that Danny Boy is gone. I just couldn't stand that clown. I disagree with Paula, he is not a bright shiny star. He was a queer little freak that will fade away and never be heard from again. Unless he tries out again next year. God Forbid. The other picks were not surprising. Aisah has a future IMO but none of the others.....

[muc33]

Come on paceman, You don't think Danny was "SPICY" like Airhead said. Tell me, did you think she was totally on the bottle this week or what. Come on, after how many seasons you would think you could spit out one simple sentance after another without making yourself sound stupid every line????

ok the whole spicy thing about Danny,ewwwwwwwww .............. I think I just tasted a little throw up!!

[Windy City Walleye Hunter]

"So my four votes are Danny and Luke for the boys and Kady and Aisha for the girls with Kristy Lee sneaking by in next to last place."

I hate to toot my own horn, I would much rather find a pretty lady to do that for me,(insert rim shot here) but this ole gunslinger nailed all four targets and I nailed Kristy Lee as the bubble girl!

I loved it when it came down to Chickeze and Danny Boy, the look on Chickeze's face when Ryan said his name, you just know that he thought he was the one leaving. Then when Danny Boy was singing his last song Chickeze was like Mr. Bojangles out there movin and groovin!

All in all I think the correct whackings occured but I would have loved to hear Aisha sing the current Alicia Keys song out there today. I think she has that kind of voice and I think she will surface in the music world. Danny, Luke and Kady will just fade into the sunset, never to be heard from again.

Windy

[Deitz Dittrich]

I really think that if you dont make the top 12 I doubt you will make it in the industry. The final 12 are decent.The best final 12 hands down. But there are a few left that I can pretty much pick will be out first..

[Windy City Walleye Hunter]

Agreed!

But I think we will be hearing something from Aisha. She has some pipes and a great personality but just picked the wrong song at the wrong time. I think she was a little over her ski's on that song.

Windy

[Deitz Dittrich]

I think these contestants really need to pay attention to past years mistakes... Whitney songs have made more people go home than just about any...Dont pick em!!!! Find a song you can sing, and go for it.

[Sandmannd]

You're right on Deitz. Plus pick some younger songs. I know you want to show off your voice but have some fun. The 80's had some real fun songs and I don't think they did a good job of covering it.

[Meaney]

no they didnt, they are always going with the tough ones..and lame ones. Wait, most 80s songs were lame

[Deitz Dittrich]

LMAO @ Meany!!!! that made me chuckle!

[bassNspear]

i was very upset that asia got voted off last night. I really liked that girl.

[Windy City Walleye Hunter]

I think you will hear from her again, Spear! She had some pipes, and a great story. I don't think I could have auditioned 2 days after my dad had died. Touching stuff.

Windy