Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
grousehunter

otter, frabill or clam?

11 posts in this topic

I am planning of buying a new portable this year and I am focusing on flip overs. It only needs to fit me and my dog while fishing(dog is going to be 80lbs plus). I would prefer to keep it as light as possible since I will be towing it by hand/dog power. The ones I am thinking of are the team wild perch one man or two man, frabil commando/recon dlx or clam guide/pro/scout.

If you had to pick one of these shelters for you and a dog which one would you choose keeping price, space, durability, weight and ease of use/set-up in mind. I will also be using a long rod...38" laker rod this year.

If you have one of these could you post pictures of the inside to show how much room there really is? Do not have a place to check them out in Ely.

Thanks,

Blake

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I own portables made by all three. So I will give you my opinion. With the dog as a factor you can pretty much cut out the Fish Trap Pro or Scout. I have both and fill them up myself, and know people way skinnier than myself who do as well. The seat design would on a Fish Trap would also make me question room for your dog. I own a Frabil two man and really like thier seats and dark color for heat and visability. Sled strength is not near as strong. Otter sleds are by far the thoughest sleds on the market, no questions asked. Weight wise they are no different, just make sure you check that information out on the sleds you are looking to purchase, they all list that information. The Otter material is not as prone to frosting up as the Fish Trap or Frabill. For sled depth and durability, for you and the pooch, I would have to think the Otter is going to suit you best. My $.02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would suggest for your situation the Frabill Trekker DLX. I think you would have more than enough room with this house and it wouldn't be a back breaker to haul around. The Commando and Recon are the one man houses and might be a bit tight with a dog and yourself.

Good luck with your decision.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also own a "Pro" and I think it would be tight with an 80lb dog in there. It would work though. Just depends how comfortable you want to be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First off I would highly recommend the 2 man version no matter which brand you go with. If you spend any extended time on the ice it is so much nicer to have the room. I have an Otter Lodge II and although it may not be the least expensive or the lightest it has plenty of room both inside and in the sled. I also bring the dog along and I did a simple mod to my sled that allows the dog to keep off the ice. I pretty much just decked the whole sled. It is a bit heavy but with a long rope you can easily pull it with your waist. Hyfax also seems to help. I posted a few pictures of this mod earlier:

http://www.fishingminnesota.com/forum/ub...Mods#Post612762

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ditto on the 2 man. I've got the Eskimo Quick Flip II andit'sbig enough for the wife and I and not too big for just me. I wouldn't want it any smaller.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have the scout and the guide and the guide would work if you are not to big. A 38" rod might be alittle tight. I use 32" rods and that is comfortable in the guide. Using the guide with one seat out would work well for fido. As for the quality compared to the rest you will get a magnatude of personnal preferences. I have Fish traps because they were a good deal and fit for me. Would i be happy with the others? Probably. What looks the best to you is what you should get.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would also say go with a two man for the room especially if your best friend is going to be going out on the ice with you. I would recommend and otter or a clam personally I don't like the frabils I have fished out of all that much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have an older otter cabin. TONS of room solo. Very easy to fish two (or 1 + dog). I've actually crammed 3 in, one sitting on a bucket near the door with all of us fishing one hole. Not ideal, but it worked. Heavier (95 lbs) but not impossible to drag by hand through snow, and I load it down pretty good with power auger, extra 12v batteries, little cooler with cold ones, flasher, camera, etc. Might also want to look at the Otter Team Wild series. 2 man is cheaper and 20 lbs lighter (75 or 76 lbs). Has a much lighter sled. I'm not brand dedicated, but I liked the extra height vs the FT Guide. Haven't fished in the Frabills though. The new ones in the store seem nice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    •   Just outlaw anything that might hurt someone.    If it saves just one life..... Do it for the children....   And they want us to believe these 2 political parties are different. 
    • Luckily for me my neighbor across the road bought a hive with 2500 or 25,000 bees, I forget, last summer. Have bees everywhere here in the summer and we plant a lot of flowers and will be increasing that this summer to help the little dudes. Even got a jar of honey from him last year!
    • I think just about anything can be smoked. would be easy to get the crappies over dry. they turned out great using the technique above. dang near as good as smoked eggs!  
    • Raised beds, you hear people talk about them but what are they? Depending on how much money you want to spend on material and dirt a raised bed can be just a couple 2x8’s nailed together to waist high beds that you don’t need to bend over to work. Now that waist high one will with dirt is going to cost you some compared to the shallow 2x8 bed. Either way a raised bed does some or all of the following things. It eliminates the need for tilling, as you never step into the bed thus compacting it. When you fill the bed it allows you too put clean dirt exactly where you want it, not on the paths between beds where you walk and never plant. Weed control is much easier. Containing the crop you are growing is much easier. Harvesting is much easier. You can add fertilizer taylor made for the crop you are growing not fertilizing the entire garden that maybe 30% of that you walk on and don’t grow in.   The last few years I have been switching to low raised beds and container growing. A typical 4x8 bed takes twenty bags of dirt to fill or about 500#’s the beds are so fluffy that I can turn them over with my hand or just a little rake. This season I am going to add three more beds which will give me total of 11 and over 50 five gallon containers. Of course if room is not a problem then traditional planting stills works just fine especially for spuds and melons and squash. Just offering other ideas.
    •   But yet Christians claim they do.....  
    •   The one I made called for cumin. I think next time I might do something in between my recipe and this one.
    • I always thought smoking was for more fattier fish such as lake trout, salmon, suckers, whitefish and the like?
    •     This sounds good. Gonna have to try it   Plus the emphasis on vegetables in most Chilis
    • Buy the best door you can afford. I installed a steel clad Peach Tree door on the front of my place mainly because it faces south and there is a big temp difference during the day. I paid 600.00 for it, not much for a door these days but thirty years ago I had the father in law scratching his head when we put it in. My back door is out of the sun and I went with an all glass Morgan door, 300.00 I think it was still looks almost brand new after all of these years. Love the light that it lets it. Both have adjustable thresholds and we keep an eye on the weather-stripping. Stay away from the box store bargain doors unless it is rental property. Another thing is don't go cheap on the lock sets, you get what you pay for. Also reinforce the jam on the lock side while you are replacing the door.
  • Our Sponsors