Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
mrpike1973

allergic to fish any one else?

15 posts in this topic

hi i have fished for 10 years now have had no problems. went fishing about 2 months ago and had a bad reaction when i was fishing went to the dr he said i was allergic to fish and never ever fish again. so i sold every thing. one week ago i couldnt stand it and went fishing with a borrowed pole. felt fine caught 2 pike no problem then i caught some sunnies then i started getting slightly itchy eyes from the pan fish this old guy comes walking up to the dock and i tell him my little story cant fish he says the doc is full of it said im probably allergic to the alge or whatever in the water. said it happened to him and gets worse in the hot days of summer has any one else heard of this or not. Im one trip away to the tackle shop to buy it all back i know youre not docs but does this make sense

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Never heard of having alergic fish reactions from fishing ... I suppose it's possible.

I use to water ski, but had got so stuffed up from what ever is in the water that I stopped doing it. Didn't bother me if I am fishing or swimming, only water sports.

I would get a second opinion, I would be seriously depressed if I had to give up fishing. Hopefully yuo can find someway to workaround whatever is causing your alergies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hi thanks for the replies i never have had a problem ice fishing. in summer it seems like the panfish bother me more than pike bass or walleye. i would love to go to another doc or allergist but i have no insurance it would cost about 1000 bucks im told for test etc i just felt with all the people on here maybe some one would have heard about it ps if i clean fish pike and walleye never bothered panfish would make me sick how can fish that live together cause that? makes me think

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The last 5 years or so my cousin has been having reactions from fish. He went to the doctor and found out he is allergic to fish slime. The symptoms include itchy eyes and throat- causing him to cough some and at times his hands may swell. I as well the last couple years have been getting itchy eyes from fish( found out when cleaning some). All the doctor told him was to take an allergy tablet- possibly claritin- not sure if thats right. I myself take benadryl when my eyes itch. When he taks the allergy tablets he is perfectly fine. for some reason the fish that he reacts the worst to are trout. We alway joke with each other about this because we are pretty hard core about fishing especially when we get together. We always tell everyone we look on the bright side and are glad we are not allergic to deer too.

MN Angler

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe wearing gloves would work. Also wash your hands after you handle a fish. I'm think you get a little slime on and then maybe rub your eyes a while later and that could cause it. I would do everything I could think of before giving up fishing.

Welcome to FM by the way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My brother is allergic to fish and it has not stopped him from fishing one bit. He is now 27 and we have known close to his whole life. He can not touch any fish/minnow but what really gets him is if we cook or clean fish in the same area as he is. He can walk into a kitchen and know if there has been fish cooked in it in the last week. The easiest way for him to go fishing is to just not go fishing by himself. It is really no big deal for him and I to go for a weekend and for him not to touch a fish. We always have gloves along on the off chance that he catches something picture worthy. We are almost exclusively musky fisherman so I do all of the unhooking/releasing.

Can you be around fish that is being cooked or cleaned?

How about seafood, can you eat seafood?

I have always personally believed that my brother’s allergy is a scam. Not having to ever take fish off, clean fish or put a minnow on doesn’t sound to bad to me.

Let me know if you have any questions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am allergic to fish. I have know since I was very young that I could not eat fish. My tongue and throat would swell up. When I was in around the 7th grade I was helping clean some fish and my hand swelled up so I learned that I could no longer touch fish. When I go fishing now I always have gloves that I wear when I need to handle fish. I still bait my own hook but I am always washing my hands. I use Lindy sportsman no scent soap. I comes in a little white bottle. I believe it is biodegradable so your not polluting the water your fishing in. I also use a hemostat to remove hooks. I still do plenty of fishing. More in the winter because that are not a slimy and smelling and are much easier to handle on the ice. I go fishing for a week in Canada every summer with friends and they do all the fish cooking outside. I also carry an epi-pen just in case. Never had to use it but I figure it cant hurt to have one with.

I am not sure what your case is but you might want to be careful with tree nuts. In my case I have a reation to an oil that both tree nuts and fish have in common.

I am 34 and still fish and plan to keep fishing. I just have to use a little more care and generlly fish with some good friends that don't mind that they will have to cook outside and are willing to clean a few for me once in a while so I can give them to my parents.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have developed a fish alergy in the last few years. 26 years of eating fish or sea food at least once a week then the allergy started. First it was just shell fish, then regular fish as well. For me it is the ability to swallow. My throat gets all tight and my stumack starts turning.

I have not figured it out all the way yet other than the bones thing. If I catch a stray bone or scale I am done. Fish with Y bones are out. Example... I can eat eel pout, but not walleyes.

I have figured out that I can eat smoked fish, like carp,trout, or salmon. But I cannot eat them fresh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep in mind that each reaction is usually worse then the previous.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

wow, I'd never heard of being allergic to fish.. adult onset allergies suck, and that has got to be the worst of them all! I could deal with the [PoorWordUsage] you have to when you're allergic to peanuts or wheat or any of the other big hassle allergies, but to be so allergic that I would have to give up fishing?? Shoot me now, lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not allergic to fish but I am allergic to dogs. I have always owned a dog. All I can say is that if the allergy is not real severe, you will just learn to live with it. You can take allergy meds before fishing, you can wear gloves, you learn not to touch your eyes or nose after handling fish. Wash hands frequently. These are the types of things that I do on a daily basis to be able to put up with having a dog in the house, but I wouldn't want it any other way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

God bless all of you. Talk about a cross to bear...That's a curse like being allergic to beer and sports and swimsuit models all at the same time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Where did you hear that food plots were to be banned?   I have seen about banning "feeding deer"  which I took to mean the classic set up a feeder and dump corn and alfalfa in it.     Jumping on areas immediately has been shown to be successful in preventing isolated cases from spreading and becoming endemic.   Once it becomes established in the herd, it seems as if controlling it is no longer possible.   It also seems as if CWD is fairly hard to catch for a deer, or else it would be all over everywhere and all the deer in an area like Dane county would have it.    Oh, and the infected deer could have come from a deer farm, or from Iowa where it has been detected in the county bordering MN on the SE.    
    • I wouldn't call myself wealthy, but I've made good life choices that have enabled me to buy my own land.  Still pack my own lunch and watch for sales at the grocery store.  I don't own land in SE MN, I own land in northern MN.  The reason I am concerned is that this will serve as a template for herd control tactics in other parts of MN.  Understand that the game management agencies have conferences where they talk about managing hunters.  You don't have to look any further than the work of Dr. Gary Alt in Pennsylvania.    I can't put my finger on exactly what is going on with the results the DNR has presented.  Were the samples snuck in by a nefarious actor?  I wouldn't rule it out.  Was the disease always here and just finally discovered?  I don't see why not.  Is there a unique environmental reason that CWD hasn't gotten a broad foothold here?  It's possible.    If the agency had some credibility going into this, I'd be on board pounding kool aid myself, but they don't.  So color me skeptical.  None of the WI border counties along zone 3 have CWD according to this map.  However, Burnett and Polk do and there is no monitoring on our side up there.  Can a scientist explain that to me?  Because the geographic barriers up there are non-existent compared to  the Mississippi River along zone 3.       
    • I made the decision to replace the pump every few years rather than the carpet.
    • On my aluminum skid house I've been using thread cutting stainless steel screws from Fastenal
    • There might be a pleasant surprise in the works.   In the meantime, it is entertaining to watch anyway....      
    • Huh---Guess you must have the butthurt.
    • You are cooking it before you eat it right? I've only heard people using Cure when using dehydrators or may be for jerky when using burger. I have never used the stuff but don't like or make dehydrated jerky.   Seem to still be alive!
    • Creepworm, I am somewhat angry.  The reason it's fool hardy to consider food plots any more threat than a farm field is that the intentions of the planter don't change the flavor of the forage.  A food plot is no more attractive than the edge of a 160 acre bean field that meets a fence line, swamp edge, or grove.     Now imagine there are no farm fields or food plots at all, not even a decent yielding apple tree.  Deer will still communicate via scrape trees and licking branches during the rut.  If the current belief is that the prions spread via saliva, what's to stop wild deer from licking a branch that an infected buck has licked?  What's to stop a buck from rubbing their face all over a contaminated branch?    My fear is that lots of deer are going to be slaughtered in an area that just happens to have been a hot target for eradication before CWD was found.  I'm also worried we're going to get all kinds of bad rules imposed that won't do squat to actually stop the spread if the disease is actually in MN.  I'm worried we'll lose a critical habitat tool that allows us in harsh winter kill areas to help the deer make it through winter (food plots).    It'd be interesting to watch the DNR try to ban food plots.  Good luck defining what is and is not a food plot. 
    • Don't know how they got there.  Maybe they got confused with CWD and wandered up from Iowa.   Or maybe there are a few more but they didn't happen to get shot or didn't get tested.     So, you are a wealthy land owner?  Is the land in 348?     Sure, you are free to question the DNR.   I never said you weren't.   And you, so far as I know, are free to refuse to cooperate with the program to control CWD.   As I have said, that is exactly the response of the land owners in Wisconsin that I recall from back in the day.     However I am curious.   Are you accusing the DNR of planting or fabricating this instance of cwd for some nefarious purpose, like killing most of the deer in that area for unknown reasons?   Or do you just think that these were the only two sick deer and everything will be fine without any action? 
    • Nice product.  Would work great with my Lindell Ice Rigs....
  • Our Sponsors