Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
fishroger

Can you hunt a pointer and retriever together?

15 posts in this topic

I have a lab that has completed gun dog training and is a very good retriever and occassionally points. I have a friend who has a pointer who strictly points. Can we hunt them together or will the retriever want to run in and flush the bird after its pointed by the other dog?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sure, I do it all the time with a buddy of mine and his lab with out much issue. Plus if the dog has completed training you should be able to stop the dog from running in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It can definitely be done. Depends on what you want and how far you want to take it. It also depends on the cover you will be hunting and dogs. Some cover it can be a great one - two punch, some cover not so good.

Depending on the maturity, the training and exposure my pointing dog has had I will hunt with flushing dogs. The less training and exposure the more likely we are to hunt the same area but go different directions. This allows me to continue to work and train while I am hunting and avoid my dog developing bad habits.

I like to let my pointing dogs run - 200 - 400 yards out when I am on foot in open cover. This can be frustrating to the flushing dog owner, because my dog has already covered the ground they are about to cover. It is a riot to walk up on my dog pointing, send his dog in for the flush, maintain my dog on point, shoot the bird and then let his dog retrieve it. My dogs typically like to retrieve and it takes a lot of repetition to get to stay on point through the retrieve of the other dog. It is also something I would not do all the time with my dogs because I want them to do it all and get rewarded making the retrieve.

You might want to check out what they do on plantation hunts. They will run pointing dogs until they go on point. When everyone is in position they will send in the flushing dogs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It can be done but I dont see the reason for it. The pointing dog covers all the ground finds the birds and then you send a flusher in? What does this make better? Even though my dogs are very steady I dont like when guys send a flusher in on point. I have done this many times and find it better just to switch out dogs at the next spot and a have a fresh one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's an aesthetic thing for some folks and can be the height of dog work/training for some. To each his own. It ain't for me though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do it all the time with a couple of friends who own yellow labs. Hunting isn't nearly as much about what dog the person has, as it is spending time with friends. Yes, their labs occasionally bust in on my shorthairs' points, but they also find plenty of birds on their own. Not to mention the number of times the labs are able to make retrieves that my shorthair possibly couldn't. For me, if it's a person I want to enjoy a day in the field with, I wouldn't care what kind of dog is in his truck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have britannys and my buddy has a lab. The lab always

keeps on eye on my dog because he likes to roam over there

when one of my dogs on point. As long as the lab's owner

keeps him off my dog, she will stay on point and not bust

the bird. Busting birds is big waste of training time and

expense. Fun to watch them all together and give it a try

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My brother and I did this for several years, I had a GSP and my brother ran a Springer. The dogs different styles really complemented each other and allowed us to work a variety of different cover situations. For example we would pull up to a spot that had a couple cattail sloughs and some woody/brushy cover, with CRP grass covering the upland areas in between. My brother and his Springer would work the cattails and brush while the GSP and I cover the uplands, a very effective way to hunt a given area. However both of our dogs were fully trained and very experienced before we even attempted this. I would not try this with young/inexperienced dogs unless you have full control over them, other wise you will get frustrated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

pointer all the way, best hunts I"ve ever been on were with a gsp and a pointing lab. I have a pointing lab and love him, bud has one also great fun in all waterfowl pheasants whatever, but gsp's are great to awsume.............

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My GSP has hunted with 2 labs on many occasions. As we cover alot of ground, its good for the 3 dogs, my dog won't hardly bother the other 2 and the same for them is likewise. all work good together in close quarters, and fine when wide open areas.

On birds holding tight, Found it was good to have both, the pointer would do his thing, and if you walked up and bird held tight in cold windy wet weather,or started runnng, the labs would be there to back you up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I personally would not want to do this with a pointing dog that is not well-seasoned. I wuld not want to go back and fix problems because the dog started seeing it as a competition to get the birds, and therefore started performing more like a flusher.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I own both, and although I would like to run them together some day, its going to be a while. My Chessie is just fine, its the 8mth old GSP that needs to work on his own for a while.

When he is solid, then I imagine them hunting together. Ill follow the Chessie closely until the GSP goes on point, at which point Ill go to the pointer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Every time I hear this question I always think about dating two women at the same time. It sure sounds like a great idea but rarely goes smoothly.

Some people can work it out, but I don't think you can get the full potential out of either dog by asking them to adapt to the ways of another dog.

If I had one of each I would hunt them independently, thus always having a fresh dog on the ground. I have never seen a dog that can hunt at 100% for more than an hour at a time. Some will say "My dog can hunt all day" Hogwash...a dog may be out of the truck and on the ground all day but they are not "hunting" effectively after they are fatigued.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Very possible.

The flusher finds all the birds the Pointer didn't. smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Surface tension you must be extremally biased towards labs to comment like that. I have seen great labs and great pointers miss birds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Check out the 2017 Obsession Hurcan 366fps and 3.9 lbs!
    •   When someone gets to the personal aspect, whether it's me or someone else, I will challenge them and if they can justify what they have said about an individual --OK -- otherwise show me why, and if it is just their opinion say so. I'll accept that if it's their opinion.   There is nothing generic about an insult, an insult is an insult. What do you consider as a douchebag?
    • Not sure why people get so worked up about being called dummies, poopyheads and sons of bees.  Whatever, its generic insults and this is the internet.   But yeah, there's a line somewhere in the there that separates the real douchebags* from the rest of us.  You know it when you see it.   *Sorry if any douchebags felt personally attacked by being called douchebags.
    • I was addressing it to JigSawJimmy Peatmoss  response : That's an opinion, not anything more , so I let it go.
    • Created/Saved all these jobs, cut gajillions off AF1 costs, etc.  Ok, so how did the that work?  Usually these sort of dealings aren't totally one sided.  At least the carrier deal had a bunch of Pence fingerprints on tax incentives Trump took credit for.   I have doubts that King Cheeto just shows up and blows a bunch of smoke up assses and corporate executives are just like, "Yay!"   Is Trump's Twitter bully pulpit that powerful?  He randomly yells at Boeing and they just fold over for him?  I thought we realized Trump on Twitter is only for the LOLs.
    • Well hope the Trump supporters are having fun, seems those days are numbered. Turns out you can't just yell fake news at real news and make it go away. The Feds are closing in, and at best it seems Trump thinks throwing Manafort to the wolves might get them off his tail. Anywho, lots of news today.   The FBI has information that indicates associates of President Donald Trump communicated with suspected Russian operatives to possibly coordinate the release of information damaging to Hillary Clinton's campaign   McCain: Congress doesn't have 'credibility' to handle Russia probes    Because this happened - House Intelligence chair discloses classified intel in clumsy effort to validate Trump   Also this earlier in the day -  Former campaign manager Paul Manafort secretly worked for a Russian billionaire with a plan to "greatly benefit the Putin Government."     And in completely unrelated news - remember those Carrier jobs you bragged about Trump saving? Yeah, those jobs are gone. Carrier pocketed the tax breaks then screwed the workers anyway. Great negotiation there. http://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/job-cuts-endure-at-indiana-factories-despite-trump-pressure-416511193.html
    •   Who are you addressing this to? I did not make the statement only re-posted it. I also don't find PEATMOSS's comment very humorous as well.   PEATMOSS said: This is still, by far, the funniest thing I have ever read on these threads in a decade.
    •   Anything you post on here from now on has no merit or credibility as far as I'm  concerned.  I wasn't even going to respond to this, but feel what you posted needed to be. If you wish to call my mother a dam, you will, the same as you called another persons mother that. I don't give a rats butt what your political views are, however when you start getting into personal attacks you had better look in a mirror. You don't probably don't know anyone on here personally, yet you attack someone on a personal bases, call there mother a dam and ridicule them because they had a lower portion of a leg amputated due to something they can control, but had no control whether they have the illness and sometime that illness makes you pay a price. BD2 has that illness he can control to a certain extent where he can lead a normal life, however there will be complications and from what I know of him he will accept that. I don't know DB2 personally, I've never met him, I've debated against some thing on this where he and I have had different views, I respect his opinions even though I disagree on many, BUT I SURE AS H--- DON"T ATTACK HIS ANCESTORY OR  ANY TYPE OF DISABILLITY
    • Yea yea all ya auld pharts would  pass out the minute she popped the first button!!
    • Would he get a free hoodie for his efforts?
  • Our Sponsors