Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Lunker

Close or too close, that is the question?

Recommended Posts

I personally won't set up within 20 yds of another person, and I use a hand auger and am quiet anyways. Even on little lakes I find that getting away from the crowd and fishing the "edge" is usually way better fishing anyways.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is a good topic jlm and I don't know the law. But I see where you are going with this. I only have a portable and I get on the ice with it before the perms do. I fish the "holes" then the perms move in on "my" spot and over run it perms making it virtually impossible for me to fish it and say within the 10 ft law. So can I mark my spot with a 2 X 4 in the ice to bring my portable to when I want to fish my usual early season spot. I usually will check it out see if there is any where to fish, if not try another spot on the lake, but sometimes woulnd't mind tryin the "holes" again that I was able to fish early season.

------------------
I like Tail

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I have thought the same thing many times. Some people with permanents hardly fish them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have an interesting story relating to this topic, just happened two weeks ago. There was a hot crappie bite going on in the lake that I fish. We put the permanant out 100 yards from the crowds. My buddy asked why are we putting it here? I replied eventually those fish are gonna work this way because of the fishing pressure. Well they did and I was the only one around we caught some nice fish. I hate the crowds, but within a week they were all right next to me. I fish mostly with my 2 sons, ages 5,8. On a tuesday afternoon after work we all went out. While driving to the house it looked like there was people fishing real close to my house. Well, real close was what I found out. 3 guys fishing within 10 ft of it. I pull up and all 3 put their head down, almost to say we are sorry to be fishing this close. I pulled right next to the house(my way of showing them they were to close) and got out of the truck. My youngest son got out of back seat and took 1 step and fell into an open hole. I ran over and pulled him out. 1 foot all the way to his hip. I got him out and started to "relay" my message to the 3 people. Took him home to change and came back and these 3 yahoo's were still there. I had to back my truck in at an agle to hook up to my house to move it. I got out and the guy was real sorry that my kid fell in the hole , but he said they didn't drill them. Lets see, I fished the day before, no holes. That day it was about 0, so any hole would have ice on it within an hour. While cranking up the house, the guy has the balls to ask me if the house was for sale and if I was moving. I guess it all comes down to courtesy of who was there first. But to this day, I still wonder what if that would have been a 10 inch hole!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm no lawyer but I would say it's 10ft weather or not someone is in there or not. Yes I would like it changed to at least 20ft.

My .02 worth

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is in response to mjgrose's post. I would have been hot to say the least about this. So hot that before I went to move my house, I would have dropped a few cherry bombs down the holes assisted with some weight. That would have ruined the fishing for them for sure! OK, so it isn't the best way to deal with it. But I know I would have gotten some gratification from it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am a hole hopping freak and this creates some problems because so many ice fisherman are like sheep. I fish outside on the ice and about 85 percent of the time and people think that they can come up and fish right next to you. Last weekend I had a guy following me as I moved around in order to stay on top of the fish. He had the nerve to fish in a hole I drilled no more than 3 feet from me. He finally got drift when I bluntly told him that the reason I was moving so much was to get away from him. I try to stay away from the crowd, however, the crowd and their permanent houses alway seem to crowd me out of the spots my brother and myself spend hours finding. A couple of weeks ago we were packing up to leave our spot and a guy and his permanent zoomed up to our spot and the guy jumped out and saw that there were fish around. Needless to say this guy and a few of his other buddies now think that they are the owners of this spot. Please give me some space!!! This weekend I'm going to a little lake in order to get away from the sheep.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Last year I had my permanent on a mile long drop off with nobody within 1/4 mile of me. I went out to my shack one early afternoon and there were two guys using it for a wind break (25+ MPH winds). They were actually leaning on my shack, so there holes weren't 3' away. I kindly asked them to move and they said it was a free lake. Within a minute or two I was pulling the shack further down the drop off while watching several pieces of their gear getting blown down the lake. Had they been decent about it I probably would have let them warm up in my shack.

------------------
Wables

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The law states that shelters cannot be closer than 10 feet, it doesn't address someone standing on the ice. I guess they can drill at an angle into your existing hole if they want (legally, that is). Unfortunately, common courtesy and sportsmanship can't be legislated. Too many people just don't care, you can see the evidence daily.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As I was reading this I thought it was sounding like the guys with the hard side houses were causing all the trouble. I am glad to see that there are portable people doing the same thing. I have both kinds of houses, and if you stay to long both kinds move in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I thought the rule was 50 feet. There's plenty of lakes and plenty of spots. How come a guy can't set uo 50 feet from another guy? I had a guy put his portable on one of my holes earlier this year. Is it not common sense to give a guy some space? FYI Almost nobody ice fishes in Wisconsin.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have all complained about some one-who-thinks-I-am-silly coming near our fish house during prime time and drilling all kinds of holes and making noise to beat the band. I hate it, you hate it, we all hate it. Or, you come out to your perm. house and some yahoo is fishing 10 feet from your front door. We all hate that one to. I posted this because I want to play the devils advocate here a little. In the St. Cloud area, the lakes can be very crowded, particularly in the good spots. So lets say that there are 20 perm. houses in the best hole in the lake. These 20 houses pretty much make this hole impossible to fish because there is no room for anyone else to set up without violating the 10 foot law. Now lets say that nobody is in these houses but they remain on the lake to "claim" their spot. Does a guy have a right to set up as close as he wants to the perm. house since it is unoccupied? If he does set up real close, would the guy who owns the perm. house be intruding on the space of the guy who set up close to his house since he was not in the house? If the 10 foot law was to be followed, why could I not go out and build 20 houses and put them out to block off a certain area of the lake (I know that is stupid, its just to make a point)? MN lakes are public so why can a guy put out his perm. house and lay claim to that spot when they are not using the house? I guess this might be similar to the tree stand on public land debate. What are your thoughts? Before anyone goes off the deep end, this is just for discussion, nothing else.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use a portable house and get so freakin nervous when I go and set-up that I try and not be around anybody out of fear of a confrontation. It also chaps my hide to set up and than have the owners of perm. houses that were where I wanted to fish to move next to me. I ahve had houses close enough after I set up thatI swear I could smell'em. Compromise is the only solution and if nothing else take some fish from previous trip and throw on onto ice. Preferable eelpout or mooneyes, let'em think about those for awhile and if they really want to be there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Last time we were up on Winnie we pulled the house out after dark on a Friday night. Went out where no one was (but we had wanted to try there). Slow all through the night and next morning so we decided to cruise around the lake and try to agree on a new spot to try. We looked at a bunch of areas (were gone about two hours) and decided to move. When we got back to our house, two portables had set up almost right in front of the house. We had to physically move the house for us to be able to hook up to the truck. They didn't even offer to help.

Now that's too close.

Vickie

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with the first statement from simcox. I have found myself in this situation:

I usually look at lake maps for some type of hole or structure before going out. I get to the spot I had decided on at home, and lo and behold, there's a permanent house or two there. I try to stay 40 or 50 feet away and use a hand auger, but the permanent guy shows up and shoots me a dirty look like I went there just because I saw his house--as if his permanent house sitting there entitles him to an entire piece of structure (sometimes the only structure on the lake) for the entire winter.

I try to have a backup spot planned out to avoid this, but it would be great if more ice fishermen were civil. Granted I get upset at people that pull up nearby, leave their big deisel running and punch a million holes right as the evening bite starts, but give us quiet guys a break.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just curious as to why people think using a hand auger is better when fishing next to people? It is a proven fact that drilling a hole with a hand auger is a lot louder under ice than a power auger. Just becuase it cant be heard above ice doesnt mean it is quieter below.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

sounds like some people just dont want to get along with there fellow sportsmen and women most people i meet on the lake stop by to talk and express were the fishing is best when they are biting there is plenty of fish to go around walleye2 just my nickle worth

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

UMD fisherman, I assume that is in response to my post, as I said, I don't fish within at least 20 yds of anybody, and whether or not hand augers are quiter or louder, I was just trying to point out that I always attempt to be as quiet as possible while fishing, ice or open.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

in fishermen did a study and they stated hand augers were quieter than chisles and i thought power augers too, how is it possible for a power auger to be quieter than a hand auger, my strikemaster hand auger has basically the same blades and pitch as my power auger(lazer mag), could you please tell me where you found this info? thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didnt mean anything in a bad way by saying that hand augers are noisier than a power auger. I got the information from a fishing show I watched a few years back where they did a study with underwater equiptment and at that time it showed hand augers to be a lot louder under ice. Things might have changed since then but I think the main reason for the difference in noise levels was the speed at which the hole was being drilled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I remember correctly, the fish were less spooked by the power auger because the of the constant speed, whereas the hand auger is more of a fast/slow sound.

------------------
Wables

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have fished with a portable in the past, And I wsa never as rude and some of tthe people you have dealt with. Im out on medicine lake and there are @ss holes all over me right now. Im on the north side of the big "village" and when I moved my house to that spot, there was nobody within 50 yards. Now there are idiots 15 feet awway from my house. I cant even take a [PoorWordUsage] without the ******* staring at my junk. If your one of these people that dont know how to fish and fishes wherever a permanent is, I fricking am sick of you!

Mike--

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Regarding the differnce in auger noise, I saw the same show. It was Tony Dean, and he sent a diver down with sound equipment to check decibel levels. The hand and power augers made the same amount of noise under the ice, but the power auger was of much shorter duration. The engine noise did not transmit itself to the water. The chisel, however, was very loud and the diver said it was like slapping him on the ears every time it hit the ice. The show also showed Tony Dean dropping his chisel through the ice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Close? You want Close? - Try fishing any of the Madison, Wisconsin lakes, Mendota, Monona, Waubesa, etc. The common practice, summer or winter is to find the crowds. In Summer it is impossible to find a good spot and them expect to cast from your boat 15 minutes later. You have to have a wire cutter in hand when you pull the anchor rope to cut off all the hooks from anglers parked right over it. In Winter, "anglers" who don't even bring out an auger, crowd into your holes - within 5 feet - - - - I've even had one kick my auger so he could fish in one of my holes. Once I invited a guy to fish right in my hole - he might as well - he was that close. My sympathies - I've been there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • A 9 year old may be a good enough shot to harvest a deer, but can he really comprehend what it means to take the life of an animal?  I'm all for taking kids hunting, but make sure they're mature enough to understand what it really means.
    • They have a meeting with everyone involved in the hunt, all hunters, coordinators, city officials, local police, all at the same time.  There's no way they can redo that to accomodate one hunter no matter how good an excuse he has.  That's why they draw alternates. Sorry, you lose this time, keep trying.
    • Without a doubt......NAP KILLZONE.  Shoot great and really drop the hammer when they connect with a deer.
    • Another win for the icefishinnut  with 323 pts. For win number 3 in the year.😀 2--Fishing_Novice             311 3--Juneau4                         292 4--BlackLundProV             283 5--Rip_Some_Lip               267 6--huckfin                           247 7--mnwildman                   239 8--rl_sd                                208 9--Swiveldigger                  80 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Season totals 1--Fishing_Novice                   7811 2--Juneau4                               7658                   The score in the top three are getting closer and with the ROVEL and Dega --🤔 3--BlackLundProV                   7654 4--huckfin                                 7485 5--icefishinnut                         7398 6--Rip_Some_Lip                     7384 7--mnwildman                         7265 8--Swiveldigger                        6971 9--rl_sd                                      6623   Good luck with the guesses this week. ( except for the  Fishing_Novice!😁 BlackLundProV could back off a Little too.😁   Good Luck in the mess this Week.
    • Sounds like a great trip and a really fun experience, congratulations! Thanks for all the pictures and sharing your story. I know that's a lot of work and it is much appreciated.
    • At this point we had one full day and one morning left to hunt.  No more elk moved into the drainage behind camp.  By some miracle a cow and spike did come back to the hillside we had elk on that first evening, but neither Dad or I could get in position quick enough before they went back over the fence.     All added up we had 2 very good opportunities, and one decent, which by our standards and past experience in general OTC type units was a pretty decent week of elk hunting even though no elk were killed.  We learned a lot about the unit and a potential better way to access the landlocked area behind us via a possible easement logging road, but we have to confirm that with the forest service at a later date.       You might be wondering what happened with our whitetail tags.   We had numerous run-ins with deer on an almost daily basis.  There were at least three occasions where does would feed right into camp, and it got to a point I kept my bow in the cook shack to try to shoot out of it as a blind.  They never stuck around long enough though to actually get a shot off.      Dad sat his tree stand a number of times above camp as he came down at sunset with enough time to sit in a tree for a half hour or so, but the deer always seemed to pass through the spots he could not shoot or see.  One time he climbed down to two deer staring at him from within range, he just did not see them coming...   Almost every evening we walked down the road behind camp we would kick up a deer or two bedding in the quakeys, but as the week progressed they clearly became more skittish of us.  I also tried hunting back down the gravel road and found some good spots where they crossed the road and creek, which if I actually focused on sitting over with a treestand I feel I could have shot a deer, but I wanted an elk more...        Our Elk B tags are good through rifle season, as are the deer tags.  If the stars align and my wife allows I might make a run back out.  I have an acquaintance in the area that I am checking with to see if he might be interested.       I hope Scoot and ArcherySniper come back to report better luck on their hunts.  
    • It rained that night, and the next morning we went up high to glass back where we left the elk.  They seem to have never left the cut we saw them bed in.       Some interesting low clouds.   It rained all afternoon, but the forecast said it would clear a couple hours before sunset.   We observed snow on the high peaks in the distance.        Once the rain stopped and the skies looked clear we went back to see if we could finally shoot an elk.  We worked the wind back up to where we had last sat so we see the elk and still move down to intercept if they came down for water/feed.   The elk were still up high, but shifted left a couple cuts.  We were now close enough to confirm that the bull was in fact a smallish 6 point.       We waited a long time watching the cows get up to feed and then bed down again repeatedly.  As sunset neared the lead cow looked ready to commit to coming down.  Our plan was to run down fast to intercept, watching as we fast-walked down to the bottom.   It was clear now the elk were following the left most ridge, and moving quite fast, they definitely wanted to get to the bottom for the good creek water and green grass!      The plan was I would run ahead to intercept as I could get their faster.  I knew the place they were going, having scouted it earlier in the week.  It was a perfect funnel.  The cows went behind the narrow ridge they were following, but the bull stayed high watching the drainage.  I managed to get up through the saplings quietly and in position, and could see the bull up high, and the cows feeding and walking right to me on a string!      Unfortunately behind me I heard a loud stick break.  The bull did too and was pacing back and forth rapidly trying to figure out what was below him...  I could see my dad standing in the creek bottom.   I adjusted my position, the cows were coming closer, I ranged for shot options, they would pass within 40yd and the bull might walk right over me...    The bull unfortunately had had enough.  He swooped down to the cows and herded them back up the hill...  The cows had no clue what was going on, but the bull clearly was not stupid.   After waiting until it was close to dark I picked my way back down to my dad, who was standing on the cattle trail we had gone up previously.  It turned out that he tripped over a downfall fell badly.   He was not hurt, but he thought the bull could not see him, but I had a better view from above as to what was going on.  Those elk were not seen again for the rest of the hunt.    
    • Unfortunately the weather turned bad on us and it rained over night, I forget if it was day four or five.   In any case a cloud system rolled in and low cloud ceiling filled the drainage behind camp.        We went up the front side of the area hoping elk would be out there to get out of the clouds.  It was extremely windy now as well.  I went high back where I saw the spike days earlier and was glassing back up the drainage when I saw a bull and three cows in the wide open up high!   I considered running down the cut between us to try to intercept in the creek bottom below, but did not want to risk bumping these elk when they were the only elk in the entire drainage!     Dad sidehilled across to join me, followed by a herd of mule deer does...      Selfie with cloud covered hills.        We watched where the elk bedded and decided to ambush them in the evening.  We decided to drive out to town to hit the grocery store so Dad could have more fresh food and not have to resort to eating what I brought.  The cloud system over the area did not look good from below at all...     That evening we went to the hill the elk were on in the morning so we could see where they were bedded.  The clouds were so thick now in the drainage we could not see up to where the elk were.  It was very windy and cold. The elk never showed up.  We left before sunset.     Another selfie in the clouds, so cold and windy I had to break out the facemask and extra layers while hunkering down behind a blowdown.      
    • I told my dad that he should not follow me up that hill, it might kill him.  He did not take me seriously...  He followed anyway.  We left camp very early as it was a long walk up the drainage, and I wanted to be on top before the elk, but I still needed daylight to get up the dangerous last 700ft.     Sunrise behind me on the way up:   I made it to the top and set up in the rock outcropping.  Time passed, Dad was nowhere to be seen behind me.  I saw a group of elk below me in the next drainage, a nice bull and what might have been the cows/calves I was seeing on the spine the previous days...     I waited, and waited, and saw lots of fresh tracks in the dirt.  Dad showed up, still no elk up high...  We waited until about 10am, long past when they had passed through the other times.  The elk below us bedded and a satellite bull moved in on them.  Another bull was bugling to the one below us, and we heard one lone bugle to the right.   We had no intention of going down to try to shoot one, because if we did it would be a nightmare for us to get the meat out again.        We gave up and picked our way back down the chute and all the way to camp.  After doing this walk two days in a row my feet hurt like hell and I was beat.  I would not be able to do it again a third day in a row.     
×