Do you make this trade?

[Born2Fish]

Him: Randy Moss

Me: Larry Fitzgerald

Straight up player for player. Do you make this trade?

[RiverFish]

Moss, IMO, is a way safer WR. Boldin is gone, Warner is gone. Moss has supporting cast and Brady.

I would easily trade Fitz for R. Moss.

[Rick]

Dynasty-keeper league, keep fitz. Re-draft-Moss.

[Born2Fish]

I do agree with River in a sense. BUT, I also agree with Rick. Fitz is the one man show in 'zona and will see the majority of passes thrown his way. Welker will take a bunch of passes from Moss. Though Moss IS in a contract year.

[Fish Head]

Difficult call, but with a PPR league I think I would go with Fitz. I know Warner is gone, but Fitz is THE man in AZ. They will throw the ball to him over and over and over.

[RiverFish]

And Fitz will draw a double coverage every down.

[jigging-matt]

Would not make the trade. Fitz make the catches and finds ways to get open, moss just doesn't isn't quite the same as he was a few years ago, he is still a good receiver, but not in the same class as Fitz. The other receivers on Arizona are not junk (Breaston, Duecet)they are more than capable of being good wr, so Fitz will still get plenty of chances for catches.

[ozzie]

I would have to look at where they were drafted. I would look at it this way if I had the pick and both Fritz and Moss were still available who would I take? I like both receivers and it is hard to bet against Moss but I would choose Fritz since he is younger and should see more action than Moss. Moss can and will put up good numbers so either way I think you would be OK.....

[FISHINGURU]

I'd take Moss everytime, Tom Brady will be back to form this year and Moss will rack em up..Fitz is good but not when Warner and Boldin are both gone. You'll see Fitz get alot of double and triple teams this season.

Like always in fantasy football it depends who stays healthy and who doesn't.

[PurpleFloyd]

Take Moss. He has Brady and a great coaching staff. Fitz you just don't know for sure with how Leinart and the rest of the team are going to pan out. They really have some questions to answer on offense before I am sold on the notion they can be what they were with Warner, Boldin, Edge etc.

[ozzie]

Edge? he wasn't in AZ last year and he was no good while in AZ......

[Cloomis]

Keep Fitz, although contract year for Mr. "straight cash, homey", makes it interesting.