Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
heat checker

Musky migrations

8 posts in this topic

Somewhat new to fishing these awesome fish, I have a few questions. Does a musky return to the same area of a lake each year? I had a big one follow, and was wondering if that same fish might be in same area the next yearat same time (assuming same water temp and conditions)? Do they "migrate" at all outside of spawning? Or do they continuously roam in feeding and resting stages?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good question. Always wondered the same thing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good article in MH this month about tracking tagged fish in Kinkaid down in Illinois. One of the biggest females they tagged spent several days at a time in a very specific area, and a lot of the year in a larger but generally same part of the lake. But other times it was all over the lake and not surprisingly many of the tagged fish spent 50% of their time over open water. And an article a few years ago described an individual who tagged his own fish and he claimed he re-caught several of them in almost the same exact spot almost to the day a year later.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's dependent on the lake and it's size/forage/cycle.

There are some great tracking studies from Eagle Lake in Ontario, huge water, very interesting info. Not sure where to find them on the net though...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IMO, and experience yes they hang in the same areas. but i fish rivers so in lakes i don't have much of an oppinion. over the years i've experienced it but most recently i know three fish in three different areas on two different rivers that i've caught in successive years. it could be more but these three fish have specific identifying marks. one actually has a messed up bill, almost like it was broken at one time. two years in a row on that one and two years on another croix muskie. and a mississippi sweety has said hi four years in a row a total of seven times. prettiest steel blue hue i've ever seen, and i mean bright, but the poor girl has a big gash behind her nether region. i call her ''old faithfull''. smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I fish a small lake a lot. After catching the same fish year after year I would have to say they stay in the same "general" area during that same year. But year after year they do move, but not much. I caught the same 46 incher 2 times this year and that dang thing didnt move more the 20 yards. I even caught it on the same lure twice. The year before last summer I caught it twice and it was about 300 yards away from the spot I caught it on last summer.

I think the fish in lakes with not much structure they stick around. But lakes like Vermilion and Mille Lacs they can move around a lot more cuz there is way more food.

Theres one fish on a lake that I fish that is known as the "Tourist Fish." That thing has been in the same spot for about 3-4 years. I've watched it grow from around 49 inches to about 53 inches. I dont think anybodys caught that thing. If you wanna see it all you have to do is throw topwater in a certain spot and sure enough it will be right behind it!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the confusion here guys, NAH, just "pullin your chain". I'm takin a geuss that the big ones are more entitled to their choice of territory and would lay claim to the choice structure? Which, I gueuss would also include doing a little roaming whenever they darn well please. Thanks for the info guys.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In general tagged fish have shown home regions, spending most of the time roaming deep water, moving into adjacent shallow water to feed then returning to the adjacent deeper water. Once caught they would leave that area in favor of another.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I like the Wal-Mart corn to!
    • When is the date unsold bear tags go onsale?
    • I may try smoked rough fish on my bait this year. Anyone tried smoke fish on the bait pile?
    • Does anyone eat or use mooneyes? I caught one in the St. Croix today. Nothing else, it was interesting fish!
    • I hope to take a trip to ND this season, maybe they will get first ice before we do.
    • Hey everybody. An FYI. There is something new coming. Should be out around October, 2017 and available for on-line purchase.   If you google : ICE WELL Live Well ICAST 2017 The video of the product roll-out at ICAST 2017 in July, 2017 will pop up.   Also you can go to the product page. See : ICEWELLLiveWell.com. The page has a separate video to view also.                        The product is being manufactured from a custom blend non-buoyant polypropylene with impact modifiers to withstand extreme cold without cracking. The product will sit within 99% of all manufactured 5-gallon buckets for transport to and from the fishing spot. It is designed to fit within a drilled 8 or 10 inch ice hole. When in the drilled hole it will fill allowing you to throw your catch in the ICE WELL Live Well. No more throwing them on the ice or in the bucket to die, freeze or turn to slime. At the end of the day, pull it, place back in the bucket for transport home. No more frozen fish and easy handling. It's going to sell for around $19.99 plus shipping. The listed page will undergo changes before roll out that will allow purchase direct on-line. This is a creation by a Nebraska ice fisherman for ice fishermen. Made in the USA. Made with recycled materials. "Respect the Resource".     
    • Can't build a taller garage when it's a tuck-under with sheet-rocked 7' ceilings!!! The truck sits up high....
    • bigger garage!!
    • Same thing here...*TWANG*  I took my big snippers to mine and screwed a black wire nut cap on the cut end. Or unscrew one from a junkyard F-150 and saw it off. Looks fine.
    • I've fished it once about 10yrs ago Ice fishing from fishermans wharf....caught one perch in 3 days.   I was thinking about trying the lake once again with my wheel house..but it looks to be shut down. I talked to a guy from the Mille lacs area last winter at upper red, and he said the lake was great and it was the best he'd had for large fish ever on the lake.   I did did some reading and seen quite a few different views. The one I found most compelling and seemed to make the most sense after reading and looking at data was the view of a walleye population being mismanaged with slots, allowing for way to many large fish that have basicly eaten themselves out of food with the baitfish they prey on. Which in turn turned them into predators of their own young walleye. Hence the collapse of the walleye.
  • Our Sponsors