Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
kato2fargo

Musky or pike

9 posts in this topic

Im sure some people are sick of this question but my bro is wondering what kinda fish his mother in-law caught and released last weekend while fishing turtle lake wisconsin area they caught 4 other pike over 30 inches that weekend. he didnt get a pore count and i can't figure out what it is so maybe someone will thanks for any help... MUSKY or PIKE???

I tried to convince her it not to cut herself out of the image but she did... lol i don't get it...

DSC01765.jpg

untitled.jpg

DSC01767sm.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

First pick had a blody fin I would say Ski as I have not seen Pike blled like that

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it is a cross between both a pike and a muskie. However, I do think it has more muskie characteristics than northern characteristics. The tail, in my opinion, has more of a rounded tail that would resemble a northern pike. Muskies have more of a pointed tail. By a cross of both, I definitely do not mean a tiger muskie, but some other unknown type.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its a Silver Northern. We have quite a few in our lakes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pike.....

Lighter spots on a darker back, as best as I can tell rounded tail fins, and the coloration in the fins and the scales on the gill plate.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Definitely a Pike... tail fin is rounded and the color definitely belongs to a Pike... if you look CLOSER at the tail leading up to the tail fin, you can see a pattern that clearly belongs to Pike, not Tiger or Pure Muskie...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i'd say pike too.

... nice looking fish

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only lake around Turtle Lake with any sort of muskie population is Big Moon. Lower Turtle Lake has a few migrants from Big Moon (meaning Upper Turtle could also have a few migrants), and Horseshoe has a few in it that the DNR has no idea how they got in (most likely illegal stocking). The last 3 I mentioned have maybe a handful of fish total in them.

And looking at the picture I'd say pike.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Google silver pike you'll find your answer. If I knew how to post pics I'd post a few identical to that one we have caught this year so far. BTW our state record Silvers 10#

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • My family is going to be headed to Birch Lake near Babbitt, MN in late June for a week on a houseboat.  This trip is a graduation present for our oldest and I am hoping to make it a week to remember.   I would appreciate any advice ranging from fishing locations, bait, suggested lures, and even sites to see on the lake.  I have done a lot of searching on Google with the hope of finding someone who maybe spent a week on a houseboat on Birch but not a lot of luck.  I have about a month to prepare for the trip so I greatly appreciate everyone input.   Thanks,  
    •     I have had good luck with the "My Plate" app.... It is annoying enough to keep you honest, but simple enough to use.
    •   Yeah well once you fire that bad boy up and show her how it works, she will get impressed pretty quick! 
    • In regards to casement windows, I have always been a fan.... Primarily, because the harder the wind blows, the better seal that you are getting. Don't get me wrong - there are drawbacks such as size restrictions, maintenance of the cranking mechanism, etc... but I like them
    • walleye, Pfunk, monster, we need one more bird to qualify for bragging rights.  You guys still after them?
    • Kept getting pushed back from moving into the new house, but finally heading up to open the camper tomorrow afternoon.  Bought a new leaf blower to keep the outside rugs clean.  On mega clearance at Wally world for 10 bucks...  Told the Mrs. it would've been foolish of me NOT to buy it.  She wasn't impressed.
    • Rot can also be completely separate from the quality of the window.  If you maintain high moisture in the house it will first collect on windows then can drip down and rot out the surrounding frame.
    • Well it looks like you have already found your plumbing company!
    • On the cheat meal issue.  There is only a minor setback physically if you limit to once a week.  What most people don't look at is the psychological benefit to a cheat meal.  The truth is most people who run a diet(excluding athletes and those that maintain a fit lifestyle for prefessional reasons) sneak snacks hear and there.  Sure some dont or dont for a time but most do.  The cheat meal gives you one day or meal all week to look forward to with those snacks to splurge.  This is by far easier than someone saying the diet is three months, or even better, 'I'm never eating processed sugar again'.
  • Our Sponsors