Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. ?

  • 0

Which *used* chip for Humminbird 587 - Lakemaster or Navionics?


Mistermojo

Question

I just picked up a new 587 CI DI and since I blew most of my budget on the unit, I am looking for a cheaper chip instead of the $120+ for new. I see some Lakemaster v.1 chips for 60-$75 range, and Navionics are not much more. Which chip is regarded as better, and why?

I mainly fish metro lakes, with the occasional trip to Mille Lacs, Leech, and Big Sandy.

Thanks,

Mojo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

when i bought my 597 last fall i also purchased a navionics for 4 reasons in order of importance to me 1. on sale (80) 2. LM all out 3. had my backyard lakes on it 4. Navionics is more regional with several states as opposed to LM being a single state specific at that time

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

My experience running the 2 cards side by side is limited to Lake of The Woods, both are pretty accurate from what I've seen. I have the Navionics card in a 798c SI and the Lakemaster in a Garmin GPS.

Does the 587 have the capabilities to take advantage of the extra features of the Humminbird / Lakemaster card? If so, it might be worth the extra money if you can take advantage of those features.

Mike

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

It is lake dependant. I have both Lakemaster and Navionics on an HDS. LM is better on some lakes, Navionics is better on others.

Examples that I've found this year.

LM is better on Mille Lacs

Navionics is better on Vermilion

Navionics is better on Spring (Scott Co)

Maybe we should compile a list. lightbulb.gif

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

It's not the 3' v 1' contours as much as the accuracy of the detail. I find the Navionics on V is more accurate and shows more detail. Details that are mssing on LM. There was a thread on the chips in the Vermilion forum a while back. I had the LM chip first and picked up the Navionics chip a year later on recommendation to use it on V.

The opposite is true on ML. Navionics has high(er?) contour on ML but LM is more accurate while displaying fewer contour lines.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

So really it sounds like either would be fine - just depends on the lake itself. I would not be fishing Vermillion, but Mille Lacs is an easy day trip for me. I have the Navionics app for my phone for ice fishing and it's OK, nothing that's "wow" about it. Better than my inland lakes maps on my handheld Garmin. The Garmin becomes hunting and hiking equipment now.

Guess I will just wait for the right price to come along, regardless of who the maker of the chip is.

Thanks,

Mojo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Hello, Kyl,

Curious about your observation that Navionics has more contours on Mille Lacs. I've only seen 1 foot contour intervals on both cards.

They are both 1' contours but they show different things.

On the surface, the Navionics looks more accurate by showing more detail but on the water, LM is more accurate while showing fewer lines.

Here are two screen grabs of the two chips on Mille Lacs. Both zoomed about as close as I could eyeball. Both of the same coordinates.

Navionics shows 15 contour lines. LM shows only 11 (counting the circle as one).

Note: this is an example of the differnces. I do not know if the bottom structures are accurate in either picture for this location. I have witnessed this issue on other occasions in other parts of the lake.

First, Navionics-2012.

Notice how this looks like more detail, but when you drive over this area you may not see all these variations in depths. By looking at this chart it looks like there is a sweet subtle inside turn to target (just to the north and east of the cross hairs).

full-28138-24727-shot4.png

Next, Lakemaster 2011.

Fewer lines but more accurate because there are not that many variations. That inside turn is not shown. full-28138-24728-shot5.png

I would bet money that the inside turns on the Navionics chip do not actaully exist in this location.

Using Navionics as a guide you will drive around looking for structure holding fish that do not exist. I've done it. Use the LM and save yourself some time targeting real structure and points.

What is strange is that this issue is lake dependant. The extra lines on the Lake Vermillion Map are real and LM is lacking but I have found the opposite to be true on ML.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now ↓↓↓ or ask your question and then register. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • First snapper yesterday. It was looking for Leech!     Was that Leech?
    • Baked taters  grilled pork chops and Califlower  . Had better Califlower though. 
    • Sunset last night on Burntside lake.    
    • Just don’t know where else to put this ray of hope.
    • We get eggs from locals who have chickens.  The difference in shelf life between washed and unwashed eggs was weird the first time I heard it.  Months for unwashed; maybe a month for washed.   Farm fresh is a fair amount different than from the grocery store.  Bigger yolks and thinner shells are two of the more noticeable differences.  I had my first red yolk eggs a few weeks ago.  Kinda freaked me out but it’s no big deal really.
    • Nature is pretty rad.    I think it's cool the eggs can just sit there for some time.  Especially because it can get quite cold.   There are sometimes a dud or two and I first thought it might be because they froze before mom incubated them but they always kick off.  When I have done post mortem examinations of the duds they always have almost completely developed ducklings inside.  I've never found one that was just some yolk.
    • No mosquitos yet, plenty of flies the last couple of days and here is my first spider outside of the house!    
    • I’ve never studied it but I’m pretty sure she has to be full time incubating before they all start.
    • I have a bunch of people telling me to install a camera in the box and set up a webcast.  I know my parents would love it.  Especially my dad, who built the house.     If I ever get around to it, I'll post a link.
    • I wish I would have caught them taking the leap and deciding which mom to follow.  I saw them that morning and it looked like about 2/3 went with one and 1/3 the other.  Definitely some gansers in the mix too.     I've caught the leap once out of 5 years.  I track it pretty close and can predict within about 5 days window of when I need to watch in the morning for mama duck to fly down and wait.  I had it nailed last year but real life prevented me from seeing it happen.   It's interesting to me that the duck lays an egg or two a day and they pile up over the course of a week/week and a half.  But they all hatch on the same day.  Crazy.  It must have something to do with development kicking off when mama duck starts sitting on them full time.  It's cool that those first layed eggs just sit there in a state of suspended animation waiting for mom to start full time sitting on them.
  • Topics

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.