Keeper League ?

[Outdoors_guy]

Alright in my leage we get 2 keepers but they can't be from the same position. I am keeping S. Alexander for sure. The other keeper I need help with. D. Mcnabb or R. Williams. Mcnabb doesn't have much of a reciever corps. Williams has kitna and a crappy offensive line. Which one should I keep? Any help would be great.

[nofishfisherman]

Any other options?

Williams isn't a good option in my opinion becuase the Lions are still the Lions and can't be trusted. Mcnabb is the best of the two but no recievers. Rumor has it they are interested in lelie from Denver though so maybe help is coming. Right now Westbrook is the best reciever on the team.

I guess I would take Mcnabb over Williams but somewhat grudgingly.

[tj417]

Holy dump - That's an easy one as far as I'm concerned - Roy Williams is going to have Torry Holt numbers this year - Remember - Mike Martz is in Detroit.

[TNFL]

I would also say RW. He is going into just his 3rd year (magic). And has a somewhat competent QB now and a genious OC (maybe). Plus Mcnabb has injury concerns for me, think matt birk. Roy definately has more upside.

[Outdoors_guy]

Thanks for the opinions guys. I am going to go With Roy. If at all i can always pick mcnabb back up in the mid rounds.

[nofishfisherman]

Chances are you could pick either one up later in the draft. Neither are top tier at their position.

[Remy]

Ok here's my dilemma, I'm in a keeper league too and I'm already keeping LJ but I can't decide what reciever I want to keep. My options are Moss, Boldin, or Chambers. My worries about each are Moss getting injured again or getting frustrated with brooks and only playing when he wants to play, Boldin losing some scoring opps to Fitzgerald and James, and Chambers having Daunte fumbling all the time or even worse having Daunte getting injured and having Harrington throwing to him.

What do you guys think.

[nofishfisherman]

Boldin all the way. He spilt time with Fitz all last year and they both had great numbers.

You know Denny will throw the ball alot so recievers in his offense are good options. Besides the O line isn't that great to sprin Edge for alot of scores I don't think.

Moss has a bum throwing to him and Chambers hasn't really proved himself yet as a big numbers guy. Besides you would have the same problem with a solid RB stealing yards away from him as you might have with Boldin.

[xedge2002]

I would definetly keep boldin as well. He is still going to put up good numbers even with edge and Fitzgerald there. No way I would keep moss because of his QB situation. Chambers is a decent reciever as well but if you want to keep him you could probably redraft him in a later round to get him back. Boldin may not be there when you would want to draft him.