Shallow-water spearing

[Ralph Wiggum]

I saw some monster carp in the shallows last weekend. They weren't feeding, so I couldn't catch them, but a bow-angler could have slaughtered them. Not being one who bow-fishes (maybe I should start)I was wondering if one could get close enough with a boat and a long handled spear, or if they're too skittish. Any tips would be appreciated.

[mncarphntr]

If you're REALLY cautious you may get one throw before they scatter, then move to a different group. My advice, rig up a bow, you won't be sorry!

[Trouthunter]

just exactly how do you plan to release one after you spear it? Just doesnt seem to make much sense...when you could be fishing with a rod and reel, instead, you decide to kill it...try going to another location on the lake and looking for the feeders...I've seen carp sunbathing and a few hundred yards away seen huge schools tailing and grubbing in the weeds...

[Ralph Wiggum]

Quote:

---

just exactly how do you plan to release one after you spear it? Just doesnt seem to make much sense..

---

I had no plan on releasing them. While they're fun to catch, they're a non-native species.

[Ralph Wiggum]

And anyone know where I can get my hands on a cheap, used bow so I can give it a shot?

[Metroguy99]

Check hsolist if your interested in a bow. We just bought an old 45lb. compound bow that works perfectly. Those fish in the shallows are by far very easy to sneak up on too. I would reccommend a canoe or water craft powered by man power rather than a loud motor. I have hit several with my paddle while canoeing. Don't know what to do about getting a spear? Make one..?

[Ralph Wiggum]

I've got a spear. I was getting pretty close with the trolling motor. Thanks for the tips!

[Fisher Dave]

I would keep my eyes open for an old recurve bow, or a lower weight compound.. you dont need 70 pounds for shooting carp. I had an old 40# recurve that worked great... it went away in a garage sale.

Check garage sales, hsolist, whatever, there are lots of old bows out there.

[Ralph Wiggum]

Yeah, I thought I might put my parents on the garage sale lookout. They can find anything.

[frabillfisher]

Soooo you got close with a speer but the real question is did you get any?

[PikeTipper]

I trashed a few good spears in a hurry on carp when I was young and wouldn't recommend it. Carp are too strong and have hard scales so regular northern spears don't fair well. I would get a bow.

[Ralph Wiggum]

Thanks for the tip. I'm on a hunt for a bow!