Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
dooger

Chumming rough fish legal??

8 posts in this topic

Hey i was just wondering if it is legal to chum rough fish in minnesota, such as eel pout or carp?? I didnt see anything in the regs but some one told me one time that it was illegal??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

chumming specifically is not illegal, but littering is. A CO will often cite a chummer for littering. It's not worth the ticket.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been chumming for carp for ever. Never even thought that this could be illegal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wondered this too. This topic arose a year or two ago and I called the MNDNR. The definition: "chumming refers to the process of scattering ground up fish (known as chum) in the water as bait." This is considered waste material and is not legal. The agent went on to say that throwing corn into the river or lake is not chumming by definition nor is it illegal or unethical as considered by the MNDNR, but that when we do it be responsible to not over litter the area. I never did ask about laying vegetation beds (I've never tried this myself). Has anyone ever tried laying vegetation beds to lure carp, meaning that one deliberately lays down a "bed" of vegetable material (corn and the like) and over time the carp learn to feed at that area - and is this ethical? Or is all of this too much work in search of the common carp?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know if I would classify this specifically as unethical, but where's the challenge involved? I know everyone has an opinion, but I don't see where this is much different than baiting deer. Basically, you are putting a food source in a specific location to attract an animal that would otherwise not go there foraging for food.

I guess I appreciate the thrill of the chase and the challenge involved with stalking a fish and convincing it to take my offering, especially if not's not hungry.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you can train Carp to feed when you throw food into the water. Is this fishing?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it might not be fishing but it could help improve with bowfishing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Thanks for the offer and info.  I will have to get out and look around at some. I'm picky and willing to wait till I find that cherry rig to come around so I might not be getting one for a while. Which is OK because I'm in no hurry.
    • little early fer that fish aint it!!!!!! I wanna see pictures of you camping come tomorrow morning when da blizzard comes thru!!!!!!!!!!!! nice pictures though!!!!!!!!!!!
    • whitefish maybe? 
    • If I understand correctly this only for bows. I have a crossbow and from what I understand it is considered a firearm. Is that the case? My son has a bow and has the archery tag.
    • so ... dillon has a bird to enter and 1957 is still hunting? looks like we are in good shape, but lot of guys still hunting in MN and WI, i assume   ended my season friday. got the blind set up before the shower started. it quit right before sunrise time and there was lots of gobbling on the roost a couple hundred yards away but none where i heard them close by when scouting a couple days earlier. a few distant gobbles on the ground, then nothing after the rain and wind picked up again. finally saw a hen step out of the woods about 830 and start heading toward me. soft yelps kept her coming, then out steps a big tom and several more hens heading my way but when they got to an opening in the fence from the stalk field into another timber, the tom paused, i had the bead on him, decided it was too far, and then they were gone the rain quit a half hour later and i ramped up the calling with some louder yelps and cutts. a few minutes later a head comes over a rise in the field and its a solo tom. he ignored the dekes and headed toward the fence gap where the others went, stopped and fanned without gobbling, but some soft yelps, clucks and purrs kept him coming my way. dropped him at 40 yards after stepping it off to where he lay, i kept going to where the other tom left the field and it was 55 big steps, so glad i didnt shoot went 23, 10, 1 but the rain cut loose again on the way back to the truck so i didnt take pictures  
    • If you were anywhere close to southern Minny I would invite you over and let you drive mine and show you the things I look for both in the jeep and plow since mine seems pretty close to what you are looking for. If you have any questions PM me.
    • Good luck PFUNK! Looking like that will be my next day out too. forecast looks good as well!
    • I think the TJ might be the best choice with the 4.0 which is what I did.I bought the plow used after the fact. I got the plow for 1200 but the wiring was not good nor was the mount so I had a new custom, heavier duty mount made at a fab shop and I bought a brand new wiring kit from Western. I also bought all stainless bolts for it so there are no rust issues with them. Wiring the plow was a task. I basically had to remove the entire interior including console, seats and many dash parts to run the wiring.   One thing to consider- There is really very little room for much of anything in them. Running new wires, adding a speaker anywhere or even having 2 guys, 2 guns, a dog and a cooler is a tight fit. The back seat works for kids but not adults and mostly I take my back seat out so I have at least some room to put stuff. Running the wiring to run the plow took probably 8 hours or more spread over a few days and for a bigger guy it's pretty much impossible to reach under the dash and run wires,connect to fuse blocks even with the seat removed.    But the ability to take off the top and cruise the gravel roads with no doors while hunting is not possible in basically any other vehicle except maybe a Manx Dune buggy which has also been on my bucket list and those aren't 4x4. 
  • Our Sponsors