Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
MinnesnowtaWild

Barbless Hooks?

9 posts in this topic

Just wondering how many of you big game fisherman are using barbless hooks. Today while Carp fishing, I had a Carp profusely bleeding everywhere and to make matters worse, the hook would NOT come out. I am using 5/0 Team Catfish circle hooks, and I have thought about eliminating the barbs on my hooks but have feared losing a real big fish.

So after I probably killed that Carp today, I flattened the barb and gave it a cast. I immediately had a very large fish on, presumably a large Carp, and after fighting it for a dozen seconds or so I lost the fish. I am used to 10-15 lb. Carp, and this thing was like none other. I am thinking it was near the 20 lb. range.

Needless to say, I was VERY upset that I decided to eliminate the barb on my hook. That's where I get my question...

Do any of you guys use barbless hooks? And if so, has your hookup rate been worse than before? Proper and safe Catch & Release is VERY important to me (even rough fish like Carp), and I am very confident that a barbless hook is much safer for the fish and easier to remove. However, I did lose a large fish today and it was probably because of the hook.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Going barbless with a circle hook works fine if you're not using live or cut bait. Its hard to keep live bait or cut bait on the hook. Would probably work alright with worms or fishing dough bait for carp though. As far as fish coming off with a barbless circle hook, I think you'd be fine just as long as you keep a tight line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When Catfishing, I always use live bait so I probably won't do that. I think I will only resort to flattening the barb if the fish really needs the hook out and it won't budge.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You must be a democrat. Don't over react to one bleeding carp. Cats and carp are tough, use a big, tough hook to catch them. Treat them with respect when you catch one doing a quick and safe catch, photo, and release doing as little harm as you can to the fish in the process.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Carp and cats, especially cats, seem to have super sensitive mouths when it comes to bleeding. The slightest slip of a hook or anything remotely sharp too close to the pad of a cat and it seems like the bleed like a stuck hog.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just curious what a democrat and a person who cares about safe release have in common?

I will probably forget using the flattened barb, but only use it if there is no other option.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have not been too impressed with my limited experience with barbless circle hooks for cats. I've tried it a few times and have had four fish hooked well and lost two of them. With barbed circle hooks I can only remember having one come off that seemed to be well hooked in the past three years.

However, in Manitoba barbless hooks are required and I've seen reports where they claimed there is no problem with barbless hooks. Maybe it is a learning thing, or perhaps barbless J hooks are better than barbless circle hooks. I like circle hooks, but am not too excited about giving them many more barbless tries.

There are a couple of things you can do to help hold on live bait with a barbless hook. If you cut a tiny piece of plastic (from a milk bottle or pop bottle) and slip it on the hook after the bait, it helps hold it on. Also, rubber bands can help hold on live bait and cut bait.

I did have good luck with barbless hooks for carp, but they were not circle hooks. I'd try it with carp first and get a little practice using barbless hooks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

^ That is a good idea. I would be way too frustrated to try it if I lost a nice cat because of it. Carp on the other hand and it wouldn't be as bad.

I will be Carp fishing all day tomorrow and then getting some Chubs for dark, so I'll see how the barbless hook does with the Carp and go from there.

Thanks for the replies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • LOL.  It's so brave of you to join the 85%.
    • Why would they bother cutting a measly 8 to 10 trillion from the debt?   And why would they consult with a kook like Rand Paul?      
    • First, I am Christian and I'm not ashamed of it.  Second, the 1st amendment to our US Constitution guarantees that the government shall not make any laws respecting the establishment of religion or the free exercise thereof.    This means that the government is not permitted to endorse or decide for the people what religion, if any, the people will follow. At the same time, there is nothing in the law that declares that we the people are restricted from expressing our personal religious views or beliefs. Therefore, it is well within my rights to share my Christian views whenever I wish except I cannot use government property or my position as a representative of the government as a forum to do so.
    • Drum roll please................. The clear cut winner was the sinking radish seed by a 4-1 margin over the floaters. I even gave the floaters an extra day to pop up but they didn’t. I know come planting time I am going to check my radish seed this way. I also hear this works for tomato seed so that may be my next experiment but not till I am ready to start growing my tomatoes. Peppers come to mind as another seed to try out.   Now the radish I have seeded will not go to waste I saw a program where a guy plants radish and lets it grow to about three inches then cuts the top two and half inches off. He sells the tops to restaurants who use it on plates and also in sandwiches. You are suppose to be able to eat the tops at this stage and it tastes like radish... Kind of like eating sprouts but only eating the top of the new growth not the bottom...
    • Yep, I have noticed that too. That is a good thing to have in your back pocket in playoffs and you get caught in your zone for an icing or who knows what reason where you cannot switch lines OR just to have flexibility with matchups line vs line, but faceoff on one side vs the other.
    • Meh, his exacts words were " I tried to set myself on fire."   Setting yourself a blaze is fairly simple and effective if you want to be on fire.   I'll put him in the bat poop crazy, drama queen Zoloft category along with a former girlfriend.   You know, the one that chokes down a handful of Bayer and chases it with a fifth of vodka then proceeds to call 911 right after. Then everyone has to listen why, all the while there was no real danger.   
    • To be honest, I think of the cross as representing a burial site of a fallen soldier.  I don't necessarily even think religion when I look at the thing. In my opinion it is not even a religious symbol in that context. But that's just me.
    • The reversible plank is what they were carrying when I picked it up.  I've just been calling it carsiding because it's what most people are more familiar with.    I have that all stained and polyurethaned on the smooth side.  To me the bead side looks kind of dated.
    • Something else to keep in mind. When I was bow hunting I learned judging distance is not as easy as one might think. The bow I used was not super fast so judging a deer to be at 30 yards when it was really 40 yards would mean missing.    In my experience, we over-estimate distance sometimes by quite a lot on open areas such as open fields or on a lake. On an open area one doesn't have anything to provide a size reference so we tend to think objects are closer than they really are. Sometimes we can be off by quite a bit.   It works just the opposite in the forest where we have lots of references for size. Most of the time when a guy says he shot his deer from 50 yards it is probably a good bet that it was not quite that far. Personally, I don't like to get too close to anyone else. When on open water I rarely fish where others are. This can sometimes work against me as there is probably a reason for them being there. When ice fishing I try to stay 50 yards or more away from others. At the very least, I don't want to be close enough that our lines could become crossed when handling fish. 
    • Exactly.     We don't need to compete with Christians and their War on Xmas for the King Crybaby award.
  • Our Sponsors