Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Birdsong

ID Help: Flycatcher???

7 posts in this topic

I thought this was a Great Crested but now I'm not sure. On other photos, tail is notched, back is brown, not greenish, wing bars obscured for the most part, but seem to be minimally present, distinct necklace between throat and top of breast. Lower story. No song. No monopod either, unfortunately, and a little overcropped for id purposes.

3503368184_ed728af305_o.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sarah, you're right in that it's a flycatcher species. It's an eastern phoebe or eastern wood-pewee. I'd say phoebe.

Using photographic guides to ID bird species isn't something I recommend as the usual course of business. Too many variables in too many processes to suit me. The illustrations in the best bird guides (Sibley, National Geographic) are more representative than photographs.

Next time, look to see if it does a lot of tail-wagging. That's a distinctive phoebe behavior. Also, check the songs. The pewee is a more musical and swooping pee-o-wee, the phoebe a hoarse phee-bee.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Eastern Phoebe for sure. You can see the wind pick up its crown feathers giving it a crested look. Eastern Pewee do have a crested look even without the wind. But Eastern Pewees do not have a yellow wash on the breast nor the contrasting darker crown vs. the cheek and other upper parts of the bird. The flicking or pumping of the tail is a good identification mark but there are other birds that also pump its tail as well.

Eastern Phoebe is the first flycatcher bird species to arrive in Minnesota. Great-crested Flycatchers do not arrive in Minnesota till about next week in southern Minnesota or so.

Mike

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks, Mike. I knew you'd be looking in and could fill in the gaps with a professional perspective.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I knew he would be, too. Thanks both. So, the little stinker was throwing me off with his little pointy head and yellow belly? I have phoebes every spring, and think of them as less brown, more dark gray and no yellow. And the morning was absolutely dead still yesterday. That being said, my Golden Field Guide, which does have drawings rather than photos, gives them a little pointy head and the juveniles look just like this one. Could he still be considered juvi at this time of year? I have never been good at flycatchers. I am hoping in the process of being out all the time again, (retirement--yay!!) that I can become a better birder. You guys are a great help and maybe a new Sibley Guide is in order.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sarah, I don't know if it would still have juvenile plumage, but Mike will know the answer to that for sure. Some bird species wear their immature plumage into their second summer.

Head/body shape can vary depending on how the feathers lie. Wind can push them around, and the birds themselves can change them (the phoebe has a small crest it can elevate, as well). There's some plumage variation among individuals in almost all bird species, and the Golden guide isn't the best at showing such variation. It's pretty far down the list of my preferred guides. In descending order, I prefer the Sibley, National Geographic, Peterson, Kaufman and Golden.

The Sibley in particular does a great job with a variety of subtle plumage differences (many of them vary slightly based on region) and on differences between adults and immature birds.

Check one out in the book store if there's a good book store near you and you'll be amazed at just how well a bird guide can be done. I sure was. You might also pick up The Sibley Guide to Bird Life & Behavior, which is an excellent companion volume to the field guide and is packed with great information.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Check one out in the book store if there's a good book store near you and you'll be amazed at just how well a bird guide can be done.

Our local book store closed up a little over a month ago. However, I was able to pick up the Sibley Field Guide and Stoke's Field Guide at 40% off. smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Shame on you for questioning  these great and wonderful plans.  Have you no faith?  Besides it's pure nonsense.  She made a lot of claims that her plans would not add anything to the deficit or debt   But we have heard those same claims many times over.  It's a mystery why people still believe that everything is going to be funded through just simply raising taxes on people making over $250,000 a year just because "their " candidate said so When a candidate comes up with more spending ideas and tells you that the "rich" are going to be the ones that are going to fund them ,what they really mean is they're  going to fund them through printing and borrowing. They just use accounting tricks and schemes to hide the cost but I prefer math   Personally, I prefer any candidate I were to support tell us how they're going to get us out of this fiscal mess we're in    
    • I agree he should not have been playing in the world cup.
    • Im going to run my Elite 5 on the dash also, soley as my gps. So that will free up space on the Garmin for the side imaging...Now I cant wait for spring to try out all the new toys haha....I've always heard Garmin were really nice I just never saw any of their units that had the features I wanted and were in my $$ range.. I think I'll be really happy with it...Im curious how the preloaded maps are that come with it (lakevu??) I think its called. It would be sweet if it would take my Garmin upper midwest fishing guide chip, but I doubt it does.
    • I don't think it will adhere to the surface very well under 50 degrees.  Especially on the bottom, it could create some real problems if it doesn't stick very well!
    • Sure wakes ya up when nodding off and that reel goes ZINGGGG!!
    • lol sugar coat it all you want Nick the Gophers are a 7th best team in the Big 10 period. They don't have a meaningful win this entire season and they didn't beat any other team in the big 10 with a winning record except for Northwestern who are 5-4 in conference play but 6-6 overall. That isnt trolling at all, its facts.   I hope they can recruit by selling a trip to the Holiday Bowl this year. Big things happening for the Gophers!
    • that sounds great!!!  they were good pictures too!
    • I use the same set up and I think it's the only way to go.
  • Our Sponsors