Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. ?

Vertical hold/fish handling


Cooter

Recommended Posts

It will be interesting to see where the best handling practices/trends will head in the future of musky fishing - and catch and release fishing in general. Some thoughts I have...

It still bothers me when bass guys torque the heck out of a fish by lip holding one yet the fish is horizontal, just can't be good. And tourney fishing survival rates...maybe another topic for later.

For muskies, do we have any valid proof/evidence that vertical holds are harmful? Seems like its best to avoid them and I follow that line of thinking. However, when was the last time you saw someone lift a musky out of a net with a proper two handed horizontal lift? I'm guilty of it, its tough on a big fish in a big boat in big waves. Also, I would think the size of the fish makes a difference - I think a little 20" musky would be less likely to suffer any damage with a vertical hold vs a 50" fish.

What about even a proper two handed, belly supporting horizontal hold? At times the the belly hand gets pretty far back and you end up with an unnatural U-shaped bend on the fish, that can't be much better(or better at all) than a vert hold, can it?

Again, it will be interesting to see what we learn in the future...thoughts/opinions?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hiya -

This really has been a pretty hot issue from time to time in the muskie world. We've done quite a bit on it in the pages of The Next Bite - Esox Angler the last few years, and there was recently an article on it in another muskie publication as well.

My take on it is that if it's a fish of a size you're interested in catching, you shouldn't hold it vertically. Period. Every biologist I've ever talked to - ALL of them - have told me it's not a safe way to handle fish you want to release. Years ago we used to argue that the risk to vertically held fish was in displacing their internal organs. There's some truth to that. Fish are built physiologically to be horizontal in a dense medium, not held vertically in thin air. But in reality, after talking with a number of biologists and fish physiologists, the real risk in long term injury is to the musclar and skeletal structure of the area around the head and gills...it was just never meant to support any kind of weight, and the muscle and ligament damage to vertically held fish is significant. Physics being what it is, the larger the fish, the greater thepotential harm. If not immediately fatal, this tissue damage can have extremely negative effects on their ability to respire and feed, which has long term health effects that can be ultimately fatal.

Black Bay referred to some articles that have been published on this topic. Check out the one by Michael Butler. Mike is a research scientist with the Ontario MNR and the Ontario Museum of Natural History. He sent out a query to fisheries biologists and fish physiologists who handle large fish all over the world asking them about vertical holds. Their response was universally against the practice. The quote that stuck with me was "my advice to anyone who holds a fish vertically by the gills is to eat it..."

There are still a few out there who will argue that there's no difinitive research "proving" that vertical holds are bad, and until there is, they'll keep doing it. I once asked a biologist from the MN DNR why there hasn't been any research on the subject. He looked at me like I was nuts, and said "we don't have the time or money to study the obvious..."

As I said, there was a recent article which made the claim that fish held vertically did just fine. This was by an angler who had done his own "study" with tags he put on a handful of fish which he later recaptured. Personally, I thought the article was irresponsible and contrived. The ONLY claim he could credibly make was "they don't all die..." yet went on to claim this as proof that vertical holds were ok. Call me crazy, but I'll give fisheries biologists and physiologists from all over the world a little more credibility than one amateur with a small handfull of fish to point to...

The bottom line for me when it comes to vertical holds is that if there's credible information pointing to its negative effects, why do it? There's absolutely no need to hold a fish vertically in the course of a capture, photo, and release. The only reason to do it is because to some, the photos look impressive. To me, that's not enough of a reason to justify it. You can have great looking photos without a vertical hold. Do a the semi-vertical, with one hand supporting the side of the fish (what several biologists have told me is preferrable if you have to hold the fish up), take an in-the-water shot, or whatever, but vertical holds just aren't necessary. To me, it's a matter of ethics. If you're going to release the fish, why do unnecesary harm in the process?

If you don't want to hurt them, why take photos at all? Many people don't. I take very few, and many of the ones I do take are in the water release shots...in part because it's easy on the fish, and in part because those are just my favorite kind of fish pictures. I understand that the topic of handling fish is a slippery slope. We run the risk of taking all the fun out of it, and I acknowledge that. But I don't think you need to go that far. There are lots of ways to safely handle fish and take photos or whatever without unnecessary risk to the fish due to overhandling, and photos are, for a lot of us, an important part of the fun.

Many who argue that we get too carried away with catch and release and fish handling is based on some PETA-like bunny-hugging mentality. Nothing could be further from the truth. Pushing safe handling and successful catch and release is the most selfish thing I do. I want them to swim away healthy so I can catch them again...

Cheers,

Rob Kimm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Rob, any thoughts/comments on removing fish from nets...like I said many people will hold them properly for photos and such but even then many are pulled out of the water vertically by a gill. Is it time to address this? Or since its usually such a short time period where the fish is lifted vertically is it insignificant? Thanks again, later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Holding muskies by the tail doesn't work well. Actually it doesn't work at all for esocids. Their tails aren't built as stout like a salmon tail. Plus the fish are so long they'll just kick your rear trying to hold them that way. Cradles are probably the best way to handle long heavy fish that you're planning on releasing.

BTW Please Please PLEASE don't use boga grips on muskies or pike! BAD NEWS!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hiya -

The tail and belly thing works ok on smaller fish, but not so much on bigger ones. As Black Bay said, they just dont' have the build for it. One DNR biologist I know autopsies a lot of dead muskies caught on Metro lakes, and he says on some of them you can see the hand print on the caudal peduncle (that's the 'wrist' of the tail, but I use the technical term because it's fun to say 'peduncle.' Seriously - try it. Peduncle peduncle peduncle smile.gif ) Plus on larger fish, you have a lot of fish hanging over in front of your hand, with your supporting hand acting as a lever on the spine. Again, as Black Bay said, cradles, hybrids like the Frabil Kwik Kradle, or BIG nets are the way to go if you don't hand land and water release them.

Cooter, to answer your question about getting fish out of the net, it is sort of tough, especially with a high front deck like I have, or with a big fish. Best you can do is get a supporting hand under them as soon as you can. I sort of grab them in a lip lock, then run my hand down their side as far back as I can reach, and lift with both hands. Kind of awkward, especially with a big fish, but minimizes weight on the gill hold.

Cheers,

Rob Kimm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • My daughter just texted and said they were awesome up in Alexandria. Cant see anything here in Arizona.
    • I was driving by so I stopped to grab a few cell phone shots. That water should be flowing for awhile. It sure is flowing through our neighborhood.    
    • Riding in Lake Havasu City….   Saw lots of wild burrows! A little shy so I had to use some zoom.    
    • looks purty healthy. must be all them delicious sunflower and bird seeds!!!!!!! 👍🤗
    • Relaxing on a nice sunny day.  
    • Nice Copy and paste.    Any links to the  Ocoopa Union 5s rechargeable hand warmers?    
    • Luxury RV camping has become increasingly popular in recent years as people look for ways to enjoy the great outdoors while still enjoying the comforts of home. With the right equipment and preparation, luxury RV camping can be a truly unforgettable experience. In this essay, we will provide you with the ultimate guide to luxury RV camping, including tips on choosing the right RV, selecting the best campsite, and packing for your trip.   The first step to planning a luxury RV camping trip is to choose the right RV. There are a variety of different types of RVs available, ranging from small and compact trailers to large and luxurious motorhomes. The right RV for you will depend on your budget, your travel plans, and your personal preferences.   One popular option for luxury RV camping is a Class A motorhome. These motorhomes are typically the largest and most luxurious RVs available, with spacious interiors, full kitchens, and even multiple bathrooms. They often come equipped with high-end features such as leather upholstery, flat-screen televisions, and high-quality audio systems. Class A motorhomes are also the most expensive type of RV, but they offer the ultimate in comfort and luxury.   Another popular option for luxury RV camping is a fifth wheel trailer. These trailers are typically larger than travel trailers and are designed to be towed by a pickup truck. They offer many of the same amenities as Class A motorhomes, including full kitchens, multiple bathrooms, and high-end features such as surround sound systems and flat-screen televisions. Fifth wheel trailers are often less expensive than Class A motorhomes but still offer a high level of comfort and luxury.   Once you have chosen the right RV for your luxury camping trip, the next step is to select the perfect campsite. There are a variety of different types of campsites available, ranging from basic, no-frills campsites to high-end RV resorts with all the amenities. When selecting a campsite, it is important to consider your budget, your travel plans, and your personal preferences.   If you are looking for a truly luxurious camping experience, consider staying at an RV resort. These resorts often offer a wide range of amenities, including swimming pools, hot tubs, fitness centers, and even golf courses. They also typically offer high-end services such as concierge service, valet parking, and room service. RV resorts can be expensive, but they offer the ultimate in luxury and comfort.   If you are looking for a more affordable camping experience, consider staying at a state or national park. These parks offer a variety of different campsites, ranging from basic tent sites to RV sites with electrical and water hookups. While state and national parks may not offer the same level of luxury as RV resorts, they do offer the opportunity to experience the natural beauty of the outdoors.     Once you have chosen the perfect RV and campsite, the final step is to pack for your luxury camping trip. When packing for a luxury RV camping trip, it is important to focus on comfort and convenience. Pack clothing that is appropriate for the weather and activities you have planned, as well as comfortable shoes for hiking and exploring.   In addition to clothing, it is important to pack all the essentials you will need for your trip. This includes bedding, towels, toiletries, and any medications or other personal items you may need. It is also important to pack food and drinks, as well as any cooking supplies you will need for meals. If you are camping in the cold weather, bring the Ocoopa Union 5s rechargeable hand warmers are easy to use for camping. First, charge it, then turn it on, and finally, place it in your gloves or pockets. Additionally, the rechargeable hand warmer has 4 heat settings, allowing you to adjust the temperature to various weather conditions. With a large 10000mAh battery, it can provide up to 15 hours of heat and could use as a power bank, making it an ideal hand warmer for extended outdoor activities.   Finally, when packing for your luxury RV camping trip, don’t forget to pack entertainment options such as books, movies, and games. While luxury camping offers many opportunities for relaxation and outdoor activities, it is also important to have options for downtime and relaxation.      
  • Topics

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.