Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Guest

STrib - Legal fish?

Recommended Posts

Guest

OK you regs readers, is the fish featured in today's Star Tribune a legal fish? The guy first tried to net it, that failed, so he plucked it from the water by hand.

It was a northern choking on a big sucker, but it was still alive, and it is a game fish. The Wis regs are specific -- it would be illegal in Wis.

It's no big deal, and I'm not suggesting he be fined or anything -- I'm just curious.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That was the first thing I thought of too when a co-worker read me the article this morning. I have a sneaky feeling that was why he said he grabbed it along with stating it wouldn't fit into the net? Most likely still not legal but I doubt anything will come of it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Guess what? I stopped at the DNR building at the State Fair yesterday and asked the COs at the regulations desk for an opinion on the manner in which the publicized fish was "caught." I did not get a definitive answer.

The two I talked with did not, or could not give me an answer as to whether it was a legal fish. One said: "We'd probably have to look in the statutes."

The 2002 Fishing Regulations we got when we purchased current licenses does not address the issue.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I reviewed the 2002 Mn. regs and could not find anything that addressed this directly or indirectly. The only net info was for smelt.
Just for the heck of it I opened a copy of Websters Ninth Collegiate dictionary. The definition of fishing is "The sport or business of catching fish." The definition of a fish-net is " netting fitted with floats and weights or a supporting frame for catching fish." This could make a very interesting court case for lawyers to determine what is legal.
Dino

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

I've seen photos/know of someone who had this same thing happen with a muskie which choked on a 4lb walleye. The Musky was dying and struggliing for life, but there was nothing anyone could do to save it. The fins of the walleye cut the inside of the musky's mouth, throat and the fish was really suffering.
The fish was over 50", people who found it just completed a day casting for ski's when they stumbled across it. They kept the fish.
What's wrong with "catching" a fish like this with your bare hands? I don't think you'll find anything in MN statutes that will tell you different. I don't think the netting thing can stand because it wasn't like a gill net or anything like that...

Pretty soon the cost of licenses are going up to compensate the printing costs of the "law" books for all of us to understand the finest details!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Statutory definitions are not taken from Webster's Dictionary, nor is the word "catching" the same as "angling."

Wisconsin regs state if very simply. A legal catch is taken by hook in the mouth. A foul-hooked fish must be released. And, it is not legal to net sportfish or to take them by hand.

Sportfish should be protected. Even the one pictured in the Star Tribune might conceivably have ultimately swallowed the sucker and survived. I've known of pike taking much bigger prey than a 1.5 lb sucker. In fact, I've used 18 inch suckers for bait when I fished for big pike years ago with live bait.

However, I still find it strange that even two COs assigned to the State Fair to answer questions about regulations could not answer my question as to whether it was a legal catch.

Yet, the DNR deems it necessary to print: "The use of explosives, firearms, chemicals (not including fish scents), or electricity for taking fish is unlawful."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

WI thinks too deep, that is why I moved out of that state! smile.gif They even outlaw trolling and backtrolling on some waters! What the?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Many have had the same question, and sundays strib confirmed: NOT a Legal catch. Taking fish by hand is not legal...apparently even taking dead fish....prevents people from 'picking up' spawning fish in the streams...noodling for catfish is also prohibited in MN.

interesting quandry...

------------------
Northeast Outfitters
915 Hwy 29 N NE
Alexandria, MN 56308
(320) 763-9598

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Milwaukee Fishing Eezy Peezy! By Milwaukee Wisconsin fishing charter Capt. Jim Hirt Lake Michigan Salmon Fishing Report 6/24/2019 Hello all, thank you for reading my reports. Joe, Laura and Jonathan Wolf from Mansfield Texas had fair weather and a multi species catch on a beautiful day on Lake Michigan. I enjoyed the opportunity to fish with them. Join us in Milwaukee! To get my fish reports and how to videos first go to http://www.jimhirt.com By subscribing you will keep ahead of the other anglers. When I post you will get it fast! Action is steady and all species are active. The water is still 50 degrees on top. This has made for easy presentation to fish. As long as this continues anglers will have success don’t miss out. Good weather and lake conditions will fill the cooler in the future. The water is warming up near shore and that area is slow. There are pods of forage from 70 feet and out to 200. The recent changes has brought many Chinooks and Coho in. Most of the fish came from the top to the bottom. Our best presentations are Church Walleye planer boards with 150 and 225 copper running 40 to 65 down and downriggers 80 to 120 feet down. Flasher and Bull Frog flies or 100 foot leads on Reaper magnum spoons on downriggers have been the best producers. Reaper magnum spoons are sold at http://www.badgertackle.com with free shipping. Our best boat speed was 2.0 mph. Wire Divers are producing very well set to #2 with 130 feet of line out. Have a great fishing season. Let's go fishing!! Jim charters out of Milwaukee, WI. with Blue Max Charters. He can be reached at 414-828-1094 or visit his web site at http://www.bluemaxcharters.com Copyright© 2019, James J. Hirt, All Rights Reserved. Fish,report,salmon,lake,michigan,Milwaukee
    • Well, after two and a half hours on the phone with Netgear and Comcast I have no resolution.  Comcast is coming out to the house on Wednesday to see what the problem is.  I am on the 150 mbs plan and I still only get around 30 on a speed test.  Even when I wire directly to the router the performance is the same.  I may upgrade to the Roku Ultra as well.
    • The speeds that you show are enough for streaming, the roku stick is not their best streaming device. I use Roku 3 and used to have your bandwidth with no problem.
    • fishingstar 4th win with 319pts. 2--Fishing_Novice             314 3--mnwildman                   304 4--Juneau4                        283 5--BlackLundProV            279 6--gregg52                         268 7--icefishinnut                   218 _____________________________________________________ Seasons totals 1--Juneau4                       4635 2--Fishing_Novice           4490 3--gregg52                        4462 4--mnwildman                 4423 5--icefishinnut                 4387 6--BlackLundProV           4371 7--fishingstar                   4309   Chicago is the next stop 🏁
    • nice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    • The greenhouse experiment this year has paid off for me. I got to plant about a month earlier than I usually do.
    • They sound like they got cold, I planted too soon years back and had the same thing. I bought smaller new plants that out performed the stunted ones. It took about a month before they started growing again. The heat at the end of this week should help them out.
    • Not really. My cukes are going well. Got 3 tomato plants that look like they don't wanna do anything though!!??
    • That's a heck of a nail driver you got there!  😉
    • vaportrail, Welcome to the forum.  You Suk!  😆
×
×
  • Create New...