Family Lake or Amphibian Lake

[OneWay]

I am wanting to plan a Canada fishing trip this summer in early August for 4 couples. I am looking at either Family Lake (Shining Falls Lodge), or Amphibian Lake (Jackson's Lodge), both in Manitoba. From their websites both places seem like the women would approve because of "indoor plumbing". Has anyone fished either of these lakes or have any experience that would be helpful in making a decision. We have one couple that has never been on a Canada fishing trip and I want to try and choose a place where the fishing will be good for them. Any advice or suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance!