Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Cooter

Livebait alternatives

4 posts in this topic

Has anyone tried using sheepshead, mooneyes, redhorse, etc for flatheads? My concern is how long they would stay alive and active on a hook. Suckers are spendy and it seems you have to keep them cool to stay alive yet with warming water temps they go belly up pretty quick once you use them. I love using bluegills here in WI, but the stretch of river I want to fish wouldn't be reliable at all for catching any of them. No bullhead dealers in my area either. Oh yeah, what about frogs?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes they all will work if you can find them and catch them and keep them alive.

If you can temper the suckers they are surprisingly tough. Slowly bring them up to temp by adding warm water or placing a hot water bottle into the bait water.

Gradually bring the temp up over an hour or two so that it is close to the temp of the water you are fishing.

I was skeptical as well, but LFC has shown me the light.

Even if you can keep them alive, they are still expensive though frown

Don't be afraid to throw out a big piece of cutbait if they do happen to die on you. Some of my biggest flats have been on a piece of cutbait. Especially during this midsummer timeframe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mooneyes are great bait. Toss a small bobber upstream and let it dift with a piece of crawler a foot down and you are in bait. I didn't know about the 1 foot rule on bait and over the years most of the mooneyes I've caught and used for bait are about that long so watch that. They are like minny tarpon and will pull you into a snag when used as bait if you don't use enough weight or give them too much leader.

On a two rod river like the Croix do the fresh bait shuffle. Keep the fresh bait on a short lease until it dies, then cut them up and throw them out as cutbait on another rig until you catch another for bait. Hans

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm thinking where I'll be fishing I can catch bait as needed - we'll see. Tempering the suckers sounds like a great tip, thanks much!

No 1 foot rule in WI.

Haven't been out since two years ago, terrible....have tons of options close to home - no excuses!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    •   "We have found they do not like limburger cheese, hot dogs, or Makers Mark bourbon.  I am thankful for that."   Thanks for making my nite.  
    • Also woodpeckers beat on stuff to mark their territory.   I am pretty sure that there aren't any bugs on my metal downspouts.
    • You will often discover that birds are picking very small insects from decks and other woodwork around your house;  they do the same with trees and any other structure that might hold the bugs. We see them often on our decks and they usually pick a little bit and then move on,  perhaps just checking to see if there is anything edible there. These rascals also love hummingbird or oriole nectar, sunflower seeds and of course suet in winter. We have discovered  many species that will head straight for the nectar for orioles or hummingbirds and also plunge their beaks eagerly into the grape jam bowls orioles love. Birds will eat a greater variety than you might think. We have found they do not like limburger cheese, hot dogs, or Makers Mark bourbon.  I am thankful for that.
    • And pretty soon there'll be little chinese restaurants springing up everywhere...there goes the neighborhood. 
    • I use the ball of aluminum foil, too. Works well.
    • lay them in the grass over night and wipe off in the morning.  the dew soaks in if it's moist out.  other wise lay them out and place wet towels over them for awhile..
    • What do you have against Japanese Beetles?   Diversity is good.   We need all nationalities of beetles.  Even VW beetles.   Asian Lady Beetles, everything.  All nationality and gender identity beetles. 
    • Tysons chicken tender, Top sirloin steak, pork chop, burgers seasoned to taste - crispy crowns, tutor tots, fries - beer batter shore lunch Walleye, Crappie all better than deep fryer, oven or gas grill. Just do potato first & keep hot in oven at 250. Even Spam is better than pan fryed but if your under 40 you may not have a clue about Spam.
    • Yes spray it, or wipe it down with an oiled paper towel before you use it.  I use a little ball of aluminum foil to scrub them after the cook, but while they are still warm. They make disposable grill topper grates that are handy too when you are cooking something that is going to be really messy.
  • Our Sponsors