• RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
ShawnZ

Dowitcher, short or long billed and why please? :)

Recommended Posts

Here is a picture of a Dowitcher photographed in Duluth during spring migration last year. Do you think it's a long billed or short billed dowitcher and why? I did not hear the bird vocalize so ID has to be based on appearance alone, BorealHunter, are you out there? Frankly, this is one species that I have little idea how to differentiate in regards between short and long billed. Minolta5d, Tokina 400mm, iso 400, f9, Converted from RAW, levels, USM. Comments and critiques always welcome. A lowere perspective was not possible due to some wood debris being in front of the bird.

Regards, Shawn Zierman.

dowitcher2.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is such a nice shot and I liked how clear the water is. If I were to give you a guess it would be a Short-billed because of the color around the neck is light colored and the spotted underparts but Steve or Borealhunter would have a better guess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is one sweet image Shawn!...short or long!....by "really" studying your image and comparing it to my "Sibleys"...I'm going with the the short billed also..well....just because the image in Sibleys (to me)looks more like the short billed ...I'm of course going by bill lengnth only and not coloration or markings of any kind....there's so many types of shore birds some are sooooo hard to tell apart!...looking forward to the arrival of some shore birds up in my area ...would be nice if the lake ice would melt of course grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Shawn:

Dowitchers are one of them species of birds that are tough to ID on looks alone without hearing their call notes. The bird in your photo is a Short-billed Dowitcher. Its not a bright adult based on the lack of strong orange buff color on the breast/belly and that might be because its in a transition molt from juvenile to adult.

You cannot ID the bird based on bill length unless if you have both species of dowitchers in the same view. I based the ID on a few factors on the photo you provided.

1. the flanks of breast is not strongly barred as a Long-billed Dowitcher would have.

2. The scapulars would have white tips to the feathers ( Sibley noted this in his book ) and the tips are buff colored.

3. The side of the neck looks spotted as well.

Again the cinch ID mark is the call note that seperates the two species from each other. Also Long-billed Dowitchers arrive in Minnesota in Late April thru mid May while Short-billeds tend to arrive in Minnesota in Early May to June 1-10. Also in the Fall season Long-billeds tend to arrive in Minnesota way before Short-billeds.

Based on the photographed you must of been in Morgan Park mudflats right?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the id help gentlemen. I agree that this is most likely a short billed dowitcher. Hopefully someday I can have the opportunity to observe both species side by side as that what really helped me in learning to differentiate lesser and greater yellowlegs. Good eye Boreal Hunter, the image was indeed taken at the Morgan Park Mudflats. I sure hope the significant rain events hold off until late May/ early June, so the shorebirding can be as good there as it has been in the past.

Last fall stunk, I could not believe how high the water levels were compared to the year before, virtually no shorebirding on the flat when a year prior I had days where I encountered birds in the hundreds!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • I have had great luck w/ my 3 yr old Big Horn. I have always said that the controller and hopper looked a lot like the Pit Boss       yeah... I'd say you've got options!
    • Actually I got a new 4 burner Char Grill with side burner this spring for up at the camper and a new cheaper 2 burner with side burner a week ago for at home, so alone with the new Char Grill smoker I got last year I have plenty of wienee cookers thanks.  😘  
    • what type of lenses? glass?
    • About 10 years ago I bought a boat that I had to track down a person that was not who I bought the boat from as they owned it many years before that!!!  But I am sure that I got the owners name from the DMV to then track down and had her sign a form, brought back to DMV, and then put into my name.  I am guessing things have changed as to how to get the name, but sounds silly to have to write a letter to get information that they could use proper discretion to give it to you or not.  Good Luck!
    • Traegers are super over-rated and over-priced for what they are. I would rather buy that big horn up above than a Traeger.    I'm fairly certain that Big Horn is just a Pit Boss. Louisiana smokers makes Pit Boss and a bunch of other stuff that other's put their own name on including PF's Cabela's model. I have a small Pit Boss that I am going to use for camping and I like it just fine. I bought that one from a friend for $50 but I'm sure that's still too much for Leech......
    • ok so story time...the one that got away but saw the fish.  I was ice fishing on Red when the eye fishing was still closed and we went out for an early season excursion about a mile out of Westwind.  It was Saturday evening when I my bobber shot down and the fight was on.  Now we were only in probably 5-7 ft of water if that but I "tired" the fish out where I was able to get it directly under the hole and all we could see was a monster northern head filling up the hole!!  No one would put there hand near that thing, let alone blindly through 2.5 ft of ice, so we just watched it for a minute or two float beneath the hole until I tried to turn it up the hole and the line just snapped when he decided he had had enough!!  That was painful not to touch but seeing it and knowing it was all of 44"+ was better than wondering.   Now to the not seen...Ice fishing Waukanabo by Leech in the deep hole on the north end and I see a mark on the bottom and I hook into it and could not budge it off the bottom.  I sat there for a few minutes with rod bent over trying to lift it with nothing but my line slowly moving away until pop it spit my lure!!!  I think the hole is over 40' deep and with 4lb test mono I guess as much as I applied pressure the hook wasn't in!!    What could have been~ so those are two stories that stick out in my mind and of the 2 the second stings more as I have no clue what it could have been and that runs through my mind but the northern as cool as it would have been to touch measure and what not, to see it and to know how massive it was, makes it "easier" to deal with. 
    • Sorry for the delayed response.    Checked in at the Lac Seul Resort on Wednesday, June 6, and checked out on Monday, June 11. Anticipating our usual needs, I preordered 200 dozen minnows and a pound of leeches from KA Sports & Tackle in Dryden for 10 guys to fish for 4-1/2 days.    This was the first time in 20 years that we actually had bait left over at the end. I gave away about 30 dozen minnows to a neighboring cabin because they didn't have any.    We found the morning bite to be slow for some reason but the evening bite was better. Most activity was found in moving water on the English River. On Friday evening another guy and myself went to Pelican Rapids and from 6:00pm till about 9:30pm we figured we boated over 200 walleyes and a few northnerns. Unfortunately, they were all between 15" - 17" in length and we were looking for the 17" - 18" size for the freezer. That's always our goal for fish we intend to take home.    The following night we went back and although the fish weren't biting quite as fast they were larger. Over the same time frame we figured we only boated about 100 walleyes but the size ranged more in the 17" - 22" size.    Overall we had a few walleyes caught in the 25" - 28" range with the largest of the week at 28.25". Northern pike were active with many caught in the 31" - 34" range. Didn't boat any in the 40" range as we usually do but those lower 30-inchers sure put up a fight.    Also found a few nice smallies and whitefish as usual.    Most fish were found in the 10' - 14' depth range, which was unusual compared to previous years when we caught them in shallow water along the shorelines.    Great weather with steady winds out of the southerly directions, which is what we always hope for but never get and nobody got hurt. Another successful year for us.
    • Seeing the fish is probably my preference since I would probably release it anyway. The only unfortunate thing would be not having a photo of it. 
    • I stick pretty simple on full chickens.... A couple of pads of garlic butter under the skin and a little olive oil rub down on DRY skin (very important to have dry skin if you want it to be crispy when you are done). Seasoned the big one with Lawry's and the small one with Weber Kick'n Chicken. Heated the grill up to 375. Both birds were done in a little over an hr..... Pretty cheap and easy - and the wife is getting sick of pork so,,,,,,