Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
olbaidhh

Best Hand Held Sonar

Recommended Posts

Who makes the best\wich one works the best Hand held sonar and WHY?

1. Marcum

2. NorCross

3. Polar Vision

4. others?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Haven't tried any others than my polar vision, but as far as I know when I put it on the ice it reads an accurate depth and that is all I need for it to be best in my mind.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have the Polar Vision, too. It is the older style, not the smaller version. It seems to work good. I have gotten some weird readings from it, but that was through bad ice. They are a lot more handy than carrying around the Vexilar. Hey, Lavoi, have you been out to Melissa at all this year?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bought the Vexilar version hand held first (yellow handle) and it didn't work so I took it back and bought the Polar Vision. I can't say enough good things about it - works great. I have used both the larger version and the smaller one, which also has the water temp on it. I would recommend the larger version.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest

Polar Vision works perfectly for me too!

------------------
Chells

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That sharper image unit on hsolist right now looks to be exactly the same as the polar vision unit. $45 is the buy it now price.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just bought the Marcum LX-i, and I really like it. It makes for quick work checking depths. The display is on top, so I don't have to scrunch down to read the depth. It takes minimal moisture (a well placed spit) to get a reading. And, it's very compact and light making for a much better deal than lugging my flasher around.

I haven't owned any other models to compare it to. Plus, I wasn't convinced that I would find it all that useful. But, after using it, I wouldn't leave home without it.

------------------
Ray Esboldt
MarCum
Stone Legacy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used the polar vision last year and it worked great. This year I am disappointed, it does not read well -- even with new batteries. It may be the ice, but even thru an open hole it takes some time and gives false readings at times. Not wanting to drill a hole anymore w/o a good wroking hand held, I now have purchased the LXi ($119) and hope to try it this weekend. I think the top readout will be a plus, but will post a report as soon as I use the LXi

[This message has been edited by iceyooper (edited 01-22-2004).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I too have been waaay impressed with the MArcum hand held!

Saves a ton of time drilling when you can get accurate and very quick readings!!!


Jim W

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have had the Norcross Hawkeye portable. When it worked it was great. It is the model with a LCD screen on it. Fit in your hand. In 11 months I had to return it under warranty 3 times. When the 4th one quit working, I took it back and got the handheld Norcross that looks like a flashlight. I am not impressed with this unit either. It frequently does not read thru the ice even with lots of water poured on it. Just reads "-----". Last time I used it I was even having trouble getting a reading thru a drilled hole. Could it be the cheap battery I put in it? I thought if the battery is low that it just would not work, but maybe I will try a good brand battery. I wish the display was on the end so I wouldn't have to take it out of the water to read it....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I too have tried the Norcross Marine Hawkeye DF2120PX depthfinder that is selling on hsolist for $35. I have used it several times, and all things considered, it works fairly well for the $35 investment. It doesnt seem to do well through very cloudy ice, but when you use it on clear ice it seems to work OK. Sometimes, it does not register the depth, but generally I have found that it is usually due to not keeping the face held flat against the ice. Considering that it (and the competing models) normally sell for $120, I think it is a fairly decent depthfinder for the money. Just my $.02

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Horns make some otherwise normal people crazy. I'm not a horn hunter myself and that is one reason why.  
    • Dang what a shame not cool at all. I agree with leech. That’s more than enough acreage for more than one hunter to hunt. If he had the guts to go talk to the neighbor lady and she was fine with it then all is good. If this “kid” ( old guy) has an issue with it then he needs to grow up It’s not his land. Not many kids even hunt anymore so the fact that he wants to is great. Let him hunt some and if it continues to be an issue then maybe just tell him to pull the plug? I’m also dealing with some crazy neighbors right now that continue to feed. The CO has been out many times and they still do the same thing tickets have been given and there’s been some talking. I hate to “ tadle” on others but when people think they have rights that others shouldn’t have then that’s where a CO may come into play. Not saying you need to do this but if he comes barging to the door and demanding your son leave then maybe something needs to change and maybe he shouldn’t be allowed there. 
    • Leech- I thought about that same thing.  I do not know the guy or the family, so unsure of what the dynamic is there.    Thanks for the responses.  We are going to head over there this evening and talk with the lady. My plan is take it down either way.  If she says he can still hunt, and boot the other guy, or even let them both hunt i dont think if the experience is going to be anything we are looking forward to dealing with.  We have 10 acres at our house he's hunting too, and going to do some more knocking on doors.  I get being protective over his "spot". It just bothers me that he would be so unwilling to allow a 15 yr old to experience what he clearly loves to do.  Life will go on.  We will be in Montana in Oct, chasing elk and mule deer. He wont be missing out!  Those bucks are roaming the river bottom we live on, maybe the ultimate revenge will be having a chance to shoot one of them on our own land we are grooming for wildlife together.
    • Dang, I just moved Duff higher on the LIKE count!  😕
    • Beisswengers Hardware in New Brighton.  Top sales of Honda Gens and excellent service. Beisswengers
    • I would get a dlb ladder stand and sit with my kid as much as I could.  Don't let the dude bully you if you have the right to be there as well.  She may not know the age of this person if he had his kid go down there and get permission and he is really doing the hunting?  
    • He has permission from the landowner, let him hunt. If the 50 year old does anything to affect his hunt that is "hunter harassment" and he should be charged. 
    • Obviously the guy has "passion" for "his" hunting spot.  I would try to meet him face to face with your son and see if you couldn't reasonably discuss it and come to an agreement.  Possibly do it at the landowners home if you want to put him in his place.  This of course first goes with how you feel this gentleman would be towards a talk.  After all it is not his land and he can't just bully his way around.  Now if you feel he is psychotic then don't bother.  I have a chunk of land that I can't hunt (even though I have permission and all the rights to hunt it) because the neighbor is crazy enough that he will possibly hunt me and I don't need that feeling of being hunted.  Hope you can work things out!  People get funny when it comes to hunting land especially when they know there is a bigger deer in the area. 
    • Can anyone suggest a good place in the North Metro to get a Honda EU2000 tuned up? Been running problem free for 6 years so I figure it's time.   Thanks in advance for the help.
    • Tough deal on this one.    You've got to decide how much fight you want to put into this.  There are also a lot of life lessons here to teach your son just depends on which one you want to focus on.    In most circumstances I would start out by going to the landowner and explaining the issues and see if you can get it resolved.  However, with it being an 85 year old woman you'll have to decide if you want to drag her into it. I'd probably at least inform her of the issue so that she's aware of what is happening on her property and what type of person is out there.  She should at least know that much as the landowner  If she wants to make it right then so be it but I wouldn't push her on it.  Just leave it as a heads up and let her know your son will move on as to not cause trouble if she doesn't seem like she's got it in her to straighten things out. 
×