Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
bucketmouth64

line recommendations

Recommended Posts

I have a canada fishing trip in June and I need some recommendations on what line to spool up. I would like to stay with 8 lb test. I've been thinking of vanish, magnaflex, or sensation. I've used sensation before, but not the others. I will be fishing walleye and smallies with this line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey Bucket-

This subject was discussed rather lengthly earlier. I would encourage you to give Gamma a try. This is a phenomenal line. The flourocarbon is the best that I have ever used, and the tensile strength of the mono which is a coplymer is so good that I have been able to drop in lb. test and feel I have gained strength. You won't be disappointed.

Doug

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've had bad luck with flourocarbons but haven't used them in a few years so maybe I will try them.

I think the best line is Maxima when it comes to mono. Ultragreen is limp and castable, while chameleon is tough and abrasion resistant. Maxima is the only mono I use at this point on my spinning and casting applications. I hate to plug something, but I believe in this line. Just my $0.02.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you plan to use a spinning outfit, I strongly urge you NOT to use Vanish. I tried it last summer and it tangled up so bad I removed and replaced it after about ten minutes of fishing, or trying to fish.

I like Trilene XL as the best of the well known spinning lines and Sufix Elite, which is better and super strong. Elite is my new favorite spinning reel line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will be using a spinning outfit. Thanks Questor for the heads up on the vanish. That is the last thing I want to deal with is a huge overrun birdnest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bucketmouth64:

You're welcome.

The Sufix Elite is great because it has the same diameter and castability as the Trilene XL, but has unbelievable knot strength. I think it's really more like 15 pound test. I've been an enthusiastic fan of XL for a long time, but the Elite really has it beat.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use Stren Magnathin in 10# on my mono rigged reels, never had a problem with it so have not tried any of the others mentioned above. Ran into the same issue with Vanish on a spinning reel once, now I use it only as a leader material.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it matters how you plan on fishing, are you fishing a river system or lake, if i was fishing a river system using jigs i would defintly go with fireline, now if i was fishing open water i would use a stren or some other brand with a flourocarbon leader. I have been up to canada fishing, but we fished a river system and i love using the fireline bc of the rocks and the pike that attmpt to take your jigs away from you. ooo.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

I have a canada fishing trip in June and I need some recommendations on what line to spool up. I would like to stay with 8 lb test. I've been thinking of vanish, magnaflex, or sensation. I've used sensation before, but not the others. I will be fishing walleye and smallies with this line.


I've been keeping a journal for the last few years, keeping track of catch rates based on line used is one of the pieces of data that I've been collecting...

Last year I plugged in the combo of the two best, and my buddies who spooled like wise... Amongst the three of us, we all doubled the catch rate percentage of any other combo of three people. Based on 300-350 hours on the water each.

Best combo was running two rods...

Rod A Medium Heavy... Spooled with a monobacker on 10 pound fire line.

This rod was used for Lindy Rigging, and trolling only.

*Note for highest percentage tie your own Lindy Rigs with vanish. (Make sure to incorporate a float on the string.)

Rod 2 Medium Light... Spooled with 6 Pound Vanish Transition... This rod was only used for finesse work, such as jiggin and bobber fishing.

****

A couple of note on Vanish or really any Florocarbon...

#1. You have to spool the line on correctly... The line reacts very sensatively to line torsion. So MAKE SURE YOU SPOOL IT ON STRAIGHT.

To many people do that dump where they just toss the spool on the floor and slop the line onto the reel, maybe holding a hand on the rod to feed the line through...

This will make a crazy amount of torsioned line on the spool.

Also, make sure it's not a cheap reel... Cheap reels create a little bit of line torsion on their own...

If you don't heed this torsion issue, you will get some of the most bizare ratnests you've ever seen!

2. Always remember... Vanish sinks... So if you're bobbering in an area where there is no current... (Or making your own Lindy/roach rigs) Keep in mind that you'll need to slowly keep working the bobber back to the boat. (Or keep a float in the line of the roach rig.)

****

The combo of these two lines used properly in the right situation really went a long way toward raising my percentages.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will be on Eagle Lake. I am assuming most of the fishing will take place on the lake with the guide. My other reels (baitcasters) have PP on them. I plan on using those for pikes and cranks. I asked the folks at Temple Bay Lodge about crappies and they said there are none. That was a shock. Is it too cold in Canada for crappies? Or are there too many big predators that would eat them? Again, thanks for the info. all of you have provided.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will have to agree with Fishbreth on this one, eventhough he is from Iowa wink.gif. You can't go wrong with Maxima. I really like the strengh and abraision resistance of Maxima Chameleon. If you prefer mono to braid on your spinning reel, as I do, it is the best stuff I have used. I have had nothing but trouble with Vanish, but I hear it has been reformulated so who knows. I would be a bit wary of superlines around rocks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

I will be on Eagle Lake. I am assuming most of the fishing will take place on the lake with the guide. My other reels (baitcasters) have PP on them. I plan on using those for pikes and cranks. I asked the folks at Temple Bay Lodge about crappies and they said there are none. That was a shock. Is it too cold in Canada for crappies? Or are there too many big predators that would eat them? Again, thanks for the info. all of you have provided.


I'm sure there are Crappies, but outside of certain early times in spring or through the ice in winter they are probably really hard to find, and in small numbers...

Crappies are plankton eaters... It stands to reason that the further north you go the lesser the growing season, meaning the lesser the plankton blooms, means the weaker the crappies can compete for food, space and forage base.

Besides you're going to Canada... Going to Canda to fish for Crappies, is like being invited to a bikini oil wrestling party at the Playboy Mansion, and then spending all night doing needle point with the coat check girl!

In Canada you fish for Walleye... If the walleye aren't biting then you fish for Champion Pike of Maybe Musky... If they aren't biting, then you switch back to Walleye.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That was great Dances. All we planned on fishing for were for walleye, northern, smallies. Muskie season isn't open during the time I am there. But if we fish for northerns I wouldn't be surprised if a muskie came around and accidently catching it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For the Canadian shield stained water lakes, I'd strongly recommend a super line whether jigging or trolling. Don't worry about flouro leaders, you can just tie direct.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quote:

For the Canadian shield stained water lakes, I'd strongly recommend a super line whether jigging or trolling. Don't worry about flouro leaders, you can just tie direct.


The problem though with jigging super line on a CS is that if you're in a rocky area, and you tied a good knot... You get into a rock snag, and unless you're lucky... You're going to be cutting your line at water level, because the knot isn't going to give...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

However, most of the time your snagged w/a superline, it's much easier to get loose. It's also much easier to feel bottom to prevent snags. You're going to lose a lot more jigs w/mono, which will break off when snagged or get cut up on rocks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fish breath knows the truth. Unfortunetly he let the cat out of the bag. Maxima is the only mono to go on any of my reels. if your going to be jigging I would strongly suggest down sizing at least 2 #s; if your going to be mostly trolling I'd stick with the 8. Maxima is the only way to go. Oh, its not that easy to find... mostly big stores or online. Strongly reccomend for many great attributes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Great anything else?  Start the slaughter!  😠
    • does he need to?  Sounds like he put a whoopin on the boys in the one practice he showed up and played in...
    • This is not good news:   http://www.startribune.com/virus-new-to-state-s-deer-inflict-quick-and-suspicious-deaths-in-herd-near-twin-cities/497832721/   "Quick and suspicious" deaths of several deer this month in a captive herd south of the Twin Cities are being attributed to a virus never before seen in deer in Minnesota, state officials said Wednesday.   The Minnesota Board of Animal Health has confirmed the first cases of epizootic Hemorrhagic disease (EHD) in seven animals in a small herd of captive white-tailed deer in Goodhue County. There is no specific treatment or vaccine available in this country. Six of the deer died this month, the agency said, while a remaining buck "appears healthy at this time and is showing no clinical signs associated with this disease."   While this is the first detection of EHD among deer in the state, it is widespread across North America. There are no known health risks to humans, the Board of Animal Health said.   EHD has previously been detected in two Minnesota cattle in southern Minnesota — in Brown County in 2012, and Murray County in 2013.   "This virus is transmitted between deer by biting midges, or gnats, which are most active in the fall before they are killed by the first frost of the season," said Dr. Mackenzie Reberg, senior veterinarian with the Board of Animal Health. "These bugs can't travel far on their own, and we're concerned by this detection because the herd owner hasn't moved deer onto the property for several years."   The "quick and suspicious deaths of the animals," as the agency's announcement characterized them, alarmed the owner, who worked with a veterinarian to submit tissues from the carcasses to the Iowa State Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory for investigation and confirmation.   Many deer species may be infected with EHD, but white-tailed deer are highly susceptible and experience high rates of mortality. Most die within 36 hours of clinical signs, which can include fever, anorexia, lethargy, stiffness, respiratory distress, oral ulcers, and severe swelling of the head and neck.   The Board has notified the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources of the newly confirmed cases.
    • Not so Young dumb and full of............   Anymore?  😜
    • I think Negan should be in a cell that has a couple walkers in a cell on each side. lol
    • So, is Butler playing in the season opener? Has he even practiced, other than that one infamous time?
    • 2 episodes in, and I don’t have much of anything to complain about. Not great episodes by any means, but not bad either.
    • Good luck to you all. Sounds like a great trip.
    • Thanks Scoot!  Yes, we have our bear spray, brought a couple extra cans to keep in our packs besides what we have our on hips.   Hopefully it remains there the whole trip. Going to try and keep this updated during our trip. My son is taking video production class in school, hopefully he can put something together when we get back. Signing off for now, going to have lunch with the wife before I head home, grab the last cooler and pick my son up from school!  
    • It was an okay trip, made the best of it. Changed destination and distance I was willing to travel in those weather conditions. Can't afford to screw up when I'm solo.  More of a winter trip feel than a fall trip. After fishing in 17 degree windchill, I found just hanging out fireside a much better option.   I think I need to do an actual summer BW trip next year, despite the bugs and crowds. Then I can take the fishing part more seriously.   Seen some groups pass by camp, so there were others as crazy as I.
×