Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
carlcmc

Opinion on lens?

Recommended Posts

In a previous post i talked about buying a Nikon D80. I'm planning on doing so in the next few weeks. It comes with an 18-135 mm lens

Reading some on the net and some have recommend getting a fast lens such as the 50mm f/1.8D AF Nikkor lens for portraits and overall good shots.

I am all chomping at the bit getting ready to buy the camera and wonder what you think about getting a prime fixed lens such as that or whether you would wait and just use the 18-135 for awhile?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Carl:

I don't know how fast the 18-135 is, but it's hard to go wrong by buying a faster lens. The zoom is by far the better lens to keep on when you're bombing around, because its flexibility will let you compose more varied shots in more varied situations. But the prime will be sharper, and when portraiture or another type of setup up comes along, one with plenty of time, and where you can move forward and back as much as needed to get the composition you want, the 50 will be great. Its speed also will help you if you're shooting indoor sports or indoor performances of some type.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I appreciate your info and insight on both this topic and the other post (8gb of storage shocked.gif )

What do you use for portraits? I had read that using a zoom lens (i.e. at the 135 setting of that lens that comes with the kit) helps control Depth of field?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Carl: Depth of field doesn't change from focal length to focal length, but through aperture. So zooming to 135 won't give you a shallower dof than 35 mm.

There is, however, an APPARENT difference that leads people to think dof changes based on focal length, which is that, when using a wide angle lens, the subjects in the frame tend to be a lot smaller, which makes the dof appear deeper.

I have made that same mistake in the past, believing that focal length changes dof. Then I was set straight by another photographer, who said it's a very common misconception.

Here's a way to prove the point. If you put on your 50mm and take a picture of, say, a car at an angle, and then put on the zoom and zoom to 135 and take the photo at the same angle with the same f-stop and MAKING SURE THE CAR IS THE SAME SIZE IN THE FRAME, you will see that the dof is the same. Regardless of focal length, if the subject is the same size within your frame and the f-stops are the same, the dof will remain the same.

Of course, the feel of the composition will vary from focal length to focal length because of the different properties of wide angle vs telephoto lenses, but the dof does not.

Go to the Luminous Landscape web site and do a search for "depth of field," and you will find this explained in more detail (perhaps more than you need.) I'd post the link here, but it's to a commercial site from a non FM sponsor, so we don't do that. I highly recommend their tutorial writing. It's clear, detailed enough so you know why a certain thing is the way it is but not technical enough to bore or turn away most people.

I shoot a lot of portraiture with my 100-400L image stabilizer, because I can fill the frame with the person's head/shoulders while standing back farther at a more comfortable social distance for the subject, and because I really like the compositional look of a tight portrait shot with a powerful telephoto.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Steve is dead on about DOF. And while I would play around with what you are getting with the camera before I jump into another lens, nothing beats a FAST Nikon prime, for a WHOLE lot of things.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Early morning bucks playing around in the back yard.
    • Nice!  Congrats to you guys!
    • Well Day 2 was a complete bust. Warm temps and high winds along with a full moon kept any daytime movement to a minimum at best. Onto the next.   Day 3 we got plenty of rest the night before and we’re ready to hit hard. We started off on the bluff where Cole had got his cow and before we could even sit down we had 3 cows at 600 yards heading at us. We lost sight around 500 and figured they would move right up the draw around 200 yards away. They didn’t follow our plan and disappeared forever. Around 10am we had some animals above us. We could hear hooves on the bluffs but never saw them. We had lunch around noon and then started still hunt ridge to ridge. Around 130pm we were on a sharp drop of when son says ELK! We immediately hit the ground as they were only 100 yards almost straight below us on steep bluff. We belly crawled to the edge and looked into the timber. We could then only see one standing looking straight away from into the wind. I slide my rifle up in front of me and placed the cross hairs behind the shoulder. My first opportunity at a Bull ever. Cole had him in the binos when I pulled the trigger. Not needed. He dropped right in his tracks. Cole tackled me and both erupted in laughter. Both of us total rookies had filled our elk tags 3 days into the season. Not sure if we are good or just plain lucky but either way it’s been an unbelievable experience.  Now we had some serious work ahead of us.  We literally had to pack him out an almost straight up vertical cliff. I have one really bad knee...all those years of jumping out of airplanes in the military have taken a toll on my knees. We each grab a rear quarter and made the first trek out. When we got back I was hurting. Cole said sit down Dad. I got this!! He then hauled out both fronts and loins in one haul. Went back down for the head and did that too. As I sat and watched him I was overcome with emotion. How did I get so lucky in raising such a grateful and helpful young man!  He got back up to me and we both broke down in tears and hugged for about 15 mins. What an experience we’ve had. The effort and hard work you go through on these hunts is like nothing else. It’s been the best we could of asked for and then some. We took the morning off while my buddy went back out. We did some scouting this afternoon and think we found a herd for tomorrow to go after with him along with trying to fill our deer tags. More to come
    • Looks great. Whats with the tray of rabbit food there? 😅
    • Gold finches are still hanging on. All juveniles though. Actually had a red winged blackbird at my feeder yesterday. 
    • So, I guess the show has a new director, and she wasn’t a big fan of how the show would drag certain things on. That’s why she hung Gregory in the first episode. Apparently she’s the reason Rick will only have 2 more episodes left. She’s not even going to drag out his demise. I like it!
    • Last batch of the season. I picked the rest of the unripe jalapenos for poppers. It sure was a great year for the garden. Just have some carrots and beets left. 
    • Oh - so that's what happens when a pike hits the camera.  Neat.  Thanks for sharing.
    • Congrats and that sure is a beaut! 
×