Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
leech~~

Human prion proteins resist chronic wasting disease.

Recommended Posts

Maybe I'm wrong but I thought the steps taken to stop CWD is meant to protect the deer herd, not humans. If CWD is not isolated and contained then it could spread to the entire MN deer herd which would have most wondering why they didn't kill MORE deer in the original CWD areas.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, nofishfisherman said:

Maybe I'm wrong but I thought the steps taken to stop CWD is meant to protect the deer herd, not humans. If CWD is not isolated and contained then it could spread to the entire MN deer herd which would have most wondering why they didn't kill MORE deer in the original CWD areas.

 

 

Who is to say that there has not away been some CWD in the herd, before they even knew what it was or had a test for it? At least take samples during Hunting season and stop taking out a bunch of Deer for no known reason because a few Deer farm animals had it.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Again correct me if I'm wrong but isn't that what the DNR did in SW MN last season. I believe all deer taken in the CWD area were required to be tested. 

 

The last mention I could find of increased harvest to reduce the spread was from 2016 and that was due to wild deer testing positive for CWD.  In 2017 no deer tested came back with a positive test result so perhaps it worked. 

 

What exactly do you propose if CWD is found in the wild deer population?  A hands off approach and let the deer herd figure it out on its own?  I don't think thats a very popular stance among hunters that enjoy having a deer herd.

Edited by nofishfisherman

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
43 minutes ago, nofishfisherman said:

What exactly do you propose if CWD is found in the wild deer population?  A hands off approach and let the deer herd figure it out on its own?  I don't think thats a very popular stance among hunters that enjoy having a deer herd.

 

The science of CWD is over my head, but there are a few groups working overtime to champion doing exactly that - nothing. They argue CWD has a negligible impact on the herd, that doing nothing will actually let the strongest survive, and my favorite, that CWD is more or less a boogeyman that allows the DNR to reduce the size of the herd in MN and other states.   And like anything, they can find experts to support that viewpoint.


I still would not knowingly want to eat a deer with CWD, would not want to hunt in an area where it is prevalent, and appreciate steps to try to contain it, even if that means temporarily lowering the population in certain areas where it has been found.

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, nofishfisherman said:

What exactly do you propose if CWD is found in the wild deer population?  A hands off approach and let the deer herd figure it out on its own?  I don't think thats a very popular stance among hunters that enjoy having a deer herd.

 

What I'm saying is that before 1967 when it was discovered what did the Deer herd and Hunters do then? Seems a little soon in the discovery to panic and start taking out a bunch of Deer on an unknown fear. Yep keep up looking at it and finding out what it may or may not impact. It's good that they found it doesn't not effect Humans.  That's a good start. 

 

Chronic wasting disease (CWD) is a transmissible spongiform encephalopathy (TSE) of mule deer, white-tailed deer, elk (or "wapiti"), moose, and reindeer. As of 2016, CWD had been found in members of the deer family only.[1] First recognized as a clinical "wasting" syndrome in 1967 in mule deer in a wildlife research facility in northern Colorado, USA, it was identified as a TSE in 1978 and has spread to free-ranging and captive populations in 23 US states and two Canadian provinces.[2] CWD is typified by chronic weight loss leading to death. No relationship is known between CWD and any other TSEs of animals or people.

Although reports in the popular press have been made of humans being affected by CWD, a study by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention suggests, "[m]ore epidemiological and laboratory studies are needed to monitor the possibility of such transmissions".[3] The epidemiological study further concluded, "[a]s a precaution, hunters should avoid eating deer and elk tissues known to harbor the CWD agent (e.g., brain, spinal cord, eyes, spleen, tonsils, lymph nodes) from areas where CWD has been identified

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, leech~~ said:

 

What I'm saying is that before 1967 when it was discovered what did the Deer herd and Hunters do then? 

It's possible it either didn't exist or existed at such low rate it wasn't noticeable.

 

HIV didnt exist before it existed.  And it floated around for 30 something years before it became a global pandemic in the 80s.

 

There's pretty good evidence out there about transmission to support the idea that if you sit on it for too long it will spread everywhere.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, bobbymalone said:

It's possible it either didn't exist or existed at such low rate it wasn't noticeable.

 

HIV didnt exist before it existed.  And it floated around for 30 something years before it became a global pandemic in the 80s.

 

There's pretty good evidence out there about transmission to support the idea that if you sit on it for too long it will spread everywhere.

 

So, your saying we should start taking out people in 5 counties around each HIV person they may have come in contact with to stop it then? :rolleyes:  :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

leech, I think it's fair to say dealing with a problem like this in deer affords the "powers that be" some luxuries that aren't possible in humans.  It probably wouldn't be too popular to wipe out a bunch of infected folks...

 

One question- it's been known about for over a half-century and you're saying it's just too early in the evolution of the understanding process to do something about it beyond let it play out naturally and see how it all shakes out?  I don't get that...  Seems reasonable (although a little paranoid) be be concerned about one little genetic tweak to one allele and boom!, we've got an epidemic of very grand proportion on our hands.  

 

I totally agree that uninformed wiping out of deer herds isn't the answer.  However, I'm not sure sitting back and watching it all play out is either.  However, maybe that's not what you're proposing?  If not, what do you suggest? 

 

An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure IMO.  I'm on the same page as bobbymalone's last sentence in his last post above.  But, consistent with what you said- it most certainly needs to be informed and not a knee jerk response.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think the biggest concern is that what if it mutates to become something that can be transferred to humans like Mad Cow Disease.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, leech~~ said:

 

So, your saying we should start taking out people in 5 counties around each HIV person they may have come in contact with to stop it then? :rolleyes:  :lol:

 

People aren't deer.  Deer aren't people.

 

There are ethical concerns with that idea, but if that happened in 1981 it probably would have stopped the pandemic.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, Scoot said:

leech, I think it's fair to say dealing with a problem like this in deer affords the "powers that be" some luxuries that aren't possible in humans.  It probably wouldn't be too popular to wipe out a bunch of infected folks...

 

One question- it's been known about for over a half-century and you're saying it's just too early in the evolution of the understanding process to do something about it beyond let it play out naturally and see how it all shakes out?  I don't get that...  Seems reasonable (although a little paranoid) be be concerned about one little genetic tweak to one allele and boom!, we've got an epidemic of very grand proportion on our hands.  

 

I totally agree that uninformed wiping out of deer herds isn't the answer.  However, I'm not sure sitting back and watching it all play out is either.  However, maybe that's not what you're proposing?  If not, what do you suggest? 

 

An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure IMO.  I'm on the same page as bobbymalone's last sentence in his last post above.  But, consistent with what you said- it most certainly needs to be informed and not a knee jerk response.

 

Nowhere did I state that I didn’t think anything should be done about the CWD issue.

That I started this post should show that I am glad they are still looking into the disease and finding out how it effects man and animal.  I am also glad that they have switched to taking samples during the Deer hunting season when a very large sample group of the whole states Deer herd can be tested at one time. This should provide way better data of all deer in every zone which should be way more valuable than taking a few test samples from Deer farms and random culling around the state. Their going out and randomly taking out a bunch of Deer out in an area with DNR “sharp shooters” has not found anything and hasn’t proven to be very effective, other than to ruin a bunch of peoples hunts in that area the next season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
On 6/6/2018 at 2:39 PM, leech~~ said:

Who is to say that there has not away been some CWD in the herd, before they even knew what it was or had a test for it? At least take samples during Hunting season and stop taking out a bunch of Deer for no known reason because a few Deer farm animals had it.

 

If you are talking about southern minnesota, there were animals in the wild that had CWD.   And the DNR used sharp shooters since hunters didn't reduce the population enough.   This same strategy seems to have worked in the area around Pine Island MN where the wild herd was infected by farmed elk.   Now we have a couple more outbreaks in SE MN and in Crow Wing County most likely due to infected deer on deer farms.   

 

If you want to know what doing not much results in, read up on Dane Co Wisconsin and surrounding area.   

Edited by delcecchi

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
48 minutes ago, delcecchi said:

If you are talking about southern minnesota, there were animals in the wild that had CWD.   And the DNR used sharp shooters since hunters didn't reduce the population enough.   This same strategy seems to have worked in the area around Pine Island MN where the wild herd was infected by farmed elk.   Now we have a couple more outbreaks in SE MN and in Crow Wing County most likely due to infected deer on deer farms.   

 

If you want to know what doing not much results in, read up on Dane Co Wisconsin and surrounding area.   

 

More out breaks? :huh:  Please stay up on how things are going Del.

 

From DNR Web site.

CWD testing areas Special hunt complete; no CWD found

Testing is complete in all areas of Minnesota. Surveillance will resume during the 2018 deer seasons.

No chronic wasting disease was detected in 275 samples from deer that hunters harvested during a special late-season hunt Jan. 6-14 in and near southeastern Minnesota's disease management zone.

Please check back regularly for important updates.

Edited by leech~~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Looking at this information I wouldn't declare the issue resolved...(thanks deer farmers)

6 cases last fall in SE mn.  

 

 

 

cwd.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
46 minutes ago, delcecchi said:

Looking at this information I wouldn't declare the issue resolved...(thanks deer farmers)

6 cases last fall in SE mn. 

 

 

 

cwd.jpg

I nor the DNR said it was resolved.  Just as of the last testing none was found.  Your chart is from 2016-2017 and is before the last testing results came in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your implication was that CWD is not a problem, since the texas deer farmers' guy says it isn't a problem for humans and the last survey didn't find any new instances.   Why are you carrying water for the Cervid farming interests?   

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, delcecchi said:

Your implication was that CWD is not a problem, since the texas deer farmers' guy says it isn't a problem for humans and the last survey didn't find any new instances.   Why are you carrying water for the Cervid farming interests?   

 

Never said that. Please start at the top and follow along. 

On 6/7/2018 at 5:13 PM, leech~~ said:

 

Nowhere did I state that I didn’t think anything should be done about the CWD issue.

That I started this post should show that I am glad they are still looking into the disease and finding out how it effects man and animal.  I am also glad that they have switched to taking samples during the Deer hunting season when a very large sample group of the whole states Deer herd can be tested at one time. This should provide way better data of all deer in every zone which should be way more valuable than taking a few test samples from Deer farms and random culling around the state. Their going out and randomly taking out a bunch of Deer out in an area with DNR “sharp shooters” has not found anything and hasn’t proven to be very effective, other than to ruin a bunch of peoples hunts in that area the next season.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@leech~~

 

CWD sampling results for the disease management area

Updated @ 6:47 p.m. on Tuesday, March 16, 2018

CWD Zone   view mapSamplesPendingNot detectedSuspectedConfirmed

DPA 603                        1,185        0             1,179               0                  6

Late hunt                         275         0                275                0                 0 

Landowner shooting    19             0                 19                0                  0

 

I hunt in 603.   our 2 bucks were good. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, eyeguy 54 said:

@leech~~

 

CWD sampling results for the disease management area

Updated @ 6:47 p.m. on Tuesday, March 16, 2018

CWD Zone   view map Samples Pending Not detected Suspected Confirmed

DPA 603                        1,185        0             1,179               0                  6

Late hunt                         275         0                275                0                 0 

Landowner shooting    19             0                 19                0                  0

 

I hunt in 603.   our 2 bucks were good. 

 

Well suks to be you. Start the shooting!  :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 6/11/2018 at 10:59 AM, leech~~ said:

I nor the DNR said it was resolved.  Just as of the last testing none was found.  Your chart is from 2016-2017 and is before the last testing results came in.

The chart was from January of 2018, and included the results from the 2017 Fall (deer season) testing which had 6 cases.   

 

On 6/6/2018 at 9:09 AM, leech~~ said:

Great. Can we stop wasting money on killing Deer in 5 counties around everyone that's been found

So, is it watch and wait or do something?     

 

One point about whether CWD could affect humans...  In UK, they found that there was enough variation among people that some could get mad cow and others couldn't.    So makes me wonder about that rat testing that kicked off this thread.  Did they test all the variations of human proteins that could be affected?  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, delcecchi said:

The chart was from January of 2018, and included the results from the 2017 Fall (deer season) testing which had 6 cases.   

 

So, is it watch and wait or do something?     

 

One point about whether CWD could affect humans...  In UK, they found that there was enough variation among people that some could get mad cow and others couldn't.    So makes me wonder about that rat testing that kicked off this thread.  Did they test all the variations of human proteins that could be affected?  

 

Silly Town a little slow Del?

why-is-yawning-contagious01.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Nope.   Saw the original post, and since I have been following the issue near here in Rochester, beginning with the Pine Island outbreak, and now the ones near Preston etc and reefing on the deer farmers for bringing it into the state I decided to participate.   I'm not sure if it was on HSO or another site but I was critical of the so-called expert brought in from Texas (he also did work for Wisconsin) by the deer farmers to spin the issue.      

Personally I believe that farming deer or elk  and/or importing live deer or elk from out of state ought to be banned since recent events have shown that the industry is incapable of avoiding the introduction of cwd into previously cwd free areas.  

 

I'll be glad to go back and find the old threads to prove it, if you need convincing.     

 

Here is one...

No idea where the picture came from, not at original link

Edited by delcecchi

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Seems like aggressively dropping the deer numbers in the disease management zone is working then, eh, leech?  

 

Because if you bow to whiny hunters like WI did and have a real mess on your hands.

Edited by bobbymalone

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Most everyone on this site has been in the coroner at least twice, especially if they have been around for 10 years plus. I know I've been and I still have the same name since 2002-even though the date shows 2006, why I don't know.
    • Nope can't say I have been sick. I visit my parents in the old folks home so maybe that will be a good test. I may need to find another chunk of two to last me the winter. I kinda enjoy being in the woods and looking for it.
    • Make sure you use shielded cable vs wiring rca ends onto standard 16 gauge wire other wise you will have interference from your other 12 and 120 volt wiring.  More insulation = less btus needed. At the very least I would spray the floor. Going to want to go 30k if you aren’t going to spray foam the walls Depends on location. 30” is optimal. If on the side of the house versus back, I would go 24” because the are nicer to sit on. I have a 36” for my fold down top bunk and it works well to sleep my 7 & 8 year old Are they nice? Yes. Are they a nessecity? No. I don’t have one and moisture has never been an issue. The only prob I have is cooking bacon in the house.... I love bacon but when u cook it in the house it lingers for days, but not sure the vent would totally solve this LED!!!!! You need to decide whether you’re going to have a generator and how long you want to run it. If you think that you’re going to constantly run a generator then you probably want to have more 120 V lights in the last 12 V lights. If you’re not going to run a generator that often or not at all then you would want to cut down in the number of 120 V lights.  Three way switches are in valuable within a fish house. Being able to switch on the entire bank of lights by the door and also by the rear bunk is very nice when you hear the rattle real go off in the middle of the night. I have three double pancake LED lights in my house that can be switched on and off individually one light or too light per fixture. I then ran the input power through a three way switch so that I can shut each light down individually or shut the whole works off as one. Hall lights are also very important, we used LED Leison plate lights and they work awesome
    • Been sick at all since starting to use it?  Friends of mine have been using it for a few years religiously for one reason or another.  They keep a jug of it next to the coffee pot.
    • After using tea made from chaga for awhile, I am not sure I have realized any positive health benifits. I plan to keep using the chaga tea through out the winter. I would also like to try a chaga tenture. If anyone has any tips or advice please share.
    • I would look at the camera you would want and add the proper wire for that. Most new cameras have hdmi out I believe. I wired our house with two hdmi ports for cameras. You can get long hdmi cables for pretty cheap online. Also bought little adapters and mounted to the right bench and one up front. They both run to the tv. You could do a 12V outlet near the area as well depending on how your camera is powered. I would get a forced air furnace if you are planning on sleeping in it. Ventless heaters are not safe in my opinion unless you leave a window open. I would definitely insulate it well. If you cut corners on insulation you will pay for it in propane in the long run. Depending on your ceiling height I would go with a full size 12v ceiling fan.  They are nice to have and are not too expensive.  We have recessed puck led lights from superbrightled.com they are a little pricey but I like them. They have similar options on amazon that are much cheaper. Porch lights were from super bright as well.   
    • no idea who it was, i was asked to be a mod years after that in the bird forum. 
    • I would definitely include one.     I would buy whatever you are going to use for mattresses or cushions and build the bunk around that.     I like having one....     12 volt RV lighting with LED bulbs. LED hole lights.     Do you live on a lake or is this going to be kept at a resort?  
    • I was up north more than ever this fall but with the bad fall weather and being busy with other things, I never even got a chance to walk the woods. One weekend I brought the gun and orange but it stayed in the truck because of cold, wet weather. My dog is not happy.
    • The Gammi’s are good!  This is a pic of my rig.  I just run 20 lb fluorocarbon to the snap and change hook sizes as needed and run the Gammi circles.   This didn’t turn out like I expected but this pike had my rig all the way around his lower jaw and didn’t cut the flouro.  It’s the same leader I used all last year, landing up to 30+ inchers.   And what do you do when you forget your tip up?  Make the next best thing with what you have.  A twist tie and candy wrapper was my flag for the weekend.  
×