Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Cheetah

Norway Maple tree damage, need opinions

Recommended Posts

Hello everyone.  Behind my garage I have a good sized Norway Maple which seems healthy in the canopy but has a large section of damage on the trunk from when a section broke off years ago before I purchased the home.   I paid to have an arborist out to the house two years back and she commented that the tree would likely get worse, but I am tempted to just take it down now.  In the canopy one of the larger diameter branches (5-6" diameter) is clearly dead, and a handful of smaller 1-2" branches are dead.   Besides that the canopy is thick in the summer and produces a lot of leaves so the tree seems to be coping with the damage.   The center of the wound appears to be getting worse this spring than I recall last year. 

 

My thought is to take the tree down now before it comes down on its own due to the weakness, also easier to clean up without all the leaf canopy.   I am curious what other folks here think. 

 

Thanks.

IMG_4280.JPG

IMG_4281.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with the aborist.  Not looking good.   The tree is coping fine as there is plenty of healthy bark and roots.   The problem is that the center looks like it is slowly rotting away and the trunk not getting stronger as the canopy grows.    

 

If you are not particularly attached to having the tree there, then it would certainly reduce the risk to your garage to take it down.  Or you could just  have it pruned aggressively to reduce the stress on the trunk.  But it sure looks like its days are numbered.  And the more I look at the pictures the smaller the number is looking.  

 

The problem, sort of like a tree I have, is that it can take a pretty long time to grow a replacement.  

It is possible you can get the insurance company to help with the cost, just ask them if they would rather wait for it to fall on the garage. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If there is a line coming up and down the tree above and below that area it may have been a lightening strike. We have a Maple lake that in our front yard.  If you are going to cut it down now may be the best time to get at it. 

200.jpg

Edited by leech~~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cheetah - does that tree have a v of limbs above the scar?  If so, that makes the tree even more suspect to end-of-life, as that would make this area of the trunk super weak.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can almost anticipate where it is going to split down the trunk....  It is a whopper of a maple.  Sad to see its condition.  

The limb on the right.  Probably going to be costly to bring it down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know anything about your tree, but I had to take a big Elm in our backyard last fall. The trunk was splitting and it was so close to the house and deck to risk major damage if it came down. I haven't been a homeowner for too long, and I'm not an insurance expert, but I found it frustrating that our insurance company wouldn't cover any of the cost to remove the tree. It seemed like a pretty small investment rather than paying out  significantly more if it fell and damaged the house.

 

I'm sure they have their reasons, and it's probably because they figured if they refused, I would eventually pay for it myself:grin:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would be surprised if insurance pays a dime to have the tree removed.  Maintaining your property and removing hazards is on the homeowner.  If they started paying for things like this then would they also pay for you to install a sump pump to prevent water damage in your basement?  Would they pay to have the brakes on your car repaired when they go bad?  If they did that then they might decide they should start mandating what other hazards need to be remedied around the house, you may find you don't agree with all of them as you probably won't have any trees at all on your property.

 

Not sure what that tree would cost to take down but from my past estimates on other trees a lot of the cost depends on how easy it is to access.  If they can get their big trucks right up to the tree and have easy places for the limbs and tree to fall then the costs are lower.  

 

Its easy from the last set of photos to see where the break is going to happen and it looks like its just a matter of time.  I'd get it take out before it causes issues.  You may have a little time so maybe see if you can work a bit of a deal with a tree service to wait to do the tree until they have another job in the area or they have a slow day. Its a long shot but maybe being flexible on your schedule can save you a few bucks. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeahbut, insurance does give you safe driver discounts for doing things that should cost them less in the long run. Health insurance covers much of the cost of annual physicals and/or joining a health club, knowing it can save them significant money in the long-run. I'm not saying you should willy-nilly be able to have trees removed and expect them to cover the cost, but when an tree expert says there is a problem, it would seem to be in their best interest to help reduce their potential payouts.


But you're right, insurance doesn't pay a dime for it and I'm sure Cheetah isn't looking for me to keep complaining that they don't.  For what it's worth, I wound up paying $2,700 to have my tree taken down last fall. Mine was a little bigger than Cheetah's appears in the photo, but is in the ballpark. Both trees also are near the house. I got bids in the spring and in the fall, and found the cost to be better in the fall. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

looks like you need to put it down before it falls on your house or garage.

hopefully it doesn't go down in this dump we are getting this weekend.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Getanet said:

Yeahbut, insurance does give you safe driver discounts for doing things that should cost them less in the long run. Health insurance covers much of the cost of annual physicals and/or joining a health club, knowing it can save them significant money in the long-run. I'm not saying you should willy-nilly be able to have trees removed and expect them to cover the cost, but when an tree expert says there is a problem, it would seem to be in their best interest to help reduce their potential payouts.


But you're right, insurance doesn't pay a dime for it and I'm sure Cheetah isn't looking for me to keep complaining that they don't.  For what it's worth, I wound up paying $2,700 to have my tree taken down last fall. Mine was a little bigger than Cheetah's appears in the photo, but is in the ballpark. Both trees also are near the house. I got bids in the spring and in the fall, and found the cost to be better in the fall. 

2700 for one tree seems high.  I had 3 mature dying box elders taken down like a year ago for 3k.   

But maybe things are cheaper in Rochester.   You don't live in Edina or something do you?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

2700 isn't to bad really, I've had quotes anywhere from 3-10 grand on a really ugly maple that spreads over a house, garage and a shed. You have a fireplace cheetah? The cheapest route would be to have it dropped and you take care of the rest.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 4/13/2018 at 9:46 PM, delcecchi said:

2700 for one tree seems high.  I had 3 mature dying box elders taken down like a year ago for 3k.   

But maybe things are cheaper in Rochester.   You don't live in Edina or something do you?

 

Nope, not Edina, but in the metro area. I got multiple bids, read reviews, etc - all the bids were in the same relative ballpark - unlike when I got bids to re-roof our house a few years ago, which were all over the map.

 

It was a big tree that hung over our house, garage and deck. If Cheetah has to get his taken down, hopefully he can find a better deal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Getanet said:

 

Nope, not Edina, but in the metro area. I got multiple bids, read reviews, etc - all the bids were in the same relative ballpark - unlike when I got bids to re-roof our house a few years ago, which were all over the map.

 

It was a big tree that hung over our house, garage and deck. If Cheetah has to get his taken down, hopefully he can find a better deal.

 

I wonder why the difference between there and here.   Perhaps disposal costs are higher, or it was some peculiarity of the location of the tree relative to the house.   There does also seem to be some difference by neighborhood, with more affluent areas paying more, or so I have been told.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • what a story!!!  and memories for ever too!!!!  glad all are good safe!!!
    • i've seen i work well, then not. did the drag also and didnt notice deer following it up. and i've never been stampeded by deer using scents, so...........   i'm beginning to be a huge believer in that little green can though!!!!!!!!!! the one that sounds like a doe screaming for a boyfriend!!!
    • I’ve used it in the past and never really had any success with it. Deer would cross the trail if I was pulling it on a rope on the walk in and not notice. I’ve tried the canisters around the stand also and didn’t seem to have any luck. The only thing that was always consistent with it was opening up in my pocket and soaking myself with it. 
    • It definitely was an adventure.  My wife wasn't to thrilled finding me looking up wall tents to buy for next year.  Hoping we get drawn for Montana again and I can leave Idaho alone for a year or so. 
    • Wow! That's why when my wife says have fun hunting honey, I say it's Not fun!  😕 It's an Adventure!!   😆   Old Indian saying.  "Only White man put his Tepee by dead tree!"  
    • Update is we are home and alive!!!   We left Friday Oct 11 with plans to shoot across S. Dakota...once we got down there the roads were ice covered so we headed down to Nebraska and across I-80 to Salt Lake City before heading north.  We got a room, shower, and some dinner before heading up the mountain first thing Sunday morning. I've never been to Idaho and hadn't talk many folks that had, so we decided to use an outfitter this year for a drop camp.  I can't say enough about the guy we used.  Tents were setup....fully stocked. Wood split and even supplied our food and when I say food...he didn't hold back.  Even had one night with ribeyes.  We ate the like kings all week.  We threw our gear into the tents and headed out scouting for elk and maybe a little deer hunting along the way.  We had 2 days to scout before elk season opened on Tuesday.  We found elk right away...all cows and calves feeding out in the meadows.  Our tents were at 7200 feet with the highest peaks around 8900.  We scouted some also on Monday and found elk again. Monday night while sitting around the campfire, the wolves started howling.  2 different packs on the ridgelines all around us.  I thought to myself this isn't good.  Tuesday morning bright and early we found ourselves at the first spot I wanted to start.  Got a beautiful picture of the sunrise coming up behind the peaks.  We put on around 7 miles by lunch time and couldn't find any elk.  We ate lunch and I drifted off for a few mins, when my son woke me up and said he just saw a bull go over a ridge.  Not sure if he was pulling my leg we headed that direction and I let out a bugle.  Not 30 secs later we got a response.  We headed that direction but as we got closer the winds were swirling, so I said lets leave him for now and head back tomorrow morning. We hiked out got back to wear we parked out ATV's and my son's machine was dead.  I grabbed the recoil and gave it a yank, only it decided to bite back and that's when my middle finger came out of place.  Being the old army medic I am, I got it back into place shortly and made it back to camp where some Windsor and water took the pain away.   Wed- We went back in the morning with good thermals, I brought my son and brother in law with, I left my gun at camp with a sore hand and bugling bull, I sent them in and stayed back with a good vantage point and called.  He fired right up.  Either one of those guys had heard a really fired up bull before so that was pretty cool. Had him chuckling and raking trees, but couldn't get eyes on him.  That went on for a while before he decided he didn't wanted to show his face and he shut up took his cows farther down the drainage and out of our lives forever.  Thur-430am- we get woken up by wind and  things hitting our tents- I looked at my buddy and said is that ice?  He got up and went outside the tent and found gale force winds, almost tornado like whipping branches through the tree line.  He stepped back in, zipped the tent up and said I hope a tree doesn't come down on us.  Then we heard it..the snapping of a tree and everyone with a oh $^#* look on their face.  I yelled get down, everyone bailed off there cots, I jumped onto my son and it came crashing down. Took the front third of our tent down.  We grabbed our flashlights, checked everyone for injuries.  A few bumps and bruised from hitting the ground, but nothing serious.  We crawled out of the tent and found a 100 foot spruce with 31 inch diameter 11 feet up from the base came right out of the ground.  If not for another downed tree and some luck on the path it took, I'm positive I wouldn't be writing this.  1 foot to right and we would of been in some bad shape.  We jumped on our ATV's and headed down the mountain to get out of the wind.  We headed to where the outfitter was operating.   He came out of his tent along with one of his guides, wondering what we were doing.  After explaining the situation around the campfire and some coffee, we all headed back to our tents with chains saws and anything else he thought we need for repairs.  We worked until noon clearing logs and fixing the tent.  We decided we probably would just hang around camp that day and gather our nerves.  Plus I had already decided at that point to rest my sore hand.  One of the guides came up with a fox pro that evening and took us out on a quick wolf hunt to see if we could get them going.  They decided to not play that night and then the snow really cranked up.  Between Thursday and Sunday morning it was hard to judge the snow depths with all the wind, but i'm guessing over 15 inches fell.  Seemed to shut all the animals down or they moved to lower elevations to look for food.  Saturday morning walking across a rock slide, I slipped twisted my ankle and banged my finger again, falling about 10 feet down the hill.  Good grief...Idaho is not for the faint of heart.  We decided Sunday morning when we got up and that is was time to head out.  More snow was forecasted and we didn't want to risk anymore trees coming down... what are the odds? I don't know but we didn't want to find out.  And boy were we glad we left.  The 90 min drive in on sunday to the trail head took 5.5 hours on the way out.  We hit the summit and rode the brakes in my truck all the way down.  Idaho is cheap on guard rail and I thought a few times we were going to find out what lay at the bottom.  We drove 8 hours that day, got a room and then hit the road at 5am.  We had a pit stop to make at a taxidermist office in Ennis to get my buddy's bull from 2 years ago.  Arrived back home Tuesday morning around 2am, I haven't hugged and kissed my family that much in a long time.  What a trip.  We didn't bring home any animals- and had an experience none of us will forget, but we still had a great time.  The scenery was amazing, the group of friends became closer then before and our outfitter couldn't have been more helpful and supportive from a drop camp perspective.  Plus we got to remind him daily about almost killing us and his camp selection needs to be revisited.  Idaho 2019 one for the record books.    
    • Thanks something to think about.
    • 😡😩 nope!!!!!!!!!
×
×
  • Create New...