Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
JJJ

Spearing Game Fish in SD "are they nuts!?"

Recommended Posts

This proposal is INSANE! my humble opinion.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Friday, November 14, 2014

CONTACT: Emily Kiel at [email protected]

GFP Commission Proposal on Statewide Spearing of Game Fish

PIERRE, S.D. — The South Dakota Game, Fish and Parks (GFP) Commission is proposing to open up game fish spearing statewide. The proposal was made as a result of an outside petition received from spearfishermen. The Commission will consider adoption of the proposal at their Dec. 11-12 meeting in Fort Pierre.

The Commission proposed the following rule amendments for game fish spearing for 2015:

• Allow spearing and bowfishing of all game fish species (except paddlefish and sturgeon) in all inland waters.

• Establish a year-round game fish spearing and bowfishing season.

• Make game fish spearing and bowfishing regulations on boundary waters match those of adjoining states.

“No inland waters are exempt from the current Commission proposal, meaning spearing and bowfishing for all species (except paddlefish and sturgeon) could occur in all inland waters including urban fisheries, small impoundments, trout streams and large lakes and reservoirs,” stated John Lott, GFP administrative chief for fisheries. “Harvest of game fish by spearers and bowfishers is not a biological issue. It is a social issue.”

Currently, the following regulations pertain to game fish spearing on inland waters:

• Game fish spearing and bowfishing season is open from June 15 to March 15, inclusive.

• Waters open to the spearing and bowfishing of game fish (except sturgeon and paddlefish) during the established spearing season in 2014 included:

o Lake Oahe;

o Portions of Lakes Sharpe and Francis Case;

o Angostura and Belle Fourche reservoirs.

• Spearing and bowfishing of northern pike was open in all inland lakes in 2014, except those managed for muskies, during the June 15 – March 15 game fish spearing season. As of last week, the Commission finalized that for 2015, the spearing and bowfishing of northern pike and catfish in all inland lakes (except those managed for muskies and areas of the Missouri River system closed to game fish spearing) and the Grand River immediately below Shadehill Reservoir, is allowed year-round. The Commission also added Shadehill reservoir to the list of waters open during the June 15 – March 15 game fish spearing season.

“By proposing a statewide, year-round season for spearing and bowfishing of game fish, the Commission has provided the public an opportunity to comment on how much spearing and bowfishing opportunity for game fish there should be,” concluded Lott.

The GFP Commission will act on this proposal Dec. 11-12 at the Fort Pierre Holiday Inn Express in Fort Pierre.

Written comments on this proposal can be sent to 523 E. Capitol Ave., Pierre, S.D. 57501, or emailed to [email protected] or [email protected] To be included in the public record, comments must be received by 12 p.m. CST on Dec. 11 and include a full name and city of residence.

A public hearing before the Commission will be held for those who want to publically comment at 2 p.m. CST at the Fort Pierre Holiday Inn Express on Dec. 11.

-GFP-

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Got an email about this. I have no problem with it. A harvested fish is a harvested fish whether it is harvested with a spear or a rod and reel.

One concern I had is during the spring they would be very easy to spear but the season would only be open from June 15 to March 15 so that is not a problem.

I agree with them when they say in the release that it is a social issue, not a biological issue.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not a fan of it. I deal with them all summer in the Pierre area. The outfitters that run spear boat are really good at dropping guys all over entire flats/points and their spear boat isn't within 1/2 mile. Dangerous as heck. They spear right below the dam in Pierre as well. I'm honestly really surprised no spear fisherman has died from being hit yet. The main channel is only a couple hundred yards wide and they drift down it all the time. Most people in town for the weekend fishing/boating have no clue what the flag and markers are for and buzz right by them within yards going 40mph. I see this was a petition from the spearfishing folks. I find that they are being awful greedy. Email the commissioners about your stance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fish populations dwindling, divers everywhere, why should we come?

The other thread discusses the social issues surrounding spearing. I really don't care about spearing, dead is dead. And winter spearing looks very interesting. But when you pull you boat 200 miles then troll across a point, land 2 walleyes and turn around to make another pass only to see a boat race in and dump their diver because they saw you catch fish...forget it. I will stay home.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd bet money it is the MN dark house association is behind the petition. I hope the angling community sends hundreds of thousands of emails opposing this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The difference between spearing & hook & line angling, and for that matter netting, is with hook & line the fish need to bite on your presentation. Spearing & netting, all the fish has to do is be there & it is dead. There is no variable of the fish being willing or active or anything, it just has to be there. Usually when i go out, alot of times i come home frustratred because things didnt go as planned, either the fished didnt bite or i was using the wrong presentation or wrong area at the wrong time. Spearing, all these variables are irrelevent, it doesnt matter that its not prime time & they arent feeding, it doesnt matter that there was just a bug hatch or that its a full moon, they just have to be there. This seems a little unsporting & in my eyes making it easier to deplete a resource. Do you actually think dark house anglers target eating size fish? Not! They are trying to kill the largest, which are the egg-carrying ones that provide the future.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My guess is that none of you have done this before just like shooting fish in a barrel isn't it they say I've been spearing all my life over 35 years and it's not that easy. Not all of us take only big ones just like a 28 inch walleye they aren't very good table fare, give me a 3 lb northern and I'm in heaven the ones nobody wants. Why would the MDAA care about SD rules when we have enough to deal with hear in MN . Don't judge us until you know your facts. If you want I'll take you out and show you what the sport is all about.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • The storm last weekend  has moved the birds into the heavy duty winter cover. We had pretty good hunting in the cattails the last couple of days. Perfect weather helped.
    • In my humblest of opinions the simpler the better for prime rib.   Take it out of the refrigerator, salt (kosher) the entire piece and let stand until it's at room temp. Stick it into your smoker/oven at 450-500 degrees until crusted (about 1 cocktail). Lower heat to 325. Have a least 3 cocktails before poking it with a thermometer. Remove once internal temp is 120. Let rest for at least 1 more cocktail Cut and serve with horseradish.
    • In the worst case, the population would have to be held at a low level for a few years, like maybe 5.      I still haven't seen much indication that prions in the dirt are an issue in actuality (as opposed to theoretically).   
    • Fire Mike Preifer now : https://www.reviewjournal.com/sports/raiders-nfl/kicking-adjustment-makes-difference-for-raiders-daniel-carlson-1546061/
    • The prions will always be in the soil, so the “clean” population will eventually contract them and we’re back to where we are now.    I love the the idea of trying to control CWD, but I don’t believe we can.   
    • I have not but it really sounds interesting. The video I watched used garlic, butter and thyme sprig when they seared it. Looked perfect when they cut it open.
    • It was probably always around but the deer population was kept to levels that were low enough that it never became an issue until people started to create game farms and food plots that concentrated the deer in smaller areas.    I suppose we could just go all in on the big antler craze and forget about eating them and just take the antlers for the wall. 
    • 99% of the time when I do beef I stick to kosher salt and coarse ground black pepper.  I salt the beef liberally as soon as I get it home from the market, wrap it back up in the butcher paper, and pop it in the fridge until cooking (24 hours is ideal, 12 is ok).   The salt will draw the water out of the meat, and then the meat will reabsorb the water with the salt molecules in it.  Seasons the inside and really helps produce a moist chunk o beef.   Check out articles on a dry brine for more details on how that science works.     Add the pepper before cooking.     I always have a bit of grated horseradish on the side.   The 1% of time I add more than salt n pepper, I add garlic and rosemary at the time I add the pepper.
    • Yeah, that also.  Thanks for coming along on the ride! 😉
×