Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
CaptJohnWis

What do they do with all the fish?

Recommended Posts

You have never been hungry, have you? I have. If I keep over my possession limit to have some fish during the winter months when I can not fish and you don't like it, thats fine , but don't start with the morality bit with me.

Yes I do fish to eat the fish I catch. Do I catch and release? Yes. Do I have at times over my possesion limit?__ __ ___ Fill in the blanks. Do I have a guilt trip because of it? NO! Will I continue to fish in the same manner in the future? __ __ ___. Maybe you should ask what species I fish for-- It's not the precious Walleye.

Someone call the CO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The late 50's and early 60's many people were hungry and yes I was 1.

Fsh. Call the CO. I will gladly give you my address if you share yours.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Somebody with more than their legal limit in the freezer is a poacher, end of story.

But every fisherman has a right to harvest fish legally in numbers that he sees fit. Catch-and-release moralists who stand in judgment of people who like to catch and eat fish LEGALLY are a pain in the rear-end. Busybodies should mind their own business. Legal limits take harvest into account. You don't want to harvest fish? Don't.

There is no moral superiority to catch-and-release. It is a matter of personal preference.

Spot on, I couldn't agree more. There have been times I've given fish away and kept more. Doesn't happen often but there are some older folks at work that love fish that just don't get out. I've offered to take them out but they don't want to. So now and then I bring them fish. I see no harm in that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You know what I love about these posts, everyone and I mean everyone, responds with "I don't keep fish all that often". With so many people never keeping fish why even have game laws. It seems no one keeps them anymore. It seriously cracks me up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The late 50's and early 60's many people were hungry and yes I was 1.

Fsh. Call the CO. I will gladly give you my address if you share yours.

Not 1 fish in my freezer. I prefer fresh, and out of cold water.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I hear what you are saying I don't think this HSOforum and these posts in particular are an exact cross-section of the fishing community. Most guys on here are sportsmen and when I say sportsmen I'm talking about guys that not just concerned about catching fish but also think about the resources and what's best for them. I believe a very large percentage of the posters on here are concerned about the resources and think about it depending on what body of water they are on. After all, every lake has different fish structures so whats ok for one lake might not be ok for another.

I will never look down my nose at those that legally keep fish, as I do it too. And if the fishery can take it go ahead and keep some for family and friends. But please realize, not every stocked lake can take a day after day pounding. Seen a lot of good lakes go south due to overfishing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know several expert anglers who insist on keeping every legal fish they catch. Why? Some of them go fishing every day and keep their limit every day. They even take extra anglers along so they can keep two or three limits. What do they do with all those fish?

You can only legally have so many in your freezer. So I assume they sell or give them away. But why? Some will tell you the fish are for this or that special event - so they probably have way over their limit in the freezer. If they are giving them away to friends, why? How many of those given away go to waste? Plenty is my guess. And if they are selling them! I would report em in a heartbeat and hope they lose all fishing privileges forever.

My personal rule is if I have ANY fish in the freezer, they git eaten before I keep another fish. If my friends want some fish, they can come along with me and catch em themselves.

And for those that insist on pounding deep water walleyes, why?? Any walleye caught below 40 FOW is a dead walleye (crappies are even worse) whether released or not. Might take a few days, but they will all die. Reeling them in slowly will not help unless you mean 24 hours to bring em up from 40 feet. If you are into catch and release, please stay in shallower water.

Spend more time fishing and less time cleaning. Report the fish hogs and other that abuse the resource.

I cant speak for everyone, but when I go fishing I will keep my legal limit. Freeze and package them. Many times I will take it to a guys place and donate extra fish. If I have a freezer full, before i go i drop him off some.He keeps them at a freezer (not sure where could be at a church) then about 3-4 weeks before christmas they put on a fish fry, all proceeds from the fish fry are used to buy presents for children and people in need for their christmas & other fund raising stuff during lent.

I guess I figure the DNR puts laws into place, if we follow them its not my business or concern on what others do with their fish if legally taken. I don't feel like I'm gaming the system when gifting or dropping fish off for a community cause when the community is benefiting from a resource they helped pay for.

Not to be mean, but you sound like one of those grumpy guys that is [PoorWordUsage] off someone else is harvesting his "fish" we have a renewable natural resource that we all pay for with laws that protect it. Those that decide to keep legal limits are well within their rights, so regardless of peoples opinion it is perfectly fine. The DNR was created for a reason. Do some fish end up going to waste.....yes, but is it really any worse then other food going to waste?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would bet that most people who Smoke, Pickle, and eat fish could say the same.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You have never been hungry, have you? I have. If I keep over my possession limit to have some fish during the winter months when I can not fish and you don't like it, thats fine , but don't start with the morality bit with me.

Yes I do fish to eat the fish I catch. Do I catch and release? Yes. Do I have at times over my possesion limit?__ __ ___ Fill in the blanks. Do I have a guilt trip because of it? NO! Will I continue to fish in the same manner in the future? __ __ ___. Maybe you should ask what species I fish for-- It's not the precious Walleye.

If you are fishing because you are hungry, there are other cheaper means of aquiring a meal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I cant speak for everyone, but when I go fishing I will keep my legal limit. Freeze and package them. Many times I will take it to a guys place and donate extra fish. If I have a freezer full, before i go i drop him off some.He keeps them at a freezer (not sure where could be at a church) then about 3-4 weeks before christmas they put on a fish fry, all proceeds from the fish fry are used to buy presents for children and people in need for their christmas & other fund raising stuff during lent.

Is this in MN or IA? I do not know the IA regs.

Define "freezer full of fish".

In MN you cannot have more than your limit. Limit and possession are the same in MN, for most species that we talk about.

In MN the party that you donated to cannot have more than a legal possession limit in storage. Also, if they have a license the gifted fish become theirs and count toward their limit/possession. If they do not have a license, then your information, name and license, are to be kept with the fish and they still count as your limit until consumed.

Finally, gifting fish away even to a licensed angler still count toward your possession limit for that calendar day. You cannot gift away a limit and keep a second limit on the same day.

No one cares if people donate small amounts to friends or family as long as it is within the law. I do not see how anyone could donate enough fish for a fundraiser without breaking MN possession laws.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Finally, gifting fish away even to a licensed angler still count toward your possession limit for that calendar day. You cannot gift away a limit and keep a second limit on the same day.

Just to add to this you cannot catch a limit of fish, eat that limit of fish the same day and catch another limit of fish after consuming the other limit. The daily limit had already been met.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And to add another to that "what you ate that day" you need to make sure that the toilet has been used and flushed before you go pursuing more fish of that same species otherwise that counts as your daily poss limit as well, if ya know what I mean.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah i don't get how someone can legally produce enough fish for a fundraiser in MN Without breaking the laws. Especially if it's for only 1 or two types of fish. Kyle pretty well covered that.

There are a few types of fish that allow very liberal harvest and are also very good to eat: Bullheads, Common Carp.

It is fairly common to have these types of 'feeds' at local community centers.

Some areas of the state (BOrder waters) Hoards of catfish could be kept. There are many very interested in lowering that limit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[

Is this in MN or IA? I do not know the IA regs.

Define "freezer full of fish".

In MN you cannot have more than your limit. Limit and possession are the same in MN, for most species that we talk about.

In MN the party that you donated to cannot have more than a legal possession limit in storage. Also, if they have a license the gifted fish become theirs and count toward their limit/possession. If they do not have a license, then your information, name and license, are to be kept with the fish and they still count as your limit until consumed.

Finally, gifting fish away even to a licensed angler still count toward your possession limit for that calendar day. You cannot gift away a limit and keep a second limit on the same day.

No one cares if people donate small amounts to friends or family as long as it is within the law. I do not see how anyone could donate enough fish for a fundraiser without breaking MN possession laws.

This is in IA.

Oh I'm sure the freezer for this fundraiser fish prya has a least a 100 over the limit if you abide by or believe the way you claim. I'm guessing they are kept in a freezer at the church, and the entire parish could be called to claim such fish if a [PoorWordUsage] caused problems about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dude. This is nothing to do with what you "believe" or "abide by". It's the law, cut and dried. crazy

You don't get a different set of rules because you don't like the ones that are in place.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You know what I love about these posts, everyone and I mean everyone, responds with "I don't keep fish all that often". With so many people never keeping fish why even have game laws. It seems no one keeps them anymore. It seriously cracks me up.

Same feeling here!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I participate in walleye fish frys all over the state. We have to have receipts for where the fish was purchased or from whom it was donated. I have been doing this for the past ten years and have actually never been approached by anyone about the origins of our walleye while doing frys. I have been asked after the fact. When the Square Hook guys were doing their investigation a couple years ago they asked me about some specific political fund raisers that we fried fish for. I bought said fish from the Red Lake Fisheries, they took my word for it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are fishing because you are hungry, there are other cheaper means of aquiring a meal.

Like what? I dig worms from my yard, walk to the river and fish for catfish. Kind of cheap. whistle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In MN the party that you donated to cannot have more than a legal possession limit in storage. Also, if they have a license the gifted fish become theirs and count toward their limit/possession. If they do not have a license, then your information, name and license, are to be kept with the fish and they still count as your limit until consumed.

Your post was mostly correct, but incorrect on one very big point. If you give fish away, those gifted fish do NOT count toward YOUR possession limit. They count toward the recipient's possession limit (whether they have a license or not). You're right that you can't catch another limit that same day, because the DAILY limit applies even after those fish are out of your possession. You CAN go out the following day and catch/keep another limit, even if the person you gave yesterday's fish to didn't eat them yet.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your post was mostly correct, but incorrect on one very big point. If you give fish away, those gifted fish do NOT count toward YOUR possession limit. They count toward the recipient's possession limit (whether they have a license or not). You're right that you can't catch another limit that same day, because the DAILY limit applies even after those fish are out of your possession. You CAN go out the following day and catch/keep another limit, even if the person you gave yesterday's fish to didn't eat them yet.

Yep. Thanks for the correction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are fishing because you are hungry, there are other cheaper means of aquiring a meal.

Like what? I dig worms from my yard, walk to the river and fish for catfish. Kind of cheap. whistle

Probably aging myself, but I remember tougher times when this would have been true. Maybe not so much now with all the support programs. Back then people were too proud to accept welfare.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • I hear ya. Although unlike CWD, I don't think there will be as much debate among different hunting groups about how bad the effects are and what, if anything, should be done about it.  Doesn't help the deer any, but at least it won't turn into debates/accusations/conspiracy theories that rival any political campaign. 
    • Great anything else?  Start the slaughter!  😠
    • does he need to?  Sounds like he put a whoopin on the boys in the one practice he showed up and played in...
    • This is not good news:   http://www.startribune.com/virus-new-to-state-s-deer-inflict-quick-and-suspicious-deaths-in-herd-near-twin-cities/497832721/   "Quick and suspicious" deaths of several deer this month in a captive herd south of the Twin Cities are being attributed to a virus never before seen in deer in Minnesota, state officials said Wednesday.   The Minnesota Board of Animal Health has confirmed the first cases of epizootic Hemorrhagic disease (EHD) in seven animals in a small herd of captive white-tailed deer in Goodhue County. There is no specific treatment or vaccine available in this country. Six of the deer died this month, the agency said, while a remaining buck "appears healthy at this time and is showing no clinical signs associated with this disease."   While this is the first detection of EHD among deer in the state, it is widespread across North America. There are no known health risks to humans, the Board of Animal Health said.   EHD has previously been detected in two Minnesota cattle in southern Minnesota — in Brown County in 2012, and Murray County in 2013.   "This virus is transmitted between deer by biting midges, or gnats, which are most active in the fall before they are killed by the first frost of the season," said Dr. Mackenzie Reberg, senior veterinarian with the Board of Animal Health. "These bugs can't travel far on their own, and we're concerned by this detection because the herd owner hasn't moved deer onto the property for several years."   The "quick and suspicious deaths of the animals," as the agency's announcement characterized them, alarmed the owner, who worked with a veterinarian to submit tissues from the carcasses to the Iowa State Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory for investigation and confirmation.   Many deer species may be infected with EHD, but white-tailed deer are highly susceptible and experience high rates of mortality. Most die within 36 hours of clinical signs, which can include fever, anorexia, lethargy, stiffness, respiratory distress, oral ulcers, and severe swelling of the head and neck.   The Board has notified the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources of the newly confirmed cases.
    • Not so Young dumb and full of............   Anymore?  😜
    • I think Negan should be in a cell that has a couple walkers in a cell on each side. lol
    • So, is Butler playing in the season opener? Has he even practiced, other than that one infamous time?
    • 2 episodes in, and I don’t have much of anything to complain about. Not great episodes by any means, but not bad either.
    • Good luck to you all. Sounds like a great trip.
    • Thanks Scoot!  Yes, we have our bear spray, brought a couple extra cans to keep in our packs besides what we have our on hips.   Hopefully it remains there the whole trip. Going to try and keep this updated during our trip. My son is taking video production class in school, hopefully he can put something together when we get back. Signing off for now, going to have lunch with the wife before I head home, grab the last cooler and pick my son up from school!  
×