Jump to content
  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
BLACKJACK

Best way to handle pike for catch and release??

Recommended Posts

Caught a nice pike on Red last weekend, 40.5 inches.

First off, as I was handling the rattle reel line, my brother wanted to get the gaff out and gaff it, I said no, I could tell it was a big one that was going back - does a gaff hooked in the mouth do a lot of damage??

Secondly, after we had it on the deck, I could see the hook was quite a ways in, didn't have a spreader, so I just cut the line off a couple inches into his mouth. How far do you go in to try and reach your hook?

Third, when it was picture time, he didn't want to pick it up, it was flopping, and was going to be quite a handful, how do you pick up big pike? Does it hurt them to hold them up by the gill opening?? Seemed like a lot of fish to be holding up by one spot.

Lastly, how much time is reasonable to keep them out of the water?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The best way for a releasing big pike is use a monofilament leader. I tie 25-50 lb test ones so I can quickly cut the line if the hook is going to be a challenge to get at. I can't remember getting snapped. I just feel the line after each fish and tie a new one if I feel any nicks in the line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hold them by the eyes they won't squirm so much. Pike often have cut or deformed jaws, it don't hurt them jacks much.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hold them by the eyes they won't squirm so much.

ummm, yeah don't hold them by the eyes.

why anyone thinks that's a good idea is beyond me.

Just cuz grampa does something doesn't mean it's a good idea. In fact, it probably isn't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Look forward to more answers. I'm no expert but I've hear holding them by the eyes or squeezing them by the head pretty much is a death sentence. Damages the optical nerves and/or brain if I remember correctly. Anywhoo, I just try to get them back into the water asap after some quick pictures. And cutting the line as far as you can in if the hook is deep is good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The wife caught a 41 inch pike last sat.aft.. Fishing out of an old camper made in to a fish house with the floor 16 inches off the ice we new this was going to be highly unlikley of getting the fish up without a gaf. The wife reminded me of how her friends dad said stick your hand in a heavy glove/chopper in there mouth and when they bite pull them up. After getting the fish up to the top of the hole in 2 ft. of ice I took mitt and poked the fish onthe end of the nose a couple times and he opened up, stuck the mitt in it's mouth and it bit down. As soon as it did I started lifting and it came right up. Took one pic.and sent it back down the hole. If I knew how to post pics I would.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A fish grip doesn't do too much damage if you are not comfortable picking it up with your bare hands and work good for pics- in a perfect world a lip gaff isn't going to hurt them much either but that's much easier said than done and I don't recommend a gaff unless you are planning on keeping one or happen to be very experienced and coordinated :-). A jaw spreaders is a VERY important tool to have with at all times fishing right next to your pliers. It makes hook removal much easier (not with your hand but with a long needle nose) and you can grab and hold the tool instead of putting your hand under the gill plate if you aren't comfortable with that. If you are comfortable putting your hand under the gill plate to help hold it before you support with your other hand, just be careful. Your finger tips can easily get in too far and get sliced not to mention the fish can thrash at any time. A 'fish' glove at this time is smart if you have one on hand.

Either way you do it it's important to remember to support the weight of the fish with your other hand. No fish on this world is made to hang the weight of their own body by their head and in some cases with some big fish it can actually damage the spine. Naturally in the water they are fully supported horizontally so do it a favor and as you immobilize the head in any way you are comfortable with (BESIDES that blinding eye grab) support the weight of the body with other hand for the pic.

Even if one is not targeting pike it sure helps to always have a 'fish releasing' kit with all of these important tools with for when the **** hits the fan and that big gator hits the floor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For those people uncomfortable handling a fish, or grabbing it under the bottom jaw and lifting it out of the hole, use some type of a fish grip system, i found this one to be the most fish frendly. It floats, and costs about $13

Works great to grab a big eye or northern as it's mouth firsts breaks the surface of the water.

full-26433-29576-13345491.jpg

Keep them big fish alive.

full-26433-29577-2013_01_18_15_41_35_859

FORGET THE JAW SPREADER! THOSE CAN REALLY HURT FISH.

Use the fish grip above, when you lock onto the bottom jaw, you are in full control of opening the mouth - making easy access to get out a hook.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hold them by the eyes they won't squirm so much. Pike often have cut or deformed jaws, it don't hurt them jacks much.

Gotta love them internet trolls!!! Who in their right mind, if you wanted to release the fish, would grind your fingers into their eye sockets??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

truth, looks interesting. Do you have a problem getting it into their mouths? Do you use to pull them out of the holes or do you just use it after you have the fish out of the hole and want to take a picture?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I mainly bought that fish grip for northerns. I have used it to pull fish out of holes, it's easy to attach to mouth. I just have it ready and grab it as i lift a fish up into the hole. 90% of the time i just use my hands though, but where it really comes in handy is pulling a crankbait out of a little slimer in the summer, that way you can hang onto the slimy buggers without getting a crankbait in the hand/leg/whatever.

It's much easier than a gaff, safer than a gaff, will keep you from getting hurt, makes it easy for kids to hold onto fish for pictures if they are uncomfortable...

most times i don't use it to get a fish out of a hole, but once the fish is on the ice i do use it often to open the mouth for hook retraction when the hook isn't on the lips.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A gaf is fine in the bottom jaw, its just like a hook, do not gaf them anywhere else though. I always bring three things with me when going to a flag. A needle nose pliers, a jaw spreader, and a gaf. I hold them just behind the head and support around the tail. Always hold a northern horizontal, holding them vertical can mess up their internal organs. A jaw spreader will not hurt a fish, all it does is open their mouth. Other things I like to bring is a scale, tape measure, phone/camera, and a heavy duty jaw spreader, Big pike can easily close a lighter duty spreader, but the heavy duty one can literally rip a small pikes jaws open, and might hurt them. I used to cut line and release gut hooked fish thinking the hook will dissolve. I now realize its better to try and get the hook out, or keep the fish. I only use circle hooks, or quick strikes now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For those people uncomfortable handling a fish, or grabbing it under the bottom jaw and lifting it out of the hole, use some type of a fish grip system, i found this one to be the most fish frendly. It floats, and costs about $13

Works great to grab a big eye or northern as it's mouth firsts breaks the surface of the water.

full-26433-29576-13345491.jpg

Keep them big fish alive.

full-26433-29577-2013_01_18_15_41_35_859

FORGET THE JAW SPREADER! THOSE CAN REALLY HURT FISH.

Use the fish grip above, when you lock onto the bottom jaw, you are in full control of opening the mouth - making easy access to get out a hook.

+1 this is a great tool for holding fish love mine, or i should say my fiance loves it shes not the best at holding flopping fish and this helps a ton

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I may have to get one of those! smile I have no problem of grabbing a pike under the jaw. BUT!! The Mrs. was not impressed when a fish flopped and my thumb slipped into it's mouth! cry I had forgotten how much one bleeds!!!!! grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hold them by the eyes they won't squirm so much. Pike often have cut or deformed jaws, it don't hurt them jacks much...

ummmmmmmm yea......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For those people uncomfortable handling a fish, or grabbing it under the bottom jaw and lifting it out of the hole, use some type of a fish grip system, i found this one to be the most fish frendly. It floats, and costs about $13

Works great to grab a big eye or northern as it's mouth firsts breaks the surface of the water.

full-26433-29576-13345491.jpg

Keep them big fish alive.

full-26433-29577-2013_01_18_15_41_35_859

FORGET THE JAW SPREADER! THOSE CAN REALLY HURT FISH.

Use the fish grip above, when you lock onto the bottom jaw, you are in full control of opening the mouth - making easy access to get out a hook.

Got my Fish Grip in the mail yesterday, can't wait to try it!!!

Looking on the cover of the last Outdoor News and the picture of the big pike, I'm really regretting not doing a better job of picking up and taking pictures of our 40.5 inch northern frown

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gotta love them internet trolls!!! Who in their right mind, if you wanted to release the fish, would grind your fingers into their eye sockets??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A fish gripper of any sort COULD be looked at as a waste of money. Or it could be looked at as a common sense tool to keep a little kid, a novice, or an expert with bad luck that day from needing to leave the water and get stiches that day. I've seen it happen to all of the above. No matter how good you are handling fish it CAN happen to you. The more fish you handle the higher the odds no matter the skill level. Kind of like hitting deer with you motorcycle. ;-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A gaf is fine in the bottom jaw, its just like a hook, do not gaf them anywhere else though. I always bring three things with me when going to a flag. A needle nose pliers, a jaw spreader, and a gaf. I hold them just behind the head and support around the tail. Always hold a northern horizontal, holding them vertical can mess up their internal organs. A jaw spreader will not hurt a fish, all it does is open their mouth. Other things I like to bring is a scale, tape measure, phone/camera, and a heavy duty jaw spreader, Big pike can easily close a lighter duty spreader, but the heavy duty one can literally rip a small pikes jaws open, and might hurt them. I used to cut line and release gut hooked fish thinking the hook will dissolve. I now realize its better to try and get the hook out, or keep the fish. I only use circle hooks, or quick strikes now.

Trust me, Drop that spreader down the hole and the gaff while your dropping things, grab them by the bottom lip with the fish grip (12" slimer or 40" slimer) and their jaw will not close. It's those little fish that it can be hard to get a lure out of their mouth, and you'll surely rip their jaw off if you put a spreader in a small pike.

You seem quite fond of pike...Be honest, how easy is it to gaff the bottom lip everytime? Been there, tried that, this is a much better method. Frankly, i just use it to assist in removing a lure every now and then. Use your finger to lift it out of the hole.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have only needed the gaff maybe 3 times ever, once was the one in my avatar pic. If I get their head started in the hole, momentum carries them out. The ones that I could not (a hard fighting 12 pound beast that was foul hooked in the pectoral fin) It was pretty easy to get the bottom jaw, and the gaff turned their head upwards. and . As far as jaw spreaders go, like most things it is personal preference. I have seen those jaw tools, they just look clumsy to me 2c

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So you ask how to hold them, and then bash a guy for giving you an answer. Nice! I see alot of guys hold them by the eyes, oldtime trick.

The key was that I asked how to hold them so they could be RELEASED unharmed. Grinding your fingers into their eyes might be an oldtime trick but it was probably done by oldtime fisherman that took home every fish they caught. Then it didn't matter how you held them or handled them, they weren't going back in the water to get caught another day.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's a good example. Sunday the walleyes were inhaling the jigs. As soon as the walleye is at the top of the hole, i grab the bottom jaw with the fish grip. Reach over to get my pliers, and gently remove the hook from back of the throat.

Harmless. Notice how i never even needed to pull the fish out of the hole wink Mouth open, easy access, and full control of the fish.

full-26433-30055-2013_02_10_07_38_05_953

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • We were "missing" a few pieces of chicken between the time we took them out of the smoker and put them on the grill with the BBQ sauce. They vanished, I swear!
    • Figured I would post me and my brothers build on here since this is where I got most of the information from. Thanks to lipripper for posting his builds and answering questions. I pretty much based the house off of his with a couple of my own tweaks. Im not sure how pictures are posted on this it’s looking like they will all be at the end of my post so maybe I’ll start with one post then keep adding to it so the pictures stay in some order ( I was bad at taking pictures so I probably missed some stuff) So here we go...   The frame is a Berkon 21’ with a 4’ V galvanized. We called berkon and the guy said they had one frame left and it was $700 cheaper than normal price since they were changing something for ice castle so we put money down to hold it then he called and said ice castle needed it but they were going to make us a new one (this was the start of our struggles). Which actually worked out nice since we could move some bracing around and move the hydraulic pump to a different spot. We had them move the back center brace so we could have 3 holes between our couches similar to papabear. We  thought about doing aluminum but the guy at berkon said the weight savings would only be about 700 lbs and I personally don’t like how aluminum seems to get brittle in the cold.  Prior to getting the frame I tried to order as much stuff as I could think of like others have said to do but since this was our first fish house I wasn’t 100% sure on everything. I used google sketch to layout the studs and the windows. Hoping everything would work out as planned. 
    • Spring only for me, when Orioles first return. Mine never get hit much. 
    • Not sure if somebody put a lot of time in to make this or if it was something Arctic Cat made. I could see someone pulling this around Hay Days.Thought it was just to cool to pass up. 
    • Whatever trades they might make won’t be to make a run. It’s going to be to rebuild. I guess there’s still some interest in Dozier from a couple teams, but otherwise, we don’t have much trade value in anyone. I’m just still hoping we finish .500.
    • The popular speculation is that the lakers are taking this season “off”, and waiting until next year to sign a big name or 2, one of which could be Butler. Personally, I don’t think there’s any chance Butler re signs with the wolves (he already turned down the first offer), as long as Wiggins remains on the team! And at this point, Wiggins is untradable. 
    • do agree, like your thoughts...
    • Yeah, none of the recipes say to pre-cook the potatoes but I think I might do it next time or else just open the packets and throw the shrimp in at the end. I was surprised though that the shrimp was good and didn't seem too over cooked. I think the key is to make sure to use raw shrimp not pre-cooked.
    • A lot of talk about a lot of nothing...until it is actually something! 🤔😏  As long as Thibs is here I believe that Jimmy has  chance to stay.  If Jimmy were to leave I would be surprised if he stayed in the west but if he did matching him up with LAbron would be a tough duo to build around.
    • A lot of good looking recipes on Old Bay's s i t e : Old Bay Recipes
×