Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
bassislife

50 Evinrude E-Tec ...VS..... Yamaha 50 4- stroke

Recommended Posts

Hello

I have a 50 Yamaha 4-stroke and not real happy with the troll down! It has the multifuction handle on the tiller that brings the RPMS down from 950 to 800, but it is still way to fast for trolling rigs. If the wind is not blowing 15 MPH or more I can't get it to troll down for rigging.

The best I can do is 1.20 MPH on a calm day, not real happy with this. Everyone claims it trolls down... IT DOES NOT!

I have talked to a guy that has had the Evinrude E-Tecs and says he loves them because they troll down very low around 400RPMs close to .50 MPH, perfect for live bait rigging.

Does anyone have a E-tec that would care to share the troll down speed? You talk to a salesman....and you can't believe a word they say!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since you have the Yamaha, why don't you just work with that instead of spending the big money for another motor. Just drag a wind sock, or install the "Happy Troller" for about $110.00. It installs in less than 15 minutes, locks up for cruising and down for trolling. Will get you down below .05 MPH and give you a better hole shot. Just a thought. I have a Yamaha, and my buddy has the E-Tech, Yamaha is a better motor in my opinion. Just a thought. Good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That wasn't my question.

I own a drift sock, but I would rather not have to throw it out everytime I want to troll. Have you ever trolled tight structure? If you did you would know what I mean.

I know in this area Yamaha is top. I know many guides out in Wisconsin and Michigan that swear by E-Tec.

Just want some stats from e-Teck owners, don't really need opions... been fishing long enough to know my options. But thanks anyway.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From Cabelas HSOforum review:

Review 4 for The Happy Troller Fixed Position Trolling Plate

4 out of 5

Happy Trolling, May 27, 2009

By rjsportsman from Roscommon, MI

"Taking the advice from other reviewers, I added a 45 degree notch to the trolling plate. Using this intermediate notch, I can troll down to 1 mph with my Yamaha 50. Also, by running at higher rpm, my motor does not load up during extended trolling. This plate allowed me to do away with my kicker motor. This is a good product!"

Would you recommend this product to a friend? Yes

Just in case you where interested. He must have it on a 2 stroke because he talks about "loading"

- WIWF

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Keep your motor and get a fuel sipping T8 kicker. It will troll down to nothing and controls like a dream. I haven't used my bow mount in 2 years.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the lowest you can get your motor to troll in gear is 800 you need to have the idle adjusted.

Without using the VTS you should be at 800 in neutral and 600 in gear.

If you're not there you need to find a dealer and have them adjust it for you.

Can someone with any actual knowledge please reply?

Easy here... there is a broad range of people who post in this forum that range from highly experienced to highly inexperienced in operating a boat. Sometimes people (myself included) jump past the easy solutions because one assumes a consistent experience level with boats. Don't take it as an insult, take it as a basic question to make sure all the bases are covered.

marine_man

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Perfect Reply from Marine Man. I wouldn't assume you will need anything other than an adjustment by your dealer. 800 sounds very high for your low idle in gear using VTS. My F75 does about 700 and could probably go lower if adjusted, and lower yet with VTS.

By chance, anyone ever have it adjusted by the dealer? How much? Is it a ECM software thing?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My dad's 100 yamy trolls down under 600 rpm. Like marineman stated 800 seems very high and you have a lot of room to go down from there. Worth a shot unless you just want a new etec. Certainly a lot less expensive if it'll get you where you want to be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think at 600rpm you won't be under a 1/2 mph, that a little unrealistic of a 50hp outboard on a calm day. Do yourself a favor and get an electric TM for the calm days. Boat control will be better, and you won't spook any fish in the shallows.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The dealer said that the RPM guages on most boats are not that accurate on low idle?? My boat is a 2008 Alumacraft Classic 165.

He said that 950 RPMs sounds high and said he is guessing that it is running closer to 800.

He also said that there is NO way to adjust any idle on any EFI motors.... they are preset at the factory and it is what it is!

My Motor is a F50, 2008. I guess the only way to find out if it the RPM's are correct is to run it in to the shop and have them hook it up to the computer.

If it is running to high (9500) and can get it down to (800) before I adjust it down, it then should get down closer to .75 MPH.

But like I said earlier... Anyone have any experience with the E-Tec's?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's a bummer and just bad design with no way to adjust even if it meant going to the dealer to get it done. My dad has the tiller with the vro and he can get it down to where he needs it.

I do know that with the etec they come programmed for 800 rpm idle speed by you can take it to the dealer and have it reprogrammed for 500 rpms. That would likely get yuou closer to what your looking for. I know a couple of guys who have them and one loves his and the other likes his once he got through some initial injector issues.

Good Luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Borch

What HP does your buddy have that likes the e-tec? Do you know how low in mph (backtrolling) he can get it down on calm water?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Yamaha should troll down especially if back trolling. Get the idle looked at.

Or use a electric wich would be my 1st choice for live bait rigging.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Borch

What HP does your buddy have that likes the e-tec? Do you know how low in mph (backtrolling) he can get it down on calm water?

He runs a 90 on a 618T Ranger and gets under 1 but if I recall not the .5 you're looking for. The 618T is a lot of boat as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's very good for a 90HP, like I said mine will only get down to 1.20 with the 50 HP.

My guess is the e-tec 50 should get down between .50 mph and .75 mph , perfect for rigging.

Thanks for the info! I think I'll be looking next year for a new rig with the e-tec.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The dealer said that the RPM guages on most boats are not that accurate on low idle?? My boat is a 2008 Alumacraft Classic 165.

He said that 950 RPMs sounds high and said he is guessing that it is running closer to 800.

He also said that there is NO way to adjust any idle on any EFI motors.... they are preset at the factory and it is what it is!

If you're convinced you're after a E-tec so be it, but I don't believe your dealer. RPM Gauges can be inaccurate, but not by 150 RPM typically.. and you can adjust the idle on EFI's... and at a minimum, verify that the throttle is returning all the way to idle.

Does your dealer happen to sell E-tec's as well?

marine_man

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No. They only sell Yamaha and Mercs.

However, I just got off the phone with Yamaha and they said my Tach must be off because you can't work the low end variable speed if the RPM's are over 900. He said I should bring it in to the dealer and have them test it to see what the actual RPM's are on there computer.

He also said there there is a slight adjustment that can be done on the throttle cable only, not on the throttle handle.

I tell you what.... there are alot of dealers and mechanics selling Yamahas that really don't know these motors very well!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd get the E-Tec if buying new (and did 115hp), but would probably stick with the Yamaha if it was already on the boat that I had.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Bummer on the deer- that's a major hazard on these trips. I've been very lucky after several close calls (knock on wood) going out west.    Sounds great so far otherwise. Good luck and have a blast!
    • Nobody knows ice better than an Eskimo. Don't try to slip a foreign language into the conversation to muddy the water. 
    • Relative Rick?  Shes such a little cutey. Is the brown glove her fishen glove so she doesn't get slime of her other pink one? ☺️
    • We arrived to camp around noon. Got my first mulie buck around 2am just east miles city. Will need 2 new doors and a new service door on the trailer. We survived with minimal damage and continued on after getting the buck off the freeway. We dropped our gear and headed right out to start scouting! Made it to the first area I wanted to check and found a 5x5 with 18 cows and a spike. We backed out quickly and hopefully they will remain close for Saturday morning. We are headed back out in the morning to check a few other spots and then come back into town to enjoy a wonderful wild game feed put on by the city. My son is having the time of his life. Can’t believe the amount of wildlife he’s seen so far. Heading to bed after a long night and day of driving. Hopefully tomorrow brings more areas of opportunity.
    • Got me too, starting early this year. 
    • LOL, that's the best any of you got?  🤔😲😱🗨️
    • NORTHEAST IOWA FISHING REPORTS Cedar River (above Nashua)
      Water levels are falling with improved clarity. Please visit the USGS Water Data website for more information.  Decorah District Streams
      Check our fall community trout stocking schedule to find out when trout are coming to a lake near you. Catchable trout stocking is now unannounced. Stocking frequency and amounts are the same as conditions allow. Many trout streams run through wildlife management areas where hunting is allowed. Wear bright colors to be seen.  Brown Trout - Fair: As brown trout start spawning, watch the stream bottom for cleared areas in gravel (trout nests). Avoid stepping in the nests. Use larger flies mimicking grasshoppers or minnows. Rainbow Trout - Good: Catch a freshly stocked trout with a small piece of worm or cheese on a hook under a bobber in a deeper hole.  Lake Hendricks
      Few anglers have been out. Water is clearing. Black Crappie - Fair: Shoreline anglers are using a tube jig fished under a bobber.  Lake Meyer
      Water temperatures are falling with improved clarity. Angling has been spotty. Bluegill – Fair. Black Crappie – Slow.  Turkey River (above Clermont)
      The Turkey River water levels are falling with improved clarity. Use care around swollen rivers.  Upper Iowa River (above Decorah)
      Water levels are falling with improved clarity. Water temperatures are in the 50's. Visit the USGS Water Data website for current information. Use crankbaits or a hook tipped with a minnow in eddies and deeper water. Upper Iowa River (below Decorah)
      Water levels are falling, but the river remains muddy. Water temperatures are in the upper 50's. Paddling activities are not recommended. Visit the USGS Water Data website for current information.  Area waters are slowly clearing, but water levels and flows are high. Rain Friday then clearing and cold. Temperatures in the upper 40's to below freezing at night. For current fishing information, please call the Decorah Fish Hatchery at 563-382-8324. Cedar River (Nashua to La Porte City
      Reports of anglers catching walleye, smallmouth bass and some northern pike on the Cedar River in Black Hawk County. Walleye - Good: Use jigs and plastics in sandbar drop-offs or current breaks. Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Try jig and plastics or crankbaits. Northern Pike - Fair: Cast and retrieve spoons or crankbaits. Manchester District Streams
      Most Manchester District streams are in excellent condition. Flows will remain swift, but clarity should be good. Silver Lake (Delaware)
      Silver Lake is in excellent condition for angling, but there have been no reports. Bluegill, crappie, largemouth bass and northern pike are the main species in this lake.  Rivers and streams are falling. There have been angling reports on the Cedar River. Trout streams should be in good condition for the upcoming weekend. Call the N.E. Iowa district office at 563-927-3276 for more information. MISSISSIPPI RIVER Fishing Reports - IOWA Wisconsin, Illinois Mississippi River Pool 9
      River level at Lansing is expected to crest at 13.4 feet and slowly recede over next week. Water temperature is near 48 degrees. New Albin ramp road is closed due to high water. The Lansing Village Creek ramp construction is complete and the ramp is open. Walleye - Fair: High water and current will make fishing difficult this week. Try fishing side channel sloughs with less debris and current. Yellow Perch - Fair: Expect the perch bite to pick up into late fall. Look for fish out of the main channel using live minnow floated under a bobber.  Largemouth Bass - Good: Look for largemouth in the slack water areas off the main channel or running sloughs. Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Smallmouth action has slowed with the high muddy water. Cast inline spinners or crankbaits along rock or tree habitat in current.  Bluegill - Fair: Find bluegills in clearer water with slow current in backwater areas away from main channel and sloughs. Black Crappie - Fair: Expect the crappie bite to pick up this fall after the water clarity improves. Try tube jigs or minnow under a bobber in submersed trees in the backwater sloughs.  Mississippi River Pool 10
      River level at Lynxville is expected to crest at 23.1 feet with a slow fall next week. Sny Magill road is closed due to high water. Water temperature is 50 degrees at the Lock and Dam 9. Walleye- Slow: High water and current will make fishing difficult this week. Try fishing side channel sloughs with less debris and current. Yellow Perch - Fair: Expect the perch bite to pick up into late fall. Look for fish out of the main channel using live minnow floated under a bobber. Bluegill - Fair: Find bluegills in clearer water with slow current in backwater areas away from main channel and sloughs. Largemouth Bass - Good: Look for largemouth in the slack water areas off the main channel or running sloughs.  Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Smallmouth action has slowed with the high muddy water. Cast inline spinners or crankbaits along rock or tree habitat in current. Black Crappie - Fair: Expect the crappie bite to pick up this fall after the water clarity improves. Try tube jigs or minnow under a bobber in submersed trees in the backwater sloughs. Mississippi River Pool 11
      River level at Guttenberg is predicted to crest at 14.7 ft and gradually recede next week. Water temperature is 46 degrees at Lock and Dam 10. Walleye -Fair: High water and current will make fishing difficult this week. Try fishing side channel sloughs with less debris and current. Yellow Perch - Fair: Expect the perch bite to pick up into late fall. Look for fish out of the main channel using a live minnow floated under a bobber. Largemouth Bass - Good: Look for largemouth in the slack water areas off the main channel or running sloughs. Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Smallmouth action has slowed with the high muddy water. Cast inline spinners or crankbaits along rock or tree habitat in current. Bluegill - Fair: Find bluegills in clearer water with slow current in backwater areas away from the main channel and sloughs. Black Crappie - Fair: Expect the crappie bite to pick up this fall after the water clarity improves. Try tube jigs or minnow under a bobber in submersed trees in the backwater sloughs.  Upper Mississippi River levels cresting this week. Many ramps are under water. Water clarity is poor with a lot of debris. Water temperatures are near 50 degrees. Fish are starting to move toward the overwintering holes. 
        Mississippi River Pool 12
      Water levels will rise this week and peak near a predicted 14.8 feet at the Dubuque Lock and Dam and 16.8 feet at the RR bridge. Water clarity is fair. The water temperature is around 52 degrees. Channel Catfish - Good:Try stink bait or worms near shore. Channel cats feed heavily near shore during flooded conditions especially along rock shorelines. Freshwater Drum - Good: Most anglers use a simple egg sinker and worm rig. Drum will be hanging out near shore in moderate current areas.  Mississippi River Pool 13
      Water levels will rise this week and peak near a predicted 15.7 feet at the Bellevue Lock and Dam. Water clarity is poor. Avoid large tributary streams as they are muddy. The water temperature is around 53 degrees. The north ramp at Sabula is not in use this year due to bridge construction. Channel Catfish - Good: Try stink bait or worms near shore. Channel cats feed heavily near shore during flooded conditions especially along rock shorelines. Freshwater Drum - Good: Fish worms with an egg sinker in moderate current areas near shorelines.  Mississippi River Pool 14
      Water levels will rise this week and are predicted to be 15.5 feet at Fulton Lock and Dam, 17.1 feet at Camanche and 10.7 feet at the LeClaire. These are Action and Moderate flood levels. Water clarity is poor. The water temperature is around 53 degrees. Channel Catfish - Good: Try stink bait or worms near shore. Channel cats feed heavily near shore during flooded conditions especially along rock shorelines.  Freshwater Drum - Good: Use a simple egg sinker/worm rig in moderate current areas.  Mississippi River Pool 15
      Water level is predicted to be near 17 feet. This level is in a moderate flood stage, so boating is not advisable. Water clarity is poor. The water temperature is around 53 degrees.   Significant flooding in much of the district. Water levels range from Action to Moderate flood stages. Most of the smaller boat ramps are usable and will have water and debris on them. If you have any angling questions, please contact the Bellevue Fisheries Station 563-872-4976.
    • NORTHWEST IOWA FISHING REPORTS Black Hawk Lake
      Water temperatures are around 50 degrees. Bluegill - Fair: Use a small jig with a small piece of crawler fished under a bobber in 3-6 feet of water in Town Bay from the stone piers along the north shoreline of Town Bay along Ice House Point and near the inlet bridge. Largemouth Bass - Fair: Catch largemouth all over the lake using traditional bass lures. There is a 15 inch minimum length limit on largemouth bass in Black Hawk Lake. Yellow Perch - Fair: Catch perch up to 12 inches with small powerbaits like crappie nibbles, perch eyes and crawlers fished 2-4 feet below a bobber.  Brushy Creek Lake
      There is a 15 inch minimum length limit on largemouth bass in Brushy Creek Lake, and a 40 inch minimum length limit for musky. Walleye - Fair: Troll slowly crawler rigs, minnows or leaches in 10-15 feet of water. Yellow Perch - Fair: Find perch along the vegetation. Largemouth Bass - Fair: Catch bass along weed lines near shore just about anywhere with traditional bass lures. There is a 15 inch minimum length limit on largemouth bass in Brushy Creek Lake. Bluegill - Fair: Try tube jigs tipped with crawlers in 5-15 feet of water.  Crawford Creek Impoundment
      Black Crappie - Fair: A recent survey showed crappie up to 10 inches along shore. Use minnows or crawlers fished below a bobber in the mornings and evenings. Largemouth Bass - Fair: Use traditional bass lures along the shoreline.  North Twin Lake
      Water temperatures are around 50 degrees. White Crappie - Slow: A recent survey showed most crappie are 6-10 inches with a few up to 14 inches. Walleye - Slow: Walleye up to 27 inches have been seen in recent netting surveys.  Storm Lake (including Little Storm Lake)
      Storm Lake has a daily limit of 3 walleye and all 17- to 22-inch walleye must be released; no more than one walleye longer than 22 inches may be taken per day. Walleye - Fair: Use crawler rigs and troll crankbaits along the edges of the dredge cuts around the lake. Try twisters and leaches fished under a bobber from shore. White Bass - Fair: Use crankbaits and crawlers fished from shore. Black Crappie - Fair: A recent survey showed crappie up to 10 inches can be found near shore; use a crawler or minnow fished on a small jig below a bobber.  Water temperatures around 50 degrees in Black Hawk District lakes. For more information, contact the Black Hawk District office at 712-657-2638.   Beeds Lake
      Black Crappie - Fair: Drift fish or troll with a tube jig or small minnow. Yellow Bass - Fair: Drift fish or troll with a small jig. Shore anglers should fish a small piece of crawler or cut bait off the bottom.  Clear Lake
      Surface water temperature is 47 degrees. Muskellunge - Fair: Fish the edge of the vegetation and near docks. Walleye - Good: Fish off the jetties after dark.  Crystal Lake
      Black Crappie - Fair: Drift or troll small tube jigs or a minnow in the dredge cut or on the edge of vegetation. Walleye - Fair: Try a jig and minnow in the area near the old road bed.  Rice Lake
      Yellow Perch - Slow: Use a small minnow or a plastic bait in the deeper water.  For information on the lakes and rivers in the north central area, contact the Clear Lake Fish and Wildlife office at 641-357-3517.    East Okoboji Lake
      Yellow Bass - Good: Excellent bite continues with good numbers of fish being caught. Cast mini-jigs or hair-jigs or use small baits tipped with wigglers. Don’t overlook the evening bite from docks as these fish will move shallow at dusk. Walleye - Good: Numbers of fish are being caught with traditional baits; good numbers of yellow bass are mixed in with the catch. Northern Pike - Good: Anglers report northern pike action on the lake; best area is where there is flow into the lake.  Lake Pahoja
      Bluegill - Good: Good numbers of large angler acceptable size fish being caught. Channel Catfish - Good: Report of a good fall bite with large angler acceptable size fish being caught. 

      Lost Island Lake
      Yellow Bass - Good: Reports of yellow bass being caught with black crappie and yellow perch up to 10 inches mixed in the catch. Use small lures such as a twister tail or hair jigs. Bluegill - Good: Recent surveys show numbers of fish approaching 7 inches in the lake. Black Crappie - Good: Reports of fish being caught from the lake. Look for the bite to continue. Anglers are catching yellow perch and crappie from the shore. Walleye - Good: The fall walleye bite has started. Use traditional baits during "prime time". Yellow Perch  - Fair: Some fish are being caught in the evening from shore with walleyes mixed into the catch. Ocheyedan Pit #1
      Channel Catfish - Good: Recent surveys show good numbers of 17 -23 inch channel catfish.  Silver Lake (Dickinson)
      Walleye - Good: The fall walleye bite is on. Troll crankbaits during the day; wader fishing is your best chance to catch trophy size fish.  Spirit Lake
      Walleye - Good: The fall walleye bite has started with action improving. Wader angler action has picked up with the best bite during the evening. Yellow Perch - Good: Good numbers of fish are being caught with sorting needed; anglers continue to harvest numbers of angler acceptable size fish. Use mini jigs tipped with wigglers or a minnow. Northern Pike - Good: Angler reports of northern pike action on the lake; best area is where there is flow into the lake.  West Okoboji Lake
      Bluegill - Good: Rock piles in deeper water with stands of aquatic growth will produce good numbers of angler acceptable sized fish.  For more information throughout the week, contact the Spirit Lake Fish Hatchery at 712-336-1840. 
×