Jump to content
  • GUESTS

    If you want access to members only forums on HSO, you will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up .

    This box will disappear once you are signed in as a member. 😀

  • RECEIVE THE GIFTS MEMBERS SHARE WITH YOU HERE...THEN...CREATE SOMETHING TO ENCHANT OTHERS THAT YOU WANT TO SHARE

    You know what we all love...

    When you enchant people, you fill them with delight and yourself in return. Have Fun!!!

Sign in to follow this  
Bogsucker

Buck management

Recommended Posts

Would a "No party hunting for antlered whitetails" rule, be a useful management tool for increasing the population and quality of bucks in Minnesota? Based on the content of another post I can see there would be some opposition to it but what do you think?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wouldn't say unenforceable.
I would say tough to enforce.

I know someone that got busted, party hunting with the all-season license.

Would it increase the quantity and quality of bucks? I think its very clear it would.
But today, MN is trying to lower the deer herd, so adding a rule that would reduce overall deer harvest won't be coming any day too soon.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you were the type that made deer drives I bet it would be tough. Can you imagine trying to ID a 4" spike buck running with 2 does at 50 yards through trees. I doubt that this state would ever make any changes to their "buck" rules. At least they have reminders in the manual about trying to shoot bigger bucks and letting the little one's walk. Speaking of the manual, did I read in it that it is legal this year to party hunt with a all season tag? I will look after doing this post. It doesn't really matter; I don't party hunt anyway. I am selfish with my buck tag smile.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Extreme
If you are party hunting, and you don't have any buck tags as a group left, you still have to be careful what you shoot at.
You cant just be whacking deer, and then go figure out what you shot.
That exact scenario occurs with the rules we have today.
One of the 10 hunting commandments, is to positively identify your target before pulling the trigger.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You have a point there. I was just stating a scenario. I have never shot a deer doing deer drives. As a matter of fact, I truly believe that deer drives ruin an area. But this is my opinion. I have been involved with them, and they can be fun, but they are never on land that I hunt on a regular basis. A person should really know their target and also know what is behind their target, so point well taken!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We make many drives each year. The situation with tags & number of deer harvested already, determines whether you need to ID the deer prior to shooting or not. We take that a little farther per hunter too. If we've gotten quite a few deer & I've already shot one with the gun & maybe gotten 1 or 2 with the bow, then often I'll hunt with the stipulation of big deer only, or whatever. It might get to the point where I'd say put me in the middle of the drive, so someone won't be mad if I don't shoot unless it's a big buck.

If your party is doing drives they usually need all of the hunters & it's frustrating to have a drive work & then the deer don't even get shot at because they happened to go by someone who didn't want to shoot anymore deer. You can predict where deer on a drive are most likely to go & on most of the drives they'll go 1 or 2 places probably 70% of the time, but the other 30% they'll go back, squirt out a side, you name it, especially the bigger deer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why not manage deer the same way we manage fish and implement an antler size minimum on bucks, shoot as many does as you have tags and let the little guys grow up, this would help the quality of bucks for everyone. It would at least be interesting to do it in a test county for a couple years to see what happens. There would be alot of resistance from some hunters but after the first few years when everyone is seeing more and bigger bucks consistantly than ever before, I bet we would see other counties begging to have this set forth on them also. Look at Buffalo county Wisconsin and Pike County Illinios, both are managed for big deer, granted most the land is leased by outfitters, but that's a whole different subject, they kick out the biggest deer the in U.S. every year, and not just a couple. I think that Buffalo County WI has the most POpe and YOung entries for one county. And if you have ever been there it's not unlike a lot of land we have here in Minnesota, mixed crops with ample wood cover. I'm sure there are other factors involved but I wouldn't be opposed to it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry got off on a tangent. No party hunting for bucks would be a nightmare to enforce & they're trying to cut the deer herd, like someone said, so it won't happen.

You have to remember some guys, not me personally, see any buck as a trophy. I appreciate any deer I shoot even if it turns out to be smaller than I thought. I think if the state really wanted to cut buck harvest, other than just by education which I'm in favor of, it would have to be one of two ways:

1) move the season to after the rut
2) lottery for buck tags

I don't like either of them, but #1 would be more preferable. My biggest horror is to be out hunting during season & have a monster go by that you aren't allowed to shoot at, that would really suck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My opinion is that a "no party hunting for bucks" rule would get broken so often that it wouldn't be effective for increasing the age/size of bucks.

I think the best ways to get bigger bucks are to:
1) Move the season to after the rut
2) Impose a 6 point minumum antler restriction
3) Have a lottery drawing for buck tags instead of doe tags
4) Make the seasons longer so hunters don't feel pressured to shoot the first deer or they see (or every deer they see if they're party hunting)

Personally, I support just about any idea that encourages the harvest of does and lets some bucks get another year or two older.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would like to get rid of pary hunting. I know guys who have shot 4 plus bucks in one season. I got 3 once. I don't think it's fair to others. We will sooner or later have to go to a drawing for bucks, it works. I hope sooner.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I firmly believe that the only way we are going to improve the quality of bucks in this state is to implement an antler restriction. I feel that a harvestable buck should have to have a minimum of 3 pts per side, so a 6 ptr or better. Also I believe that if you get an antlerless tag, you have to shoot an antlerless deer. I was talking to a guy the other day and he said Minnesota is the only state in the Union to allow a person with an antlerless tag to shoot whatever they want. That just doesn't seem like a sound management tool to me. I feel the DNR should be able to have a pretty good idea of the buck to doe ratio in certain areas and allot the appropriate amount of tags for does and bucks. I'm a die hard bowhunter and have rifle hunted maybe 5 years I believe. I'll be the first to admit that I've shot some bucks that are basket racks, both with bow and rifle. Now that I've been deer hunting for 18 years, I'd like to see the quality and quantity of bigger bucks improve. On my dad's property starting this year, we're gonna pass on all bucks under 8 pts and try to thin out the large doe herd we have. We have 120 acres to hunt on with private and county land around us, so sure some of the little bucks we pass up may get shot off our property, but there'll be a few that hang out and grow decent racks. I really don't believe in the party hunting scenario. As far as the antler restriction, let the kid's say 12-15 years old shoot what ever they want. We have to remember that they are our future and if we don't have them, our future looks pretty dim! If we don't get more kid's hooked on the outdoor life style, be it big or small game hunting, or even fishing for that matter, the future doesn't look good for our outdoor life style.

Brian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey bmc, I agree with most of what you're saying. Except the part about Minnesota being the only state that lets you shoot what you want if you have an anterless tag. I've hunted in 3 other states where I've had anterless tags, and in those states I could shoot either an antlered deer or an anterless deer on those tags, or shoot one of each. Very similar to Minnesota.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks PerchJerker.

I believe when I used to bowhunt Iowa, whatever sex tag you got was what you shot.
This November 4 of us are heading out to Medora, N.D. for an archery hunt. We can shoot one deer. It can be a buck or doe, either specie. I'm hoping to get an arrow into a nice muley buck, but then again if it's late in the trip, I'm going home with some venison.

Brian

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not party hunting that makes your bucks die at a young age! It's the fact that anyone can simply walk in and by a buck license in MN. You see, Minnesota manages the deer population, not the buck population. A drawing is your answer.

I grew up hunting in SW MN. I moved to Eastern SD two years ago. Same terrain, crops etc.. and I have seen more wallhangers in the last two years then the previous 15 years combined hunting in MN.

I have a buddy that films quite a bit out in the field. He has two years of bowunting on a tape. Two years worth of huge bucks! When I showed the tape to my brother and dad, they were shocked at the size of the antlers here. (Just 30 miles accross the border from them).

In SD, we send in for a drawing each year. Most counties, you will draw a buck every other year. A sacrifice I gladly take to improve the odds of shooting a big one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Rost makes some good points, but I think you might be missing one too. I don't remember the dates for SD's gun deer seasons, especially the difference for East River and West River, but I think SD's gun deer seasons are in late November after the peak of the rut. I wish Minnesota's gun season was after the peak of the rut - I think a lot of 1.5 year old bucks get shot while their all hyped up to find a doe. I think just postponing the season a few weeks would save a lot of those young bucks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with SD having far better hunting, their state actually manages the deer herd. Our state just gives unlimited tags and expects to manage itself. It's clear that this system is not working. We have far to many deer, and are buck to doe ratio is out of whack. I don't know if anything can be done since traditon is hard to end. But these things need to be done.
1. Start gun season the 3rd weekend of Nov.
2. Limit the number of buck tags. Drawing.
3. Increase doe tags. Drawing.
4. The state needs to manage the deer herd.
We know this already works, other states do this. And they are very happy with it.
I read something pretty funny last month. Mn is doing a study to find out why the deer hunting in NE Iowa is so much better than SE MN. Can anyone quess?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks PJ
Yes, your are right. The Northern part of the state season is Nov. 20-27, South is Nov 27-Dec 5.

I am not sure why MN draws for doe tags? It seems weird doesn't it? Maybe the guy that made up that rule was the same guy who insists that I have a shelter licence for my portable fish shack smile.gif

It's common sense! If you let everyone shoot a buck, they will. Most people are excited to just say they got a buck. And they are not too picky either.

Either educate people-let them know that you can't catch and release a buck. Pass them up. Or write your congressman.

It's funny, I grew up in a small MN town where word travels fast. And when there was a buck lucky enough to get big, EVERYONE knew about it. And everyone flocked to that area come opening morning. In SD, I see a big deer and maybe mention it to people, they usually shrug their shoulders and think "Obviously Rost has not seen my wall."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heres' what has happened, at one time not so long ago there weren't very many deer in MN and around 1970 they actually did not have a deer season. The reason for the doe lottery was a to utilize a mangement tool to control the harvest of does which just happens to be the controlling factor in a deer population, from a herd population management perspective bucks are insignificant. Thus to increase the deer herd size the MN DNR implemented the antlerless lottery. Guess what, it worked. Now they are trying to manage an over-abundant herd of deer.

Now, how might we increase the quality and number of bucks in minnesotas herd without dictating what size buck a person might shoot. By disallowing party hunting for bucks, less bucks will be shot, yet no fewer hunters will shoot bucks, thusly increasing the number of bucks and in turn providing the opportuntity for more bucks to grow larger.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When you say "Party" hunting, you mean hunting in groups or tagging each others deer?
Making party hunting illegal would be a tough law to enforce. Impossible to eliminate grey areas with that law.

A lottery is cut and dry. This way,you can either shoot a buck, or you can't. Plus, a lottery actually breaks up "party" hunting a bit. EX: The party I used to hunt with had about ten guys. If only 5 guys drew a buck, the rest does, I can guarentee that the five that did not draw will be pheasant hunting.


[This message has been edited by Rost (edited 09-06-2004).]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think I could live with the party hunt restriction a lot easier than any other ones. Yeah, It would be hard to enforce but I think it would give some incentive not to shoot the small one that comes by on opening morning, or maybe put a damper on one member of a party getting the hot stand and shooting several small bucks just for the meat pole. We also should keep in mind we are only a harsh winter or two away from doe permits being scarce again and with a buck lottery we would have to tell some hunters that they are going to have to sit the season out. We have alot more deer hunters in this state than IA or SD and I really like the current system that gives us the opportunity to hunt every year and have a buck tag. We all don't hunt in large parties either where we can count on a tag being available, if buck tags were limited. Even with our curent population, as stated earlier, somne people would not hunt if they didn't have a buck tag- this would result in less does being taken at a time now when we should be trying to take more.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What I mean by "party" hunting for buck is tagging a buck shot by another hunter or intentionally shooting more than 1 buck with the intent that someone else would tag it. I have no problem with party hunting in general as it pertains to the harvesting of deer for the "meat pole" and as a management tool for harvesting does. I just think it would really help the buck population and quality without getting into the minimum rack size or quota issues.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have listened to most of the different arguments about this issue for the last couple of years. My old home state, Missouri, has come up with a plan that I would endorse. You can have as many doe tags that you want, but they have an antler restriction of 4 points per side, or an 8 pointer. According to the survey on the web site 51% of the deer hunters voted for this over four other management plans. I have to admit since moving to Minnesota, the attitude toward deer hunting is unusual.

I hunt with a group, and most of the group only gets buck tags. They will shoot any buck that walks by, which is usually a spike or forkhorn. Then when I come in with a quality buck about every other year, they think I am just lucky. I try and tell them that if they would just shoot does for the meat pole, and leave the small bucks alone, they would have opportunities to shoot the type of bucks I get. I know that they will never change their ways, that is why the buck to doe ratio is so screwed up, so this year I will be making sure all of the doe tags are filled. I do this every other year, when I don't buck hunt. If more people would concentrate on does for one year, you would be suprised at the size of the bucks you would have running around.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of the problem I've heard with antler restrictions is that high grading occurs, the genetically superior younger bucks are harvested at a higher rate, and the end result is actually a genetically inferior buck population.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a very sensitive subject for many of us who are passionate about deer hunting. I am pleased to see that this discussion has gone so well, usually these threads end up in cyberspace because it gets out of hand.

I have managed the deer on our land for approximately eight years now and the results have been pretty good. There is no question that antler restrictions and limited buck harvests will help. However, you need to understand one thing. Even with the best heard in the country and perfect buck to doe ratios, not everyone will be happy with what we have. All public land holders will further their restriction on access to their land and public lands will continue to get pounded. Not everyone will harvest a nice buck, that just the way it is. One other problem I see is that we are only shifting the age of harvested deer. instead of spikes and forks we are now taking small eights and tens. Sure they are better bucks but we will still have a poor buck to doe ratio.

I could go on forever on this. I do support QDM but it does have its pitfalls as well. Its that grass is greener on the other side thing that we are all guilty of. We need realistic expectations on this or we will be disappointed.

In my opinion, QDM should be voluntary. The movement has begun and it will be a few years but it will catch on through peer pressure and education. Remember when filling out meant all bucks. A group would go out and harvest 15 bucks. I thik that is a thing of the past. We have changed our ways and others around have as well. Anyway, good luck all!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Your Responses - Share & Have Fun :)

    • Okogie and KBD are both healthy, but sit due to Thibs having his head in a dark place. I sure hope they get some playing time tonight. Looking at the minutes given to Butler, Rose, and Tolliver, I doubt they'll play for awhile.    Bummer, since they both had a good preseason. I can see Okogie developing into Butler 2.0 so why not play him while he can learn from 1.0?
    • Near that same area, I watched a guy from Pennsyvania hit a huge muley buck totally demolishing his truck.  His hunt was definetly ruined.  Consider yourself lucky. Good luck on the rest of your trip and continue keeping us up to date. 
    • It wouldn't be an elk hunting trip if something didn't break.  At least you got the vehicle damage out of the way early and made it to your hunting area.  Should be smooth sailing from here.     Don't forget to let your insurance company know of the accident.  
    • Bummer on the deer- that's a major hazard on these trips. I've been very lucky after several close calls (knock on wood) going out west.    Sounds great so far otherwise. Good luck and have a blast!
    • Nobody knows ice better than an Eskimo. Don't try to slip a foreign language into the conversation to muddy the water. 
    • We arrived to camp around noon. Got my first mulie buck around 2am just east miles city. Will need 2 new doors and a new service door on the trailer. We survived with minimal damage and continued on after getting the buck off the freeway. We dropped our gear and headed right out to start scouting! Made it to the first area I wanted to check and found a 5x5 with 18 cows and a spike. We backed out quickly and hopefully they will remain close for Saturday morning. We are headed back out in the morning to check a few other spots and then come back into town to enjoy a wonderful wild game feed put on by the city. My son is having the time of his life. Can’t believe the amount of wildlife he’s seen so far. Heading to bed after a long night and day of driving. Hopefully tomorrow brings more areas of opportunity.
    • LOL, that's the best any of you got?  🤔😲😱🗨️
    • NORTHEAST IOWA FISHING REPORTS Cedar River (above Nashua)
      Water levels are falling with improved clarity. Please visit the USGS Water Data website for more information.  Decorah District Streams
      Check our fall community trout stocking schedule to find out when trout are coming to a lake near you. Catchable trout stocking is now unannounced. Stocking frequency and amounts are the same as conditions allow. Many trout streams run through wildlife management areas where hunting is allowed. Wear bright colors to be seen.  Brown Trout - Fair: As brown trout start spawning, watch the stream bottom for cleared areas in gravel (trout nests). Avoid stepping in the nests. Use larger flies mimicking grasshoppers or minnows. Rainbow Trout - Good: Catch a freshly stocked trout with a small piece of worm or cheese on a hook under a bobber in a deeper hole.  Lake Hendricks
      Few anglers have been out. Water is clearing. Black Crappie - Fair: Shoreline anglers are using a tube jig fished under a bobber.  Lake Meyer
      Water temperatures are falling with improved clarity. Angling has been spotty. Bluegill – Fair. Black Crappie – Slow.  Turkey River (above Clermont)
      The Turkey River water levels are falling with improved clarity. Use care around swollen rivers.  Upper Iowa River (above Decorah)
      Water levels are falling with improved clarity. Water temperatures are in the 50's. Visit the USGS Water Data website for current information. Use crankbaits or a hook tipped with a minnow in eddies and deeper water. Upper Iowa River (below Decorah)
      Water levels are falling, but the river remains muddy. Water temperatures are in the upper 50's. Paddling activities are not recommended. Visit the USGS Water Data website for current information.  Area waters are slowly clearing, but water levels and flows are high. Rain Friday then clearing and cold. Temperatures in the upper 40's to below freezing at night. For current fishing information, please call the Decorah Fish Hatchery at 563-382-8324. Cedar River (Nashua to La Porte City
      Reports of anglers catching walleye, smallmouth bass and some northern pike on the Cedar River in Black Hawk County. Walleye - Good: Use jigs and plastics in sandbar drop-offs or current breaks. Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Try jig and plastics or crankbaits. Northern Pike - Fair: Cast and retrieve spoons or crankbaits. Manchester District Streams
      Most Manchester District streams are in excellent condition. Flows will remain swift, but clarity should be good. Silver Lake (Delaware)
      Silver Lake is in excellent condition for angling, but there have been no reports. Bluegill, crappie, largemouth bass and northern pike are the main species in this lake.  Rivers and streams are falling. There have been angling reports on the Cedar River. Trout streams should be in good condition for the upcoming weekend. Call the N.E. Iowa district office at 563-927-3276 for more information. MISSISSIPPI RIVER Fishing Reports - IOWA Wisconsin, Illinois Mississippi River Pool 9
      River level at Lansing is expected to crest at 13.4 feet and slowly recede over next week. Water temperature is near 48 degrees. New Albin ramp road is closed due to high water. The Lansing Village Creek ramp construction is complete and the ramp is open. Walleye - Fair: High water and current will make fishing difficult this week. Try fishing side channel sloughs with less debris and current. Yellow Perch - Fair: Expect the perch bite to pick up into late fall. Look for fish out of the main channel using live minnow floated under a bobber.  Largemouth Bass - Good: Look for largemouth in the slack water areas off the main channel or running sloughs. Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Smallmouth action has slowed with the high muddy water. Cast inline spinners or crankbaits along rock or tree habitat in current.  Bluegill - Fair: Find bluegills in clearer water with slow current in backwater areas away from main channel and sloughs. Black Crappie - Fair: Expect the crappie bite to pick up this fall after the water clarity improves. Try tube jigs or minnow under a bobber in submersed trees in the backwater sloughs.  Mississippi River Pool 10
      River level at Lynxville is expected to crest at 23.1 feet with a slow fall next week. Sny Magill road is closed due to high water. Water temperature is 50 degrees at the Lock and Dam 9. Walleye- Slow: High water and current will make fishing difficult this week. Try fishing side channel sloughs with less debris and current. Yellow Perch - Fair: Expect the perch bite to pick up into late fall. Look for fish out of the main channel using live minnow floated under a bobber. Bluegill - Fair: Find bluegills in clearer water with slow current in backwater areas away from main channel and sloughs. Largemouth Bass - Good: Look for largemouth in the slack water areas off the main channel or running sloughs.  Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Smallmouth action has slowed with the high muddy water. Cast inline spinners or crankbaits along rock or tree habitat in current. Black Crappie - Fair: Expect the crappie bite to pick up this fall after the water clarity improves. Try tube jigs or minnow under a bobber in submersed trees in the backwater sloughs. Mississippi River Pool 11
      River level at Guttenberg is predicted to crest at 14.7 ft and gradually recede next week. Water temperature is 46 degrees at Lock and Dam 10. Walleye -Fair: High water and current will make fishing difficult this week. Try fishing side channel sloughs with less debris and current. Yellow Perch - Fair: Expect the perch bite to pick up into late fall. Look for fish out of the main channel using a live minnow floated under a bobber. Largemouth Bass - Good: Look for largemouth in the slack water areas off the main channel or running sloughs. Smallmouth Bass - Fair: Smallmouth action has slowed with the high muddy water. Cast inline spinners or crankbaits along rock or tree habitat in current. Bluegill - Fair: Find bluegills in clearer water with slow current in backwater areas away from the main channel and sloughs. Black Crappie - Fair: Expect the crappie bite to pick up this fall after the water clarity improves. Try tube jigs or minnow under a bobber in submersed trees in the backwater sloughs.  Upper Mississippi River levels cresting this week. Many ramps are under water. Water clarity is poor with a lot of debris. Water temperatures are near 50 degrees. Fish are starting to move toward the overwintering holes. 
        Mississippi River Pool 12
      Water levels will rise this week and peak near a predicted 14.8 feet at the Dubuque Lock and Dam and 16.8 feet at the RR bridge. Water clarity is fair. The water temperature is around 52 degrees. Channel Catfish - Good:Try stink bait or worms near shore. Channel cats feed heavily near shore during flooded conditions especially along rock shorelines. Freshwater Drum - Good: Most anglers use a simple egg sinker and worm rig. Drum will be hanging out near shore in moderate current areas.  Mississippi River Pool 13
      Water levels will rise this week and peak near a predicted 15.7 feet at the Bellevue Lock and Dam. Water clarity is poor. Avoid large tributary streams as they are muddy. The water temperature is around 53 degrees. The north ramp at Sabula is not in use this year due to bridge construction. Channel Catfish - Good: Try stink bait or worms near shore. Channel cats feed heavily near shore during flooded conditions especially along rock shorelines. Freshwater Drum - Good: Fish worms with an egg sinker in moderate current areas near shorelines.  Mississippi River Pool 14
      Water levels will rise this week and are predicted to be 15.5 feet at Fulton Lock and Dam, 17.1 feet at Camanche and 10.7 feet at the LeClaire. These are Action and Moderate flood levels. Water clarity is poor. The water temperature is around 53 degrees. Channel Catfish - Good: Try stink bait or worms near shore. Channel cats feed heavily near shore during flooded conditions especially along rock shorelines.  Freshwater Drum - Good: Use a simple egg sinker/worm rig in moderate current areas.  Mississippi River Pool 15
      Water level is predicted to be near 17 feet. This level is in a moderate flood stage, so boating is not advisable. Water clarity is poor. The water temperature is around 53 degrees.   Significant flooding in much of the district. Water levels range from Action to Moderate flood stages. Most of the smaller boat ramps are usable and will have water and debris on them. If you have any angling questions, please contact the Bellevue Fisheries Station 563-872-4976.
    • NORTHWEST IOWA FISHING REPORTS Black Hawk Lake
      Water temperatures are around 50 degrees. Bluegill - Fair: Use a small jig with a small piece of crawler fished under a bobber in 3-6 feet of water in Town Bay from the stone piers along the north shoreline of Town Bay along Ice House Point and near the inlet bridge. Largemouth Bass - Fair: Catch largemouth all over the lake using traditional bass lures. There is a 15 inch minimum length limit on largemouth bass in Black Hawk Lake. Yellow Perch - Fair: Catch perch up to 12 inches with small powerbaits like crappie nibbles, perch eyes and crawlers fished 2-4 feet below a bobber.  Brushy Creek Lake
      There is a 15 inch minimum length limit on largemouth bass in Brushy Creek Lake, and a 40 inch minimum length limit for musky. Walleye - Fair: Troll slowly crawler rigs, minnows or leaches in 10-15 feet of water. Yellow Perch - Fair: Find perch along the vegetation. Largemouth Bass - Fair: Catch bass along weed lines near shore just about anywhere with traditional bass lures. There is a 15 inch minimum length limit on largemouth bass in Brushy Creek Lake. Bluegill - Fair: Try tube jigs tipped with crawlers in 5-15 feet of water.  Crawford Creek Impoundment
      Black Crappie - Fair: A recent survey showed crappie up to 10 inches along shore. Use minnows or crawlers fished below a bobber in the mornings and evenings. Largemouth Bass - Fair: Use traditional bass lures along the shoreline.  North Twin Lake
      Water temperatures are around 50 degrees. White Crappie - Slow: A recent survey showed most crappie are 6-10 inches with a few up to 14 inches. Walleye - Slow: Walleye up to 27 inches have been seen in recent netting surveys.  Storm Lake (including Little Storm Lake)
      Storm Lake has a daily limit of 3 walleye and all 17- to 22-inch walleye must be released; no more than one walleye longer than 22 inches may be taken per day. Walleye - Fair: Use crawler rigs and troll crankbaits along the edges of the dredge cuts around the lake. Try twisters and leaches fished under a bobber from shore. White Bass - Fair: Use crankbaits and crawlers fished from shore. Black Crappie - Fair: A recent survey showed crappie up to 10 inches can be found near shore; use a crawler or minnow fished on a small jig below a bobber.  Water temperatures around 50 degrees in Black Hawk District lakes. For more information, contact the Black Hawk District office at 712-657-2638.   Beeds Lake
      Black Crappie - Fair: Drift fish or troll with a tube jig or small minnow. Yellow Bass - Fair: Drift fish or troll with a small jig. Shore anglers should fish a small piece of crawler or cut bait off the bottom.  Clear Lake
      Surface water temperature is 47 degrees. Muskellunge - Fair: Fish the edge of the vegetation and near docks. Walleye - Good: Fish off the jetties after dark.  Crystal Lake
      Black Crappie - Fair: Drift or troll small tube jigs or a minnow in the dredge cut or on the edge of vegetation. Walleye - Fair: Try a jig and minnow in the area near the old road bed.  Rice Lake
      Yellow Perch - Slow: Use a small minnow or a plastic bait in the deeper water.  For information on the lakes and rivers in the north central area, contact the Clear Lake Fish and Wildlife office at 641-357-3517.    East Okoboji Lake
      Yellow Bass - Good: Excellent bite continues with good numbers of fish being caught. Cast mini-jigs or hair-jigs or use small baits tipped with wigglers. Don’t overlook the evening bite from docks as these fish will move shallow at dusk. Walleye - Good: Numbers of fish are being caught with traditional baits; good numbers of yellow bass are mixed in with the catch. Northern Pike - Good: Anglers report northern pike action on the lake; best area is where there is flow into the lake.  Lake Pahoja
      Bluegill - Good: Good numbers of large angler acceptable size fish being caught. Channel Catfish - Good: Report of a good fall bite with large angler acceptable size fish being caught. 

      Lost Island Lake
      Yellow Bass - Good: Reports of yellow bass being caught with black crappie and yellow perch up to 10 inches mixed in the catch. Use small lures such as a twister tail or hair jigs. Bluegill - Good: Recent surveys show numbers of fish approaching 7 inches in the lake. Black Crappie - Good: Reports of fish being caught from the lake. Look for the bite to continue. Anglers are catching yellow perch and crappie from the shore. Walleye - Good: The fall walleye bite has started. Use traditional baits during "prime time". Yellow Perch  - Fair: Some fish are being caught in the evening from shore with walleyes mixed into the catch. Ocheyedan Pit #1
      Channel Catfish - Good: Recent surveys show good numbers of 17 -23 inch channel catfish.  Silver Lake (Dickinson)
      Walleye - Good: The fall walleye bite is on. Troll crankbaits during the day; wader fishing is your best chance to catch trophy size fish.  Spirit Lake
      Walleye - Good: The fall walleye bite has started with action improving. Wader angler action has picked up with the best bite during the evening. Yellow Perch - Good: Good numbers of fish are being caught with sorting needed; anglers continue to harvest numbers of angler acceptable size fish. Use mini jigs tipped with wigglers or a minnow. Northern Pike - Good: Angler reports of northern pike action on the lake; best area is where there is flow into the lake.  West Okoboji Lake
      Bluegill - Good: Rock piles in deeper water with stands of aquatic growth will produce good numbers of angler acceptable sized fish.  For more information throughout the week, contact the Spirit Lake Fish Hatchery at 712-336-1840. 
    • SOUTHEAST IOWA FISHING REPORTS Environmental Discovery Park North Pond
      The fall trout release will be Oct. 27th at 10 am; 1000 trout will be released with 100 trout tagged for prizes. Rainbow Trout - Excellent: Two weeks to go until the release  Iowa River (Columbus Junction to Mississippi River)
      NOAA is forecasting the Iowa River to still be above flood stage through the end of next week. Lake Belva Deer
      Still plenty of water leaving the lake. Water clarity is almost back to normal. Water temperature is in the low to mid 50's. Black Crappie - Fair: Cappies are sticking to the deeper water; drift the lower end of the lake. Start in 16 to 18 feet of water and work your way into shallower water until you find fish. Largemouth Bass - Slow: Picking up a few bass in the more shallow water along the rocks and gravel bottom areas.   Lake Darling
      Water level is still about 6 inches above normal. Water clarity continues to improve. Water temperature is in the low 50's.Bluegill - Fair: On the less windy days, anglers are catching some nice bluegills in 5 to 8 feet of water around the habitat. Black Crappie - Slow: Anglers are starting to once again catch some crappies, but they have moved back out to deeper water (10-12 feet). Largemouth Bass - Fair: Anglers are catching some decent bass in fairly close to shore; use a little flash to the lure with the water clarity. Lake of the Hills
      The fall trout release of 2000 trout is scheduled for Oct. 20th at 10:30 am; there will be 200 tagged trout for prizes. Rainbow Trout - Good: Since the river is still going to be above flood stage, why not try a little trout fishing this Saturday?  Lost Grove Lake
      Bluegill - Fair: Get back into the standing flooded timber out of the wind; look for fish to be in 6 to 8 feet of water. Maybe a little shallower on the north side when it’s sunny. Black Crappie - Fair: Still are out in deeper water; they should start moving in shallower if the weather calms down. Skunk River (Coppock to Mississippi River)
      The river is off the boat ramp parking lot at Brighton and continues to drop. Level is still above flood stage. Wilson Lake
      The fall trout release is scheduled for Oct. 27th at noon; 1000 trout released with 200 tagged for prizes. Rainbow Trout - Good: One week to go!  For more information on the above lakes and rivers, call the Lake Darling Fisheries Office at 319-694-2430. Central Park Lake
      The lake is full after the renovation project; fingerling fish have been stocked.  Coralville Reservoir
      The lake level is at 711' (normal pool is 683.4') on 10/18. This is the crest height; the lake is predicted to slowly start falling after the weekend. Diamond Lake
      The lake is at normal level, but is still a little muddy. Minnows are not allowed here. Bluegill - Fair: Use small worms or jigs tipped with worms. Black Crappie - Fair: Anglers are catching fish off the jetties. Jigs tipped with worms work best. Most fish are 8-9 inches.    Kent Park Lake
      The lake is currently drained for a lake restoration project.  Lake Macbride
      The motor restriction is off; any sized motor may be used at no-wake speed (5 mph). Water temperatures have been in the mid 50's. The fish cleaning station at the primitive campground has been shut down. Black Crappie - Fair: Use jigs or minnows over brush or rock. There are a lot of 12 inch fish right now. Walleye - Fair: Troll crankbaits in 8-14 feet of water. The shallow water bite should pick up along windblown rock especially towards evening. Wiper (Hybrid Striped Bass) – Fair: Try topwater baits early and late then troll during the day.  Pleasant Creek Lake
      The lake is still about 1 feet low. The fish cleaning station is closed. White Bass – Fair. Wiper (Hybrid Striped Bass) – Fair. Bluegill - Fair: Fish along weed lines in 7-9 feet of water. For more information, contact the Lake Macbride Fisheries Station at 319-624-3615.   Lake Keomah
      Bluegill - Fair: Use small jigs tipped with live bait near shore and around the fishing jetties. Black Crappie - Fair: Try a jig tipped with a minnow around deep structure. Try different depths until you find active fish. Channel Catfish - Fair: Use stink bait or chicken liver. Largemouth Bass - Fair: Cast the shoreline with spinnerbaits or crankbaits. Try a rubber worm or a crawdad imitation around the fishing jetties and along the dam.  Lake Miami
      Largemouth Bass - Fair: Cast crankbaits or spinnerbaits around the cedar tree piles and the fishing jetties. Try also rubber worms or other plastic along the rip-rapped shorelines and in the cedar tree piles. Bluegill - Fair: Use a chunk of night crawler along the fishing jetties or around the cedar tree piles. Black Crappie - Fair: Try jig and minnow combinations around the cedar tree piles.  Lake Sugema
      The south boat ramp off of Highway 2 has been reopened. The north ramp is now closed due to a construction project.  Largemouth Bass - Fair: Cast the shorelines with crankbaits and spinnerbaits. Use crawdad imitations along the rip-rapped shorelines and the fishing jetties.  Black Crappie - Slow: Try different depths with minnows and jigs until you find active fish. Drift or use a slip bobber and a minnow. Bluegill - Fair: Try live bait tipped on a small jig around the shorelines and fishing jetties. Keep moving until you find active fish. Walleye - Slow: Use a nightcrawlers rig or a jig and minnow combination along the dam.  Lake Wapello
      Channel Catfish - Fair: Use chicken liver or night crawlers; look for areas with some water flow. Largemouth Bass - Good: Cast spinnerbaits or crankbaits around the cedar tree piles. Try crawdad imitations along the rip-rapped shorelines. Bluegill - Fair: Cast small jigs tipped with a chunk of night crawler around the aquatic vegetation. Black Crappie - Fair: Drift or troll jigs tipped with a minnow in 6-10 feet of water.  Ottumwa Park Pond South
      Trout will be stocked on Friday, Oct. 26th at 11 a.m. Rathbun Reservoir
      The current lake level is 912.07 msl. Normal operating elevation is 904.0 msl. The lake has risen over 6 feet since last week, so be aware of floating debris. Lake Rathbun has zebra mussels, so make sure to properly drain, clean, and dry equipment before transporting to another water body. Channel Catfish - Fair: Use night crawlers or chicken liver in coves or areas with some water running into the lake. White Crappie - Fair: Try minnows around structure. Look for submerged trees and stumps.. Wiper (Hybrid Striped Bass) - Fair: Troll crankbaits along rocky shorelines and around rock piles. Follow the gulls as they will be where the schools of hybrid striped bass are feeding. Try also vertically jigging spoon baits around rock piles. Walleye - Slow: Use night crawler rigs or jig and minnows around rock piles and submerged points.  Red Haw Lake
      Largemouth Bass - Good: Cast the shorelines using rubber worms or spinnerbaits. Black Crappie - Fair: Use tube jigs along the shorelines; try tipping the jig with a minnow . Bluegill - Fair: Use small jigs tipped with live bait along the shorelines and around the fishing jetties. Channel Catfish - Fair: Try night crawlers or chicken liver around the fishing jetties and the outer edge of the lily pads.  The district includes Mahaska, Lucas, Wayne, Monroe, Appanoose, Wapello, Davis and Van Buren counties. Contact the Rathbun Fish Hatchery at 641-647-2406 with questions about fishing in south central Iowa.   Mississippi River Pool 16 Fishing Reports
      Tailwater stage at Lock and Dam 15 in Davenport is 16.21 feet and has been falling this past week. Flood stage for Lock and Dam 15 is 15 feet. Many of the boat ramps are inaccessible due to the high water. The ramps at Marquette St, Credit Island, Clark's Ferry, Shady Creek, and Fairport are all under water. Fishing has been slow with the high-water conditions.  Mississippi River Pool 17
      Tailwater stage is 16.92 feet at Lock and Dam 16 in Muscatine and has been falling this past week. Flood stage at Lock and Dam 16 is 15 feet.The ramps at Big Timber and Kilpeck are closed due to high-water. Fishing has been slow.  Mississippi River Pool 18
      Tailwater stage is 19.19 feet at Lock and Dam 17 above New Boston and is falling. Flood stage is 15 feet. The Toolsboro landing is closed due to high water. The Hawkeye Dolbee ramps will be underwater. The Ferry Landing is closed. Fishing has been slow with the high-water conditions.  Mississippi River Pool 19
      Tailwater stage is 15.26 feet at Lock and Dam 18 above Burlington and is falling. Flood stage is 10 feet. Fishing has been slow with the high water conditions. River stage is still above flood stage throughout the pools. River levels have been falling this past week. Most boat ramps are under water due to the flooding conditions. Fishing has been slow with the high water conditions. If you have questions on fishing Pools 16-19, contact the Fairport Fish Hatchery at 563-263-5062.
×