Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
marksullivan

dew claws

12 posts in this topic

just had a batch of purebred labs wondering if someone could set me straight on the removal debate. Some say yes some say no.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its best to take them off at 3 days...There is no real good reason to keep them on the dog. A torn dew claw is very very painful for a dog and is bound to happen to a hunting dog at some point. Can require surgery after torn and unnesseary expenses to whoever purchases a dog from you. I vote removal!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know if I will set you straight but with two labs(one large, one small) and not having them removed I have not had any problems. We have pheasant hunted in central Minnesota and we live in north east Minnesota where we hunt grouse often, never had a problem.

We had a litter of pups in November. We didn't have it done on them. I guess I am not for having anything done that isn't necessary.

I would be willing to bet you would probably hear an equal amount of arguments for and against.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have them taken off all of our springer pups. For the few seconds of pain to the dog it is not worth the risk of having a serious and major injury later. Could ruin someone's hunting trip as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The whole dew claw removal thing may be on a slow road to extinction (much the same as tail docking). There have been many studies done to show that there truly is a use for them and that their removal is not warranted for fear of injury. It is rare for a dog to tear a dew claw....

Wolves and coyotes have there's intact and you'd be hardpressed to find one with a torn dew claw.

To date I remove them not because of my belief in the necessity to remove them, but rather the publics perception that they need to be removed. As it becomes more accepted to leave them on, I will quit removing them.

They should be removed on days 3-5 if you want to proceed. They do heal up rather quickly, and are generally no worse for the wear within 12 hours.

Good Luck!

Ken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Haven't done it on last 3 dogs without problems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is opinions both ways here, Peope do like to buy them with them done. I have seen the injurys that can ocur with leaving them, yes you may never have it happen but when it does it is way more painfull of a repair to an older dog. Plus the bill. Pups can be done at a vet eaisly and very quick, much cheaper than later with a problem, I think it is a no brainer to do it . We used to run coon dogs and always had tears on the dogs that never had them done. I have never had a problem with a dog that has had them removed propery. Just my experiance. Our vet has them done from 2- 4 days old.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My dog had to have one of hers removed at about age 2. One was missed as a puppy, and the vet did it for free becasue they missed it, i was suprised to find the extent of having it removed as an older dog. Full on surgury, and a 2" cut, few stiches later. Its a bear trying to keep the bandage on without them chewing it up. I'd vote for having them off as pups, alot less painful, time and money consuming.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When days old dews just pinch off. Easier than cropping tails. That said ALL my Sibs (sleddogs) and Springers have their dews, never been a problem. While I have had digits removed that are prone to breaking or my old lead had two extra toes I had taken off, I see no need to remove the dews. The Springers head right for cattails and the Sibs break ice and wind blow trail all winter, still never a dew issue.

Are those adamant about removing dews also still cropping ears? Haven't heard anyone do that in years. Show doesn't match the field (though I know a musher who runs and wins shows with the same dogs, very rare.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have heard of many dogs ripping there dew claws off and one case where the dog almost lost its life because of it. It might not happen to your dog, but with as easy as it is when they are days old I just think it might as well be done. The only real benefit to dew claws is helping them climb steeper embankments(s.p.). It is probably not heard of that much since most dogs have them removed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Point taken.

Lots of odd injuries happen to dogs. One Springer took a 10" stick low in a rear leg. It pushed way up into his thigh and the dog never slowed down. The vet pulled it out a couple days later after it fluid began to build. Same dogs ripped its neck open nearly ear to ear, still he's fine. Yeah, he's seems a bit accident prone.

My point is, watch your dogs, learn how to read their behavior, inspect them often and don't hesitate to pull a dog from the field (or tugline.) Some people have a real hard time leaving a dog home or in the truck when they should. We run multiple dogs so dropping one is no big deal, except to the dog. Also, keep a medical kit in the truck. I've stitched dogs right in the field, carry it with you along with lots of water.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

and one case where the dog almost lost its life because of it.

Did it bleed a lot or get an infection or... ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • The Schrillary reich didnt compromise Bernie? And when hasnt the biased media compromised an election in recent memory? Nick is a hack and consistently posts 2nd grade propaganda, hes sold out to the party. They've been exposed and are resorting to extremes.  They went all in with obama and got called, he had far more to do with the outcome of the elections than anything  leaked by anyone.  Now its the fake blame game, humorous to say the least.   Snowflake butthurt apparently leads to desperation.
    • Really??? Catfish is my favorite fish.
    • I suspect you haven't visited this year or seen the reports.     And, for the record, I didn't say I was catching "tons" on Mille Lacs, but it was the best lake I've visited in the last two years.  And it wasn't even close.    
    • I think Schells is Minnesota's oldest brewer, so they must be doing something right.   I know some guys from New Ulm, and they all drink Schells.   That's how I got turned onto it in the first place.  Never got burned out on it, though..
    • Sink or swim? I am sure that some of you have heard that if you put seeds in water the ones that sink are better then the ones that float. I have heard this from the old guys but I have never tried it myself. Well I found myself with some radish seeds and I decided to pour them into a cup of water and sure enough about half sunk to the bottom while the rest floated. I got out a bowl and filled it with coconut husk planting mix and put the floaters on one side and the sinkers on the other. I am now waiting to see what side comes up first or if both sides will come up at the same time.   Any comments? Has anyone else heard of this and does anyone check their seeds before planting?
    • Maybe he's just hungry............    
    • Catfish!! I haven't had that in about ten years! Dang, that looks good! 
    • All day long you sit here and demand answers from everyone else but you never answer anyone else's questions. I wonder why that is?    
    • I would guess even Fletcher would say Stall has passed all expectations. I will give credit to Fletcher for building this team from absolute zero, we had almost no skill or prospects when he took over,  sure it took longer than we wanted but right now it is worth it. No doubt luck can play a roll, most GM's don't have a Suter, Parise, Stall & BB fall into their lap but quality drafting and development are also paying big dividends right now. We also have a lot of high end prospects that can fill in for the vets in the coming years. A cup is still a long ways away but this year is probably the best NHL team the state has ever seen.
  • Our Sponsors