Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
s2h

Fish Pain?

30 posts in this topic

Do fish feel pain when they are hooked? I searched it on the internet and there are studies that say yes and ones that say no. I personally dont think they do when hooked in the lip. But wonder when the fish swallows the hook, if it hurts them or not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe they do feel pain, especially when hooked deep. Ive had a lot of deep hooked fish thrash like crazy as soon as you grab the hook to try and free it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably does hurt....but not on a level like we experience and identify pain. Most wild things have a way different pain system then what we have.

They are moving and living in a whole different world, far removed from ours and their nervous systems are way different!

How the wild things would equate pain, I don't profess to know, but I do know this, I don't clean live fish if I can help it. I let the live ones sit in the fridge until the next day and then clean em, or sometimes if I'm limited on time and have to do it right away, I rap em in the head a few times until they go stiff and start to quiver and as soon as I'm done filleting, I break their backbone just behind the head to make sure.

The experts would probably know if fish feel the pain....you know, the people that have never fished a day in their lives and have no actual hands on experience in the field....they would know. They always know....they'er experts. Now if you can find an expert.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

pretty sure they feel pain. otherwise how would they fight so hard or react when you poke em with a knife?

Pain is a tool to let an animal know that damage might be occuring to tissue/organs

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

im sure they do.. like previously said if a bear tried to eat you while sleeping and you couldnt feel pain you would get eaten.. same with fish.. minnows freak out after being hooked..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would have to agree with everybody else here. Im sure that fish do feel pain but maybe not on a level like we do...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

they probably do, but who cares, I mean as long as everyone uses sharp pointy hooks to catch them no one will change that

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

your opening a can of worms..... you would think fish feel pain. However, i've read about studies conducted which say they don't feel pain.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's funny though. If they do feel pain, they don't really show it. I've had bass that have hit my crankbait 3 times before finally being hooked and I've even had them hooked for a while and they still come back for more. It sure makes you think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fish may feel pain when hooked, but not as much pain as I feel when they spit the hook out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

sice Ive had both my lip and tongue pierced, I suppose I could answer this...

crazy

I would assume in the lip being its all cartalage It would not hurt not so much. Swollowed I would assume is would hurt. But yes I do think animals register pain differently.

and no having a needle shoved through my tongue or lip didnt hurt at all. a sharp needle or hook is nothing compared to a dull torn gash. How many times have you sliced your finger on something very sharp and just looked at it and didnt feel a thing? Hooked your hand on something dull that took a chunk out?? OUCH!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

fishing-woman.jpg

This largemouth species doesnt seem to be wincing....on a serious note ye they prolly do but it is different than what we conceive pain as.

Drewski, maybe the lakes you fish are full of S&M Bass thats why they keep biting wink.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well according to peta.....just kidding grin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It depends on what you want to call pain. Pain is too subjective. What I consider pain is different from what you might.

Fish don't feel pain like we feel pain, but they definitely feel something. Their nervous systems are advanced enough they some sensation that could arguably be defined as pain. It's something that is necessary for survival.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I assure you, the young lady in your picture will not put up much of a fight. You tug on that line and that lady will go where ever you pull. WHY???? Because it hurts!!! Fish swim away--.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i think the onlt reason why fish swim away is because they don't know what is going on. i mean something is pulling them, and their away of thinking is to get away from what ever is pulling them. thats what i think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think it is painful for fish. I don't think a fish has the mental capacity to be able to recognize the diff. b/t instinct and feeling; everything is just instinct. Instinct tells the fish that getting hooked, poked, cut, whatever is dangerous so out of instinct they thrash or jump. If they felt pain they wouldn't fight back b/c it would just hurt them more.

Maybe this is totally off, but it's just what I believe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think that they may feel pain in all parts of their bodys. But that their boney, thin skined, mouth areas where created to be able to eat other spiny things like other fish and crayfish that could give them a little pain. If they felt it all the time, they may just go hungry then do that again?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Lot's of opinions. Not much evidence being presented here...so I'll toss in mine. I don't know about the pain, but assume that most of what we see is fight-or-flight characteristics. They are smart enough to know to try swimming away from something that is trying to pull them in. When they are out of the water, they realize that something is different and try to wiggle their way back into the water.

Reasoning that they feel pain just because they flop when you pull out a hook is faulty logic. Correlation does not equal causation.

It would be good to read some actual research. I'm sure that a marine biologist could settle this whole thing quickly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i saw an article in i think field and stream a couple years back that had a study saying that fish lack the nervous system to register pain like we do. obviously there is a sensation that they will feel when being attacked or hooked, but it may be that it is a different sensation as others have said

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Outdoor life has an article saying Fish are incapable of feeling pain the way people experience it. "On the basis of brain anatomy," noted the scientists, " it seems highly unlikely that fish experience pain in the same manner as humans, because fish lack a neocortex, the brain structure that enables the sensation of pain in higher vertebrates."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    •     They were in all different stages on this lake, was messed up and I didn't know what was going on
    • Good Borch!   I have seen a large up tick of birds locally as well this last.  Although not hunting.   Trying to convince the wife and kids to hit a time or two yet.
    • They can sure humble a person. 
    • Well I tagged out this morning.   I got out later as my daughter and her family were over so I headed out after breakfast.  I drove by the field to see if there were any there so I could plan a route to the blind.   There was a fl8cknof Jake's and a flock of longbeards.  I quickly snuck into my blind and stuck a funky chicken decoy out.  As I was stepping into the blind the Jake's start clearing the trees between the blind and them.  They worked around out front a ways.  Suddenly I see 2 toms fly into the field.  The jakes immediately charged the toms driving them out of the field.  After that the jakes saw the funky chicked and headed over to check it out.  With the toms gone and time dlipoung away I picked one out and shot him at 30 yards.  He'll taste good on rhe grill this summer.   Got in the blind at 10 am and was done by 10:15 am.  It's been a long season. 
    • Fun in the yak today in SE SD caught and released a bunch of these today:
    • How can a bird with brain the size of a pea out smart us!
    • The 2 lakes i bass fish have slowed way down the last week.   A swim-bait ripple shad was hot ticket for a while but that is just a pike attraction right now.  Been switching to a Senko and helped a little.   Pads are coming up fast now and we should see a spike up in activity soon.  Cannot wait to throw the frogs soon as that is the biggest rush watching those eruptions in the water!!   Thanks for posting as i found it to be quite slower than usual also.   Which means i need to find better ammo during those times.  
    • Tomorrow we will be back at it
    • I am giving it a last hurrah tomorrow. Sorry I haven't been able to check in here much. I have hardly been able to get out this year between work, a baby at home, and a recent trip out of the country for a relative's wedding.    Last time I was out I had a real nice Tom within 20 yards after a very long standoff. I think I screwed it up by rushing myself a bit. He stood around 50 yards out literally strutting back and forth like someone had drawn a line in the mud that he wouldnt cross. He must not have wanted to fight with the strutter decoy we had out. He did that for 45 minutes to an hour and finally came our way after a hen led him towards us.    They came past us but were outside the decoys and angling slightly away from us. Then the tom turned and started angling straight at the strutter decoy. That meant he was basically quartering to me and when he was 15-17 yards or so out I drew because in the back of my mind i was thinking if he kept moving that way and past the decoy he would quickly be in a spot I would have had no shot.   In hindsight I think he had realized (once he got close enough) that he would have been able to whoop up on the decoy and he was coming in to do just that. I probably should have waited to see, but I didn't and right as I hit the backwall of my draw his head popped up on alert and he turned around and walked straight away knowing something wasn't quite right. I could have easily shot at him at 20 yards but he was facing away and I just didn't feel comfortable. I am confident I would have hit my mark but I didn't like shooting at something walking straight away when I am not experienced with bow hunting turkeys.   I know some people will say that I should have shot, but I have been bow hunting for awhile and never wounded anything because of a poor shot or poor shot selection, so I didn't want that to be a first. Hopefully I get a shot at redemption tomorrow!
    • Way to go team!! I sure took the avg score down with my jake
  • Our Sponsors