Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
firstimer

A hard choice 10mm or 45

12 posts in this topic

This is my first time here, so here it goes.

I've been shooting handguns for over 10 yrs now and never owned one or purchased one. So about 2 months ago, i decided i will get a purchase permit and go get one for the first time. I narrrowed it down to 3 guns i really like-glock 20sf, glock 21sf ,and the xd 45. I went back and forth between the three for about 3 weeks and finally I made a decision. So over the weekend i went out and got the 45xd and 200 rd. After shooting it I think i made the right call.

i hope the xdm 45 is just a rumor, or i will kick myself, if its not then i might be getting that one too.

2 hands = 2 guns smile

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome to Fishing Minnesota (FM)! I have a friend with the glock 29 in 10mm and since it is a hand cannon in that sub compact frame I don't like to shoot it much. I own a taurus pt1911 and considered the xd, but I went the traditional 1911 route. do you reload yet? You will soon, 45's are getting very expensive.......... I was at a gander mountain about 2 weeks ago and they had a full sized 10mm glock 20 with adjustable sights for 419. It was barely used and my left hand had a very hard time walking away from that one..........I am glad I did too, I am now looking for a new 17hmr henry varmit lever action rifle.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That Glock 20 makes a very nice Whitetail gun(about a 35 yard range). But that is about it. Just to big to be of much use other than that. Not that that is gospel, only my oppinion. I have fairly small hands, therefor prefer more of the "Compact" size handguns.

Welcome to FM. Let us know how your new toy works for you. I am also thinking .45acp for my next handgun purchase. Leaning twards the officer/comander size though. Preferably comander sized slide, officers frame.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've had the xd45 for about 2 years now and I really like it...it's the first auto I've owned and it took some rounds for me to get used to it, but now it's the one I grab first at the range...Enjoy!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The .45 xdm is not just a rumor sorry. I have been using the xd .40 for my conceal carry gun for 5 years now and love it very realiable and accurate gun easy to clean. I bought mine before they made it in a .45 wish I would have waited but it gives me an excuse to go by the .45xdm. Another one that I bought and really love and is more accurate for me is a sigpro it comes from their custom shop like the xdm. If you try to shoot hollow points out of your xd I had a problem with the winchesters they would catch and jam so insted of wasting money on ammo that won't feed before you buy them open the box and see if their is a taper to the hollow point the narrower at the tip the better they feed the corbonds and remingtons worked well for me

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The .45 xdm is not just a rumor sorry. I have been using the xd .40 for my conceal carry gun for 5 years now and love it very realiable and accurate gun easy to clean. I bought mine before they made it in a .45 wish I would have waited but it gives me an excuse to go by the .45xdm. Another one that I bought and really love and is more accurate for me is a sigpro it comes from their custom shop like the xdm. If you try to shoot hollow points out of your xd I had a problem with the winchesters they would catch and jam so insted of wasting money on ammo that won't feed before you buy them open the box and see if their is a taper to the hollow point the narrower at the tip the better they feed the corbonds and remingtons worked well for me

Did you try polishing the feed ramp? I had a gun that needed shining a while back. Traded it away for unrelated reliability issues.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1000 rounds, thats nothin'!!! You are still breaking it in. grin

Still, FTF is an issue, especially right out of the box. By "polished" are you talking factory, or did you diy/have it done. I think some brillow pad time may be in your future. Just as a touch up, mabe....

Does a hard smack seat the round? Or is it a tap/rack/bag type failure? Or like you said, just use a different round.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nope gotta rack it to clear the round had the gunsmith that works on my trap gun go through it for me and said it was probably the ammo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After over a month shooting the xd 45 and more than 1000 rds thru it I made a right choice on the gun. The feel on it is very natural, shoots very smooth and very easy to fieldstrip for cleaning, havent had a problem yet with jamming or misfire. The ammos for these are getting expensive, but the prices for ammo overall for any caliber is getting up there too. I wont be plinking as much maybe once a month or every other month. As for this being my very first gun I bought I'm pleased with it and love it. I will buy another gun later on in the year, it will be another springfield. Like I said in my first post I've been shooting pistols for over 10 yrs and in my opinon if you want price and relibility a glock or a springfield is where you should go, but thats my opinon.

I want to thank everyone who replied and have a safe and happy shooting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Congrats on your new gun. Definatly look in to getting a reloader. The 45 acp is an easy case to load and you'll find yourself shooting alot more. I started out loading for my 44 mag and before I knew it, I had 15 different sets of dies on my bench. Good luck. Did you save all that brass by the way?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Lol. Wasn't fired. Just retired. Keep trying JV.........    
    • We can say we were there anyway.
    • Hey Push nice to see you used D2E.  Sorry about your mod badge.  I'm pretty far from liberal but if it helps you wipe away the tears feel free.  Maybe next time you won't sit out the election.     #rentfree   For those opinions that matter here on this subject I do hope that the futures deals are not like this one.  However it is nice to see a politician actually do what he said he was going to do even though I may not agree with the solution to the problem.  
    • I read you should freeze your venny for 60 days so you kill any organisms.  Looks like I will be waiting a little bit.  I will have to try something else.  Wheres your favorite place to purchase cures and seasonings?  thanks again.   
    • CCG here is an old tsb.  Not for your year but it's the same smoke and mirrors.   #PIP4574M: Excessive Oil Consumption And/Or Blue Exhaust Smoke - Investigation Update

      Subject: Excessive Oil Consumption And/Or Blue Exhaust Smoke - Investigation Update

      Models: 2007 Buick Rainier

      2007-2008 Chevrolet Avalanche, Silverado, Suburban, Tahoe, Trail Blazer
      2007-2008 GMC Envoy, Sierra, Yukon
      2008 Pontiac G8
      2007-2008 Saab 97x
      with a 5.3L or 6.0L Aluminum Block V8 Engine
      and AFM (Active Fuel Management)
      RPOs LC9, LH6, L76, or LFA


      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

      This PI was superseded to include revise the affected RPO codes, specify that this is for Aluminum Block Engines only, update models and provide a general update on the status of this investigation in step 5. Please discard PIP4574M.

      --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

      The following diagnosis might be helpful if the vehicle exhibits the symptom(s) described in this PI.

      Condition/Concern:
      Some customers may complain that their vehicle has been using approximately 1 quart of oil every 500-1,000 miles. In most cases, the customer will advise that this did not start until the engineaccumulated approximately 30,000 miles or more. In some cases, the customer may note that this is more apparent when driving at highway speed. In rare instances, a SES light and engine misfire may be encountered with a P0300 DTC.

      Upon inspection, an oil fouled spark plug(s) may be noted. In most cases, static compression and cylinder leakage testing will appear normal. Excessive oil may or may not be found in the intake manifold.

      In most cases, this is the result of stuck oil control rings. Generally, the stuck oil control rings are the result of excessive oil on the cylinder walls. The excessive oil can come from the PCV system and/or the AFM pressure relief valve in the oil pan.

      Recommendation/Instructions:
      If this concern is encountered, follow the steps below:

      Visually inspect the entire engine and the underside of the vehicle for any evidence of oil leaks and repair them as necessary.
      Inspect the fresh air hose/pipe that is attached to the RF (passenger side) valve cover and all related connections for restrictions, such as plastic casting flash or a pinched hose, and repair as necessary. A restriction in this area may cause excessive crankcase vacuum and oilconsumption through the PCV vacuum tube.
      If the truck has an engine misfire and a spark plug that is obviously oilfouled, skip to step 4 since this proves that it has an obvious oilconsumption concern. If not, perform an oil consumption test as outlined in the latest version of oil consumption of 01-06-01-011 to verify the concern before proceeding to step 4. Allow the vehicle to sit on a level surface with the engine off for at least 10 minutes to allow the entire engine to drain back to the oil pan before checking the engine oillevel and adding oil. Compare the oil consumption test results to one of the scenarios below to determine further direction:
      • If oil consumption is Less than 1 quart of oil every 2,000 miles and no low oil light has been experienced, no repairs should be performed as this should be considered acceptable oil consumption as outlined in the latest version of 01-06-01-011.

      • If oil consumption is Less than 1 quart of oil every 2,000 miles but the customer has experienced a low oil light, refer to the latest version of PIP3959 for a potential low oil light sensor concern.

      • If the dealership verifies that oil consumption is More than 1 quart every 2,000 miles, perform the steps below as necessary:

      Determine if the engine has been ingesting oil through the PCV system by removing the intake manifold and measuring how much oil can be poured out of the throttle body opening with the throttle bodyremoved. It is normal to get a couple of teaspoons of oil out of the intake. If the engine has been ingesting oil through the PCV system, several ounces of oil will be measured, many times as much as a 1/4-1/2 quart.
      • If the engine HAS NOT been ingesting oil through the PCV system, go to step 5.

      • If the engine HAS been ingesting oil through the PCV system, inspect the PCV baffle as outlined in the rest of Step 4 below:

      4a. Remove the LH (driver's side) valve cover and inspect the PCV baffle drain holes shown below to see if they are plugged with hardened oil deposits. If they are plugged, replace the valve cover, ensure that the customer is changing their oil according to the maintenance schedule in their owner's manual, and re-evaluate the concern. Generally, this would not be a concern until several thousand miles have accumulated.

      4b. With the LH (driver's side) valve cover removed, inspect the PCV baffle to ensure that it is properly sealed to the valve cover by flipping it over and adding a little oil to the corner of the valve cover as shown below. The oil should stay in place as shown on the 2 outer valve coversbelow. If the oil drains into the PCV baffle as pointed out on the middle valve cover below, replace the valve cover. Generally, if this is the cause of the concern, it would have been present early in the life of the vehicle or shortly after valve cover replacement.


      Important: If Step 4a or 4b led to valve cover replacement, perform Step 4b again on the replacement valve cover before installing it.


      • 4c. If the engine HAS been ingesting oil through the PCV system but the valve cover passed the tests outlined above, the engine may have an over-aggressive lifter that is causing the oil ingestion through the PCV system. Sometimes the lifter may be doing this intermittently so it is not always possible to isolate one by inspecting the lifter flow with the driver's valve cover removed. As a result, it is suggested to replace all 8 of the left/driver bank lifters due to the oil in the intake and re-evaluate the oil consumption concern. The right/passenger side lifters should not cause oil in the intake so there is no need to replace them. If the vehicle returns with excessive oil consumption but is no longer ingesting oil through the PCV system, it most likely has stuck oilcontrol rings as outlined in Step 5.

      If the engine HAS NOT been ingesting oil through the PCV system and there are no obvious valve seal concerns, this is most likely the result of the AFM pressure relief valve in the oil pan spraying oil on the bottom of the cylinders when active fuel management is on. This may eventually cause the oil control rings to stick and increase the rate of oilconsumption. As outlined in the July 2010 GM STC Service Know-How Emerging Issues Seminar (10210.07D), a related bulletin is going to be released to repair this by cleaning the oil control rings and installing a shield over the AFM pressure relief valve. This bulletin was scheduled for a July 2010 release but the bulletin is still going through the final stages of the release process. At this time, it is on track for a mid-August release date. Once released, you will be able to find the new bulletin in the New Bulletins Section of Service Information and this PI will be updated to include the bulletin number as well.
      If you would like to view the July 2010 GM STC Service Know-How Emerging Issues Seminar (10210.07D) mentioned above, you can find it by following this path:

      • Go to the GM Training page. (If necessary, there is a link to this page at GM Global Connect "Dealerworld")

      • Enter your Training Person ID and Password.

      • Click the "Service Know-How/TECHAssist" Link

      • Click the "Emerging Issues" Link

      • Click the "Searchable Streaming Video" Link

      • Click the "10210.07D - July 2010 Emerging Issues" Link

      • Click the 9th Link down for High Oil Consumption

      Notice: Piston and Ring sets should no longer be replaced for this concern unless it is absolutely necessary. If stuck oil control rings are found and you decide to replace all 8 pistons and all 8 piston ring sets, we DO NOT recommend honing or deglazing the cylinder walls due to the great variation between equipment, machine shops, and technicians performing these repairs. This is because it is generally unnecessary and can induce unnecessary cylinder wall and/or piston ring damage if it is done incorrectly or not cleaned thoroughly. The cylinder walls just need to be cleaned thoroughly with brake cleaner before the new piston and ring sets are installed. At this time, you may also experience a back order situation if you order new pistons and rings.
    • Bummer start of the year but the weather next week looks like ice making weather
    • I also have a pair of their binoculars and really like them my next scope I plan to get will be a Vortex there pricing is great for the quality you get
    • So.... Is the govt financially better off having those 1000+ carrier tax paying jobs in the US for the next 10 years while giving the tax breaks to theckmpang... Or having them all in Mexico?
    • LaCross Alpha Ice Kings with SmartWool socks.  Love mine.
  • Our Sponsors