Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
thefarmer

Fish Lake (west of Ivanhoe MN) froze out?

12 posts in this topic

Heard a rumor that they never turned the aerator on this year and all the fish were dead. Does anyone know if this is true or have been out there this winter? My bro was there in earlier this winter and no aerator but managed some fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am unsure of the aerator situation, but with all the heavy snow we had early on it made access to the lake really difficult and I am sure that had a bad effect on the o2 levels in the lake.

hopefully it didnt winter kill but I personally havent fished so I am not sure. they are some nice pike in there and a ton of little pearch

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have been on cochrane (ten miles north) once before and once after the warm spell. Both times there was very little snow on the lake but maybe because of the tall grass surrounding fish lake it held more snow? Last year the aerator was running and we pulled some dandy perch out of this little lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

they did put the areator in about a month ago but it might have been a little too late. was there a few days after they put it in and never graphed a fish or had a bite. i can't confirm it winter killed though but the o2 level was very low when they put it in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I know the end of January there wasn't an aerator going and it was all snow covered. I don't think they could get the aerator out there because the snow in the south landing was like 4 feet deep.

The GFP manages this lake for perch and northerns because they can survive the best in low O2 levels.

I hope it doesn't get hurt to bad there were some nice perch in there. But it could use some thinning out of carp.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The lake is dead guys. I can personally and 100% confirm that. I was over there about a week ago and there were MANY fish dead under the ice. I could not tell what kinds, but they were of all shapes and sizes. The ice was pretty thick, so I could not exactly see what species. I have a friend who walked on the ice inside the "Thin Ice" signs and confirmed hundreds of dead perch. The aerator was certainly going, leaving a large open hole, but word around here is that it was a little too late. Too bad. A lot of locals are also mad because it was turned on too late. Not sure how a ball as big as that could be dropped.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Who would a guy call or write to get some answers on why the aerator was'nt put in on time. What a waste. There is very few lakes with decent size fish in them around here, I guess now there is one less. I am sure the people of South Dakota are glad their tax dollars are being used to aerate a dead lake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't believe the state of SD has anything to do with the aerator. It's the Duel county sportman's club. I also wonder why they didn't put it in January?

The state will restock this year. The northerns were getting to be good size too. Everyone the last couple years were complaining about all the people fishing the lake, so it was probably a good thing alot of fish were caught out of there the last two years now.

I'm sure a few fish will make it. The smaller perch can do better in low O2.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hmm ... thought i heard the GFP managed it. Well if it was locals I guess they are the ones that will be hurt the most by the lake dieing off. How long would it take for a pike to grow to 10 lbs, 10 years? And perch to be "eaters"?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would say a couple years and the perch will be good size again. Last couple years they were 10 to 14 inches long with smaller ones.

There are very few lakes in SD that have aerators, but most of the lakes in Duel do have aerators going. The GFP will restock the lake this spring and summer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talked to someone today that fishes the lake quite often, he said 5 years ago it froze out. Last year we pulled alot of 14 inch perch out of Fish. So I guess they must grow pretty fast.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Nah....walleyes would be hard-line Republicans;  conservative with little or no imagination, terrified of doing something new or different or pushing ahead with anything not tried before. Show me a 6-pound walleye and I'll show you Barry Goldwater with scales  or Ronald Reagan when he was not napping. PF is right, catching a walleye,  even a nice big fat one, is about as exciting as a naked tussle with Rosie O'Donnell or dragging a bag of seaweed into your boat. We used to catch some really big ones in MT and after a bit we learned that the big perch fought better and were way more tasty!  No kidding, those perch....12-15" were way better eating.  But then we were catching them from cold clear water. But if you are really new to fishing and don't possess a lot of skill by all means become a walleye fisherman-anybody can do it.
    • Well it's "Throw Down" time! For years I have kept a bag of sunflower seeds in the cup holder of my SUV to nibble on as I ride along. In the last few weeks since about the last weekend up north Deer hunting I would come in and think, man I really down some seeds, that was a pretty new bag? Then checking my oil one day noticed some empties under the hood!  Um, someone's having a party? Went to pick up my Deer at the butcher today and again found the new bag almost empty! Checked back seat floor and found a few sprinkles on the floor! That's it, don't mind the little guy along for a ride but don't touch my seeds! Thought about setting up the trail cam to plan some strategy, but just went with the blind two trap set front and back seat floor. Report when I get some results!
    • Read it again grasshopper, I never said any such thing.     Pence LOST jobs, Johnson gained jobs and the money didn't come out of revenue that was already being produced. Johnson's money came out of NEW tax revenue that would have never been earned if they didn't do the deal.   I don't know what that quote is you posted but I never said any of that.
    • Catching a walleye is about as exciting as reeling in a bath towel. Not sure how that justifies being an elitist. Bullheads put up a better fight.    I always considered walleyes to be the liberals of the fish world. 
    • When was the last time? 1835? That was the last time the national debt was paid off.     How would you know that? We've never taken a trillion dollars off the debt EVER.      
    • Lo, many years ago I tried something similar to deal with feral cats at a house that I was renting.   (next door neighbor fed them, and they would come in our garage or climb up under the hood of our cars.)   Covered a piece of cardboard with aluminum foil and wired it to one side of a 700 volt power transformer.  Other side was wired to a half open can of sardines insulated from the foil by a thin layer of plastic.   Primary went to line power.   No cat touched the sardines so long as the electricity was on (several days).   When I turned it off to see what would happen, they ate everything they could get out of the can in a short time.   I hope mice aren't as sensitive or smart. 
    • Pence is governor of Indiana.   Johnson was governor of New Mexico.   Why do you claim Johnson's deal was local, and Pence's was not?   Pence kept actual jobs, Johnson was chasing hypothetical jobs.   Pence benefited residents of his state.  Johnson benefited folks coming in from out of state...     
    • I would avoid one with a touch screen and stick with buttons.  You cannot work a touch screen with gloves on.  I guess it depends if you where gloves.  I have one of each and my Garmin with buttons is the one that gets used.
    • With any luck, we will get out of the debt issue with a period of moderate inflation, just like we did the last time.  5% inflation takes a trillion dollars a year off the debt.   Add 3-4 percent constant dollar growth, and in under a decade the ratio of debt to GDP is cut in half, even allowing for some deficits along the way.   Janet Yellen has already signaled she is willing and ready to let the economy run "hot", ie inflation exceeding the 2% target.     The trick, of course, is to pull it off without anything blowing up.     Now all that remains is to make it happen.  
    • which models of striker bibs/ coat?
  • Our Sponsors