Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Franchise

Portable heating question

16 posts in this topic

So I've upgraded to a 2 man portable ice shelter, and now I'm debating on heating units.

2 of my friends use sunflower heaters, one of which has burned his shelter twice, and I also plan on bringing my son out come next year, and I know sunflower heaters + enclosed space + kids = troouble.

I've decided to go with either a Buddy Heater or a Big Buddy, but with a 2 man shelter, does it make a big difference between the 2?

Thanks in advance for the replies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Always go bigger grin That way you will be prepaired for unexpected conditions. I have the big buddy and I love it the regular buddy looks rather small to me but I have never used one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been using the Big Buddy in my Otter Lodge and its worked great. I haven't had any of the issues others on the site have with it staying lit. I use an 11# tank with the quick-connect regulated hose.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you've narrowed it down to the Buddies, go with the Big Buddy, you can always turn it down, but you can't turn the Buddy up any higher than it will go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been using the Big Buddy in my Otter Lodge and its worked great. I haven't had any of the issues others on the site have with it staying lit. I use an 11# tank with the quick-connect regulated hose.

Yeah, I have read some negative feedback regarding that problem. The nice thing though is, even if you have to manually start it, its still seems a better option size wise and a safer alternative to a sunflower.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have the buddy heater and a 3 man portable and i have never ever been cold with it on... the majority of the time, i only keep it on low because it will get too hot...

i think you guys would be surprised the amount of heat a buddy heater kicks out.. especially when you are in a small portable (2-3 man)...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have the buddy heater and a 3 man portable and i have never ever been cold with it on... the majority of the time, i only keep it on low because it will get too hot...

i think you guys would be surprised the amount of heat a buddy heater kicks out.. especially when you are in a small portable (2-3 man)...

Well idk how cold it is when you fish,I used the little buddy in the yukon one day when it was -5,no way had to pack it up and go home. Now I got the big buddy and man I'm glad I got it. Was out fishing in the porty one day when it was REALLY cold last month,if I remember right -20,and I was sittin in a long sleeve!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had the same dilemma as you and I went with the big buddy. You can always turn it down if it's too hot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

friend had the buddy heater in his two man, was always cold.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I use both the big buddy and the regular buddy. I had the buddy first.I use it with my fish trap scout.It worked great in the scout, and my smaller two man the eskimo travler. I then bought the fish trap voyager, a dig two man or three man portable. I had to up grade to the big buddy to keep the voyager warm for mom and the kids. These heaters are both very safe. I have never burnt a hole in any of my portables with them. I can't say that with the sunflower heaters. As others have said before get the big buddy and trun it down when it get to hot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both, and Otter Cabin. The small one is good enough to heat it to waterever you need, for the most part.

The main thing I would say, if you pull shack with sled or atv, or just always use the car/truck to get out there, then get the big one with the gas line and filter with 20# tank.

But if you are going to pull by hand, the small one.

I also think the small one starts better, I like the pilot and ignitor separately and think it works better to start. But I like them both.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: jwmiller33
i have the buddy heater and a 3 man portable and i have never ever been cold with it on... the majority of the time, i only keep it on low because it will get too hot...

i think you guys would be surprised the amount of heat a buddy heater kicks out.. especially when you are in a small portable (2-3 man)...

Well idk how cold it is when you fish,I used the little buddy in the yukon one day when it was -5,no way had to pack it up and go home. Now I got the big buddy and man I'm glad I got it. Was out fishing in the porty one day when it was REALLY cold last month,if I remember right -20,and I was sittin in a long sleeve!

i have fished in very cold conditions this winter... went to mille lacs over Xmas break and it was 30 below with windchill during a whiteout storm and we had my little buddy heater heating our 3 man portable and it worked just fine... maybe my little buddy heater is just the sh*t. i have fished probably over 10 times this winter in below zero temps and have never been cold when i had the buddy heater on

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have them both, got great deals on them on CList so I couldnt resist getting each of them. If you shop around right now you can buy new ones for very good prices! For the extra couple bucks I would get the big one, personally I like to be warm and take my jacket off!!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Now that I want one, I cant find them. [YouNeedAuthorization], even the nearest Gander is out.

Might have to trek to Mankato to grab one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • any ideas on where or what to fish around there between oct 10 15?  
    • Gotta love rural America!
    • I don't think you need to do much scouting lol, that one in the picture is all you need to know however many people are getting giants on trailcam NOW, that they won't get come November. Are you bowhunting ? I'd assume maybe posting this in the archery forum and I'd assume my stand would be in appleville for now, one stand on each end, I'd try to figure the bedding area he or other nice bucks tend to use and then play the wind 100% of the time. Hunt weather changes types of days and if you have the chance I'd hunt as much as possible the 7 days before rifle opens, by then you should see ground scrapes in that area, I wouldn't hesitate to hunt 25 yards from the biggest freshest scrape you find come later October/first 4 days of November you could see him or another at high noon etc. 2 o'clock etc. they cruise daylight hours heavy then because they've already smelled or bred their first doe of the year and the woods are usually left quiet for rifle season so they travel like crazy.
    • I settled on the Muzzy 3 blade after going back and forth on all of the options.  I've been out tearing up my target with them the last several days and they've been shooting well for me.  I was a bit nervous the first day out with them as they were terrible groups and about 4-5 inches high and left.  I took a day of off shooting and came back and started shooting again and all of a sudden the groups where down to 3" and right on target.  Been shooting fine ever since.  I guess we all have our bad days. One of the big reasons I went with Muzzy is because I'm shooting a lighter draw weight so everything I've seen said to stick with fixed blades when shooting lower weights.  They've also been around forever and have stood the test of time.  Plus you can get a 6 pack + practice head for $37 at fleet farm so they are about $6/head versus $10-15 for alot of other brands.
    • Selfish lives matter, he's has the right to leave this country also, do it and see how things are in other countries. He needs a haircut really bad. Big tough guy Colon Kaepernick speaks we should all listen, I'd like to see how far a military man's boot could fit into that colon.
    • I've done some practice in a seated position as well and was shooting just fine so that is also an option.  I think i've got my bases covered to adapt to whatever the deer may throw at me.
    • Don't get it either fishuhalik, he's gonna burn quite a few dollars making that hiatus to go shoot up the local mallards, some honkers and maybe some shovelers,gadwalls, idk lol. Tomorrow morning I'm going to do in some honkers first, then hit the river woodies (solid bank type river easy walking) then put binocs on those mallards and if any appear green headed they're going to get it to and I'm riding a bicycle to my hunting spot(s). A mini ND run in a way lol. This is not the year in this area where you should feel the need to hunt outstate, but most still are going. Like last weekend, I guess I'll battle these swarms of ducks and geese, alone. Roosters in this east central mn area also it showed ->49 per square mile on the charts yet everyone bails for Morris, Marshall, or the Dakota's or Iowa. Must have money to burn but oh well thank you, I'll be on my bike for those soon enough also lol. Good luck everyone, heard if true the morning should be fairly cloudy burning off around noon kinda hope they're right, that sun can be nasty some mornings, next need a wasp/skeeter killing freeze ! 
    • I shot a lot of deer with the good old Bear Super Razorhead.  In 2008 when I finally bought a new bow, I bought carbon arrows for the first time and used Rocket Steelheads.  I've shot 12 to 15 deer since then with the Steelheads, both 100s and 125s.  All but one has been a pass through.  I think they are an amazing head.  The 125s are my favorite, but they quit making them.  I bought a bunch on hsolist so have probably a 10 year supply.  Not sure if I should buy more or finally move on to a new head when I run out.
    • Maybe, but the total kill and the kill of big bucks had been declining significantly before the tough winters hit.  Look at the kill stats from the early 2000s on.  Massive increase in doe harvest when bonus tags were allowed.  That, combined with wolf predation and winter drove the herd down extremely low.  IMVHO, you can't keep whacking the heck out of does when you have other very significant mortality factors at play. On a positive note, talking to one of the environmental staff this past June, he said they had been seeing more big bucks this year.  Hopefully one walks past me.   Good luck everyone!
    • Anyfish2 has good advice!
  • Our Sponsors