Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
chasineyes

Here's a Common Sense Thought

28 posts in this topic

When we have our normal, crappy winters, why don't they open up the snowmobile trails to four-wheelers. At least this way if people wanted to make a weekend out of riding, they still could. The ground and lakes are frozen thereby eliminating much of a footprint. Especially in the southern part of the state that seems to never have decent snow supply.

Thoughts??

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree and in fact I'd take it a step further and question why ATVs are not allowed on snowmobile trails anytime during the winter. ATVs don't damage a groomed trail any more than a snowmobile and probably less. Naturally, we would expect to be charged the trail fee as well.

I do understand how allowing ATVs on trails during the off season would be a problem as our tires will dig in and make ruts and this would certainly damage the trails.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys I do have a sled and 4x4 but would never think of riding on the sled trails in the winter. There is a 4x4 only trail open all year up by Outing. But "please" post this on the Snowmobile forum! grin I haven't seen any fireworks since the 4 th of July!!!!!!!! laugh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You have a point leech~~. It will certainly stir the pot. But I can personally attest to 4x4 ATVs NOT CAUSING DAMAGE to snowmobile trails when ridden responsibly. The trails that consist of steep grades are another issue as there isn't enough of a foot print to maintain sufficient traction with a "wheeled" machine.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Many of the snowmobile trails cross private property. The landowners do not want atvs on their property due to the possibility of damage. I ain't gonna get into that argument. A lot of the snowmobile clubs have a lease arrangement with the landowners that excludes atvs but allow snowmobiles. I don't think we will see that change much. Several of the DNR trails are open to both snowmobiles and atvs. Look at the DNR HSOforum to find them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

LEP, where 4x4's cause trail damage the most is when it starts to get a little warmer out like right now and they start to dig in. Anyone that has driven one out on a lake or followed a 4x4 trail out on a lake can see how that happens. They just do not stay on top of the snow like a sled can. Plus sledders are paying twice right now for the trails. Lic, & Trail tab!! frown Once they get eoungh 4x4 trails established you can say good by to riding in the ditchs, and hellow to trail tabs!! mad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

leech~, I fully understand when and where ATVs are causing damage and yes, the temps above freezing like they have been are a perfect exaample of WHEN an ATV should not be allowed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I say this is a bad idea. ATVs should not be allowed on snowmobile trails due to rutting, and slow moving vechicals, but mostly rutting up the trail. And if it does get above freezing you would have people out mudding, etc...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I say this is a bad idea. ATVs should not be allowed on snowmobile trails due to rutting, and slow moving vechicals, but mostly rutting up the trail. And if it does get above freezing you would have people out mudding, etc...

Rutting up a trial...have you ever seen the machoeisim displayed by the guys on their 900's who like to see if they can spin their tracks up ever hill and at ever stop sign?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

idk what the trails are around your guys area but i wouldnt ride them down here even if i could, all trails around here go right across the plowed fields,a little rough for my liking

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To slow!! LOL speed limits on trails is 50mph. I know my wheeler will do 70. Just to many other reasons that I dont understand?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

atv's wreck the groomed trails lets be honest about it,this is why areas of wisconsin have cut back on atv's on snowmobile trails and other states don't allow it. i'm pro atv and am willing to try it, but i can forsee the problems it will cause between snowmobile groups and private landowners. when the snow melts you don't even know a snowmobile was even there, not so sure you can say that with an atv with mudzillas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I own both and ride both and would be against riding atv's on snowmobile trails for all the reasons above and then some. As an ATV rider in the winter, yes it does suck to not have much to ride on - probably the biggest reason I picked up a sled this year after many years without one. As far as an ATV NOT being slower than a sled.... c'mon, anyone who's ridden both know's the answer to that question. On a straightaway with no bumps and perfectly groomed with a 50mph limit, I can see an arguement (maybe), but in practicality, there's no comparison.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Being both and ATV and snowmobile rider I am against atv's on designated sled trails.

For someone to even say atv's do not rut up sled trails is being dishonest. Not only do the ruts make for and unpleasant ride getting a ski into a rut can be very dangerous. Case in point: The snowmobile clubs that groom the trail from the south end of LOTW to the NWA have said if non tracked vehicles continue to use the trail they will move it more to the west thus moving it away from the fishing areas around garden island etc. This trail is currently used buy fisherman etc. and the clubs have no problem with that but are tied of working so hard to groom the trail to have it all rutted up by atv's and wheel houses.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: MNexpoler
I say this is a bad idea. ATVs should not be allowed on snowmobile trails due to rutting, and slow moving vechicals, but mostly rutting up the trail. And if it does get above freezing you would have people out mudding, etc...

Rutting up a trial...have you ever seen the machoeisim displayed by the guys on their 900's who like to see if they can spin their tracks up ever hill and at ever stop sign?

I have never seen a snowmobile make a rut on a packed snowmobile trial. I have seen atvs and wheeled vechicals make ruts on packed snowmobile trail many times.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To slow!! LOL speed limits on trails is 50mph. I know my wheeler will do 70. Just to many other reasons that I dont understand?

I am sure your wheeler wont to 70 miles per hour on snow. I have a sportsman 700, no way will it hit top speed on packed snow. And the speed limit being 50mph, alot of snowmobilers go over that speed, I know I've gone over 100mph before. If the trail was filled with atvs it would just clog up the trail for the snowmobilers. If you want to ride it the winter then buy a snowmobile there 100 times funner than a ATV in the snow, period.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

fishorgolf, I was up on that trail to Garden island 2 weeks ago and from what I could see some of the trail damage comes from the resort bombers and pulling their skid houses out to the reefs! And yes I do believe there are some 4 wheelers and even a truck once in a while screwing them up! Kind of sad! frown

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm glad you picked a non-controversial topic. This thread should die off quickly. :-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you want to ride it the winter then buy a snowmobile there 100 times funner than a ATV in the snow, period.

Maybe in your opinion, but a snowmobile is about as boring as it gets for me. Riding a groomed trail, I might as well just drive on the road with my wheeler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you don't want to drive a sled on a groomed trail, why on earth would you want to drive a wheeler on one? Just curious.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't even approve of the sleds going through my yard, the studs rip up my tar,let alone a atv in the easement, the [PoorWordUsage] sleders run when theres hardly any snow and the atvs would rip the shix out the soft portion, I ride on the groomed trail at my place only for about 1 mile, and if they don't like it, they can reroute the [PoorWordUsage] thing off the private property,,,lol

To the topic though, no atvs on trails I agree**** unless it's private property and land owner does it himself<<<< >>> thats ME.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

But "please" post this on the Snowmobile forum! grin I haven't seen any fireworks since the 4 th of July!!!!!!!! laugh

Pretty please! laughlaughlaugh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i dont think this is all that bad of a idea, but everyone knows someones going to out there and wreck it for everybody and i dont disagree with them for not allowing them to ride on the trials even though it would be fun just for that reason? anyone agree?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    •     I believe you said it was "libertarian" drivel, actually, so you dismissed it out of hand...          
    •   You posted about neither.     But if you would read the article, my commentary and TJ's commentary you would know that's not really what the article is about.     You have to be kidding, right? Just about everyone who has an opinion on politics at all is this sort of person. Do you look at social media at all?
    •     Ok, now getting back to whether Trump will win the War on Drugs, do you think he will take any steps at all to decriminalize drugs, such as reclassifying marijuana, and recognizing state laws and programs designed to move towards the decriminalization of drugs?   Or do you think he will take steps to protect vested interests, such as prisons and the pharmaceutical. industry?   Just going off his rhetoric and his choice for a drug czar, I'm guessing he much prefers the latter, and will end up spending a bunch of taxpayer's money, and actually lose ground by continuing on with the brute force/criminalization approach.        
    • Because at the time, I don't have anything better to do.   I posted about the article, and you wanted to talk about the topic.  I posted about the topic and you want to discuss the article.    Which is it?     I support a particular candidate because their positions, taken as a whole, are preferable to me as compared to the other candidate(s).   In a few years I get to do it over.     I don't think there are really that many ardent "rah rah for my party" type folks out there, in spite of what we see on TV, or the occasional people we meet.     So the article is basically drivel, as I said before, based on a false premise.   
    • Borch I just signed up Ryan, Morgan, and me but I only see my name listed in the summary. Do my kids not show up because they don't have hso usernames?  Or did I not enter it right?     Please let me know how to fix it and I'll do so.  Thanks!
    •   Because I think self reflection is good for all of us from time to time.   If you don't wan't to discuss this article, why do you persist in posting here?           No one is disputing that at all. The premise of the author's article is in regards to the hypocrisy of then justifying everything your chosen candidate or party does blindly while vilifying the other candidates or party. It's the "all in" sports like mentality that is being discussed here.  
    • There is a really excellent book called "The Righteous Mind" that approaches this tribalist mindset from an evolutionary psychology standpoint. The author, Jonathan Haidt, does a remarkable job of unpacking why people persist in truly irrational defense of the indefensible - when it's their team doing the stupid stuff. I highly highly highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in lessening the hyperpartisan idiocy we have today.

      The trouble is that the closed-off mindset that lends itself to reflexive support for Obama/Hillary/Trump/whomever also tends to preclude any serious engagement in self-examination that the book is designed to provoke. Really good read, though.
    •   I get what your saying here but I think what Dave is talking about is the willingness of some to blindly follow, without question, their party or candidate. I saw this first hand during the primary with some of my own relatives, for example. I had a SIL who was a huge Bernie backer. The things she said about Hillary were worse than anything said here. As far as she was concerned, Hillary should be tarred and feathered and ran out on a rail. Then Bernie loses the nomination. She then became Hillary's biggest defender. Everything she said about her during the primary was instantly washed away. Even her own husband called her out. She wasn't simply voting for her because she found Trump worse. That's understandable. She defended or at least tried to deflect the issues with Hillary when just a few months prior, she said things that would make even Cooter or Bill say, "man you're harsh on her."   I don't think this is a new phenomenon. I also don't think it's widespread. Like everything else, access to more and diverse information just makes it possible to hear more about it than before. I think human nature causes people to internalize candidates and/.or elected officials. It's a "if you're critical of my candidate, you're critical of me," kind of thinking.   I don't fault anyone for voting for a candidate that one feels best represents their line of thinking. Or even defending their candidate from detractors. I don't think that is what Dave is talking about here. It's also the flipping of political opinions just because the candidate you voted for or support is supporting certain positions. For example, many conservatives opposed BHO's stimulus, including myself. It didn't work  as promised and we just added more on to the debt. So on the campaign trail, Trump also spoke of a stimulus plan that was even more expensive than BHO's and  those same people not only supported it but are justifying it. In summary, one can vote for a candidate without defending everything that person does        
    •  Come on.   The world, life is a bit more complicated then that.          Quit passing the blame. Your whole thesis is on choice and owning it.   Let me guess, you hate big banking also since they made it easy to refinance and purchase.   It just proves that general society is incapable of making the right decisions as a whole.   Sorry, you go down with the ship.    
  • Our Sponsors