Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you Sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Jameson

angler and spearer using same hole--not legal?

31 posts in this topic

Is it legal for one person who only has a fishing license, no spear license, to fish out of a spearers hole while that second person is spearing?

A CO in my area was asked this question, and said it was indeed ILLEGAL. Anyone have any first hand experience with a CO checking them while doing this?

Personally I think that as long as not more than one limit of pike are speared, it all should be good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Illegal. Can't angle and spear out of the same hole, at the same time. That's all there is to it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Illegal. Can't angle and spear out of the same hole, at the same time. That's all there is to it.

I don't know if that is true.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is it legal for one person who only has a fishing license, no spear license, to fish out of a spearers hole while that second person is spearing?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can angle out of the same hole, as long as your spearing decoy doesnt have a hook on it!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you have already asked the CO I would advise you to print that page out and take it with you. It MIGHT(?) save you a free ride in a police car. lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IS IT PERMISSIBLE TO JIG OR USE A SPOON IN THE SAME HOLE USED FOR SPEARING?

Yes. A person may angle and spear at the same time, and may angle and spear in the same hole.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IS IT PERMISSIBLE TO HAVE MORE THAN ONE SPEAR OR ONE ANGLING LINE IN THE HOUSE AT THE SAME TIME?

Each person may use one angling line while spearing. If two people are in a house and only one of them is spearing, the person spearing may use one angling line, and the person not spearing may use two angling lines. It is also permissible to have additional spears and angling equipment in possession in the house provided such equipment is not in use.

It was said that the second person angling could not use the same hole (the spearhole) to angle. So yes, they could both be in the same house, but the angler would have to have their own hole(s).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It was said that the second person angling could not use the same hole (the spearhole) to angle. So yes, they could both be in the same house, but the angler would have to have their own hole(s).

That is really spliting hairs.

It does not specificaly state that 2 people can fish and spear from the same hole. It does not specifically state that 2 people can't fish and spear from the same hole.

I am not sure how a judge would rule on that one.

You make the call.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally Posted By: mndnrwebsite

IS IT PERMISSIBLE TO HAVE MORE THAN ONE SPEAR OR ONE ANGLING LINE IN THE HOUSE AT THE SAME TIME?

Each person may use one angling line while spearing. If two people are in a house and only one of them is spearing, the person spearing may use one angling line, and the person not spearing may use two angling lines. It is also permissible to have additional spears and angling equipment in possession in the house provided such equipment is not in use.

It was said that the second person angling could not use the same hole (the spearhole) to angle. So yes, they could both be in the same house, but the angler would have to have their own hole(s).

Where did you get this information from? As far as I know the law only states that laws of 2 lines per angler, not per hole. Your spear counts as a line.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Little background on why I asked about this here. A friend and I both got into spearing now two seasons ago. We worried about bringing newbies out to give them a glimpse of the spearing world if they weren't licensed as a spearer. My assumption was it was O.K. just to have an angler angle out of a spearers hole, as long as at the end of the day only one limit of pike was speared. My friend disagreed, saying with no "party" spearing it would be considered helping the spearer by having extra baits in the water. He fired off an e-mail to the DNR, and received a response stating they weren't sure. Next time he ran into a CO, he asked as the CO. The CO's response was that an angler could NOT angle out of the spear hole at the same time as the person spearing it.

Anyone have any first hand experience with a CO over this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...Your spear counts as a line.

Man I wish that was true. Could have speared many bass this winter. If my spear was counted as just a line I would have even tried to set up in some walleye spots.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

so if its not right to angle our of the spear hole, then why did they make it legal for a spear to be able to use two lines in the same hole?

I have talked to a CO about it, and they say as long as there is not a HOOK on the spearing string, you can have another line down the spear hole!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...then why did they make it legal for a spear to be able to use two lines in the same hole?...

Are we really limited to two lines? uh-oh. I've never read that. Where does it say that? Doesn't the regs state that a person spearing is allowed one angling line? I can have 5, 6 decoys down( all with no hooks )the hole can't I?

The one time I was checked by a CO this winter I had three wooden decoys down and one sucker on a hook. Maybe he was just having a good day.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i'm out of state so i can't spear but i have been with my in-laws angling while they were spearing. we were checked once and they CO didn't mention anything about it being wrong.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i think u got it BNS as long as your friend is licenced i dont see a reason y they cant fish in your spear hole.

you can angle and spear out of the same hole at the same time if there is one person in the house. providing you have a spear and only one line in the house your legal, at least that is my take on the reg book.

so i dont see a reason why a second party cant fish in the same hole you are spearing out of. the caption out of the reg book doesnt accually say that the second person needs to have their own hole(s) right?

from the 2008 reg book: pg 55

"A person may take fish by angling in a dark house if only one angling line is in use and any fish caught is immediately released or placed on the ice."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

how could you even spear with 5 decoys down there? Id be scared of hitting mine!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

how could you even spear with 5 decoys down there? Id be scared of hitting mine!

Great point!

Jameson, i sent email information to the DNR. once i recieve it, i will post it here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One angling line can be used by someone spearing. No party spearing allowed. So if someone is spearing over two angling lines is that not considered party-spearing?

No that is not party spearing

An example of party spearing would be if you filled your limit of pike then started filling another licenced spearers limit of pike.

Much like party hunting for deer. With deer hunting you are allowed to fill multiple licences for other licenced hunters in your party.

With spearing you can only spear your own limit of fish.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i have never speared with 5 decoys but my buddy has a 8x8 portable with a 4x8 hole and we put 4 down in that house no problem.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is the most confusing thread to read. We have had many CO to our MN Darkhouse Assoc. meetings to confirm this. The law was changed this past year to allow spearing and angling from the same hole. The spear counts as 1 or your 2 lines. When I say lines I mean ones with hooks (not sure if you were being sarcastic about the decoy lines?). Party spearing refers to spearing all or part of another person's limit. As far as I know you can have as many people as you want spear and angle out of a single hole as long as everyone has the proper licenses. If your CO told you different I would have him call his supervisor and get it straightened out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • Nelson has been down in recent years in terms of Walleye fishing. Depends on what kind of water you like to fish. The flowage and Moose Lake are good if you like fishing really dark water. Grindstone and Lac Courte Oreilles, maybe even Round are also good walleye lakes, but those lakes have very clear water and will fish completely different than the dark water river impoundments in the area.
    • I think it would be an offensive and experience(post season) up grade. I all reality, we dont have the means to make the trade.  We are nearly out of money(cap space) and only have 11 players.  We need food cheap role players right now.   Only way would be to package Wiggins with future draft picks.  If the analysts are actually correct on how improved we will be, those draft pick wont carry a ton of value.
    •   Well not as many as up by the Emily-Outing area but a few.
    • Still on the fence between going with the cabin or lodge, my dad has a normal lodge and it has tons of room which is great but it also is somewhat heavy for 1 guy to load and pull it seems. I mostly fish with just 1 other person and maby 25% of the time by myself so that was why I was leaning to the cabin which also seemed to have plenty of room for 2 it seemed to me. Also from what I understand the cabin will fit in chevy crew cab box and the lodge won't? I have a 04 crew cab short box so one more incentive for the cabin if thats true.
    • Sounds perfect, thinking your guys reviews will seal the deal for me once I can see one in person again, a hyfax kit will also be on my list as I plan on pulling it behind my sportsman 570. Thanks for the review also AAmerican, it's early to be thinking ice fishing but I'm sure there's people out there like us that are a little anxious!
    • The Chippewa flowage would be a great place to start. I will be honest. Walleye are not what I have ever chosen to Target when I fish up there but the flowage is a great fishery.    Nelson lake would be another choice.
    • I have had 3 of the otter pro xt's, a cabin, lodge and resort. I still have the resort and recently purchased the cabin. I have not had many different brand portables but have fished in other brands buddies have. They are the nicest portables I have personally owned and until I try something I like more I wouldn't change from them at all. The resort is heavy and not something I like dragging far by hand especially loaded with gear and much snow on the lakes. But it has tons of room and I have fished 4 people in it before, a little tight but doable. The cabin I purchased for more hand pulling and an extra for if I have people along. They are very warm and I have fished in them down to -30 deg F. A regular buddy heater keeps them plenty warm, if it isn't to cold or the house is banked well its easily t-shirt weather inside. The resort needs a big buddy heater for colder days sometimes due to the larger size but isn't terrible with a regular. Overall very happy with them all and have been very durable. Also no dripping of water from the ceiling. Highly recommend a set of hyfax for the bottom. I had over 1000 miles pulling my old lodge and they hyfax held up great but I always pulled on snow and not across asphalt much at all.   Changes I have made to them: - added a battery box and inside LEDs  - used stainless screws on the band that hods the fabric to the tub only because I don't like the look of the rusted screws.     If you think you'll be purchasing one I would recommend stopping at a Gander Mountain if you have one near by and getting a set of hyfax since they are going out of business there is a good amount of ice gear. I found hyfax recently there for $15 a set.
    • We are on Lake Edward at WildWoods RV resort just north of Merrifield, MN. It is nice just driving up, unlocking it, playing for the weekend and locker her back up and leaving the frig on.  They let Atheists and Jesus freaks all in!
    •   My wife and I are starting to think about parking ours someplace. I'm tired of trying to get reservations and having to hook and unhook and all that goes with a weekend of camping. Plus I would like to have the toys available like 4-wheeler and boat.   We are looking at places up north. We know several people and like the Emily-Outing-Remer-Hill City area. I think you a further west, right? Brainerd area maybe?  
  • Our Sponsors