Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
The Grebe

Question...how does this work?

16 posts in this topic

I was just thinking about something....The big ice chunk that busted off Lake erie at Oak Harbor and stranded all those fishermen....what happens to their gear? I suppose small gear could be retrieved with a boat, motor out, hop on the ice and get your stuff.

But what if there was a vehicle out there, or atv's, would they be responsible getting them off the floe? Other then an air lift, how would they do it? Wait and see if it butted up with solid shore ice somewhere, build a quick bridge and drive em off?

If the floe busted up way out in the lake and a persons vehicle went down, would they still have to retrieve it like they do on any other lake?

I don't know right off hand how deep Erie is, but I suppose it has some pretty deep areas, how would that work?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

good thought. my first thought would be that I'm the only thing that can't be replaced out there, the rest can easily be replaced, get my rear end off of there as soon as possible.

but you're right, what about the wheelers and equipment that's out there? I'm sure they're watching it to see what happens, and I'm sure they'll be able to retrieve most of it. they were planking out there, so I don't know how many wheelers are out there. did anyone see the interview with the Sheriff, he said "there's no law against stupidity, otherwise all those fishermen would be in jail". he seemed like a pretty big [PoorWordUsage]!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As far as a wheeler or a vehicle being out there I don't think it would have been possible since they had to jump over a 3 foot crack that was already there when they went out.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The pics on the news had wheelers on it so they got them out there somehow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

good thought. my first thought would be that I'm the only thing that can't be replaced out there, the rest can easily be replaced, get my rear end off of there as soon as possible.

but you're right, what about the wheelers and equipment that's out there? I'm sure they're watching it to see what happens, and I'm sure they'll be able to retrieve most of it. they were planking out there, so I don't know how many wheelers are out there. did anyone see the interview with the Sheriff, he said "there's no law against stupidity, otherwise all those fishermen would be in jail". he seemed like a pretty big [PoorWordUsage]!!

From what I understand, they had to build some type of bridge to cross some open water to get on this ice floe. I guess I have to agree with this sheriff. There were helicopters, boats vehicles and about 70 people that risked their lives to help a bunch of people that should not have been where they were. This has been going on for years and gets to be a very expensive operation when these fisherman are rescued. I'll bet that these people would quit doing this if they received a bill for the cost of their rescue. Maybe there needs to be a policy that says "The first time is free, after that you pay.". I have never been in a situation like that and in my opinion it is because I have used my brain and chose to be safe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From what I understand this was a big chunk of ice that broke off so you could liken this to crossing an ice bridge on Mile Lacs the only difference being there is that much more water for the flow to move around in. Not mitigating the circumstance of the rescue and all but perhaps the fisherman did not know what they were getting into or onto just a thought. As far as getting equipment off perhaps a barge or helicopter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They had to cross a 1ft crack. Who would have thought that crack went all the way from one end to the other. They could have easily drove machines over the piece of plywood that bridged the crack. This was a huge piece. Somewhere I heard 8 miles across. After all was said and done the chunk ended up 1000 yds out. Maybe the wind will shift and it will come back towards shore.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thats what emergency personnel are for. They were all on the clock, IMO there must have been a Coffee break interupted or something. I understand it was a stressful morning for most of them, but lets have a little professionalism (regarding the sherrifs comments)and take into consideration that one of the fisherman did die. I am sure that if this was known to happen no one would have been there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would guess that the wind would blow it in or out more until it hit somthing and then they would have to set up some tupe of mission to get there wheelers back.

Sifty

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That sheriff really seemed like the wrong spokesperson. As far as I am concerned that is there job and to be that ticked off for having to work... well all I can say is quit your whining.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As for retrieving the equipment I'm sure they will use a barge with a crane or something like that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that the sheriff's comments were not appropriate. The article I read did say that some people got off the ice on wheelers through a spot that had not separated off yet. One person interviewed said he was hoping the wind blew the ice back so he could retrieve his belongings. People in the great lakes area should know the risk they are taking by being out in strong winds. It doesn't take much to form a current on that big water and when it forms weak spots in ice can separate like it did and float away. It has happened in the past so I would think most people would have more common sense. They are just some fish, not worth risking your life over. On a side note, I watched a show where some guys went out on Superior to fish trout. They brought all of their stuff out in a canoe or small boat in case the ice separated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am originally from Northwest Lower Michigan. It hasn't seemed to be an issue nearly as much as it use to, however for many years ice fishermen were stranded on ice flows in the Saginaw bay 2 to 3 times a year. Saginaw Bay is part of Lake Huron and is the large bay between the thumb and the mainland. The Coast Guard out of Tawas always plucked people off of the ice with helicopters free of charge. If memory serves, the coast gaurd started charging for this service about 8 years ago and it only included you and your clothing. All equipment was left on the ice.

After the ice melts, you are responsible for removing ATV's, snowmobiles, and or vehicles from the bottom of the lake. You can imagine this is a hefty cost. I don't know if this is fact, but I am pretty sure there is also a fine from the Michigan EPA too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They got all of their equipment off yesterday. Got out there with fan boats not exactly sure how they got the stuff off.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Posts

    • I'd like to see your definition of "elitist", by the way.

      Gary Johnson and the Libertarians are not Trump's problem.   He has the same problem as Hillary - himself.

    • Actually, you just chose not to.

    • I've had a Marcum camera for many years and have found it extremely educational.  When I take new anglers on the ice, they love watching the fish.  Never had the camera spook a fish.

       

      I used a Marcum battery-powered panner to rotate the camera, and that helps identify my lure.  However, you also have to be pretty confidant with the depth of your jig, so that it will show up on the camera.

       

      I've found the camera of limited value during the summer, because it's constantly moving up and down, and a little side to side.  Even if I can find my jig, it's not for long.  What I use the camera for during soft water season is to identify bottom structure and get a general idea what's down there.  

       

      During hard water season, I use it primarily to see bites before they happen.  Not only do I know exactly what's near or looking at my jig, but I can see when they're actually going after it.  I have pulled the hook away from fish that were obviously too small, and also been able to set the hook on a bite before I could feel it.

       

      I love my flasher, but I have out-fished buddies with my camera.

    • $750 this week only or it gets winterized

    • Yaggie takwes top honors this week beating our points leader by three points. Yaggie's team finished 1st, 6th, 7th, and 13th earning him 379 points for the week and his thrid weekly win of the year. 379 points is also yaggies top score of the year and the third highest score of all the teams for the year. Congrats on a great week Yaggie!

      yaggie   379
      Fishin-Novice   376
      BlackLundPro   334
      Huckfin   329
      gregg52   309
      88fan   304
      fishing star   297
      Rip_Some_Lip   297
      SwivelDigger   292
      musky999   269
      juneau4   263
      mnwildman   263
      Jar Jar   261
      jwhjr   259
      cat-man   235
      Airjer   234
      Moose   149

       

      Total Points

      1     Fishin-Novice   7,929
      2     musky999   7,921
      3     gregg52   7,910
      4     Rip_Some_Lip   7,748
      5     jwhjr   7,698
      6     yaggie   7,575
      7     mnwildman   7,569
      8     88fan   7,504
      9     Huckfin   7,447
      10     Jar Jar   7,357
      11     BlackLundPro   7,348
      12     fishing star   7,341
      13     Airjer   7,298
      14     SwivelDigger   7,267
      15     cat-man   7,231
      16     juneau4   7,188
      17     Moose   6,622


  • Posts

    • I'd like to see your definition of "elitist", by the way. Gary Johnson and the Libertarians are not Trump's problem.   He has the same problem as Hillary - himself.
    • Actually, you just chose not to.
    • I've had a Marcum camera for many years and have found it extremely educational.  When I take new anglers on the ice, they love watching the fish.  Never had the camera spook a fish.   I used a Marcum battery-powered panner to rotate the camera, and that helps identify my lure.  However, you also have to be pretty confidant with the depth of your jig, so that it will show up on the camera.   I've found the camera of limited value during the summer, because it's constantly moving up and down, and a little side to side.  Even if I can find my jig, it's not for long.  What I use the camera for during soft water season is to identify bottom structure and get a general idea what's down there.     During hard water season, I use it primarily to see bites before they happen.  Not only do I know exactly what's near or looking at my jig, but I can see when they're actually going after it.  I have pulled the hook away from fish that were obviously too small, and also been able to set the hook on a bite before I could feel it.   I love my flasher, but I have out-fished buddies with my camera.
    • $750 this week only or it gets winterized
    • Yaggie takwes top honors this week beating our points leader by three points. Yaggie's team finished 1st, 6th, 7th, and 13th earning him 379 points for the week and his thrid weekly win of the year. 379 points is also yaggies top score of the year and the third highest score of all the teams for the year. Congrats on a great week Yaggie! yaggie   379 Fishin-Novice   376 BlackLundPro   334 Huckfin   329 gregg52   309 88fan   304 fishing star   297 Rip_Some_Lip   297 SwivelDigger   292 musky999   269 juneau4   263 mnwildman   263 Jar Jar   261 jwhjr   259 cat-man   235 Airjer   234 Moose   149   Total Points 1     Fishin-Novice   7,929 2     musky999   7,921 3     gregg52   7,910 4     Rip_Some_Lip   7,748 5     jwhjr   7,698 6     yaggie   7,575 7     mnwildman   7,569 8     88fan   7,504 9     Huckfin   7,447 10     Jar Jar   7,357 11     BlackLundPro   7,348 12     fishing star   7,341 13     Airjer   7,298 14     SwivelDigger   7,267 15     cat-man   7,231 16     juneau4   7,188 17     Moose   6,622
    • Got my Helix 5. Now just need to get my sled out of storage and figure out where to mount it.
    • Now that's funny.  I chose not to answer a ignorant question that an elitist like yourself could care less the answer to.  The only reason you want an answer to that question is to spend the next week trying to find some ignorant reason he/she is a bad choice. #rentfree
    • But you couldn't articulate who your favorite Trump picks for justices were, or why.
    • Many of the resorts / cabins where I stay on weekend fishing outings do not have a fish cleaning house. I also do not like the smell of dead fish from the cleaning process in my home. My wheel house is a fishing shack only, non-sleeper, which I take off the ice each night. It has both A/C and propane heat so I usually plug it into an AC outlet at night.   I decided to build a retractable / drop-down fish cleaning table 17” x 48” up and out of the way while on the ice and a warm place to clean fish. I use clear news print between the my fish cleaning board and the table to eliminate the need to wash the table every time I use it. Functionally works well, still needs some finish touches, paint, stain, rust treatment. I can also see many uses for this table while on the Ice. Fish Cleaning Table.mp4
  • Our Sponsors