Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
MoCarp

how to Ice Carp

22 posts in this topic

make sure carp in the water you're fishing...

Spread out over an area in 5-8' deep with some (but not too many) weeds, preferably near where a creek enters. mimic areas like where you'd find pike at ice-out.

cut holes by making a "triangle" of sorts by drilling 3 holes was using a large auger, (you might need a bigger hole)

then chip out the center with a spud. Make sure the bottom is chipped out and smooth on all sides

Chum each hole with ground up bread. toasted but still white is best for chum but untoasted for hook baits

There are other baits that work in winter, but I find bread to be the best, probably due to it's starch content.

dip it in condensed milk soaked sweet corn.....stuff rocks!

best Use NO weight (especially in any weed), long mono leader, and just a #6 hook. Form untoasted wonder bread (about 1/3rd slice, newer and "doughier", the better) around the hook so it's firm enough to stay, but soft enough to allow a hook to set through.

on a tip up Set the flag REAL EASY to trip. The slightest tension will cause the fish to drop the bait...

used several set ups and rods/gear all can work

Once found, the fish should take. The question is finding them.

They DO fight great through the ice, BTW, small ones under 5 pounds are great eating out of cold water

one big one we couldn't get through the hole!

tipup.jpg

riggs.jpg

icecarp2.jpg

landing.jpg

carpice.jpg

icemirror.jpg

nice10.jpg

note... added a nice thick bunch of twisted copped wire onto the flag shaft on a tipup in a D shape and put the T on

it reduced amount of energy needed to trip it by over 75% it took about 8 oz to trip before and now it only takes about 1 ounce to trip

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is one of the coolest things I have seen all year!!! That one looks like a Mirror Carp with the scales that way. And the picture of the carp in the hole is one of the neatest pictures I have seen this season.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, the scales through the hole is a great picture.

And you are probably one of the very few people who can say that they've caught a mirror carp through the ice. That's really, really cool.

Thanks for the post... it gives me hope that I might someday ice one myself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There have been many questions regarding carp through ice. This is a great post. Thanks for the information. I am definately going to try this. I hope that others do as well and we can add to the wealth of information already presented here. Awesome work guys.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

lol i find it funny that theres pics of you guys using tip ups and ice rods then all of a sudden theres one of you having a 6' medium heavy rod on the ice lol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice job man. right on. I too like that pic of the scales through the hole. Must have felt pretty cool to crack the code.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yea great job. I've been trying to get some on ice but cant seem to get it right. I've tried local ponds that hold fish but discovered the deepest water i could find was maybe 5 ft this pond is small 5 acres at most but tons of carp in the open water. Where do these fish go no way in or out that I can see. Well theres a grate on one end dont think fish could fit through though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

that picture with the tip up (with the wire) is mine from last year! that is not ur idea its mine!

i posted it on CAG (carp anglers group last year) even look on my photo bucket page. i added it last year! it was cristmas day. and i went down on lake winona by my grandmas apartment.

and none of those people are u. they are all pictures from the CAG HSOforum

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, the scales through the hole is a great picture.

And you are probably one of the very few people who can say that they've caught a mirror carp through the ice. That's really, really cool.

Thanks for the post... it gives me hope that I might someday ice one myself.

thats not him. thats scott osmond.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I read that on the Carp Angler's Group too. That's an old post from 2005.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I went over there and checked it out. Applause to carpmanjake and your efforts. Absolutely give credit where credit is due.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is possible that this person posted these pictures on that HSOforum as well, and now has found FM to post on?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, the guy says use wonder bread - but if you look in one of the photos there is clearly a can of corn sitting on the ice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Busted. smile I accidentally snagged a carp this winter fishing for panfish and it put up a great fight. I got its head to the top of the hole but wasn't sure how to pull it out. Any tips? I tried getting my thumb in its mouth but couldn't get a good grip. I didn't want to gaff it and soon it wiggled off my hook.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice job carpmanjake!!

I thought something was weird with that post when I first read it. I think it was the fact that his avatar says he is from Texas, only ice I know of in Texas is in a vodka/tonic, and I doubt you will find any carp under that ice!!LOL Not to mention it is his only post.

Again Great job on calling him out on this Jake!!! Care to enlighten us on how YOU got into those carp through the ice?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hooked into two a couple weeks ago on a jig and waxie while panfishin. They were cruising 6-7 ft down in 13 ft of water. Went back the next day properly geared but no luck.

022609_163701.jpg

31"

022609_161400.jpg

022609_161500.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It is possible that this person posted these pictures on that HSOforum as well, and now has found FM to post on?

no. scott osmond lives in massachusets. and scott wouldnt be caught dead posting pictures on any site other than CAG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice job carpmanjake!!

I thought something was weird with that post when I first read it. I think it was the fact that his avatar says he is from Texas, only ice I know of in Texas is in a vodka/tonic, and I doubt you will find any carp under that ice!!LOL Not to mention it is his only post.

Again Great job on calling him out on this Jake!!! Care to enlighten us on how YOU got into those carp through the ice?

those arent my carp. i have yet to land 1 through a hole while fishing them on purpose. i was pounding a small jigging spoon packed with waxworms on a soft bottom for jumbo perch when i caught my carp through the ice.

but he is right on one thing. bread is the best producer of winter carp. i have only got the chance to go ice fishing for carp twice. i did hook up with a good fish that wouldnt fit through the 8 inch hole (i thought that was all i would need because winona doesnt have very many big carp)

that was on corn with carp juice in glow bait flavor in it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Still nice fish. Someday I hope to get one through the ice, On purpose or on accident doesn't matter to me!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Popular Now

  • Posts

    • 1 hour ago, blue_healer_guy said:

      leech, it does sound like an odd concocktion.  but you gotta try it.  225 for 2 hrs, helps if u use thin bacon.

      Man, I can see cream cheese but peanut butter? I may have to give it a go sometime, maybe the bacon will off set the oddness? :eek:  :)

      Edited by leech~~
    • Sorry I missed that. The brown and blue wires are the Transmit TX and Receive Rx wires for connection via single cable to NMEA 0183 compatible devices. nmea 0183 is the protocol for compatible devices, computer, plotters, auto piolet, Radar, radio, etc. All of these devices including your GPS can be connected to a single cable. The brown and blue wires allows the sonar to communicate to other devices. Google nmea 0183 compatible devices for a raft of information on what this is.

      My brother, a charter Capitan out of Cortez FL. uses these devices on his boat for off shore fishing up to 100 miles off shore. Nice to have to talk to other Capitan's ship to shore, radar, GPS and  to get back home without running into sunken islands.

       

    • Trump stumped on terrorist quiz as he can't identify the leaders of ISIS and al-Qaeda – but Carly Fiorina shows she knows her Nasrallah from her al-Julani

      • Radio host Hugh Hewitt asked Trump and Fiorina the same questions about terrorist leaders in separate taped interviews on Thursday
      • FIorina answered confidently and Trump seemed flummoxed, confusing 'Quds Forces' with 'Kurds forces'



      Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3222467/Trump-stumped-terrorist-quiz-t-identify-leaders-ISIS-al-Qaeda-Carly-Fiorina-shows-knows-Nasrallah-al-

    • 12 hours ago, delcecchi said:

        He can't be as ignorant and inept as he has come across in TV interviews.  

      I ask the same thing about the other 2 candidates, especially the one that is your favorite.

       

      12 hours ago, delcecchi said:

      That would have been a fine answer.   Unfortunately instead he sat there with his mouth hanging open (figuratively) and looked like a total dolt.   This is the second time he has handled something in an interview poorly.  I guess he feels he needs the exposure but unfortunately he is not especially good at the interview thing.   At the very least he needs to practice deflecting the question.  Perhaps the "nobody especially" but "I prefer to look to American leaders of the past like (Calvin Coolidge, Teddy Roosevelt, Thomas Jefferson, William Calhoun, whoever he wants)" 

      He can't just sit there and and look stupid, which is what he did.    Maybe some role playing in preparation would have helped.   He can't be as ignorant and inept as he has come across in TV interviews.  

      What do you care? I thought he was irrelevant anyway?

       

    • Oh yeah.  I keep forgetting about all that modern computer stuff in cars.   So the computer would notice the tranny didn't shift all the way down as the car stopped?     There goes that theory.   

      And why only after a couple hours of driving?   Some sort of overheating of the transmission fluid?  cooler plugged in the flush process?   

      Here is a question for Carpmaster..... Is it different in the summer vrs winter?   Like you only have to drive 50 miles in summer and 200 in winter?  

      You guys that actually know can feel free to ignore my suggestions if you don't want to waste time answering.  



  • Posts

    • Man, I can see cream cheese but peanut butter? I may have to give it a go sometime, maybe the bacon will off set the oddness?  
    • Sorry I missed that. The brown and blue wires are the Transmit TX and Receive Rx wires for connection via single cable to NMEA 0183 compatible devices. nmea 0183 is the protocol for compatible devices, computer, plotters, auto piolet, Radar, radio, etc. All of these devices including your GPS can be connected to a single cable. The brown and blue wires allows the sonar to communicate to other devices. Google nmea 0183 compatible devices for a raft of information on what this is. My brother, a charter Capitan out of Cortez FL. uses these devices on his boat for off shore fishing up to 100 miles off shore. Nice to have to talk to other Capitan's ship to shore, radar, GPS and  to get back home without running into sunken islands.  
    • Trump stumped on terrorist quiz as he can't identify the leaders of ISIS and al-Qaeda – but Carly Fiorina shows she knows her Nasrallah from her al-Julani Radio host Hugh Hewitt asked Trump and Fiorina the same questions about terrorist leaders in separate taped interviews on Thursday FIorina answered confidently and Trump seemed flummoxed, confusing 'Quds Forces' with 'Kurds forces'

      Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3222467/Trump-stumped-terrorist-quiz-t-identify-leaders-ISIS-al-Qaeda-Carly-Fiorina-shows-knows-Nasrallah-al-
    • I ask the same thing about the other 2 candidates, especially the one that is your favorite.   What do you care? I thought he was irrelevant anyway?  
    • Oh yeah.  I keep forgetting about all that modern computer stuff in cars.   So the computer would notice the tranny didn't shift all the way down as the car stopped?     There goes that theory.    And why only after a couple hours of driving?   Some sort of overheating of the transmission fluid?  cooler plugged in the flush process?    Here is a question for Carpmaster..... Is it different in the summer vrs winter?   Like you only have to drive 50 miles in summer and 200 in winter?   You guys that actually know can feel free to ignore my suggestions if you don't want to waste time answering.  
    • leech, it does sound like an odd concocktion.  but you gotta try it.  225 for 2 hrs, helps if u use thin bacon.
    • nw wisconee private marsh
    • Sorry, I thought the model was listed on the title of my question.  Anyway, Garmin 53dv EchoMap.  This one has downview, but is chirpless.  Seems like nice unit, tough.  Just wondered about those 2 wires.  Thanks.
    • should trigger a check engine light....
  • Our Sponsors