Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
jhol

Handgun Question

33 posts in this topic

I am thinking about spending some money on a handgun and I am wondering what most of you guys have or like for brands and caliber. I am getting it for home protection and also something I would like to take out to the range and shoot a little. Probably not going to use if for any kind of hunting, I usually just bowhunt and muzzleload. I am definetely trying to stay under a $1000 and would like a semiauto not a revolver.

Thanks for all your input.

jhol

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Home protection in a semi automatic? Look at a glock. 40 cal or 45 acp. I have a friend with a CCW and he got rid of his 9mm and picked up a 380 auto, but that is concealed weapon.

Another friend has a glock subcompact in 10mm. Those things kick in the small package. I have a Taurus 1911 and I love it. I don't leave guns laying around the house, they are always locked up in the safe, but the 1911 is stored with the action open and two loaded magazines lay next to it in the safe. I can open the safe in under 5 seconds, but if I have time to run down the stairs to the safe, I can just as easy grab the 8" kitchen knives from the knife block.

the 45 acp is a proven stopper at self protection range. BUT if you are serious about home protection, get a shotgun. Just the simple cycling of the action will scare the bejesus out of anyone trying to enter your home.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

boy is there a lot of room for answers here...

Personally, I think a 9mm is a very adequate self defense round and cheap and easy to shoot. Many will say 9mm isn't enough and if you believe that, then I'd go to the .40 cal. However, it is a heavier duty shell and its going to give you more felt recoil and it costs more to shoot as the ammo isn't as prevelant.

As for brands, you'll find lots of Glock lovers out there although I wouldn't be caught dead with one. Terrible safeties and I personally know a gun who had one explode in his hands as he shot a reload through it which you aren't supposed to do I guess. Fortunately for him he wasn't hurt. I loved my Beretta 92FS although I sold it now as I was cash strapped and it was expendable. I've shot Rugers too although their grips did not fit my hand very well. Sig makes an excellent handgun too.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A few quick questions, are you experienced with a handgun?

If not and looking for a home defense weapon go with a revolver.

Many times inexperienced shooters in a stress condition drop magazines or have ejection failures in low light and do not realize it.

Caliber wise if your inexperienced start with no more then a 9mm or .38 until your comfortable shooting then decide.

Again for home defense I also recommend a shotgun using bird shot not slugs or buck shot especially if your family is on the other side of the wall. If you choose a handgun as your choice go with low velocity rounds to prevent over penetration especially in apartments or other occupied rooms.

Do not get into the Chevy vs. Ford mentality. Shop around and find the one that fits you best for your purpose.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I picked up a Springfeild XD in a .40 cal. I talked to a few of cops that had 9mm Glocks, and they are starting to transition to .40 for better wall/door penetration. You can't beat a .45 ACP for penetration, but the ammo is so much more expensive and I wanted to shoot it recreationally, too. There are 3 guys at work that have XDs (2-.45s and a 9mm) and have had great luck with them, so I followed their lead. I like that it has a grip safety in addition to the trigger safety, plus a firing pin block that pulls out of the way when the trigger is pulled for an extra step in safety. Glocks are good guns but I liked the ambidextrous features of the XDs (I'm left handed) that the Glocks don't offer. Just so you know, all of these guns (XD, Glock, M&P) are hammerless semi's, so they are missing that safety feature.

Another good semi is the Smith and Wesson M&P for different grips and ambidextrous features. It was a tossup for me between the XD and the S&W M&P, but the S&W was so new I wasn't going to take the chance, especially after all of the mediocre reports of the S&W Sigma handguns.

As far as personal home protection, there is nothing better than a short barreled shotgun for the visual scare factor and actually hitting a target when it counts. That will be next for me!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I could afford one right now I would get the "Judge" made by taurus. I believe it is a .38 but can also chamber .410 shells. I think that would be fun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have said this before here and will say it again! A handgun is a very personal choice, do not buy into "I have this, a buddy has that." Go to a gunshop and handle every possible gun that looks attractive to you, DO NOT look at the price tag or brand name until you get it nailed down to a few finalists. Don't let the salesperson push you into any particular one either until you have specific questions. Then go somemhere you can shoot them, there are a few ranges around the area that have a nice selection of rental guns. Next, get a safe that can be mounted in an easy to reach spot and has a quick system to access it, don't skimp here, and don't go too complicated(gunvault style comes to mind). Good luck and have fun! Shop around and take your time to get what YOU like!

PS the Judge is 45LC or 410.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Smilin Bob said it right. Its YOUR choice.

I will add, stick with a reputable manufacturer, find one that fits your hands, you are comfortable with the sights, and find the controls easy to operate.

As far as caliber, 9mm is plenty adequate no matter what anyone says. Todays bullets are way better than the past (as seen in deer rifle calibers). 9mm is readily available, most people can handle the recoil, and it will be one of the cheapest to shoot. You will shoot more when its cheap, also honing your skills. Enjoy you choice!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with everyone that a shotgun is a great for home defense and there is one a few steps away, I guess I am also considering getting my Conceal to Carry.

I have shot a few handguns including a glock 40, a kimber 40, and a smith and wesson(don't remember the caliber). I am leaning towards the 40 caliber, I think I should get out to a few gunshops and handle a few more brands and calibers. I would also like to shoot some recreationally so maybe the cost factor could push me to a smaller round.

As for the gunsafe, my wife is onboard with a new handgun as long as the new gun safe comes with it, we do not have kids but they are in the future and that is a huge concern.

thanks for the responses

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Picksbigwagon already mentioned the handguns I would recommend.

The only other handguns that I have shot are hand-cannons in .308 and 7mm-08 single shots and a .44 mag S&W.

My next handgun purchase will be intended for hunting and I'm looking at the .460 Magnum.

Do I dare say it would be a little overkill for home protection?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also agree with the post by "SmilinBob". There are so many choices of handguns that you really need to do some hands-on homework. IMHO, a 9mm is all that you'd need for home defense. I got my Permit to Carry in early 2000's because I could. I didn't plan to actually carry. However,I did start carrying regularly in late 2007. Personally, I carry a Taurus Millenium Pro 9mm or sometimes a Taurus 38 special. The 9mm was purchased was based upon size, performance, and carrying comfort. (Some are critical of Taurus but I have 3 from that manufacturer with no complaints.) Plus, with a 9mm, you won't break the bank when practicing at the range...something you must do to become familiar and comfortable with any handgun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I purchased my first handgun about 3 years ago... At that time I was not sure about what I wanted. I visited a local gun shop and handled alot of different handguns. The one I walked out of the store with was the Browning Hi Power 40 S&W. The reason I purchased it was that it was a good fit for my hands as well as well balanced. We determined that it could be used for hunting as well as target practice. Since that time I have purchased a Ruger 22/45 22 cal handgun and a Hi Point 45 cal handgun... Between them all the Browning is my favorite although I do use the Ruger more for my farming operation. The Hi Point was an inexpensive gun to purchase but the handling is rather clumsy.

The most important thing to remember is to purchase a handgun that fits your hands and is comfortable to use...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would recommend buying a revolver if you're useing it for home defense. As far as calibers go, I would recommend maybe a .357 mag. I say that because when you want to go to the range, you can also shoot .38 specials in the gun, saving some cash and your arms while getting a feel for the gun. I like revolvers for home defense, because if the gun sits too long without being fired, it will be fine, whereas a semi auto has a very good chance of developing memry in the magazine when not used on a regular basis and sits for a long period of time, and if the time comes to use it, you will have problems feeding new rounds into the gun. Not with a revolver.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you gun sits so long that you give a spring "memory" you better not intend on using it for anything,especially in an emergency, you need to practice regularly. The modern metals used in guns and springs also makes that a non-issue. Caliber is not as big of deal as one may think, there are a lot of dead people that will argue a .22 won't do the job. There again, pick what you like and are comfortable shooting. Now that the pot has been stirred, I miss my XD45, but the Colt Defender that replaced it is a beautiful piece. I like revolvers also and a 357 is very versatile, recreation with 38's, hunting and personal defense with the magnums, and it's hard to beat the romance of a nice wheel gun. As far as shotguns go, the pattern you will get, even with a short barrel, in a typical house of 10-15 foot rooms will only be about 4-6 inches in diameter, maybe 10 if you are using trap loads, you still need to aim, and movement with possible physical contact in less than a seconds time will put you at a significant disadvantage. If you don't believe it, pattern one, then when no one else is home, try moving tactically around your house, You will learn a lot, and find a lot of your pre-concieved ideas need revisiting. Remember, a home invasion happens very fast, and you are the one being taken on in a defense role with the bad guy having the element of surprise and desire to obtain something or do harm on their side. This will thankfully never happen to the vast majority of us, but there is no prediction of who or where is next, don't be paranoid, but as the experts say, be alert and prepared. Practice, Practice, Practice!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was going to post about choosing a revolver over a semi because of accidental magazine drop, but I must have omitted that. I have a Taurus 38 spec. / 357 mag with a 6" barrel. very intimidating to be looking at that from the wrong end of the gun (I actually looked in a mirror and pointed it at myself, the barrel looks ginormous). It points very natural for me and is pretty darn accuate out to 50 yards with Hornady Leverevolution (almost as hard to type as it is to say)

If you can find a gun range that rents them out, it is worth your time to do that. I think Bill's Gun shop in Robbinsdale and I believe there is another bill's in Circle Pines MN. They have a HSOforum and a lot of guns listed to rent to use on their range.

Good luck and good decision on the gun safe. Funny, my wife said the same thing before we had kids. "You need to get a gun safe or keep them in the garage." Hello gun safe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good luck and good decision on the gun safe. Funny, my wife said the same thing before we had kids. "You need to get a gun safe or keep them in the garage." Hello gun safe

umm.....duh!?!?!?!?!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hesitated to include this in my first post, but I'll say it now in response to the "intimidation" comments.

I'm no firearms expert, but I've been trained to understand (and believe) that a handgun if a self defense tool. If brandished, you had better be prepared to fire the weapon, to kill. Chances are that you'll be dealing with a low light situation where nobody is going to be able to see well and the display of a shotgun isn't necessarily going to help. Find safe cover, give verbal commands, and be prepared to fire if you or your family is in imminent danger. If you do fire, be prepared to be treated like a criminal, keep your mouth shut until speaking with your attorney, and get out the checkbook for your legal defense. This is serious stuff.

If your true intent is to simply intimidate a bad-guy who has broken into your house by showing them that you have a weapon (shotgun or other), leave the gun locked up and find a baseball bat and hope that the bad-guy doesn't have an itchy trigger finger.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

while you make good points dellfin, I might disagree a little bit on the point that if most intruders see a weapon brandished at them, especially a gun be it a handgun or shotgun, will try to hightail it out. Not all, but a good percentage will.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Possibly. But, they need to "see" it. Again, darkness is against you. Maybe you have Fort Knox in your basement and the bad-guy breaking in will be professional wearing night vision goggles to see your cannon. I'm just a common guy with a few TVs and some fishing tackle.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think Bigdrift had a goodpoint about the simplictiy of a revolver in low light conditions. You give up magazine capacity for simplicty.

The articles I have read on Home defense typically say the same thing about "Chambering a round" in a shotgun. It may very well scare some...but it may also show that you are ill prepared.

I would never have any loaded gun in my house..I feel the risk of a child getting shot is greater than the risk of someone breaking in...if I was to have a shot gun...the round would be in the chamber...I would "grab and go"...it gives you just a small andvantage..and some stealth...it is your house..you know it better then a would be burglar.

For the hand gun..I would go with a Springfield Arms XD 45. ACP...it gives you 14 rounds vs. a revolver.....use the Military mentallity...scared soldiers need more rounds...that is one reason they went to the 5.56x45 over the 7.62...soldiers could carry more ammo which they were burning up when scared.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes, in most cases darkenss would be against you. Not all break ins occur at night. Just this last Saturday, my parents house was broken into at 1:30 in the afternoon. They have an alarm system that went off, and the burgler, who happens to be a neighbor, was smart enough, or dumb enough (however you want to think about it, to actually sit and wait for the cops to show up. I don't have Fort Knox in my basement, and like you am just a common guy with a few TV's, some fishing and hunting things and a few other things that may not be worth much on the street, but mean something to me. As far as gun safety goes, there are things on the market called trigger locks. You can get them with either a key lock or combonation lock. They work. Or, do what I do and have a trigger lock on the gun, and have the gun in a small safe that requires a combo.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I won't get into caliber or brand. But check ammo prices they very dramatically based on caliber and popularity! Ballpark $10/50 smaller calibers to $40/50 on .44Mag.

Your covered with a ~$100 handgun safe able to function by feel in the dark. This should be close at hand while sleeping of course to be useful. I believe there is a federal law that requires all handguns to be secure if minors are around in, like in your future?

What I find just as important to home defense is my Crimson Trace laser grips. Spendy ($200+) but well worth it for me. No more need to pull the gun up traditionally and aim (if you can't)! Just put the bright red dot on target from behind cover or whatever awkward position you might be in and your good to go. I think it gives you an extreme muzzle awareness from a safety aspect also. Handguns can be inherently dangerous to handle for new shooters you need to think SAFETY at all times!

From the sounds of it you might be describing several purchases for your wants and needs. Join the club! Just remember you don't NEED all of them at once. One here, one there, next thing you know you got it all covered until you see another one you just need smile

You will need to go to your local law enforcement and apply for a permit to purchase (free). I think it takes a couple weeks to process. An important note is if you go through the permit to carry class ($100) and receive a permit to carry another $100. You can purchase handguns over the counter after they call the FBI to see your a good guy.

Good ear muffs are essential for handgunning $20 on up. you'll only forget them once...hehe!

Don't forget to practice, shooting is fun for the whole family and bring friends! By all means involve your wife in your training and shooting so she isn't afraid to have a handgun around.

Good luck,

Ferny.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As always there is a ton of good info from everybody. I did some online research from brand to brand today and I think there are a lot of good options. I think after the holidays I am going to start making the rounds to different gun shops and talk to people and shoot a few.

I have never regreted buying a firearm and I think they are a great investment and I am sure handguns are no different.

As far as the permit to purchase, you cannot go do a gun store and buy a handgun without one and just wait for your background check???

As for anybody that has done the conceal to carry did you like the class and the info, and how much do you really carry your weapon???

I will let you all know what I decide, thanks for all the advice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No, you cannot purchase a handgun in MN without a "permit to purchase." The P2P is available at your local law enforcement agency, and there is a form that you will have to fill out. There will be a week or so long wait to receive your P2P, and from there you can purchase a handgun (or handguns) for up to 1 year (or is it 2?) from the date of issue in MN.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • wear a good balaclava and get a open face with a cold weather breath box never had a problem
    • In my opinion I would look for a nice used wingmaster 2 of my friends have bought a new 870 express about a year apart and they both had the same shell extraction problems. Maybe just a fluke but when I see two different people have the same problem with a Gun makes me think to find a different choice. Heck I have a Mossberg 500 that I treat like poop and I have never had one single malfunction.   I have shot my friends newer express and I can really tell the difference in quality beside my wingmaster  
    • I have Ice Kings.  They are in a word, awesome.  They are about 20-25 years old. Dang I hate dating myself but I have never even bought new liners for these boots.  They are probably one of the finest products I won.  I have never had so much as a chill i my feet.  I usually fish outside but if I am in a flip over, my feet are usually on the ice.  Again, never a chill.  I typically wear a midnight smart wool sock.   For some reason I have been considering new boots.  I guess it is the weight, I would love to have something that is not s heavy and also has better traction.   Today I visited Joe's Sporting Goods and saw some really nice boots (they have a great selection) by Muck, Lacrosse, Sorel, Baffin and some other Canadian made boot that looked very nice. I checked out the ice Kings........they are not the same boot as I have, they don't seem to have the quality to me.  They might be as warm but the rubber feels more stiff almost like it would crack, the uppers are solid leather, mine are leather and corder combo.  The liner also seemed thinner.   After looking at all the boots, I am surprised none offer water proof uppers. Also I am not entirely certain why some seem extend up to your knee with insulation.  Just seems like Over kill because most who would where these boots owed also have some sort of insulated pant on.  Overall I found the boots to be pretty heavy, I was surprised with 20 years past boots have not advanced more.
    • But will be missed but most.............you mad bro?    
    • You boxed yourself.   He was not supporting the Vikings stadium, he was saying that Republicans supported it and now are feigning outrage over the cook subsidy. And then not to be outdone the Republicans are now celebrating the Carrier subsidy.   Pretty much just reinforced his point.      
    • Think we should change the topic to "Trump for Trees."........and all will be well.
    • Had to go all the way back to Missouri to hunt in the snow this year! Beautiful morning but not much movement. Did see some late rut activity Friday.
    • Dotch, you guys over there are almost famous....   Almost because it is Waseca, but whatever.    Mark Seeley's weather blog... http://blog-weathertalk.extension.umn.edu/   .... Waseca now reports 54.13 inches of precipitation for 2016 and this is a new statewide annual precipitation record, surpassing the old one of 53.52" at St Francis (Anoka County) in 1991.
      ....   And an interesting thought...(from Mark, not me) Commentary on Winter TIME: No question will be answered this week, but I want to take TIME to make a comment about Winter TIME. Managing the TIME in the Winter Season in Minnesota is a different ball game than other seasons of the year, because everything takes longer. No question winter will be felt more frequently soon in the daily weather, and snowfalls will become more frequent this month. The rash of bicycle, pedestrian, and vehicular accidents reported during the snow storms towards the end of November reminded me about adjusting for Winter TIME. Our concept of time needs to be adjusted. Lengthen the time intervals that you have intuitively built-into your everyday habits and tasks. It takes longer to walk places, longer to drive places, longer to dress and undress, longer to warm up the car, longer to degomble (shed snow) when you come into the house. You need to make time to shovel snow, scrape the windshield, clean the furnace filters, When you walk take shorter steps and not too fast...put the boots, gloves and hat on when you go outside....check on the neighbor if their place hasn't been shoveled...everything should slow down..except for the long Minnesota goodbye..that is better shortened...just say goodbye, open the door, leave and close the door behind you....no need to stand in an open doorway for minutes conversing about last minute stuff. Winter TIME is an adjustment that may save you anxiety, regret, or even injury.
    • Would you use a bobber on your rattle reel with these? I would think a lively minnow would pull the line out of the contacts.
    • My my, how the mighty have fallen...  I went back to the thread on the cook subsidy, and what did I find in the second post from you, on the second page....     Gee, you were ok with the 66 million because it wasn't a stadium or something, but now all butt hurt over 7 million of Indiana money?    Now that there is a funny joke.  
  • Our Sponsors