Guests - If You want access to member only forums on HSO. You will gain access only when you sign-in or Sign-Up on HotSpotOutdoors.

It's easy - LOOK UPPER right menu.

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
TOLLEFRY

Guns & Ammo

14 posts in this topic

I just put in for my first turkey tag. The shotgun I own is questionable at best for a first time turkey hunter. I have a 20ga savage pump, with a modified choked barrel. I do have the option of using a Beretta O/U 12ga.

Why is an O/U not used by many turkey hunters? In my case, the Beretta is a no brainer, I'll use that and choke it for turkey. Would I be better off trying to borrow a 12ga semi auto?

Also, is Federal Premium a good round for either, 20ga, or 12ga?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I currently use a 20ga O/U for hunting turkeys. Most people don't own double guns so that's the main reason you don't see them used for turks. I think the second reason is most people like the option of a pump gun or semi to get multiple shots.

I purchased several choke tubes and tried them out. I also tried several different loads in my guns to get the best possible pattern out of my 20ga. I am deadly at 30-35 yds and at 40yds it hits the limit. I get the min amount necessary for a "lethal" pattern. The rule is to get at least 5 pellets in the head area of a target.

Federal Premiums have been good in my gun, but that doesn't mean anything. Most guns prefer one or two loads more than others. You'll have to pattern them and see.

The advantage of having a 12ga is more power, more pellets, and better choice of hunting loads. Downside is the size, weight and the punch of shooting turkey loads.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that the 20 can be a great little turkey machine. My son has been shooting his 870 Youth with an Undertaker choke tube, Federal Premium #5 turkey loads.

Whatever gun you settle on, you need to pattern test a few different loads. You'll be surprised at the differences in the various loads.

Deadly out to 40 yards.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Pattern both guns and use the one with the best pattern. There is no difference in power between 20 ga or 12 ga A #5 pellet moving at 1300 fps has the same knockdown power whether it came from a 10 ga or 410. Larger gauges have more pellets per shell that is the only difference. In fact most 3 inch shells are slower than there 2 3/4 inch counterparts and are actually weaker. They just have more shot in the pattern. Paterning is the only way to decide on which gun for turkeys. Don't rule out hevi shot or other non toxics as they pattern very well and have heavier than lead pellets so more knockdown at longer ranges.

Mwal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh boy, someone new to talk turkey with! Welcone Tollefry!

If your 20 has a fixed modified barrel, then yes, it is a no brainer. Go with the 12. Get a good XFull Turkey Choke and try a few different loads. My 870 shoots Fed Premium very well, but like Powerstroke said, that doesn't mean anything.

BTW, a good friend has shot several birds with his O/U.

Good luck drawing that tag and welcome to the addiction.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Welcome to the adrenaline rush of turkey hunting. The 12 gauge is the no-brainer, but as a first timer I would want the confidence of being able to take a second shot. I've seen birds flinch at the last second. Sometimes when you miss they'll be momentarily confused and you'll want to chamber up and get another shot off. If you have access to a gun that you can get two shots, whether it is the O/U or the semi-auto, go for it. Like Powerstroke said, you can kill turkeys just fine with a 20 guage, but when you are trying to get a couple pellets in the neck or cranium, I'd rather have more pellets than less, so the 12 gets the nod over the 20 given the choice.

Good luck drawing your tag, don't be afraid to get in line for a surplus if it doesn't work out, work hard (scout a few spots you have access to, practice your calls, make sure you have your gear laid out and ready), put in your time, and pattern your gun with a few different loads. You'll be happy you did when your hands are shaking holding that bird up for the camera.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The flexibilty of the removeable chokes tips the scale to the 12 gauge as you can pick up a good turkey choke for it. Plenty of good ones out there from $15-$45.

Believe it or not the new rage in turkey guns is the 20 gauge and all the new loadings for it. Guys are getting tired to getting pounded by heavy loads in 3 1/2 guns. My dauhter's 20 gauge 870 youth with no work done to it patterns Hevi Shot densely out past 45 yards with plenty of knock down power to that range. Guys are getting much better results than that when they work on the gun, choke and ammo combo.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am somewhat suprised that the O/U aren't more popular in the turkey woods. Most are nice and short but still have a nice sight plane and the option of having one barrel tightly choked and the other with a Mod. choke for when birds get in tight would be nice as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know for sure why they aren't more popular. Some thoughts ar that guys like to camo up their guns and many of the O/U are shiny and pretty. Also they tend to be lighter and there is no recoil releif like you get with many of the pumps or autos.

Those turkey loads pound on both ends of the gun!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There definately is no recoil relief in a double gun.

My gun is not selectable barrels so I keep them both tightly choked, but I feel its perfect for the job and being a 20ga makes it even easier.

I'm glad to see the trend moving more towards 20ga guns now. I know you will never get away from the 12ga, but for a while there was too much push for 3.5" loads and even some 10ga guns.

Like was said before, a pellet traveling at 1300FPS doesnt fly any faster or harder from a 20ga or 10ga. So even if you're shooting a 10ga you still cant take 60yd shots at turks. And just cause you can get a bynck of pellets in the circle doesn't mean that they will have enough energy to kill the bird. These physics are really coming around and people are learning the lethal range of the loads rather than just using a patterning board and counting pellets.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's right. Punching holes in paper is not the same as breaking bone in a turkey's head and neck.

I'll repost a patterning article within the next month or so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That was a great read Borch for new and experienced turkey hunters.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the ideas. I'll keep my eye on the Borch Blog for the article. Now I wait to here from the DNR and practice my calls. crazy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0



  • Posts

    • I guess the one positive regarding this Carrier deal is at least, of what I've seen from watching some of them, the press starting to question government involvement in  private enterprise and cronyism.   It only took them eight years but better late than never, I guess.
    • They're made by NGP, an industrial producer in Ningbo, China. Good luck getting service or parts on that, is all I'll say. I know all the other augers engines, etc, are made in China, but they also have been around for years with an established company, which is a huge difference. I'd be real cautious...
    • I use 100 pound power pro braid never had any issues with it.
    • I've been looking into them.   I believe 33 is a typo.
    • Old fashioned black Dacron musky line. Durable tough  Have thought of trying  50 or 100lb flouro but knots are hard to do in it then you have to use crimps etc more point to fail. Interested to see what others do.   Mwal
    • I kinda wish Parise would have opted for the surgery this offseason and miss the first month or so, rather than to rehab it.  Its starting to show.
    • Here is good overview article that might be interesting...   https://www.dgif.virginia.gov/wildlife/diseases/cwd/science-behind-cwd-management/   The Science Behind CWD Management Why Manage CWD? Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) has the potential to negatively impact deer herds wherever the disease occurs. CWD is always fatal and while there have only been 13 cases detected in Virginia, as of February 2016, CWD could have serious negative impacts on the state’s deer population if it became established and widely prevalent (Almberg et al. 2011). CWD infection decreases deer survival odds and lowers total life expectancy (Miller et al. 2008). If a large percentage of the population were to become infected there could be negative impacts for the population, including: A decline in doe survival, which results in an overall reduced population (Gross and Miller 2001); Fewer older bucks, as male animals are more likely to be infected due to specific male social and behavioral tendencies (Miller et al. 2008, Jennelle et al. 2014); and An overall decline in population (Gross and Miller 2001, Almberg et al. 2011), as exhibited in Colorado. In the area of Colorado with highest CWD prevalence, mule deer numbers have plummeted by 45%, in spite of good habitat and protection from human hunting (Miller et al. 2008). DGIF is concerned about the impact CWD could have on Virginia’s deer herd; once CWD has become well established in an area, its persistence in the environment makes eradication extremely difficult, if not impossible. Taking action to keep the percentage of infected animals low helps to prevent (or at least slow) the spread of CWD to new areas, and also helps to slow the transmission of the disease between individuals. Understanding the Spread of CWD CWD prions, which are the infectious proteins that cause the disease, are found in saliva, urine, feces, and blood (Mathiason et al. 2006, Mathiason et al. 2009). They can persist for years outside the body, in soil and in other substances, and can be transmitted by animals that are not yet showing symptoms of the disease (Miller et al. 2004, Mathiason et al. 2009). Halting or slowing the spread of CWD is therefore a matter of reducing transmission between deer and making deer less likely to pick up prions from the environment (Mathiason et al. 2009, Grear et al. 2010, Storm et al. 2013). Differences in behavior make tracking the spread of CWD different between does and bucks and between younger and older adults. Bucks are more likely to become infected, for reasons that are not well understood (Grear et al. 2006, Miller et al. 2008, Jennelle et al. 2014). Higher CWD prevalence is found in older age classes of bucks (Grear et al 2006). Adult bucks make long excursions outside their home range, bringing them into contact with a wider area and more individual deer (Karns 2011). Young bucks are more likely to disperse from their mother’s home range and can cover many kilometers, thereby potentially spreading the disease across the landscape (McCoy et al. 2005). Young bucks infected with CWD may not be indicative of established CWD presence at the location they were killed because the buck may have been traveling. Does are relatively sedentary, usually spending their lives near their place of birth and with a related social group. Does only rarely make excursions (Kolodzinski et al. 2009, Miller et al. 2010, Grear et al. 2010). Locations where infected does are found are likely to be a source of further infected deer (Grear et al. 2010, Magel et al. 2013). An infected doe suggests that CWD is established in the population where that doe was killed (Grear et al. 2010, Magel et al. 2013). Of Virginia’s thirteen infected deer (as of February 2016), just four were does. Of the nine infected bucks, seven were harvested within just a few miles of the does, suggesting a small cluster of infection. The last two bucks were killed several miles from the cluster. The fact that these two outliers were young bucks makes it likely, though not certain, that these individuals were on the move, dispersing from their birth places. Managing CWD Due to the nature of the prions which cause CWD (please see the What Are Prions page for more information), treatment of diseased animals is not an option. Research suggests that there is some hope of managing CWD, and that the best methods available are: Decreasing transmission opportunity by:Lowering the density of the deer population A lower density population surrounding a location of known infection reduces the chances of deer picking up CWD prions from the environment, or from each other. Research indicates that indirect transmission is just as important as animal-to-animal transmission (Storm et al. 2013). Population reduction could reduce contacts between infected and susceptible individuals and consequently reduce the disease transmission rate. Analysis of spatial data indicates that CWD is clustered on the landscape, from which one could infer that deer near CWD-positive deer are more likely to be infected (Joly et al. 2003.) Earn-a-Buck, currently in effect in Frederick, Warren, and Clarke Counties (the cluster of infected deer is located in Frederick County), is designed to reduce the overall deer population by focusing more hunting pressure on the female segment of the population. Banning feeding or baiting of deer in areas with CWD CWD prions can be found in saliva (Mathiason et al. 2009), and feed or bait piles are excellent modalities to transfer saliva between deer. Feed and bite piles also artificially congregate deer, thereby facilitating transmission through urine and feces. Prevent the introduction of CWD prions into new areas: VDGIF prohibits the movement of deer carcasses out of the CWD Containment Area until after they have been processed according to guidelines described in Transporting Carcasses Within and Out of the Containment Area. VDGIF prohibits the transport of carcasses from states/provinces listed as CWD Carcass Restriction Zones into Virginia unless they have already been processed according to these guidelines. VDGIF prohibits the possession and use of attractants made from real deer urine or other natural body fluids from deer while afield. CWD prions may be found in the urine of infected deer even if the deer is not showing symptoms (John et al. 2013). There is no live animal test for CWD that is approved by the USDA, therefore deer farms producing and bottling urine cannot guarantee that they are collecting urine from healthy animals. There is no economically viable way to test urine for CWD after collection. Doing nothing to manage CWD is not a satisfactory option, as shown by a number of studies that have examined hunters’ attitudes toward current and potential strategies for managing CWD (Vaske 2010). Among hunters in most states and studies, (a) testing harvested animals for CWD and using hunters to reduce herds in CWD areas were acceptable strategies, (b) agencies taking no action and allowing CWD to take its natural course were considered unacceptable, and (c) using agency staff to reduce herds in CWD areas was controversial. Hunters also generally supported efforts to minimize spread of CWD and eliminate the disease from animal herds (Vaske 2010). A VDGIF survey conducted following the discovery of CWD in Frederick County in 2009 concluded that respondents supported five of seven potential strategies to control CWD in affected areas, including mandatory disease testing of hunter-killed deer, deer feeding prohibitions, deer carcass movement restrictions, restrictions on deer rehabilitation, and reduction of deer populations using hunters (VDGIF 2010, unpublished data). Respondents did not support the use of sharpshooting to reduce localized deer populations (42% opposed, 36% supported, 22% were neutral), but the strongest opposition was recorded for the option that described a complete lack of effort or attempt to manage CWD (79 % opposed, 8% supported).   (the references are at the link and appear to all be from various scientific type journals)
    • The recount effort underway in Wisconsin is turning out to have some disappointing results for former Green Party nominee Jill Stein and former Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton. By the end of the fifth day, and after more than 1 million votes were recounted, Trump grew his lead by just over two dozen votes.     Meanwhile in Pennsylvania, Clinton has only gained five votes after the state’s two largest counties completed their recount.     
    • It turns out that there haven't been many studies of long term impact of cwd, that I could find.    Here is a write up about one of them, from Wyoming.    http://www.wyofile.com/study-chronic-wasting-disease-kills-19-deer-annually/ and this one... http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0161127 Chronic Wasting Disease Drives Population Decline of White-Tailed Deer David R. Edmunds , Matthew J. Kauffman, Brant A. Schumaker, Frederick G. Lindzey, Walter E. Cook, Terry J. Kreeger, Ronald G. Grogan, Todd E. Cornish      
    • I use a thin super-line/braid. That said,  a friend of mine swears by mono in really clear water and I've sat with him and seen a lot of wary fish that still get close enough to ruin their day. Not sure if it matters or not... I just like the assurance of braid.
  • Our Sponsors